News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by wgx on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:05AM (#3016760)
Speculation on the delay or otherwise of a future iPhone model is one thing, but claiming Apple are scared of Samsung's Galaxy is just laughable.

Apple, love or loathe them, created a complete vertically-integrated product stack precisely so that they never need be scared of a competitor again.

They built the game in which they compete with nobody.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by barista on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:12AM (#3016773)
He is so naive to believe that a dry subjet like a patent lawsuit can actually distract people from a juicy news of an expected successor to the most successful phone model in US? And that too from one of the most beloved company in the gadget world?

If that is what Apple's strategy looks like, it certainly isn't working becuse I see at least one neew piece every day about the iPhone 5.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by nickheer on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:11AM (#3016771)
Joe Wilcox isn't the sharpest when it comes to Apple rumours. My personal favourite is his bit [1] on why the Verizon iPhone wasn't announced by Apple (there's a great response in the comments which Gruber grabbed and put on DF)[2]. Apple's biggest problem with the iPhone 5 is that it isn't out yet, but that's OK because the iPhone 4 continues to sell reasonably well (ref. AT&T data showing it as the #1 selling smartphone in the most recent quarter).

[1] http://betanews.com/2011/01/08/why-verizon-won-t-let-apple-a... [2] http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/01/13/wilcox-claim-cho...

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by ugh on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:32AM (#3016810)
iPhone 3GS:

  IV:   7.4m
  I:    8.7m
  II:   8.8m
  III:  8.4m
iPhone 4:

  IV:  14.1m
  I:   16.2m
  II:  18.7m
  III: 20.3m
Notice that drop in sales of the iPhone 3GS right before the iPhone 4 came out? That didn't happen to the iPhone 4 in the third quarter. Its sales increased. (The iPhone 4 was announced two weeks before the third quarter ended and it started selling at the start of the fourth quarter. That might explain some of the difference, not sure whether that's the whole story.)

I think Apple is doing alright.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by z92 on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @05:37AM (#3016932)
iPhone and iPod sales is limited by production only, not demand.
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by jemeshsu on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:22AM (#3016791)
Apple scared of Samsung? :-) My guess the main reason iPhone 5 is delayed is due to waiting for iCloud. It might be for marketing purpose: building up anticipation to fever pitch due to the delay, thus generating greater demand. I hope Apple is making sure its supply chain is in tip top condition, or else we will see iPhone queue from Oct launch all the way to Christmas.

One outcome of the 'war' with Samsung might be Apple investing more in its other supply chain vendors as Apple is likely in the process of abandoning Samsung. This could only be positive for the industry as a whole.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by ryannielsen on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:17AM (#3016779)
I wish journalists were forced to distinguish between "shipped" and "sold" numbers. Those figures can differ dramatically, and often in very telling ways. Who cares if Samsung shipped 20MM phones? How many phones did they sell? How large is their platform base, in terms of real, honest users?
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by yardie on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:29AM (#3016802)
This is a redherring because the difference between shipped and sold is very small. Retailers don't keep more stock than they actually need. Except for high demand items and new products if it ships it's practically sold.

Unlike Apple, once the phone leaves the factory Samsung has very little information on where it will end up. They could call every retailer and ask for the quantity sold, but if they weren't selling the retailer would ship them back, ala Best Buy and the HP Touchpad.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by ryannielsen on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:58AM (#3016861)
http://allthingsd.com/20110816/ouchpad-best-buy-sitting-on-a...

At least according to this article, HP shipped 270,000 TouchPads to Best Buy. Best Buy, in turn, sold 25,000. Anyone estimating the number of TouchPad users based on HP's shipment numbers to Best Buy would have been off by over an order of magnitude. (Before the $99 fire sale, of course.)

So it's clear that, at least in some cases, the difference between shipped and sold units can be quite dramatic. Without getting the actual number of units sold, minus the number of units returned, (or getting some other stat entirely, such as unit activation/registration numbers) it's rather difficult to accurately estimate a product's actual user base. The best you can do with the shipping unit number is guess, and your guess is as good as mine.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by yardie on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @09:59AM (#3017546)
This is why I excluded high demand and new products. New products are shipped in higher quantities to meet retailer demand (ever been in a store that has exactly one new item?). But once the supply pipeline is flowing its much easier to estimate demand and produce enough to meet it.

This is something that Apple has been terrible at despite great marketing.

But all companies will parade the numbers that show them in the best light. Samsung isn't producing a lot of tablets just to dump them in landfills and retailers aren't stocking more than they can realistically sell in <1 months time. For the retailer it ties up money and floorspace. Apple owns all it's stores and can tell you exactly how many iPhones they have sold, they won't tell you how many Apple TVs they've sold even though they know that number. Samsung might be able to tell you how many tablets sold. But numbers shipped is more palatable to investors and developers. If they were getting a lot of returns (and early android tablets were) they wouldn't exactly parade them out.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by ugh on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @07:47AM (#3017168)
But that’s because the TouchPad was a failure. Samsung’s phones are actually selling.
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by rsynnott on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:07AM (#3016762)
Apple in not-launching-phone-until-ready shocker. Presumably, they should just have launched it in a broken state in June and patched it up in software later, as this works so very well for certain Android OEMs. I mean, look how well the Xoom did!
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by inflatablenerd on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @05:02AM (#3016867)
The biggest challenge I see for the iPhone 5 is a bigger screen size. If Apple do follow the competition/the demands of their users and make a bigger screen size, how are their apps going to scale? Either they lose the retina display branding and save app developers headaches, or they increase the resolution without doubling, making resizing of existing apps awkward and uneven.

Is there a way around this beyond adopting Android's flexible UI approach?

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by ugh on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @07:50AM (#3017173)
The demands of their users? I know plenty of people who absolutely loathe those 4“ (or more) monsters.
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by Steko on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @05:15AM (#3016889)
This silly analysis doesn't even pass the smell test.

They're scared of Samsung so they ... massively delay the release of their new phone.

If you were really afraid that you had lost the market you wouldn't take your sweet time, you'd be rushing like crazy to get the iphone 5 out as soon as possible.

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by chrisbennet on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @03:55AM (#3016742)
I couldn"t read it with my nook browser, to much ad cr•p popups in the way.
Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by josteink on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:00AM (#3016753)
Sorry. Didn't spot any of that in Firefox. Here's a copy & paste:

iPhone 5 has a big problem - By Joe Wilcox, Published 2 days ago

Apple has been doing a good job covering it up.

As I've so often asserted: In business, perception is everything. Successful companies often create positive perceptions about their brands, products and business practices. But there also is the tactic of misdirection, of controlling perceptions by getting people to look somewhere else so that they miss flaws with the company's products or business strategies. Apple uses "magical" to describe some of its products. Magicians are all about getting people to look over there so they don't see the secret behind the trick over here. Apple's patent assault on Samsung, and even HTC, is very much misdirection, so that eyes turned away from iPhone 5 problems.

I should have connected the dots sooner. About two weeks ago, I asked: "Is Apple engaging in innovation by intimidation?", where I explained the implications of Apple singling out Android creator Andy Rubin in a patent suit against HTC. Rubin worked for the Apple filers of an obscure 1994 patent part of the HTC case. The intimidating message: Anyone who worked for Apple could be guilty of intellectual property theft by association, and the companies now employing them.

In August, I asserted that "Apple is a patent bully", as it's clear that legal attacks against HTC, Samsung and others aren't so much about protecting Apple intellectual property rights but asserting them as competition by litigation. Proof point: Apple's IP cases are focused at major competitors. Particularly, Apple has systematically increased legal attacks against Samsung, as its market success has grown. Apple isn't seeking damages so much as to stop Galaxy S II smartphone and Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablet from launching in many countries.

Making Excuses

But I failed to fully connect the dots, as Elias Samuel brilliantly has done in today's post: "Apple’s iPhone 5 Dilemma: Is it Samsung Galaxy S2 or Android OS?" Samuel puts the patent lawsuits in another context: Apple's late delivery of iPhone 5. Of course!

"Backed by huge production of the upcoming iPhone 5 and cheaper iPhone 4S, Apple has revealed its fear of Samsung phones as they continue to sue them for patent infringements", he writes. Yes. Yes.

Look at how things really are. The first four iPhones launched in summer -- July for the original model and June for the others. But June 2011 passed without a new iPhone. First there were rumors of August, then September, more recently October and now perhaps even later -- as new rumors (if you believe them) suggest a production delay. But if you take a close look at the rumors -- and leaks behind -- they are really a series of justifying excuses for why iPhone is shipping later and that it's okay.

Let's be clear: Apple changed its delivery pattern for iPhone. It's a delay, and a big one. Potential buyers, carriers, peripheral partners, software developers and Wall Street analysts clearly expected summer launch before June's Worldwide Developer Conference when the company said that iOS 5, and presumably iPhone 5 with it, wouldn't ship until autumn.

Samsung Rises

Meanwhile, Samsung launched the hugely successful Galaxy S II, which has set sales records for the company and helped propel it to a close rivalry with Apple. During second quarter, Apple shipped 20.3 million smartphones, with Samsung following close behind with 19.2 million units, according to IDC. A year earlier, Samsung shipped just 3.1 million smartphones. Do the math -- that's 520 percent year-over-year growth.

Samuel rightly concludes: "By suing Samsung, Apple has actually taken away the public attention from the problems the company is facing, of late. After Samsung Galaxy S2 was received with rave reviews, it looks like Apple, which usually launches the iPhone versions in June failed to introduce their next iPhone".

Reviews are sizzling: "The Galaxy S II's screen is nothing short of spectacular", writes Vlad Savov for Engadget. Praise continues -- from the "onscreen keyboard is terrific" to "general responsiveness is absolutely exemplary". Savov concludes: "It's the best Android smartphone yet, but more importantly, it might well be the best smartphone, period".

Another: "The finest Android phone we've seen so far, the Samsung Galaxy S II isn't just a competitor to the current iPhone. It competes with the next iPhone", writes Sascha Segan for PC Mag.com, giving the smartphone an "Editor's Choice" rating. That last statement is the clincher. Samsung already is one generation ahead of Apple.

Apple's Indecision

Samuel emphasizes:

    As most predictions point towards two models being produced -- 
    iPhone 4S and iPhone 5 -- it is becoming evidently clear that the
    iPhone 4S which should have been introduced earlier would have lost
    the appeal of its iPhone fans had it been released along side Galaxy S2.
    Hence, Apple’s rampant rumor that the iPhone 5 prototype was lost in a 
    bar and suing Samsung paved the way to deflect the public curiosity from
    the company’s actual issues.
The IP attacks against Samsung make the South Korean electronics giant appear to be the bad guy -- a copycat of Apple's good work. But the lawsuits serve another purpose, generating news about Apple vs Samsung rather than Samsung the successful competitor vs Apple the suddenly indecisive. Seemingly every day, this misdirection keeps pageview-hungry blogs and news sites writing about the lawsuits rather than asking the big question: Why hasn't iPhone shipped yet?

Apple is undergoing a major leadership change, which occurred during the late-stages of iPhone 5 development. What? You think Steve Jobs gave Apple's board or new CEO Tim Cook no advance notice? Surely, his eventual resignation, and ongoing health problems impacted his participation in the iPhone development process. Meanwhile, Samsung emerged as a sudden, unexpected competitor.

The lawsuits are as much, if not more, about misdirection as they are enforcing Apple patent rights. Apple is grappling with co-related problems: A serious smartphone competitor's emergence and unfortunately-timed leadership change. iPhone 5 will be the first major Apple product launch of the post-Steve Jobs era. Is misdirection really the measure of executive execution?

Re:iPhone 5 has a big problem by cubicle67 on Tuesday September 20, 2011 @04:02AM (#3016755)
you didn't miss much at all; just rambling conjecture

tl;dr - iPhone5 hasn't shipped yet, so it's obviously been delayed and delayed again, and Apple's legal assault on Samsung is because they're scared of the Galaxy S II. Oh, and if he were boss of Apple he'd have done X, Y and Z differently.