This I took as a sign that the end is near.
That's the point of proof of work: longest chain wins.
Yes in a netsplit you can spend on both chains, but you would need access to both chains to do so. And you don't even ever have to merge them again, there could just be AmericanBTC and RussianBTC from here on out.
They will most likely just collude and attempt a simultaneous "rug pull" on the entire crypto market once the SEC announces plans to audit "stablecoins".
Trillions in "crypto wealth" will just evaporate into the electronic ether from whence it came
No government auditor took out Madoff, nobody wanted to touch it, because he was so popular and his clients were influential, and anyone investigating him would be sticking their neck out. That's the kind of risk that if you don't get it perfectly right destroys career and even if you're right you may get blamed and destroyed anyway for pressing the button.
Much easier politically to mop up after it all collapses.
Same thing here since if the SEC pops Tether then now you'll trigger automatic lawsuits from Tesla investors, and there's too many billionaires that are still true believers who have enormous influence over the government and will cause them to be overly cautious.
This has been tried. We've tried pegging currencies. We had the Bretton-Woods system. We've had currencies that were partially or fully backed by hard assets (most notably gold). For the record, since this seems to come up so often, the US dollar was never 100% backed by gold. Not once. Ever. Fiat currencies exist for a reason. Central banks and managing money supplies exist for a reason.
Ultimately a stablecoin is a form of price control between two assets. And just like any other price control, its ability to maintain that peg only go so far as how much money someone has to fight against the market forces driving those prices apart.
Not the case today, but things shift over time.
Anything that is not truthfully fully backed by assets outside of crypto land will almost certainly be affected.
Tether is just a temp variable for trading.
But, if Tether goes down it will be bad news but not enough to destroy the whole market. USDC is gaining ground pretty rapidly.
The key item here is "attestation report". What does this mean?
It means those issuing the report have no reason to doubt what they are being told/given. They haven't actually verified/audited anything.
Tether paid someone to issue some of these as well.
But everyone who didn’t just fall off a truck knows Tether is capitalized at maybe 30%, and there’s a lot of mediocre commercial paper in the assets it does hold.
USDC and Tether are completely different asset classes.
USDT is casino chips you have to buy to play the low-cap alt-coin slot machine. USDC has a de facto address within reach of the FBI.
What does this mean?
If USDT fails and goes to 0, people will lose their money, and probably no government will be able to go after the creators of USDT (Bitfinex?) and their "collateral".
If USDC fails, the US government can actually make Coinbase responsible. And that's a public company with a 51B USD market cap. As a holder of USDC, you could reasonably expect to see some money back.
Maybe, maybe not. USDC is not legal tender. Coinbase could easily argue it is nothing but monopoly money with a value of $0USD.
But the point is that the USDT people are already some combination of accused/investigated-for/sanctioned-for misrepresenting the amount and quality of the collateral, seem to have very little to lose by doubling down and to many (most?) people look like a worse credit risk than CoinBase.
Not being an accountant I rely a lot on inside baseball, but I know some whales and I’ve never heard Tether described as credibly backed.
See in particular this comment from a user who claims to be a former auditor: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27532670
Thank you for pointing me to it.
Now I’m no CoinBase apologist, they’re accused of stuff that would make Dutsche blush, but USDC is a completely different animal than Tether. I won’t take payment someone’s share of dinner in USDT or ETH for that matter, I will happily hold USDC for short periods of time.
Basically, you're just trusting Coinbase.
I'd rather trust a publicly-traded company in the United States which has serious accountants certifying the validity of their books and plenty of assets subject to seizure in the the same jurisdiction I live in than some guys who at least one state has already decided don't have the money.
I'm working on my HN etiquette but it's been a long week. If I act a like a fucking smartass, call me on it, and I'll return the favor. Don't be a smartass.
Agreed! But I'd propose refraining from just making stuff up off the top of your head that is demonstratedly wrong on every level. Don't be an idiot.
What part of "I'd much prefer to hold USDC than USDT personally because I think not all accountants are Arthur Anderson-level criminals" are you objecting to exactly?
Use your words.
Because of volatility, or something else?
The concrete reason is that I'm not (nor interested in being) a currency speculator, and so I do all my currency speculation in the form of being at least somewhat long the one currency I understand reasonably well, which is `USD`.
Unless you think exchanges are somehow misrepresenting the trades occuring or the state of their order books, but I think this fraud would be difficult to maintain for this long on any exchange that actually supports withdrawal. If you have evidence of exchange manipulation I'd be interested to read it.
How did you verify this?
Has your favorite exchange ever been audited by the SEC to confirm it is actually playing by theses rules?
I think this fraud would be difficult to maintain ...
I think it would be incredibly easy to maintain --- simply because no one ever audits their books. The crypto market is *unregulated*.
Because mechanically this is how an exchange order book works. Go to any exchange to place a trade and you will see this.
> I think it would be incredibly easy to maintain --- simply because no one ever audits their books.
Publishing an order book and the resulting trades is the entire point of an exchange. The whole purpose is to provide a venue where buyers submit bids and sellers submit asks that are advertised to each other. When they happen to agree on price a trade automatically occur.
If I go on an exchange and I can see in the order book that there are only 1000 USDT available for $1.00, and the next 1000 USDT are only available for $1.01, and I submit a buy order for 2000, I will break the "peg." However, since the majority of market participants will disagree with me, they will almost certainly quickly submit new orders willing to sell USDT for $1.00 again and the "peg" will be restored.
The "peg" terminology comes from currency markets like USD <-> RMB where China sets the price by law and there is no order book price discovery at all.
This isn't to say it's impossible for exchanges to engage in shenanigans. They can generate wash sales at no cost. But if they see you're going to break the peg, so they magically insert 1000 more USDT available for $1.00, and they support withdrawals, they are going to have to give you that money in which case the exchange has just made itself as regular seller and can only keep it up for as long as it is willing to set money on fire. And before you suggest they have unlimited USDT and so don't care, remember it goes both directions. You could also be a seller of USDT looking to find a buyer paying you in USD. For the "peg" to function the price needs to stay the same both ways.
And there is no way to manipulate this "order book", right? Just using my imagination here, but how about this:
Any offer to sell USDT for less than $1USD, the exchange itself buys it under whatever name they choose and then immediately lists it for sale at --- you guessed it $1USD.
Any order to sell USDT for more than $1USD just sits there unexecuted until a suitable idiot is found or the order is cancelled.
Meanwhile, any offer to buy/sell USDT at $1USD gets executed almost immediately.
By doing this they are manipulating the market and making money by fixing the price of USDT at $1USD. As long as all (or most) of the exchanges follow suit --- USDT stays pegged at $1USD --- even though it may only be worth $0.30 at maybe nothing at all --- you really have no way to *know*.You have placed all your trust and blind faith in these unregulated exchanges that no one ever audits. You *assume* that they operate just like similar regulated markets but no one ever verifies this.
You know what happens when you ass-u-me too much, right?
There's no trust or blind faith here, just knowledge of how order books and exchanges actually work.
Not true! In crypto land, they have unlimited funds --- just mint more Tethers --- which they have done repeatedly.
As I mentioned in the other comment thread, Coinbase and Kraken trade USDT, are highly regulated under US law, and are audited regularly. Gemini is also highly regulated under US law and audited regularly, though they don't trade USDT. I don't know where you're getting this idea that most exchanges are unregulated and never audited, or that it even matters as long as the particular exchange you are using is regulated and audited.
It would be really hard for me to believe that both Coinbase and Kraken are colluding to trade USDT at a rate other than fair market value as determined by their order books.
They may not be a party to any collusion. They may simply be powerless to prevent or affect it in any material way.
As the crypto market stands, the largest exchange in the world has access to unlimited crypto funds simply by minting more Tethers. At the same time, their trading volume alone gives them significant price influence over these same Tethers.
If they collude with enough other exchanges to control a substantial majority of the Tether market volume, any outlier exchanges (like Coinbase and Kraken) would just be along for the ride.
Coinbase does not trade what are currently considered securities by law, so its trading operations are not subject to SEC oversight. However, Coinbase has gone through the SEC listing process for its common stock.
https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1679788/000162828021...
> I think it would be incredibly easy to maintain --- simply because no one ever audits their books.
"We undergo regular financial and security audits by external firms. SOC 1 Type II, SOC 2 Type II."
If the majority are colluding to game the price of USDT, Coinbase will be forced to either go along or not trade in Tether. And since Tether is used in more than half of all crypto trades, refusing the Tether fraud would place them at a serious disadvantage.
As I tried to explain above, with control of a majority of the Tether trading volume, *you* could pretty much set the price any way you want. Anyone else who wants to participate and trade would have little choice but to follow your lead.
In addition, let's assume you have access to unlimited funds (by simply minting more Tethers) and *you* would have everything you need in place to control the "market price" and commit Tether fraud on a massive scale.
In other words, *you* would be just like the current crypto marketplace.
Honest exchanges could let individuals trade it among themselves using an order book at no particular price, which is what they do. I wouldn't call that following a lead.
The NYSE can't fabricate stocks they are a market maker for. Not legally anyway.
Just like all other non-bank fintech companies (like Paypal, Square, etc.), US crypto exchanges are regulated by FinCEN, the Bank Secrecy Act, and the Patriot Act, and are obviously legally liable if they try to commit fraud. Most other countries have similar money servicing legislation, and even if they didn't, fraud is still illegal in all but the least legally responsive jurisdictions. Committing fraud doesn't suddenly become legal just because your company is classed as a crypto exchange.
Now, just like there will always be a poorly regulated bank somewhere in the world, there will always be a poorly regulated crypto exchange somewhere in the world.
> Need an example of crypto-fraud? The most widespread example is Tether, USDT. The idea that USDT is backed by USD is a well known joke. No one really knows the full extent of this fraud but all indications are it is one of epic proportions. > > Yet the exchanges maintain the $1 peg for USDT.
USDT is a Bitfinex product. If you believe that "the exchanges" other than Bitfinex are in on Tether, I'd like to hear your reasoning. Most likely, the USDT fraud will collapse at some point, and the rest of the exchanges besides Bitfinex, along with the rest of the crypto market, will go on business as usual after a short market scare.
Yes, it does. Crypto isn't a regulated market. As long as the scam stays inside crypto land, it is totally legal. As far as the SEC and CFTC are concerned, you're playing a game with Monopoly money.
Elon Musk can and has openly run crypto "pump and dump" scams that would be blatantly illegal in any regulated market. The only response from the CFTC was a warning to consumers.
https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/7697-18
If you believe that "the exchanges" other than Bitfinex are in on Tether, I'd like to hear your reasoning.
The only way to maintain a firm 1 USD peg that everyone (even you) knows is a fraud is through collusion.
That's your opinion. I would be more interested in the opinion of a judge. If you can demonstrate that monopoly money has some kind of market value, and someone else steals it from you, then that's a crime. There is no legal precedent set that fraud is okay as long as it involves cryptocurrency.
> Elon Musk can and has openly run crypto "pump and dump" scams that would be blatantly illegal in any regulated market. The only response from the CFTC was a warning to consumers.
The CFTC is a mess, so just because they aren't successfully helping prosecute a specific case doesn't mean everything that was done was legal.
> The only way to maintain a firm 1 USD peg that everyone (even you) knows is a fraud is through collusion.
They don't maintain a firm peg. Tether trades on exchanges at market value, just like any other cryptocurrency.
Also, I find your "even you" comment to be a strange personal attack. Are you trying to say that I'm stupid?
The fact that crypto is unregulated is not just my opinion --- and I think you know that --- or at least you should.
They don't maintain a firm peg. Tether trades on exchanges at market value, just like any other cryptocurrency.
Pure speculation and misplaced trust on your part. The truth is you really have no way to *know* what the exchanges do to set the "market value" of USDT.
Are you trying to say that I'm stupid?
No, I'm referring to the fact that you called Tether a fraud --- "the USDT fraud will collapse at some point" --- your words, not mine.
That’s a hardcore misunderstanding of the technology! It makes transparent what until now has been very opaque.
As an example, what does your crypto "technology" say about Tether? Is it fully backed or blatant fraud? Please show the technology that provides a definitive "transparent" answer.
Crypto doesn't displace trust --- it misplaces it.
Instead of trusting the regulated banking system, you end up trusting unregulated "exchanges" --- where fraud is not even illegal.
Need an example of crypto-fraud? The most widespread example is Tether, USDT. The idea that USDT is backed by USD is a well known joke. No one really knows the full extent of this fraud but all indications are it is one of epic proportions.
Yet the exchanges maintain the $1 peg for USDT.