News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by dang on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @12:09PM (#30349276)
Also "disingenuous", which is a fancy way of saying lying.

Edit: that's not quite right, as throwaway894345 and xyzzyz and Sohcahtoa82 have pointed out below. It's also not quite what I meant (I was being hasty). The point is that 'disingenuous', like 'lie', implies intent to deceive.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by throwaway894345 on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @12:32PM (#30349699)
I think “lying” as more of a “your claim is outright false” while “disingenuous” lends itself to more subjective forms of misleading. For example, if I refer to a given protest as “violent” on the basis that a literal handful (out of tens or hundreds of thousands) were violent, I’m not really lying but I’m certainly misleading people by way of my characterization.
Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by pvg on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:14PM (#30350374)
Both imply intent and the common messageboard usage is a kind of pretend-polite way to claim someone is intentionally misleading when they might simply be disagreeing or just unintentionally wrong, misinformed, etc. A strongly held inaccurate belief is not 'disingenuous'. It's a tropey comment-cliche word that is probably best avoided when addressing people you disagree with online.
Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by throwaway894345 on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:38PM (#30350738)
If you call someone disingenuous, then yeah, you're being offensive. But if you call the idea disingenuous, then it's much less offensive. If you phrase it like, "isn't that a little disingenuous?" it's even less offensive yet (I think "isn't that a lie" would come off a fair bit more offensive). Using "disingenuous" and words like it, I've had a lot of success finding common ground or at least identifying the locus of disagreement.

But of course someone who is set on causing offense can probably manage with any word.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by dang on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:45PM (#30350851)
Ideas can't be disingenuous because they don't have intent to begin with. Therefore, if an internet comment calls an idea or an argument disingenuous, it's calling the idea-holder or argument-maker disingenuous. It may be a little more indirect, but it's still an attack.

In my observation, that word has the opposite effect of 'finding common ground', so I'm surprised to hear you say that. If finding common ground is what you want to do (which is great), there are other words that should give you even better results.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by throwaway894345 on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:56PM (#30350999)
> Ideas can't be disingenuous because they don't have intent to begin with.

I don't think that's required. If I call an idea "disingenuous" (or "misleading" for that matter), it doesn't imply that the arguer intended to mislead, but only that the idea lends itself to misinterpretation ("it seems disingenuous to suggest that the protest was violent on the basis of the actions of one or two out of tens of thousands" <- this seems about as polite as anything IMHO). But any way of suggesting that an idea is incorrect or inaccurate risks causing offense--it's a perilous enterprise and no matter which word you use, ultimately you have to lay a lot of groundwork to demonstrate good faith, common ground, etc.

That's my $0.02, anyway.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by dang on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @02:42PM (#30351595)
Dictionaries define the word in terms of human qualities (dishonesty, insincerity, etc.), so I don't think this argument is on solid ground lexicographically :)

The etmyology is interesting: ingenuous originally meant noble, which is also only something that would be said about a person (https://www.etymonline.com/search?q=ingenuous).

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by throwaway894345 on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @03:19PM (#30352071)
I don't know man. I've spoken English my whole life and I've never heard of anyone being confused about referring to an idea as 'disingenuous' or similar. :) Certainly no one (except you) has corrected me that it can only apply to people. Indeed, dictionary.com offers examples of "disingenuous" referring to ideas:

> The move has no political chance in a Democratic House, but sends a clear, though disingenuous, message about punishing supposed “extremism.”

> He would rather endorse someone with genuine doubts than someone with disingenuous beliefs.

And there are many examples in which "disingenous" refers to things other than people.

> The etmyology is interesting: ingenuous originally meant noble, which is also only something that would be said about a person

I wouldn't be surprised at all if "(dis)ingenuous" originally referred only to people but came to take on a broader meaning. This happens all the time--words are fluid on even very short timespans. Consider the verb form of impact:

> Sense of "strike forcefully against something" first recorded 1916. Figurative sense of "have a forceful effect on" is from 1935.

In only 18 years the word acquired a figurative sense (and I strongly suspect linguistic velocity--the rate of change of language--has much increased in the Internet era--although not uniformly across the lexicon). Considering your Etymonline link dates "disingenuous" to the 1650s, it would be surprising if this figurative sense hadn't developed in the intervening ~370 years.

Anyway, while I do enjoy discussing and learning about language, I have to get back to work. Thanks for the conversation, and enjoy your day! :)

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by dang on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @06:55PM (#30354617)
The first example does refer to people. That's the point of using the word "disingenuous" there. "Sending a disingenuous message" means a message you don't really believe. The second one is hard to make sense of without more context.

Words are sort of statistical meaning clouds—people have different associations and use them differently. Regional variations play a large role. I'm pretty sure the word disingenuous does imply intent to deceive, though, and it's a significant moderation issue because it's extremely popular in internet arguments: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que....

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by pvg on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @07:27PM (#30354869)
The second one is very much about disingenuous people (and their dealings), it's from a WaPo piece headlined Deshaun Watson is taking a stand against disingenuous NFL owners. It could change the league.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/2021/02/01/deshaun-wat...

Just like 'shut your lying mouth' is, in fact, calling someone a liar and not merely an observation about some independent attribute of their piehole.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by dang on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:43PM (#30350820)
Yes—there are subtle distinctions between these words ("dissimulation" is another, but that one hasn't become internet-popular). The aspect they have in common, as pvg points out, is that they all imply intent to deceive.

Since internet commenters basically can't ever know that about each other, they're not allowed to direct those words at each other here (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html).

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by diag on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @06:02PM (#30354106)
A phrase I've heard that demonstrates that concept is "hiding your power level"
Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by BoxOfRain on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:16PM (#30350406)
It reminds me of the House of Commons where it's permissible to lie but under no circumstances can your opponent respond by calling that lie out as a lie because that would be un-Parliamentary language. As a result, people twist themselves into all kinds of rhetorical contortions to imply someone is a liar without actually making the accusation.
Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by Sohcahtoa82 on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:43PM (#30350818)
I wouldn't equate them.

I would label a statement that is technically true but highly misleading as disingenuous. For example, the statement "Vaccines won't prevent you from getting COVID" is technically true, because you can still get COVID despite being vaccinated. However, it's misleading because the statement carries a strong implication that the vaccine is worthless, when the truth is that is the vaccine greatly reduces your chances of getting it, while also significantly reducing likelihood of hospitalization and death. The statement isn't a lie, but it's certainly disingenuous.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by tekknik on Wednesday February 16, 2022 @11:10AM (#30361821)
This statement is also disingenuous. Anecdotal but from my experience those I’ve known with COVID that were not vaccinated and we’re not hospitalized.

This is part of where vaccine hesitancy comes from, it seems like you’re injecting something that’s almost useless (I won’t say it is yet) as it seems those who are healthy (read no underlying conditions, known or not) don’t have issues.

Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by xyzzyz on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @12:35PM (#30349748)
That’s not quite true. Lying is typically understood as actively saying something untrue. What is more typical, especially in media, is selectively sharing true information, but obscuring other true information, which would present the narrative in completely different light. This way, one can manipulate people to have misconception about the reality, without actively saying a single lie. It is still disingenuous, though, if done deliberately.
Re:The “misinformation problem” seems like misinformation by dang on Tuesday February 15, 2022 @01:48PM (#30350895)
I agree, and should have known better than to post something so brief about a somewhat subtle point. More at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30350820.