I want to expand on it because it's really unique and amazing.
For those who don't know, each episode opens with us seeing the crime being committed and covered up. We always know who it is, immediately.
Then in the 2nd act we're introduced to Columbo, and we observe him trying to figure out what we already know.
For all of the reasons stated in the parent article, Columbo is one of the most perfect representations of a "real smart person" in media. Another favourite of mine is Jonathan Creek
Also, I watch with headphones on, and it's amazing to me how much food people eat, and how loud they are, in many TV shows. Just went through Blue Murder (also with Caroline Quentin in it) and every episode there's one or two roundtable shots of the group eating... loudly.
But yeah, JC is good, and I'll be watching another one tonight :)
I agree with you about the picture quality. Black Canary from the DVD is really very noisy and grainy - to the point where I actually made my own "remastered" version by doing some basic color correction and digital noise reduction. It looks a lot better.
Some modern televisions have pretty good built-in modes for doing noise reduction and improving the color, try experimenting with those. (Just don't leave it on all the time.)
Read the closing credits at the end of each show and you may find a foley artist was part of the production (and therefore the likely person who created recordings of simulated eating sound effects, to sync with the filmed visuals of the actors eating)
The tech in those is a bit more modern (I think the most recent is in something like 2015)
Good show though!
Except that that's not really what happens. Somehow, Columbo seems to know immediately who the perpetrator is, and spends the rest of the episode just trying to figure out how to prove it.
One episode where they actually showed some of that is the one where the murderer was the architect of a high-rise building. He needed the plans or some time with the building authority to have something explained to him, and he was shown waiting in line for a whole day with all the people applying for building permits, getting pushed from office to office, etc.
https://columbophile.com/2016/08/14/episode-review-columbo-b...
For added thoughts on Columbo, here's a short breakdown if the tactics used to find the guilty party was legal in court.
https://columbophile.com/2017/05/17/what-happens-when-columb...
It's funny how much more character development shows had back then. For example Columbo talking to a parking attendant about something random that has absolutely nothing to do with the case. Or scenes of people walking down hallways, not saying anything, just strolling. I like the slow pace so much more than today's TV.
Real police work is not like this. I feel like the shows of the 70s were a lot more realistic. Columbo, Hill Street blues etc.
Even though Columbo was not really a realistic depiction of detective work, it did make it feel like work and not just competence porn.
Then in the 80s the whizzbang started with Miami Vice and its blue night skies, cops driving Ferraris etc.
The good shows these days take a step back from this. Like The Wire. But must of them are just fluff IMO.
Why in disguise? It’s just simply a masterpiece, not just as a detective show but also as a vehicle for the actors to enjoy themselves. It made it so much better watching the stars of the time do something they clearly liked. Everyone is in on the gag, the writers, the star, the guests, and the audience. It was more of the next verse in a familiar song than it was a show every episode.
> Conversations are done with no malice, but with that clear objective in mind.
At first, but by the middle of most episodes, he knows all he needs to already and is just playing cat and mouse with the villain, and the audience.
the character is not in representationIt is a learned skill that is enormously effective. The great thing is you can practice a little at a time.
That's where you discover that:
- he takes NOTHING as assumed
- he works A LOT (usually not shown on screen, but sometimes mentionned by him, and you can infer that a given piece of information took a lot of time to discover)
- he always starts from the ground up, asks (what seem to be) stupid questions
- All of his actions are here to close the options. Conversations are done with no malice, but with that clear objective in mind.
I do a lot of the Columbo way at work, and it works surprisingly well.