News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by junon on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:03AM (#30241267)
TEDx ruined TED, in my opinion. I worked for a person that did a TEDx talk and over the course of my employment learned they had absolutely zero authority to talk about any subject, let alone on a stage in front of a bunch of people.

The integrity died in the name of views, I think. I don't miss TED.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by smnrchrds on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:29AM (#30241425)
While I share your frustration with TEDx, it's important to note that the article is criticizing TED itself as being useless. It's not like TED has been a success, weighed down by the its association with TEDx. TED itself, according to the article, has been a disappointing failure.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by camillomiller on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:35AM (#30241480)
I think you’ve stopped reading the article too soon. If anything, the article says the opposite. TED has been an amazing success, just not in the way we think of it.

>> TED of course can’t be held solely responsible for the increasingly eschatological pronouncements of this cohort [the tech elite]. That would be, in a way, to buy into its hype too much. But as the most visible and influential public speaking platform of the first two decades of the twenty-first century, it has been deeply implicated in broadcasting and championing the Silicon Valley version of the future. TED is probably best understood as the propaganda arm of an ascendant technocracy. It helped refine prediction into a rhetorical art well-suited to these aspiring world conquerors — even the ones who fail.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by JohnJamesRambo on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:13AM (#30242206)
Wait, is that supposed to be uplifting? The Silicon Valley version of the future has turned out to be a dystopian nightmare.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by fknorangesite on Monday February 07, 2022 @12:37PM (#30248160)
No, it is not. It is supposed to point out that TED has succeeded at its actual purpose - just not the purpose we were led to believe.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by JohnJamesRambo on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @02:35PM (#30263395)
Ah I see. Yes I’d agree with that.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by ImaCake on Monday February 07, 2022 @07:48AM (#30244067)
I stopped before this point. Thankyou heaps for reading further and sharing this quote. I think it really nails it.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by smnrchrds on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:18AM (#30241788)
You are right. I read the first part and added the article to my reading list to finish later. But the conclusions of the first part mirror how I personally feel about TED.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by pjmlp on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:15AM (#30242220)
Like many things TED was fashion.

For a while it was cool for people to do such talks, the problem is that those people don't have unlimited things to say, so naturally when all important stuff is said and done, only lower quality content is left, with the expected spiral to the bottom until it doesn't matter any longer and is time to move on.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by ghaff on Monday February 07, 2022 @09:15AM (#30245107)
I think your first sentence captures it better than the second (though there's some truth to that as well.)

TED talks tend to have a certain style and pattern. And, like a given TV show, there comes a point when the particular style and pattern starts to get repetitive and tiresome. Once you've seen 50 TED talks, even if the 51st would be fairly compelling in isolation, it maybe feels like more of the same in context.

The fashion has mostly moved to other things.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by junon on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:32AM (#30241450)
Well yeah, TED hasn't been relevant in a long time. The way I see it, it failed years ago. It turns out, even seemingly smart people have a lot of sensational garbage to say.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by CPLX on Monday February 07, 2022 @05:53AM (#30243031)
He’s not saying TED was a failure at all. He’s saying TED was and is a propaganda tool of a newly ascendant branch of the ruling class and its fans, at the time, were marks.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by mayankkaizen on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:14AM (#30241331)
I too know a guy who did TEDx talk. After he did this talk, he suddenly became self-proclaimed intellectual authority on everything from Quantum Mechanics to politics to religion to what not, on his Facebook page.

He couldn't write a 3 line Python program or solve a high school trigonometry problem or answer a basic history question.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by snowgrove on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:05AM (#30242134)
I think Sam Hyde’s TED talk, or even just his introduction, is the final word on that group’s lack of speaker vetting:

https://youtu.be/9cflCyyEA2I

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by mayankkaizen on Monday February 07, 2022 @06:49AM (#30243519)
Holi shit! You weren't kidding.

Couldn't watch it beyond 5 minutes. But comments there was fun to read.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by gigaflop on Monday February 07, 2022 @09:22AM (#30245200)
Oh no, this guy? I just saw the iDubbz video about him over the weekend...
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by Inu on Monday February 07, 2022 @07:48AM (#30244075)
That was really funny.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by AcerbicZero on Monday February 07, 2022 @09:25AM (#30245249)
Haha, that was great.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by andi999 on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:30AM (#30241435)
So he is more of a 'big picture guy'?
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by danrocks on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:49AM (#30241581)
More of a C-level executive
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by rgoulter on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:04AM (#30241691)
Reminds me of the "company hierarchy" as discussed e.g.: https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2009/10/07/the-gervais-principle-...
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by kevin_thibedeau on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:28AM (#30241868)
Presidential.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by crdrost on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:11AM (#30241741)
It's just more touch and go.

At a TEDx I attended, wind powered beach robots dazzled, a consultant gave a powerful spoken-word poem suggesting that consultants’ reports should be written as poetry to actually drive real change... [I actually have done bug reports as poems, which was great.] Both truly wonderful and stuck in my memory.

But another sticks in my head for just being a weird thing in that forum: a woman upset after her uterus crapped out after three kids, when she wanted like 6+... Normally such a talk would be about dealing with grief around broken dreams and moving on with life, or about her adventures with adoption... but rather this was how she stuck with those dreams for a biological child even though hospitals were like “you have three healthy kids why are you trying to do IVF with a surrogate?” and eventually they got the IVF done abroad but it didn't implant but they have new schemes and plans. I'm not even opposed to her goal, just it didn't seem very TED-y.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by P_I_Staker on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:33PM (#30249808)
The core problem is with TED itself, at least that's the problem the article talks about. TEDx is a sideshow to the real issue, just like the show itself. Entities like Malcolm Gladwell and TED have done a great deal of cultural damage.

IIRC Holmes appeared on TED, not TEDx. There's been plenty of hucksterism associated with the main TED. The concept itself is a bit grifty. It's sugar coated glittering generalities and idea peddling (what if xyz were true?)

If it's truly for entertainment value, there's nothing wrong with TED, but it pretends to be something else. It pretends to be a beacon in society; a marketplace for the hottest new ideas.

When you listen to speakers like Gladwell (who I've heard accurately described as the walking embodiment of a TED talk) they are very convincing with whatever idea they're selling. After you peel beneth the surface you find the evidence is really shaky for what he claims, but he makes it seem like such a sure thing; settled science. In some ways I think he acts as an information distortion/amplification device. He makes claims with certainty no self-respecting scientists would make.

Also, this isn't talked about much, but TED has always been a gathering of the elites. You're literally not invited. I'm somewhat surprised it hasn't showed up in more conspiracies. They've been running these shows in a cult like atmosphere, too. This has never been an accessible program. It's where billionaires go to smooze and decide how to spend their money. You might as well be watching a Goldman Sac's retreat (but this is silicon valley, so it's supposed to be different for some reason)

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by np1810 on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:21AM (#30241365)
I agree, I recently found out about Lex Fridman [0] podcast and I am very satisfied with the experts in their field expressing their history and opinions, kinda reminds me of old TED... :)

[0]: https://youtube.com/c/lexfridman

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by bee_rider on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:46AM (#30241985)
Huh, I wonder if podcasts ate TED and TEDx talks' lunch. They can cover anything TED would, plus you get recurring hosts with fun personalities.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by hocuspocus on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:54AM (#30242537)
To me it's been clear that the TED talk format favors good presentation skills above anything else. And I feel it's impossible for the audience to tell if an idea really matters given such a short delivery.

It's much harder to bullshit your way through a 1-2 hour long podcast conducted by a knowledgeable host.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by np1810 on Monday February 07, 2022 @08:38AM (#30244626)
> It's much harder to bullshit your way through a 1-2 hour long podcast conducted by a knowledgeable host.

A great take, in one line... ;)

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by vaylian on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:13AM (#30241329)
I understand your frustration. But finding one bad apple does not mean all apples are bad. And this problem is not limited to TED/x.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by Broken_Hippo on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:58AM (#30242072)
If you pick up a bag of apples and find one bad, do you take that particular bag home?

Probably not. You would be reasonable for avoiding the bags touching that one, just to avoid the rot. The reason "on bad apple spoils the bushel" exists is because obvious rot generally means there is other rot you cannot see without further inquiry - and that those without rot will probably be tainted soon.

And that's the problem: Once you find one bad speaker, you have to be suspicious of so many more. It is probably better to move onto something more trustworthy because watching nonsense means you've increased your chances of remembering and repeating nonsense later.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by barbecue_sauce on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:13AM (#30242210)
I generally pick up a bag of apples without checking if any of them are bad, and then just discard the bad ones as I come across them later.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by tdeck on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:44AM (#30241546)
Sure, but if your brand is "apples worth eating" and I run across several completely rotten apoles with your sticker on them, I'm going to stop trusting that brand.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by Doxin on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:33AM (#30241466)
"One bad apple spoils the bunch"
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by pessimizer on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:16AM (#30242228)
The most bizarre transformation of a saying in history. "One bad apple" now means the same thing as "don't throw out the baby with the bathwater."
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by junon on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:29AM (#30241421)
Of course not, that wasn't my point. I've watched a ton of TEDx talks, this was my conclusion after that experience. It's a sentiment pretty openly shared by many, too.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by haasted on Monday February 07, 2022 @04:44AM (#30242454)
I agree. It's difficult to find a brand that devalued itself as much as TED did with TEDx. The vetting process for getting on stage at TEDx is vastly different, which provides for some rather ludicrous entries at local events.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by fortran77 on Monday February 07, 2022 @09:51AM (#30245592)
I dislike TED as much as Oscar Schwartz (the writer of this essay). But TEDx has almost no standards. The local private High School ("Harker Academy") has TEDx talks given by high school kids who use it as just one more thing to put on their college applications to Stanford, Harvard, and MIT.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by agumonkey on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:38AM (#30241497)
Isn't it the spirit of the era ? availability of everything to everyone ? you can all produce and distribute content, have an audience, be heard ? so that whatever group can monetize the attendence.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by lkrubner on Monday February 07, 2022 @02:31AM (#30241439)
My ex-business partner inherited $2 million, then burned through all of it on various startup ideas, and when he was almost bankrupt, he dealt with the stress by smoking more and more marijuana. He also promoted himself as a visionary, someone who could put into words how the future would answer the bright hopes of humanity. As part of his effort to sell himself as a visionary, he got himself invited to give a talk to the local TEDx chapter. You can see him here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8znQZ1RUckg

He gave that talk during 2015, the same year that Bill Gates gave the talk about the possibility of a global pandemic. As the article above suggests, Ted Talks were at their peak in 2015, but also TEDx was ruining the brand.

If anyone is curious about my ex-business partner, I talk about him, and my time working with him, in the introduction of How To Destroy A Tech Startup In Three Easy Steps:

https://www.amazon.com/Destroy-Tech-Startup-Easy-Steps/dp/09...

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by goldtownjac on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:37AM (#30241926)
Once I got over his… interesting… affect, I found this to be a pretty enjoyable watch. Certainly there’s not much technical merit to the ideas, and I definitely wouldn’t want to start a company with him or invest in him as a leader, but it was entertaining and at least a little thought-provoking about the future of media technology. I have a relatively high tolerance for bullshit though, so I can see how this could be unwatchable for many.

So, this is a great example of the ideas discussed in the article. Entertaining, a little woo-woo, preying on optimism, and ultimately, probably entirely inconsequential.

Your book looks interesting, too. I’ll check it out.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by lkrubner on Monday February 07, 2022 @12:52PM (#30248377)
That's just it though, he can be interesting. I worked with him for 6 years. I wouldn't have stayed that long if he lacked all merit. He has an obvious natural intelligence, and some creative ideas. Especially in the early days, he had a charisma that allowed us to raise more money. We did some really interesting work. However, it was more important to him to be seen as a visionary than a successful entrepreneur, which is part of why our projects never seemed to take off. Which is why I eventually left.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by dmix on Monday February 07, 2022 @09:25AM (#30245248)
Being interesting for a conversation is kinda the bar to cross for TEDx.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by legutierr on Monday February 07, 2022 @08:41AM (#30244674)
It's not an entirely uninteresting idea that he is presenting in that TEDx talk, although I can't see how it would be the basis of a business. It's very similar to the premise of the TV show "Devs" on Hulu.

I wonder how your ex-partner feels about the fact that this book exists documenting his missteps and misfortunes. Ironically, with your book, you have created a durable artifact of the type that he described in his talk, giving people a chance to replay a portion of his lived experience.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by lkrubner on Monday February 07, 2022 @12:55PM (#30248426)
Well, hopefully I'm fair to him, and note his strengths as well as his weaknesses. And as I point out at the end of the book, my version of events is not the only version of events that could be told. If he also wrote a book, a fuller picture of events would emerge, though still not the 100% pure truth.

As I said elsewhere in the thread, I worked with him for 6 years. I wouldn't have stayed that long if he lacked all merit. He has an obvious natural intelligence, and some creative ideas. Especially in the early days, he had a charisma that allowed us to raise more money. We did some really interesting work.

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by hycaria on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:10AM (#30241732)
What a strange and salty message
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by guiriduro on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:32AM (#30241889)
And yet, surprisingly perhaps, it promotes the content of the 'salty' ex's ex rather than being whitewashed out, or being 'cancelled' that you might expect from true saltiness. Like TED therefore, its a clever trick to spice up the banal and offer it for consumption.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by hycaria on Wednesday February 09, 2022 @09:05AM (#30272723)
That is part of the strange
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by dmix on Monday February 07, 2022 @09:27AM (#30245279)
Looks like they got a book deal out of it and that saltiness is heavily refined and packaged for public consumption.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by bobiny on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:52AM (#30242022)
Ted talk was fun though
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by Fememto on Monday February 07, 2022 @05:12AM (#30242674)
Funny when I read that idea of natural language, SQL and 2 million I thought: "that will fail" "what a weird idea".

Don't be too salty, the idea was shitty from the beginning :-)

Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by gbersac on Monday February 07, 2022 @03:28AM (#30241870)
Hey, I read that book! A good one honestly. I enjoyed it a good story about how crazy the work world can be.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by refurb on Monday February 07, 2022 @08:55AM (#30244862)
This may be the best post I have ever read on HN. It encompasses so much of Silicon Valley.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by jacquesm on Monday February 07, 2022 @12:20PM (#30247897)
To be fair, it was his to burn, wasn't it?
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by lkrubner on Monday February 07, 2022 @06:44PM (#30253152)
Not exactly. We began as a 50/50 partnership. I had spent 3 years developing some CMs software, and, to create the partnership, I was donating the software, and he was putting up some money. As time went on, his money certainly gave him an advantage, regarding our long-term direction, but there was the sense that I had given up something important on the assumption that we were going to work hard to build a successful business. So there was a sense that his impulsiveness undercut our original understanding. The same is true of the investors who eventually put up about $2 million. They took small slices of the company on the understanding that my ex-business partner had already invested a lot of his own money, but then, that investor money was put up with the understanding that it would be transformed into a successful business, so, again, his emphasis on aesthetics rather than substance did disappoint the hopes of those investors.
Re:What Was the Ted Talk? by jacquesm on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @01:42AM (#30255576)
Right. Here is something that I've noticed some time ago and which applies to your history, but which of course isn't very useful to you now because it all has already happened, but partnerships are best formed between parties that are at the same level of commitment and with aligned goals.

If not it is a fairly surefire recipe for disaster, there are some exceptions but the majority of the cases that I am familiar with the party with the money ended up either taking advantage of the other(s), ended up with a disproportionate share of the loot or was able to take more risk. This skews the outcome in their favor more often than not.

It is a pocket edition of why when you're born wealthy you are likely to end up even more wealthy.