News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:18AM (#30478833)
I got rid of a Mercedes C class for this exact same reason, it tried to kill me - twice - and that was enough for me. No more automatic brakes on my cars, the risks don't seem to outweigh the advantages. At least Honda seems to be responsible enough to address this. According to MB there was absolutely nothing wrong with my car, it was 'operating as designed'.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by blueprint on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:36AM (#30479050)
Mercedes treated me similarly. I had a brand new sprinter van. The power braking fluid lines exploded just after I got off the highway. I got extremely lucky it didn't happen 5 seconds earlier than it did. Turns out they use plastic rings instead of metal ones and it turns out it happens to lots of people. They refused to buy back the vehicle. I wanted to sue them but I've got too much stuff on my plate, or so I tell myself. Needless to say, I lost a lot of trust in them and (perhaps stupidly) sold the van shortly afterwards.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:46AM (#30479166)
> Needless to say, I lost a lot of trust in them and (perhaps stupidly) sold the van shortly afterwards.

I know this is very off-topic but don't beat yourself up about making quick decisions like this that cut that kind of persistent, simmering rage out of your life.

We have enough of this stuff with people in our lives, often unavoidably, so letting appliances/devices/products cause it is not something we have to tolerate. If a _thing_ makes you feel unsatisfiable anger, get rid of it.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:38PM (#30479725)
Very good advice. Vote with your feet and move on. Life really is too short, if MB wants to burn their brand more power to them. I bought a 25 year old car and had it rebuilt end-to-end, this cost a bit but the result is fine. No electronics other than ECU and some minor bits like ABS and pretty reliable. It will outlast me.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by unfocussed_mike on Saturday February 26, 2022 @04:22PM (#30482089)
I bought a (really cheap, hybrid) resonator guitar about 15 years ago. It wasn't very expensive, it _looked_ really cool (great headstock). But I couldn't get a sound out of it I liked, and over time the resonator became difficult to "tune" or maintain. And I felt sort of guilty and stupid for buying it.

I couldn't get on with the thing, but I felt bad about selling it to anyone because the resonator was more trouble than it was worth. Some frustrations should not be sold on.

So I kept the very nice guitar case, and gave the guitar away to a talented, broke musician, who used its rather scratchy, broken sound for effect on a couple of recordings.

I could have sold it for a few quid but I have never regretted this; I turned my frustration at this thing into a gift and a bit of joy for someone else and then moved on.

Not something I'd recommend everyone does regularly, because if we all do it, it just prolongs poor product design by failing to reject it, but it helped this one time.

(It also taught me an important lesson about musical instruments; the next guitar I bought was better, but more basic in appearance and already scratched from the shop.)

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by gruez on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:25PM (#30480224)
>Vote with your feet and move on

Isn't the correct term "vote with your wallet"? "voting with your feet" implies switching jobs or emigrating.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:43PM (#30480417)
Walk out of one store and into another.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by gunapologist99 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:39PM (#30480371)
You probably did the right thing -- life is short.

I had a similar experience and called an attorney, who explained that, in the U.S., you can really only sue for any actual loss (whether to the vehicle or to you). If you weren't injured or killed, and didn't suffer extreme anxiety or something like that, then you suffered no real loss and really have nothing to sue over (unfortunately). You can't sue for what might have happened, only for what actually did. (You probably could have sued, at least in small claims, for the loss of use, cost of repairs, decrease in value, etc, if you wanted to take the time.)

With that said, you might have been able to get them to take it back under your state's lemon law, if you hadn't already sold it, but the lemon laws generally only cover multiple defects over a period of time anyway. :(

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by blueprint on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:59PM (#30481905)
given they know about it already but still sell the vehicles I think a fraud case is in the cards. then a recall will be issued.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by monus21 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:57AM (#30479306)
A good number of their engine components these days are made of cheap plastic that just disintegrates after slight use.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by blueprint on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:59PM (#30481907)
suchas?
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by philsnow on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:12PM (#30480749)
What model year was that sprinter?
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by blueprint on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:59PM (#30481910)
couple yrs ago
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by 3pt14159 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:25AM (#30478914)
Yikes. I remember when my dad bought the first fly-by-wire car and even back then I was kinda spooked by it but accepted that adults knew what they were doing. The funny thing is that our next door neighbour bought the same car and the computer saved his life when a semi-transport truck merged into him and it took over the wheel.

I'm still on team "put computers into cars" for the long term benefit of ending routine automotive collisions but the medium term is frightening.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by wyldfire on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:11PM (#30479481)
The term "fly by wire" refers to the lack of mechanical linkage between the operator controls and the flight control surfaces. Cars have gone through similar design changes, yes. The car accelerator no longer opens valves/injectors for the gasoline to enter combustion chambers.

In both cases - aircraft and cars - the primary goal was reducing weight.

But this term is not intended to refer to driver-assistance features.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drive_by_wire

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by kube-system on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:42PM (#30479781)
> The car accelerator no longer opens valves/injectors for the gasoline to enter combustion chambers.

The part you're thinking of is the throttle (which is why the accelerator pedal is sometimes called the throttle pedal), which controls the flow of air into the engine.

The flow of gasoline has always been automated as a derived value from this (and often, other factors) -- even when engines were entirely mechanical; this was the function of the carburetor.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by sidewndr46 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:47PM (#30480463)
That's not universally true for internal combustion engines. Many old diesels had a "rack" that was tied to a system of levers. Each lever controlled a single fuel injector. The throttle cable was tied to this rack.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by twofornone on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:48PM (#30481137)
Because diesels (even modern) don't use throttle plates. They control power entirely through fuel metering, as predetonation is not an issue given the the more robust cylinder design and nature of diesel fuel.

Some diesels use so called J-brakes which effectively function as throttle plates to induce engine braking, but they are exclusively for slowing down the vehicle.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by kube-system on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:51PM (#30480515)
That’s good context, but I did specify gasoline.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by KennyBlanken on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:34PM (#30480321)
> In both cases - aircraft and cars - the primary goal was reducing weight.

That wikipedia article is a lot of unsourced nonsense written by complete idiots who clearly lack subject-area knowledge

The goal for drive-by-wire in cars was primarily emissions reduction. Many cars "smooth" throttle inputs to improve mileage and emissions. In some cars "eco" mode exaggerates that smoothing, or changes the mapping of the throttle to allow for much more control over a lower portion of the throttle range. In others, "drive" is smoothed, and "sport" mode is not (unfortunately "sport" mode often makes the transmission far too aggressive.)

It brings mechanical simplicity, because cruise control can be integrated in.

Drive by wire throttles were notoriously unreliable for almost a decade after their introduction. They get gummed up, the actuators fail, the position sensors fail, etc. It's a laugh that the article claims they're "easier to service" - they're usually buried in difficult-to-access places and there's nothing "serviceable" about them compared to a true mechanical throttle that can usually be completely rebuilt.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:39PM (#30480379)
Correct. The whole idea was to decouple the accelerator pedal from the throttle using a sensor, a computer and an actuator to ensure that the right amount of fuel/air would be passed into the engine.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stoichiometry

If you don't do that then the excess fuel goes back out unburned. Multi point injection has changed this process a bit in that compared to the first single point injection systems the fuel is mixed with the air on a per-cylinder basis leading to better fuel economy and even more efficient combustion. This is also why these systems have air mass sensors, the amount of air is an important thing to measure in order to determine the right amount of fuel. Essentially fuel injection systems they have all of the complexity of a servo system, and the number of failure points compared to a direct linkage is huge, especially when you have a block that is split into two cylinder banks, V or Boxer.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by KennyBlanken on Saturday March 05, 2022 @12:06AM (#30564470)
Drive by wire throttles have nothing to do "ensuring the right amount of fuel/air would be passed into the engine."
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by theluketaylor on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:05PM (#30480694)
Jason Cammisa did a great video explaining how modern accelerator pedals work and why: https://youtu.be/gKsCHx5NOMM
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:32AM (#30479005)
If not for many years of pingpong I probably would have smashed into a bridge support. Crap car. The situation is a bridge with two steel supports rising up with a 2 ton weight on top to lift the bridge, apparently the radar return of the posts is such that the radar interprets it as an imminent frontal collision if you pass between the two posts. And then immediately hits the brakes, hard.

Second time was in a bend, with a big sign on the far side of the bend (me on the inner lane). Same stuff. If there had been oncoming traffic I would have certainly hit it because the car became uncontrollable instantly.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by 3pt14159 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:16PM (#30479529)
Wow that is bonkers. Do you think Musk is right about the audiovisual-only approach to self-driving automotives? I must say I rarely disagree with his thinking when it comes to physics and computer science, but that was one of the few times I thought he was wrong and I'm still not sure, but your story does make for a compelling piece of evidence.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by mjevans on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:27PM (#30479641)
If we had Scifi style millimeter wave radar (I'm thinking 'Snow Crash' (book) style stuff) that gave the computer a surface shape and 'signature' model to think about? That'd probably be the safest since it's better than human vision ever could be, though it'd still be tough since humans are analog supercomputers that are well versed in traversing 3.5 dimensions of space and the advanced memory and hazard prediction elements really help.

Vision based computer systems really need the persistence and object recognition factors. A strong specialized faked intelligence might be sufficient, more so if it's less distracted than humans.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by the__alchemist on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:12PM (#30480098)
I'd love to see something like Knight Visions. Even if it were just an IR overlay, in a way that looked natural, and was smaller/lighter/better FOV than traditional NVGs. The mm-wave part would be great too!
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by andi999 on Saturday February 26, 2022 @01:46PM (#30480449)
What I dont understand, since these cars use ABS, shouldnt you always be able to steer it (even if it fully breaks).
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:10PM (#30480732)
The car was thrown into a spin the first time because it was on a bridge with a very uneven and slippery surface. Really, I'm sure it was 'the perfect storm' for that particular emergency braking system but I would rather trust myself than to gamble on tech that fails twice within a year for such a critical function.

There isn't a whole lot of room on those bridges for evasive maneuvers either.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by hammock on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:31PM (#30479670)
How did ping pong save you?
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:36PM (#30479715)
Reflexes.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jeffbee on Saturday February 26, 2022 @11:49AM (#30479206)
On the other hand the IIHS says the MB C-Class has a fatality rate of zero, from 2015-2017, the latest data available. They must have done something right.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by function_seven on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:49PM (#30479848)
That rate is for the 4WD version. The 2WD version has a fatality rate of 28.

Now I'm going to assume that adding the 4WD option to your sedan isn't that good at increasing safety. Yeah, more driving wheels does improve control and will probably reduce fatalities. But from 28 dpm to 0 is going to also be attributable to statistical noise. (Case in point, IIHS' 2014 statistics have the 4WD version at 25, and the 2WD at 11).

Also note that the death rate is in terms of deaths per million registration years and only includes the driver of the car. So for the C-Class, which sold about 80k units in 2014, one driver death in a 3-year span would be a '4' on the rate. The intervals on this data are very wide, and every year relatively low-volume cars will score a '0' just by statistical chance.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by fredoralive on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:01PM (#30481270)
A factor to increase noise on the four wheel drive version of the C class is that 4WD saloons and estates[1] just aren't that common, it's a niche option for those types of car. Checking a UK second hand car sales site for a non scientific survey, it seems about 1 in 10 C classes for sale have the option (these ratios will probably differ between markets of course).

[1] Or sedans and station wagons if you insist.

Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jeffbee on Saturday February 26, 2022 @03:38PM (#30481713)
I don't know if that's really true in the U.S. where people have an irrational attraction to AWD. Looking at the pre-owned inventory of my nearest M-B dealer two thirds of it is 4Matic cars, only one third RWD.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jacquesm on Saturday February 26, 2022 @12:35PM (#30479710)
I didn't die either. But I could have. Those bridge posts are the diameter of trees and at least as strong.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by weaksauce on Saturday February 26, 2022 @02:45PM (#30481114)
these systems remind me of when i think it was volvo put on a demo press event thing to promote their new auto-breaking systems and the car just straight up drove into the back of the semi truck under ideal conditions. either it was a thing to drum up some news stories under the "there is no such thing as bad press coverage" or they demoed it way before it was ready.
Re:1.7M Hondas are being investigated for phantom braking by jjtheblunt on Saturday February 26, 2022 @05:26PM (#30482585)
which mercedes c class year? i had a 2008 and a 2010 w amg and they were awesome. i'm guessing you had some option I didn't opt for.