News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by dmitriid on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @10:42AM (#30429271)
> I don't think the vast majority of users would be able to notice the difference or cares that much.

Users do notice these things. They just can't explain it in technical terms like "i feel like this app is built with a non-native toolkit that is why animations are wrong".

They explain it as "this feels off" and "why doesn't it run like X" and "I don't like it" etc.

Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by mariodiana on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @11:17AM (#30429699)
I think long-time users of Apple's various platforms will notice, especially. I bought my first Performa back in 1996. That old OS -- especially up against Windows 95/2000/XP apps -- conditioned people to be UI snobs. If I download an app from the App Store, and something rubs me the wrong way within the first few seconds, I will almost always ditch it. I want a native experience, and I don't think I'm alone.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by Steltek on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:02PM (#30430397)
It boggles my mind that anyone invests precious time and effort chasing such a fickle group of users. Anything less than Apple's vision of perfection and harmony or you'll be dumped in a heartbeat. "Think Different" indeed.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by evilduck on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:59PM (#30431095)
The people willing to put up with mediocre and bad software aren't willing to spend money on it either. Just look at the revenue gap between iOS and Android. It makes sense that people put time and effort into pursuing the fickle users willing to pay money.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by raydev on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @01:02PM (#30431136)
> It boggles my mind that anyone invests precious time and effort chasing such a fickle group of users

This "fickle group of users" is eager to spend money, moreso than other groups of users.

Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by spideymans on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @07:51PM (#30436113)
Or, you know, developers could be thoughtful enough to create a half decent UX. That's not asking for a lot.

I'm happy a significant portion of consumers have been trained to expect better than the bare minimum in terms of UX.

Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by vineyardmike on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @10:40PM (#30437300)
Look how loyal those users are. If you can keep them long enough... they may develop their own loyalty to you.

Also they're rich.

Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by robertoandred on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @05:03PM (#30434529)
It's not "fickle" to want competently built apps made by developers who respect their users.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by skybrian on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @01:00PM (#30431107)
If you've been around that long, you know that Apple changes their UI guidelines sometimes and not always for the better. I no longer know what a "native experience" is supposed to be. (I haven't even used Monterey yet.)
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by dmitriid on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:01PM (#30433721)
Yup, the downfall of Apple's UI is obvious, public, and heat-breaking.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by mariodiana on Wednesday March 02, 2022 @04:32PM (#30533478)
This is valid criticism. Apple's taste isn't what it used to be.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by mypalmike on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @10:00PM (#30437068)
And then Kai's Power Tools came along with its completely unique UI and everyone loved it. And other developers decided to emulate that idea - that a funky UI is a differentiator.
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by sarsway on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:32PM (#30430770)
I don't think it's fair to blanket blame Flutter though. What you are noticing are poorly made apps. What you are not noticing are well made Flutter apps, that are almost indistinguishable from native apps. I guarantee you we all interact with way more different UI frameworks then we are aware of on a daily basis.

Some apps also fail by trying to emulating native UI so hard, when it would be better advised to just adopt a more abstract style. Today's flat UI is just simple shapes after all.

From technical a standpoint, Flutter definitely is performant, capable of delivering smooth scrolling and 60 fps. Your experience may vary of course, but I've been shipping an app with it for 2 years now and things been working out well. Can only really say great things about it.

Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by dmitriid on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @04:00PM (#30433703)
> What you are not noticing are well made Flutter apps, that are almost indistinguishable from native apps. I guarantee you we all interact with way more different UI frameworks then we are aware of on a daily basis.

That is, indeed true. So the question becomes: does the framework nudge you towards and help you with making well-made apps almost indistinguishable from native apps, or the opposite :)

Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by thehappypm on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @10:57AM (#30429460)
Exactly this. For example when I started playing Wordle the first time, I was like what is this keyboard this just feels kind of odd!
Re:Flutter is the most popular cross-platform mobile SDK by Drew_ on Tuesday February 22, 2022 @12:36PM (#30430813)
I'd wager these sentiments have more to do with performance/responsiveness than they do with whether or not UI elements and animations are system defaults. Pretty much every wildly popular application in the market has a totally custom UI.