I don't know how significant it is. Dictatorships have always been feared and despised. And armies lost motivation many times in history, before the internet.
From a military perspective what I think is different this time is how (probably) US intelligence is helping Ukrainians. It seems they know any Russian move in advance in real time and I doubt such a feat could be pulled in the past.
While it is still a bit unclear to me at least why Russia sent their seemingly old gear without proper support and young conscripts in first, the terrible parachute attempts still stand out.
When you want it to be over quickly, you have to send in the best soldiers with the best gear first to seal the deal?
In addition to live NATO intelligence, it is clear to most europeans that US intelligence tried to warn about this at the start of December, with photos showing large preparations for heavy army movement all around the Ukrainian border.
I recently learned their economy is as big as the Benelux. What a joke for a "world power".
Their elite spetsnaz got captured, the elite chechenians got annihilated before they could move a finger. No supplies, soldiers are uninformed, ... .
5 days of war, no major city captured, no air control, no cut in communications, electricity, ... .
They got nukes, yes, it seems that's basically all. If they are as good as the rest, they might even explode before they leave the surface ;).
Why send not the best, brightest and most advanced? Because you only jump as high as you need. And using your most sophisticated gear in an area that is most likely covered NATO detection gear and consultants / advisors doesn't sound to smart neither.
To use them as cannon fodder to see what military capabilites Ukraine has been given by the West?
1.Russia doesn't have much new gear and 2. the old at least works reliably in the field. Russia for example backed down from gas turbines in tanks (like T-80) because of poor reliability and high maintenance (and maintenance is always a huge issue in Russia)
> without proper support
that is the best Russia can. Support and logistics has always been an issue.
> and young conscripts in first
the young people grew during Putin's Russia and they are much easy to make them kill Ukrainians.
> you have to send in the best soldiers with the best gear first to seal the deal
that were the ones who were dropped on the airfields near Kiev in order to capture them and thus facilitate coming of the next wave of the best - the Pskov's 76th paratroopers - who were to flew in. The capture of any of the airfields failed.
The ground attack, even by the best of the best, was too slow to make to Kiev for the "Czechoslovakia 68" plan to work.
The Russian propaganda effort seems to have involved the internet a lot, and you can see their talking points come out of the mouths of Western speakers in all the usual places on both the far-right and far-left.
Remains to be seen how well the domestic Russian propaganda effort will hold.
> It's harder to mobilise people behind a corrupt cause once blood starts flowing.
Only if that's your blood. If it's someone else's people are often fine with it. The returning dead Russians could make the country go either way - demands for revenge.
> from a purely geographical perspective, this is the first war on the European continent in the 2000's.
It's not even the first war _in Ukraine_ in the 2000s! Has everyone forgotten Crimea and the Donbass?
Maybe it's part of a larger strategy. We might see more crisis popping up soon.
So perfectly valid assumption is that command chain inflated the capabilities and morale of the army wildly.
Also, I think it would be naive to think that the army is the one place were kleptocracy is not stealing from.
So who knows, maybe the tyrant is playing 5D chess and shit is going to go really bad or he could be playing 1D chess because ...
It feels like a distraction because the "goal" seems ... both unclear and not worth the reputation damage.
In all those years after hearing this, it has always been the former :D.
I would have thought that if they could buy it now / soon, then they could probably have bought it at not much a percentage premium prior.
I'm not across the realpolitik of this kind of thing though, but interested to learn.
No and yes. He's taking it slowly because he knows the West won't interfere.
It's not a blitz, it's a siege.
Paratroopers/fast armor columns and sieges aren't mutually exclusive, they can be used to probe weaknesses in a siege.
There's a traffic jam of refugees at the border, but the roads, railways and airports are still there and in Ukranian control? I don't see what obstacle there is.
They expected capitulation by Sunday, with some ongoing attrition medium term. This is both from US Intel and now confirmation via a deleted, but luckily web archived, article/commentary on one of their major state-media sites, praising the (now impossible) “success” and their resurgence, while also flaunting the west.
I don't know what US intel you're referring to, so no comment.
In the end, we shall see, but from their positioning imo it looks like a siege.
They did encounter much stiffer resistance than they expected, but there are still hundreds of tanks and tens of thousands of troops around Kyiv. Now that the West is sending arms to Ukraine, there is an increasing probability that they will manage to defend themselves. But unfortunately it's far from certain, or even probable at this point.
The bombings and shelling looks really, really bad.. Kharkov will be nothing but rubble.
There is also the confirmation from the British Ministry of Defence: https://twitter.com/DefenceHQ?ref_src=twsrc%5Egoogle%7Ctwcam...
They are Ukraine aligned but are IMO more trustwordy.
Overall, I admit the fog of war is thick. But even maintaining my skepticism, the info seems coherent enough to convince me.
Just saying "You cannot base opinion on online media" is useless because what are YOU basing your opinion on? Online media, written media, whatever.. it's all information, one way or another we're all basing our view on external sources. The trick is filtering it and I think it's possible to at least glimpse reflections of the actual status. If you don't take into account any information you know nothing and just go off on projections in your head. Much worse state of afairs.
Not to mention that Spanish media even used footage from video game to "illustrate" the fake news about the war.
Most shocking for me was the videos of the TB2's incinerating some BUK systems I think. I was... astonished, it means Ukraine can still operate in the airspace and that does not bode well for the Russians.
They were poor, it's true. Tragically, because they were a centrally planned economy, the USSR could starve its citizens to funnel wealth to its war machine.
Russia is richer (about as rich as the state of Florida) but less centrally controlled, so it will find it harder to concentrate wealth into state initiatives at the expense of the lives of its citizens.
That would a stronger point, if one could not also unfavourably compare the size of the USA's military and social welfare budgets. And also the ease of expanding the former, vs. the difficultly in expanding the latter.
1. The US also has loads of value which is not mediated by the state. A shop can decide what to sell, and you can decide to buy it, without any central planning or money spent by the state. All of this value could be (and was) decided by the state in the USSR.
2. "social welfare budgets" are not in the same league as what happened with central planning. From Wikipedia:
> In 1928, Stalin introduced the first five-year plan for building a socialist economy. In place of the internationalism expressed by Lenin throughout the Revolution, it aimed to build Socialism in One Country. In industry, the state assumed control over all existing enterprises and undertook an intensive program of industrialization. In agriculture, rather than adhering to the "lead by example" policy advocated by Lenin,[31] forced collectivization of farms was implemented all over the country.
> Famines ensued as a result, causing deaths estimated at three to seven million; surviving kulaks were persecuted, and many were sent to Gulags to do forced labor.
We know that it rarely makes sense for other people to even plan software timelines for teams of 4 developers, and the team members are the best people to estimate timelines, pick tools, and solve problems. How much more does that scale up for a whole country's economy? How much more damage can someone do if they are choosing centrally to deprioritise wealth creation over the latest thing the state wishes to accomplish?
For the US and UK it was always a preferred modus operandi: to make other people and nations fight for them. Like before WW II they explicitly stated that they would be happy to see both USSR and Germany mutually annihilate themselves, so that US can come to what is left and occupy the remnants.
Islamic terrorism is also a child of USA.
Assaults on massive countries are not won overnight. USA had a quick win of a month in Iraq by using shock and awe. Blowing everything up and killing any civilian who got in the way.
This created a massive insurgency, which was fine because they didn't plan on occupying only destabilising.
Russia plans on occupying, to reduce NATOs ability to out flank them over the European plane.
So it takes longer.
Secondly, the young soldiers. Its called training, they are battle hardening the next generation in a 'easy' war, for if they ever need to use them in the future.
Russia is clearly taking the slow and careful approach, he wants these people to be part of the union eventually.
The invasion tactic was shock and awe.
They didn't plan to occupy, they thought it would be easier to setup a puppet government than it was. They couldn't leave until Iraq was in a state to balance Iran's regional influence.
USA wanted to use Iraq for a oil/gas pipeline to Europe from Saudi/Qatar. They realised that was not possible due to the USA lack of state building abilities. So they turned their attention on Syria for the pipeline.
Jordan agreed but Syria was a under the Russian sphere of influence, so they needed to topple this government for the pipeline.
The pipeline would have challenged Russian oil/gas monopoly in Europe.
Why have a navy if you have nukes, why build tanks when you already have nukes, why not let your adversary encircle you if you have nukes.
Nukes are typically tactical weapons, you will still have a deal with a ground force once all the nukes have been used.
While it is undeniably true that open communication and the internet has corrupted the value of information, it seems that for the first time in 20 years we're witnessing the flip side of this coin as well. It's harder to mobilise people behind a corrupt cause once blood starts flowing. Curious to see how this plays out!
And yes - there have been wars for the last 20 years, I know. But if we're honest, from a purely geographical perspective, this is the first war on the European continent in the 2000's.