For me, this approach worked when I switched from Novolog to Novolin R, which has a slower effect rate. I use shots so it helps match the blood sugar profile of eating higher protein and fat meals. If you use a pump, you can adjust your bolus to give a % upfront and a % over a period of 2-3 hours so that you can match the slower glucose production from protein. In Bernstein's book, he had some typical ratios for grams of protein to insulin that turned out to be pretty close for me.
It obviously doesn't solve everything but I certainly feel better when I'm at 60 and have 1.5 units on board compared to if I had 7. The Novolin R makes me feel even better because I also know my blood sugar can't drop too fast, where Novolog I could be dropping 6-7 mg/dl per minute. So I have time to react and let my body absorb some simple sugars before it's too late.
Just a personal anecdote, maybe someone will find this useful!
My wife is type I, so I have a sense of what you live with.
She bought a book, "The Insulin Murders", which looked at a number of cases where insulin was the weapon of choice. The good news is that it is actually really hard to die from low blood sugar, assuming good medical care is available.
Coma to death is > 12 hours, more like 24 or 48. Assuming other people are around, there is plenty of time for medical response. And treatment is easy, glucogon turns it around in minutes.
And I'm not sure a 20% insulin overdose would trigger coma. Definitely hypoglycemia, but blood sugar has to be pretty low for coma.
Look, I'm not saying it is easy, and risk of harm from getting it wrong is high (as you wrote), but risk of death is much lower than you might think
Yes, but the bad news is it only takes one mistake to do you in, and the battle never stops for your entire life. I had a fellow T1D friend die last summer from hypoglycemia. Wikipedia says (with a citation, available at link):
> In terms of mortality, hypoglycemia causes death in 6-10% of type 1 diabetics.
It's the kind of thing that hangs over you. Every time you go to sleep, you wonder if maybe you took too much at dinner and this will be your last night. (I'm sure you know this from your wife--there's a reason she was interested in that book--but the reading audience may appreciate the context.)
Except it's extremely hard to get medical care when your mind and body shuts down because of a severe case of hypoglycemia. There isn't always somebody around to call an ambulance.
If you haven't experienced a severe episode of hypoglycemia yourself, you really don't understand fully how it can effect both the mind and body, even if you've seen it in your wife.
And like the other poster mentioned, 6-10% of T1D's die of hypoglycemia. It's a lot easier to die of than you're giving it credit for.
If COVID had a 6-10% death rate, I don't think anyone would be saying "it's actually really hard to die from COVID".
> And I'm not sure a 20% insulin overdose would trigger coma
You can experience hypoglycemia without any insulin overdose. There are many other factors that impact your BG, and sometimes a combination of those will hit a T1D with a severe hypo, even if they took what should have been the correct insulin:carb ratio.
One of the worst hypos that I have had (Fingerprick said 1.9mmol/l which is about 34 mg/dl) was a 'Lantus low' which is not really an overdose.
You might not die, but might develop some nasty problems later on in your life...
Assume a 1:10 insulin to carb ratio (though I don't think insulin dosages have a strictly linear effect) and a meal of 100 carbs. If the meal, in reality, has 80 carbs, you've injected two extra units of insulin. We might expect a unit of insulin to reduce blood glucose by 30-50 mg/dl, so we've reduced our expected blood glucose by 60-80 mg/dl. If you target a blood glucose of 80 mg/dl, this would mean your expected future glucose is 0-20 mg/dl. In that case, you would die.
Now, the problem with this example is that I would 100% take action to avoid dying, so my actual risk of death is still minute despite having a lethal dose of insulin in my body at the time I inject myself. However, it's still a bit strange to know that, conditional on me taking no independent action, I'm hours away from death in certain situations.
And yet, have there not been a number of cases where medical professionals have been convicted of the murders of several patients by injecting them with insulin? I would expect that these patients should have had 'good medical care' available to them.
I have not read the book, but perhaps it is ignoring the fact that extreme hypos may trigger other problems such as heart attacks. When a condition becomes common enough to be given a non-medical name, as in the 'dead in bed' syndrome, then I you can't *assume* you will survive for 24 hours.
The risk of death might be lower than I think, but I'm not to be ignoring any alarms I get.
(Type 2 but insulin dependent)
I am very curious about gluconeogenesis. I am well aware of this pathway but have read a few times that glucose generation from protein happens very rarely. Have you ever tried eating zero carb whey protein in a fasted state? If yes, have you noticed a spike in glucose? I am genuinely very interested in your experience with gluconeogenesis as a person with diabetes.
First, I believe you're correct that gluconeogenesis happens rarely. More specifically, I believe it happens in the absence of carbohydrates in the food you consume. Since I eat a low carb diet, it would make sense that I experience gluconeogenesis.
Second, have I noticed a spike in glucose? Yes! I have to take some amount of insulin if I have a protein shake. The coffee has no effect, so any effect comes from the almond milk and whey. There's maybe half a cup of almond milk in my shakes which is close to negligible. We can probably assume that whey drives most of the glucose effects from my shake.
Third, why is there so much variance in my blood glucose response and insulin requirements? Here, I do not have a defined answer. One aspect may be that whey is quickly digested. The quick digestion may accelerate the effect of gluconeogenesis. Another factor may be the state of the glucose reserves in my liver before I consume the whey. If I'm in a state of ketosis, it may be that my body accelerates gluconeogenesis because it believes it's in a carbohydrate shortage. In this situation, the glucose spike may exceed what would otherwise be expected. There's a few other things such as exercise I'd include here, but I don't have a single definitive answer to this.
A final note: In some sense, I can feel/anticipate my insulin sensitivity during the day. I cannot explain this in writing in any coherent way, but I have decent intuition on what insulin dose between 2 and 4 units I should pick each day. Or, before bed, even if my blood sugar appears constant and in-range, I may anticipate that it'll go up and down as I sleep and eat/inject insulin accordingly. One part of this intuition is "knowing" rather a protein heavy meal will kick into gluconeogenesis while I sleep. Anyways, I can answer more, but as you can perhaps tell, most of my explanations are of the waves hands variety.
There are quite a few pathways for your muscles and liver to release "stored glocose". If you want to artificially do it, get a glucagon siringe and get the worst hyperglycaemia you ever had since your liver starts converting glycogen into glucose en-masse. Natural release of glucagon is also regulated by having a low carb diet.
If you have the misfortune of having those errors match up (and they will at times) they you eat something that overestimates carbs by 20% and a blood test that overestimates your current glucose level by 20%. Give yourself a corresponding dose of insulin and drive your levels through the floor.
Is this accounted for by product-to-product variation or package-to-package variation?
Here is the actual rule from https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/scripts/cdrh/cfdocs/cfcfr/cfr...
A food with a label declaration of calories, total sugars, added sugars (when the only source of sugars in the food is added sugars), total fat, saturated fat, trans fat, cholesterol, or sodium shall be deemed to be misbranded under section 403(a) of the act if the nutrient content of the composite is greater than 20 percent in excess of the value for that nutrient declared on the label. Provided, That no regulatory action will be based on a determination of a nutrient value that falls above this level by a factor less than the variability generally recognized for the analytical method used in that food at the level involved.
Reasonable excesses of vitamins, minerals, protein, total carbohydrate, dietary fiber, soluble fiber, insoluble fiber, sugar alcohols, polyunsaturated or monounsaturated fat over labeled amounts are acceptable within current good manufacturing practice.
Some products may just have variation. Some foods will be maliciously mislabeled with 19% less calories/sugar/fat but may have little to no variation within the same product.
Sensible dieting talks about 10% reductions in intake along with light exercise.
Trying to manage that by those labels would be impossible.
However eating packaged processed foods isn’t a very good way to lose weight anyway.
I lost 180lbs a few years ago by cutting processed food, soda and alcohol out of my diet. Didn’t change anything else.
I presume the carbs in veggies are pretty much accurate by weight a carrot is a carrot (except for water content).
My "solution" is to eat low-carb/keto as a "variance reduction" strategy. Still, removing carbs also introduces gluconeogenesis (the production of glucose from protein) as a factor to consider. The synthesis of protein to glucose also occurs on a much time different time horizon than the consumption of carbs themselves which has implications for insulin dosing and insulin type.
I could go on! But long story short, modelling blood glucose is bloody hard.