Of course it isn't as private as cash, but it is a step forward from mag-swipe.
Square has a good explainer if you want to read more: https://squareup.com/us/en/townsquare/what-does-tokenization...
I agree with the GP, this is a huge privacy blind spot.
There are multiple attack vectors. One of them is "why did I just get another charge from that place we visited last June". Another being "oops, we plugged our pin into a skimmer", etc.
Agree that letting Visa/MC/whomever know everything about your transactions is a choice...
Otoh if they pay you 3ish % for it, you might decide you're more than happy to.
Basically like privacy.com, but why use a new card per merchant?
So now Apple gets to know what Visa knows. Still, for the time being, they don't seem to know individual items. And many here seem to think Apple is more trustworthy than random anonymous data broker.
Though at least in the EU the mag-swipe method was phased out and replaced with a chip based method years ago. (A chip with secure module, requiring PIN if you pay for more then a small amount, or otherwise unusual.)
And as far as I know that method is still more secure then Apple pay and similar.
More recently, an additional identifier uniquely identifying the underlying card has also been added [1]. That one persists even across multiple devices and token deletions.
[1] https://www.level2kernel.com/payment_account_reference.html
If it's actually encrypting information (not just signing it), then that's another thing entirely, but signatures don't hide data.
But that's not necessarily the case either, as somebody else brought up the fact that identifiers ARE in fact passed to the merchant.
I personally like using a credit card because it creates a data trail I can use to review my spending and budgets.
Sure, if you prioritize anonymity in your transactions over convenience cash is much better.
OTOH, contactless pay with your phone is so much better than handing your card to a random server to make an imprint or whatever - and more secure/privacy maintaining than using the card itself if done right.
It's not a binary decision.
This already happens. My closest NFL and MLB stadiums do not accept cash for anything inside the park.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/23/nyregion/nyc-cashless-ban... - Note the date
I can't count the amount of times I've lost or been robbed physical bills. Never once have money siphoned out of my online bank. I don't use cash anymore, I'm all digital, and still use a VPN to watch porn.
Turns out different people have different threat models. My threat model includes my neighbour, my ISP (to a certain extent), my employer (again, to a certain extent), private companies like Google or Facebook, burglars, thieves, and scammers.
It doesn't include the NSA, the government, the NSO group, banks, or North Korean government-sponsored hackers. If you think you can defend yourself against the NSA, lol. Good luck.
For example, your credit score is penalized if your have high utilization on your card doesn’t matter if you never default on a payment, Low credit score results in low limits in turn keeps utilization high.
Bank knowing I defaulted on a card as a risk parameter is one thing, them knowing how much I spend every month and likely on what line items is not ideal when they can control a lot of your life.
Bad credit score can mean high interest rates , higher down payments rejected for loans that can have major impact on your life.
It is also likely bank or payment processors can indirectly sell our buying patterns for targeting ads.
It would be one thing if Credit Score for a government run central thing, couple of private companies having all your spending data without your consent at all seems major invasion of privacy.
Scoring methodology depends on sharing my private spending data to others, data that I cannot control being resold or have full visibility into its use. CRAs will try to charge you to "freeze" your credit or even see your own data!.
This is extremely anti-consumer, CRA industry did not develop for consumers or their protection, it is merely a tool for businesses to improve their operations.
Imagine if FB had a "social credit" and that is now used every social gathering as an eligibility criteria, and Facebook charged you to see your own data, that is how the current system feels.
On the one hand, we have threads about how browsers are fingerprintable and some app is using telemetry and endless discussions on theoretical zero-knowledge protocols and the importance of cryptography and Snowden saying this and that that get voted up to the top.
On the other hand, something like this comes up which is basically another step along the "no-one accepts cash" funnel and so now everything you ever buy with metadata is part of the borg. Like, you've literally deliberately introduced an MiTM.
I don't get this blind spot. Paying with cash is literally the easiest thing I do to reduce my data trail.