News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by jsnell on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:56AM (#30205253)
Is it really nuts though? This should be a completely unsurprising move, given this is exactly what Play Store did in South Korea [0]. That's three months old, has anyone heard of a followup suggesting their solution is being treated non-compliant by the regulators? This solution also seems to be in line with what the US courts found in the Epic vs. Apple case.

> Imagine if in the past Apple would have had to pay 30% of their gross to Microsoft in order to be allowed to run their software on Windows.

Anyone making software for the Xbox has to pay Microsoft. Why is this different?

[0] https://developers-kr.googleblog.com/2021/11/enabling-altern...

Edit: Good grief, people. I am not pro-App Store. But jacquesm is literally claiming that Apple is nuts and that their solution will never fly. But everything we've seen so far in analogous cases suggests it will.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by Tijdreiziger on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:30PM (#30210919)
> That's three months old, has anyone heard of a followup suggesting their solution is being treated non-compliant by the regulators?

Yes, reported on yesterday by Reuters [1]:

> As for Google's plan, the official said the KCC was aware of concern over Google's planned policy of only reducing its service charge to developers by 4 percentage points when users choose an alternative billing system, and the regulator is waiting for additional information from Google.

> "As a result of any policy, if app developers find it realistically difficult to use an alternative payment system and resort to using the dominant app store operator's payment system, it would not fit the law's purpose," the official said, adding that this stance would likely be reflected in the final ordinance.

[1] https://www.reuters.com/technology/skorea-seeks-improved-com...

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by jsnell on Saturday February 05, 2022 @10:32AM (#30222039)
Thanks! That was great timing.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by schmorptron on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:01PM (#30210260)
Consoles are a super interesting comparison. In principle, I agree that they should have to be open too. On the other hand, consoles' hardware is nearly always subsidized by expected future software royalties, while Apple makes a lot of profit just by selling the hardware alone.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by thegrimmest on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:45PM (#30211940)
But these are internal details that shouldn't matter at all when deciding if a business practice is valid or not. If I want to sell a toaster (regardless of whether it's sold at loss or gain) that only toasts bread that I bake, I should be perfectly entitled to do so. And if users flock to my toaster due to its simplicity, predictability, and ease of use, then the fact that other bakers are upset about this shouldn't matter in the least bit.

Whether a toaster or console or smartphone is sold at a loss or gain is an internal detail that isn't even public. It's totally irrelevant.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by 8note on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:46PM (#30213751)
Once it's in the hands of the user, they have the freedom to make it work with whatever bread they want
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by thegrimmest on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:50PM (#30213804)
Well, sure, and you can try to and some even succeed in jailbreaking their iOS devices. That doesn't mean that Apple should be anything but hostile to such attempts.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by schmorptron on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:06PM (#30213997)
We've reached the first point in recent history where we're really seeing products with actively anti-user features at scale. Coffe machines that only take proprietary coffe pods, printers that have DRM on ink cartriges, and more. These are all on a much smaller scale than a computing device that we use for a significant portion of our lives, both for management and entertainment.

Another comparison would be a car that can only drive to restaurants that agreed to give the car company 30% per customer that arrives in one of their cars, and there have to be fences around it to make sure you're not walking to the restaurant next door by foot.

I'm not sure I agree with "I should be able to sell anything with any anti-features I want" anymore to a certain extent, since it does affect such a large part of our lives, as general computing machines.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by thegrimmest on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:51PM (#30214563)
Arrangements that subsidize a large purchase (printer, paper towel dispenser, coffee maker, razor, smartphone, tractor, etc.) by locking the purchaser into an exclusivity agreement for consumables from the same company (ink, paper towels, coffee pods, razor blades, smartphone apps, tractor maintenance, etc.) are as old as these have been feasible. This innovation tremendously benefits both parties. I'm not sure why you'd dispense with it really.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by linspace on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:05PM (#30213197)
A simple line of reasoning, like the Earth being flat. Big companies love it because it's the perfect way of avoiding competition, leveraging existing monopolies to build new ones, locking customers, using assimetry of information to hide true costs from them, etc... It has plenty of regulation against it, although it is not truly enforced thanks to deep pockets.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by thegrimmest on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:09PM (#30213258)
It's a line of reasoning that follows the original intended definition of liberty. Anything I should be free to do in my basement and sell to my neighbours I should be free to do at massive scale. There's no avoiding competition. If someone out there innovates the next generation of personal computing, they will eat Apple's lunch, just like Apple ate RIM's.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by clusterfish on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:47PM (#30213774)
That's just ideological propaganda that ignores the last 200 years of economic theory and observations.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by thegrimmest on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:58PM (#30213905)
It's ideological because this whole idea of forcing terms onto Apple to open it's store is basically socializing parts of Apple infrastructure and parts of its workforce. To me this is totally unacceptable. Apple's innovation has advanced the state of the art a great deal. This company literally invented the concepts that we're now seeking to rob it of. Why can't we just be grateful that the free market was able to produce such a marvel, be glad for the nice devices we all carry around, and leave the org and its investors well enough alone?

Also which economic theory am I ignoring? Didn't Apple itself enter the smartphone market by massively disrupting the existing players and forcing the entire industry to play catchup for over a decade? Didn't they do this without any regulatory intervention to weaken the market incumbents at the time? Why can't we expect that the next smartphone-level innovation to personal computing will come without similar intervention on our parts?

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by clusterfish on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:35PM (#30216919)
Lol sure let's invalidate all patents for starters, if you want a free market. Copyright next. See how much will be left of Apple's hegemony. Or just admit that regulations are a thing we use to get socially optimal outcomes and not get trapped in market failures like monopolies, duopolies, and negative externalities. Your fetish for unregulated capitalism is not as popular as you think even in the US.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by 30204604 on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:37PM (#30211026)
>Apple makes a lot of profit just by selling the hardware alone.

Do you suppose that means Nintendo, which has sometimes turned a profit on their consoles, should have an open system? Interesting take, and I wonder what, in your mind, the threshold is for "makes a lot of profit." I.e., if Apple cut the price of their devices to make as much profit as Nintendo, would they get a pass?

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by schmorptron on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:53PM (#30213839)
To be honest, I haven't thought about that much, and don't have the mental capacity right now to really think about the answer. It's a good point.

On the spot though I'd say that that would make Nintendo the ones that should open up their system in my mind though, provided they are making a sizeable (10% including stuff like R&D over the span of a few years) profit.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by dustinmoris on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:37PM (#30211025)
> On the other hand, consoles' hardware is nearly always subsidized by expected future software royalties

Legally that has no bearing on the matter though.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by vhgyu75e6u on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:38PM (#30211858)
It would be interesting to see the reaction if consoles had to be open to other store (my opinion is that they shouldn't since their are not general purpose devices per se). When the Epic Game Store appeared, the pc gaming community was up in arms against it because it was a Steam rival (sort of a tribal reaction) but were complaining against the NVIDEA GPU monopoly
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by schmorptron on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:56PM (#30213880)
How would you feel about a, say 100€, fee to "unlock" your PS5 and turn it into a general purpose device that can run ubuntu?

And I think if you put your xbox into development mode you can run your own code on it, like RetroArch although I don't know to what extent that goes.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by clusterfish on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:03AM (#30205297)
Why? Because how much you have to pay is determined by how much the platform owner can get away with. There is no fundamental logic to it other than market power. Why don't you compare to better, open platforms instead - desktop apps, the web. Why does everything has to be as shitty as something else.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by jsnell on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:13AM (#30205369)
I'm not comparing to those other cases because the question being asked was "what if Microsoft had been charging a fee", so it seems rather relevant that Microsoft has been charging exactly that kind of a fee for a couple of decades.

I hope we can agree that laws need to apply to everyone equally. For a long time, it's been fine for platform owners to charge e.g. licensing fees, for store owners to charge a fee, etc. Why is Apple different, such that they cannot charge such a fee while others can? If they're not substantially different, do we expect that going forward nobody can charge a fee?

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by stale2002 on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:55PM (#30211266)
> Why is Apple different, such that they cannot charge such a fee while others can?

The difference is market power.

Yes, literally if a company is big enough, then they should be legally prevented from doing certain things that anti-competitively take advantage of it's market power.

For video game consoles, I am less concerned about the platform taking a fee, because there are 3 major consoles, as well as an absolutely huge PC gaming market, and the PC gaming market is very open

Where as for smartphones I am concerned, because it is a 2 company duopoly, and there is no major open competitor, with significant market share.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by shkkmo on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:24PM (#30210821)
> I'm not comparing to those other cases because the question being asked was

The question being asked was specifically about windows, and wasn't about Microsoft being "good", but rather about how Apple benefited from platforms being open.

> If they're not substantially different, do we expect that going forward nobody can charge a fee?

That seems reasonable.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by elliekelly on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:09PM (#30211446)
Doesn’t Google allow alternative app stores to be loaded onto Androids though? If that’s the case I’m not sure the comparison makes sense because consumers aren’t forced to use the Play Store to install software. Give Google 30% of sales or have no sales at all the way it is for iPhone developers.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by wccrawford on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:24PM (#30212557)
Yes, but side-loading, either directly or through third-party stores, prompts the user with dire warnings, making it almost impossible for developers to realistically use that method.

The exceptions are hardware manufacturers that ship custom versions of Android that have their own stores.

If it weren't for that detail, or that Google warned all installs about the same thing (even from their own store), I wouldn't have a problem with it.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by warkdarrior on Friday February 04, 2022 @07:35PM (#30215676)
Alternate app stores, like F-Droid, trigger no "dire warnings" when used.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by 908B64B197 on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:22PM (#30211622)
> Anyone making software for the Xbox has to pay Microsoft. Why is this different?

Historically, writing software for the Xbox meant getting dev kits not sold to the public as well as access to private documentation. And there was a level of support from Microsoft game studios could expect. The deals between studios and Microsoft could also include co-marketing or exclusivity. Plus to get an Xbox tittle out you needed a distributor (remember brick and mortar stores) so it really was B2B. Today I wouldn’t be surprised to see Microsoft just going with the Store model and taking a very small cut from indies. But distribution is nowhere as hard and expensive as it was back in 2001.

I really don’t think it’s the same as Apple that advertise it’s developer program to individuals. Apple’s developer program almost seems like a consumer product (term and conditions are pretty much the same for every individual dev out there, it’s a flat fee).

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by PretzelPirate on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:03PM (#30211372)
I think that the Xbox should be an open platform. Microsoft has built in enough sandboxing and security that I’d hope they could handle arbitrary downloads while offering their store + online services for games that use their store (provide actual value for their cut).

It’s not like they make money off of the hardware, and their new push is in Gamepass subscriptions which people will still want.

There will of course be people who pirate, just like they do on the switch, but piracy is likely to be so small that it won’t affect Microsoft’s profits.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by threeseed on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:57PM (#30213082)
> but piracy is likely to be so small

Odd take given how rampant piracy is within the PC gaming market.

Losing a similar percentage of sales in consoles would absolutely make it unprofitable for smaller developers.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by clusterfish on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:52PM (#30213829)
Right because you have data to show that piracy takes away more than 30% of small devs' desktop games' revenue? Given that most pirates wouldn't actually buy it if they had to pay?

Smaller developers publish PC games just fine, you know, choosing whichever store they like most, or choosing to entirely self publish. This is how it should be everywhere.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by threeseed on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:17PM (#30214885)
From a survey in 2016, 35% of surveyed PC gamers said they pirate:

https://www.pcgamer.com/au/pc-piracy-survey-results-35-perce...

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by kmlx on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:24PM (#30211643)
> It’s not like they make money off of the hardware

microsoft hasn’t made any money off of the whole xbox ecosystem since it’s inception 20 years ago. it’s been loss making since day zero.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by vhgyu75e6u on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:41PM (#30211885)
Quotations needed please. You are not 20 years in an industry without making a buck
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by spywaregorilla on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:57PM (#30212129)
They make it up on software royalties
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by blinding-streak on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:38PM (#30211042)
I'm not sure that Google Korea blog post supports your assertion. It says:

"97% of developers don’t sell digital content and are not subject to any service fee for having their apps displayed in the Play Store or for any of the services listed"

And it mostly talks about fees going down.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by amelius on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:36PM (#30211005)
> Is it really nuts though?

I don't know. But I do know it is nuts that we programmers still support these extortionists.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by theli0nheart on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:27PM (#30210864)
> Anyone making software for the Xbox has to pay Microsoft. Why is this different?

It's different because Apple sells and markets their hardware as general-purpose computing devices. An Xbox is a gaming console and that's what it's sold and marketed as.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by SllX on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:35PM (#30210991)
To my continued disappointment, this is exactly how they have not marketed iPhones since the beginning.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by clusterfish on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:56PM (#30213887)
"A general purpose computer is a computer that is designed to be able to carry out many different tasks."

"There's an app for that"

Seems pretty straightforward that they did. Them doing their best to lock down the ecosystem for profit does not make the device non-general-purpose.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by gjsman-1000 on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:50PM (#30215205)
There is literally no legal distinction whatsoever between general-purpose devices and non-general-purpose devices. I don't know where this legal myth on HN came from, but there's no law anywhere saying Apple has to be one or the other, or that marketing has anything to do with what a device should be allowed or not allowed to do, nor does the law define these terms anywhere.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by clusterfish on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:28PM (#30216870)
Nobody's saying that this has anything to do with legality under current laws. Neither does whataboutism that this is usually in response to, for the record.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by SllX on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:54PM (#30217117)
The part of the “general purpose computer” that Apple does not display in its iPhone marketing is the “computer” part including the original “there’s an app for that” commercial. Arguably also the “general purpose” part in that a general purpose computer will run any calculable task, and App Store + OS policies prevent this or at least make it difficult and the messaging around this also comes out of their crack marketing team. Feet to the fire, Apple would probably call iPhones pachinko machines before they ever called them general purpose computers in any part of their marketing.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by pininja on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:39PM (#30211058)
What do I know, but I see Xbox as more than a gaming machine with its steaming and web browsing features, and iOS as less than general-purpose since I can’t execute code outside of a very narrow and curated api. OSX is general purpose, no doubt, but I’m not sure it’s relevant since I can basically run whatever I can compile.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by 30204604 on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:36PM (#30210998)
>Apple sells and markets their hardware as general-purpose computing devices

Could you point to what makes you think this? As well, are there any court rulings that indicate this matters when it comes to this issue?

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nirvdrum on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:58PM (#30211303)
Apple ran an ad campaign with the message "Your next computer is not a computer": https://youtu.be/awTP7IUY3uo
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by kmlx on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:25PM (#30211661)
that’s just one of many ad campaigns, plus a computer is not by definition a general purpose device.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nirvdrum on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:38PM (#30211850)
I cited one campaign that very clearly answers the question posed. It was not incumbent on me to go through all of their campaigns and conferences and earnings calls and whatever else. Although, this campaign was hardly the first time Apple suggested their mobile devices could replace a computer.

> plus a computer is not by definition a general purpose device.

What are we even talking about then? It's not like this campaign was suggesting the iPad would be a fantastic purpose-specific replacement of my TI-89 or my web cam. What, based on the context of this discussion, are we supposed to understand "general purpose device" to mean if not the colloquial definition of a computer?

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by SllX on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:42PM (#30212843)
I looked at that ad you posted earlier and refrained from commenting at the time, but if you take the ad at face value, Apple is claiming that iPads are not computers, or at least not the general purpose ones that culturally we refer to as computers (desktops, notebooks) and do this in both the slogan (“your next computer is not a computer”) and by demonstration, inviting the user to think of iPads as something else. It’s not an ad for tablet computers, it’s an ad for iPads.

Technically, iPhones and iPads are absolutely computers. General purpose computers. In fact arguably they are even more general purpose because you can easily and non-trivially manipulate them in 3D space in ways you probably wouldn’t even manipulate a notebook computer, which makes the inclusion of various sensors in the body of the device more useful to a broader array of applications. I will absolutely use my phone as a wallet in the way I never would a MacBook Pro. Apple has absolutely never marketed them as general purpose computers though even though I think you and I can agree that’s exactly what they are. Duplicitous? I think so, but it’s also the exact same strategy that game consoles benefit from today and in either case I think both Apple and game console makers are at the moment on solid legal footing.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nirvdrum on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:00PM (#30213126)
We'll have to agree to disagree. This ad to me looked just like the "Mac VS PC" ads, where Apple wanted to convey to you that their personal computers weren't "PCs", but something else, something better. But, they very clearly were advertising the product as a replacement computer.

They want people shopping for iPads, not tablet computers. I'll grant you that, but that's just a marketing gimmick as far as I can tell. This ad to me says "don't bother with another laptop because the iPad can do the same stuff, but better (and you might look really cool using it)." It's a marketing campaign, so it's going to resonate with people differently.

I still don't know anyone that went out and purchased an Xbox to replace their laptops, but I know plenty of people that have done so with iPads. And they're checking email, commenting on Facebook, taking pictures, editing video, surfing the web, managing todos, making video calls, watching video streams, playing games, and doing many other activities that they used to on a laptop or desktop, while Xbox users play video games, maybe consume media, and possibly deal with being called racist names on a voice chat.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by SllX on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:30PM (#30213546)
We probably will have to agree to disagree, but I’m trying to see the message I think Apple intended to sell and I think trying to sell a replacement for or an alternative to computers is a lot more in line with how they’ve always marketed iPads. The reason to look at their intended message specially is because this is the marketing gimmick that colors their PR and lobbying campaigns.

I don’t think it is severable from the manner console manufacturers operate either. They sell locked down computers with operating systems and license the software that can operate on it. In terms of functions and capabilities, they’re as Turing complete as any other machine, you just have to jump through extra hoops to run unlicensed software and they take explicit action to prevent this or make it more difficult.

The intended use is basically irrelevant. A device that’s there to operate Facebook or Spotify or a device that’s there to operate Halo or HBO is functionally still just an entertainment device. Where they significantly differ is that Apple licenses a broader array of software and Sony, Microsoft and Nintendo license mostly entertainment software (games, video apps, music apps and comic book readers). If you actually bought an Xbox to do the functions you could on a Windows PC, you would be disappointed but not because there’s some inherent Xbox property preventing this, but because Microsoft does not license Xbox software in the manner Apple does iPhone and iPad software nor allow unlicensed software to run the way it does on Windows. That’s a corporate choice, and because that corporate choice was made, it would be a bad choice to buy an Xbox for those functions or else some people might actually choose to use an Xbox to check their email or do whatever else they do on their PCs. If you think about it, $500 is not bad for a decent gaming computer that lets you get rid of your PC.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by scarface74 on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:39PM (#30212811)
So you would be okay if Apple just opened up the App Store for iPads?
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nirvdrum on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:22PM (#30213429)
I think it was pretty evident that computers were going to continue to get smaller, handheld, wearable, what have you. Apple didn't invent the space, they just made the product that got people to adopt the new form factor en masse. That's no small thing. But, I don't think they deserve near full control and a 30% tax on all revenue transacted on that form factor as a result. We wouldn't have tolerated it if Microsoft had done it on the desktop environment. We wouldn't have tolerated if Microsoft forced all purchases through their platform.

We've backed ourselves into a weird spot. It's essentially impossible for a new platform to develop in the computing space. Google did everything it could to kill off Windows mobile. Mozilla took a crack at it and failed. There's an illusion of choice, but it's quite difficult to get by without an Android or iPhone. That became very evident to me with the pandemic. Virtual doctor visits, check-ins, mobile passports, and so required a device running one of Android or iOS/iPadOS. My wife isn't fond of smart phones, but we had to get her an iPhone to participate in society. Companies don't want to support web sites for mobile and Apple's support for PWAs is pretty bad, forcing you back into their app ecosystem. Moreover, switching platforms is quite expensive and often impractical, in no small part because your purchases are bound to a particular platform (desktop licenses, on the other hand, often work across operating systems or charge a nominal fee to have licenses for macOS and Windows).

That's a very long-winded way of saying, sure let's start with opening up the App Store for iPads. I think we should do it for phones, too, but I'll take what I can get. For many people, their phone is their "computer" these days as well and as I said, I think that result was inevitable. We can argue about whether smart phones are general computing devices, but I'd argue the only reason they're not as "general" as desktops is because Apple won't allow them to be. Microsoft and Samsung both had interesting technologies (Continuum and Dex, respectively) that could turn your phone into a portable desktop that showed promise for what the space could be. But, people make do with the restrictions placed on them, if for no other reason than switching is expensive and hard.

Regardless, smart phones a completely different class of device than video game consoles. People run many of the same tasks on phones & tablets that they would on a laptop. Despite that, video game consoles are more open. I can buy video games from a dozen different stores, get them on a secondary market, and I can lend them out to people. But, let's open up the consoles too if that's what's holding us back with Apple and Google.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by scarface74 on Friday February 04, 2022 @07:02PM (#30215349)
Well, first to set the context. Most money on the App Store isn’t being spent on the little Indy developer. It came out in the Epic trial that the large majority is being spent on games, in-app purchases and loot boxes on pay to win games.

Now, let’s talk about the challenges on the App Store for the Indy developer. 15% vs 30% is the least of it.

1. You have to be discovered among the millions of other apps. The App Store is horrible for discoverability. Even if you do get a one day pop from it being spotlighted, that’s fleeting. 2. The value of an application has been devalued. Back in the day, people didn’t mind spending real money on applications. People think spending $10 on a mobile app is overpriced.

3. No one wants to pay for upgrades even if the App Store made that easy. I once bought an app - Tempo Magic in 2010. I hadn’t thought about it for years. But 10 years later I looked for it. Downloaded it and it still worked. The developer has kept the app working for a decade and through the 32 bit to 64 bit transition. I haven’t paid a penny more for it. How is a developer suppose to sustain themselves?

The only business model where high quality productivity apps are sustainable are via subscriptions. That’s why you have MS Office available.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nirvdrum on Friday February 04, 2022 @10:29PM (#30216874)
Apple's insistence on setting the terms of the sale is also problematic and all the more reason to support another store. I absolutely loathe IAP. The last thing I want to do is download an app and guess what parts are going to get unlocked when I pay for something. I'm in favor of having a paid upgrade path. And I'd love to see a trial option that wasn't tied to a subscription. And I think app prices are too low. It's another case of having made a few bad initial moves and then pushing the whole industry that way. The top selling app on the Google Play Store is a slot machine. This is not good for society.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by scarface74 on Friday February 04, 2022 @11:10PM (#30217276)
Let’s stick to the crux of the matter - people don’t want to pay for stuff. If an alternative App Store set a minimum price and sn upgrade path, not many people would buy the apps.

The only successful model so far has been subscriptions for productivity apps. For arcade quality games, the streaming services have a chance and Apple is subsidizing non slimy games via Apple Arcade.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nightski on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:13PM (#30211494)
The fact that they provide development tools and almost anyone can write an app for it?

Xbox is not open to anyone to develop on. It's very closed to new developers and expensive.

FWIW - I think Xbox should be forced to open up it's platform as well, not be used as a justification for closed computing platforms.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by threeseed on Friday February 04, 2022 @04:01PM (#30213133)
Xbox is very simple and affordable to develop for. On par with iOS actually.

How do you think all of the tiny indie studios build games ?

[1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/gaming/xbox-live/get-starte...

[2] https://www.xbox.com/en-AU/developers/id

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by scarface74 on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:38PM (#30212794)
Apple sells a device that is called an iPhone how is it any more general purpose than a powerful computer sold as a game console?

Heck most of Apple’s App Store revenue comes from games.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by Apocryphon on Friday February 04, 2022 @03:48PM (#30212967)
Even from the beginning it was more than a simple phone. It was at least a phone, an iPod, and a breakthrough internet communications device.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnrJzXM7a6o

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by scarface74 on Friday February 04, 2022 @05:21PM (#30214178)
But it didn’t have an App Store….

You could always “sideload music”

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by withinboredom on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:05AM (#30205323)
Just out of curiousness, does the Xbox have a shell like my iPhone? Can I ssh from my Xbox? I can from my iPhone, for all intents it seems like a personal computer (PC) and can do anything my computer can do. My phone wasn’t marketed as a gaming console either. I’m not sure comparing an Xbox and a phone is anywhere near the same thing. I could be wrong though.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by jsnell on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:25AM (#30205448)
The Xbox certainly has sufficient hardware and software capabilities to run a shell or a ssh client; it is basically PC hardware and a PC operating system, just locked down. If it doesn't have a ssh client, it's only because Microsoft didn't let the app onto the Xbox store. If that's the line you draw, then the obvious thing for Apple to do is to remove ssh clients from the store.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by meheleventyone on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:31PM (#30210934)
It has Edge on it so if you can do a browser version you can do whatever. If you plug in a keyboard and mouse you can gamedev on our platform for example.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by nomel on Friday February 04, 2022 @02:25PM (#30211656)
Imagine how well the xbox would sell if there was a PC "homework" mode, where you could just boot into windows. I doubt Microsoft would do that to their PC making brethren though.
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by withinboredom on Friday February 04, 2022 @06:28AM (#30205462)
Heh, that’d actually be entertaining. After that it would be image editing, then text editors, then, actually just delete the utilities section from the App Store…
Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by tehbeard on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:29PM (#30210897)
The previous gen had a developer mode which practically let you run Windows apps... All for a one time fee of $20?

Of course this was within their hypervisor and security systems, so you were kept well away from the games/dashboard/Xbox live.

But, homebrew and emulators could run pretty well on there, an SSH client or vscode probably would just take a small amount of porting.

Re:Apple will charge 27% commission for alternative payment ... by kitsunesoba on Friday February 04, 2022 @01:20PM (#30210774)
The latest models of Xbox and PlayStation are basically just Ryzen 3700X + Radeon 5700XT PCs, with the former running a Windows variant and the latter running a FreeBSD variant. They’re pretty similar in stymied potential to iOS devices.