News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by csours on Sunday January 30, 2022 @04:26PM (#30141282)
> "The problem isn’t really that complicated: originally the defroster icon was visible on the bottom. With the latest December 2021 update it is now hidden behind the temperature indicator. Tapping the temperature brings up a sub-window with the defroster icon."

Even after reading that, I had to look at the pictures again, and read the paragraph again to find where you are supposed to tap. When they simplified the UI, they also removed the degrees symbol and the fan.

Seeing as how 60-70 are both reasonable temperatures in Fahrenheit and speeds in miles per hour, it is not at all clear at a glance what that number means.

(Disclosure, I work for GM)

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by mortenjorck on Sunday January 30, 2022 @04:56PM (#30141547)
> When they simplified the UI, they also removed the degrees symbol and the fan.

This, I believe, is the real point of failure. The value of reorganizing the icons into sub-menus can be debated, but some of the details that were removed in the course of this change appear to have been critical.

There is a concept in UX design called "information scent" – the combination of spatial, contextual, and cultural cues that clue a user in to where they can find what they're looking for. Simply keeping the fan icon next to the temperature display/button might have been enough to make the mental connection for the OP (and likely countless others).

Of course, this is the kind of thing that tends to shake out in user testing, and I'm very surprised that this appears not to have shown up in the testing I would assume Tesla must do with any change to the dashboard, certainly one this fundamental.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by Smoosh on Sunday January 30, 2022 @05:29PM (#30141892)
I somewhat disagree. My brain does not see a climate control button and think "that button which can control fan speed and cabin temperature probably also controls the weakly-related function of window demisting".

I would have no trouble adapting one I knew, but I doubt that I would find it for myself. And relying upon users discovering where functions are located by randomly pressing buttons is a bad UX/interface for a vehicle IMO.

EDIT: Or how about this one as in my 2000 model S4: http://www.2040-parts.com/_content/items/images/50/340150/00...

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by bener on Sunday January 30, 2022 @11:17PM (#30144421)
I agree with all of this, but the assertion that some are making that the window demisting is weakly related to the climate control system seems very odd.

It's literally a function of the climate control system, and is almost always part of the same set of buttons as temp/fans etc in a car with hard buttons.

When you push the demist button, air is directed to the windscreen, by the same system that directs air to your face or feet.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by avianlyric on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:10AM (#30146434)
I can understand why people would consider window de-misting weakly related to climate control.

The use of climate control to de-mist a windscreen is pure implementation detail, and I don’t think the Model 3 even uses climate control for de-misting, instead relying on resistive heaters embedded in the windscreen.

Personally I associate climate control and the temperature setting with personal comfort. But de-misting is a core driving control, and sits along side wipers, lights, fog lights etc. I use all those to drive safely, and expect them to be within easy reach of the driver and readily available. Climate I’m happy to have in a sub-menu, because I can always wait to adjust the temperature if I’m dealing with tricky road conditions, same doesn’t apply to de-fogging equipment (which may, or may not, involve the climate control).

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by MBCook on Sunday January 30, 2022 @04:46PM (#30141455)
I read the description and the whole article too.

I don’t think I would have EVER tapped on the temperature without reading about it somewhere.

It doesn’t look tappable, as the article says. It’s not a common thing to tap on in other systems I’m aware of.

I think the writer’s guess of the car icon is excellent. That probably would have been my first guess too.

(I’ve also never used a Tesla)

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by bagels on Sunday January 30, 2022 @06:33PM (#30142424)
This was my reaction as well when the update happened.

I had foggy windows and had to watch a youtube video to figure it out before I could drive the car.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by sn1de on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:46PM (#30153228)
lol'd at this one. i have a new tv, I have gone to youtube several times now to figure stuff out, and I am well versed in a/v.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by a9h74j on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:37AM (#30145225)
Well, that's one path to monetizing your UX.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by masklinn on Sunday January 30, 2022 @05:24PM (#30141837)
> Seeing as how 60-70 are both reasonable temperatures in Fahrenheit and speeds in miles per hour, it is not at all clear at a glance what that number means.

I would not even consider the speed being on the center console so I’d have assumed it would be the temperature either way.

However in all the cars I’ve used that would either be completely inanimate (as affordance as it would be easy to hit when trying to increase or decrease the temperature), or it would lead to extended climate control configuration (e.g. vent speed, multi-zone temps, …).

I’d never think of looking for the defroster there though: while defrosting uses the same hardware as climate control (heating and vents), it’s not actually the same function.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by borski on Sunday January 30, 2022 @05:38PM (#30141974)
What’s funny is… the center screen is exactly where the speed is, as in the Model 3 there is no other screen. So this is a completely legitimate confusion.

https://cdn.carbuzz.com/gallery-images/original/270000/800/2...

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by masklinn on Monday January 31, 2022 @02:50AM (#30145559)
Oh god, today I learned teslas don’t have a driver gauge cluster, what the ever living fuck?
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by kwhitefoot on Monday January 31, 2022 @07:52AM (#30147364)
Model S and X have an instrument cluster directly in front of the driver, the 3 and Y do not.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by ulrikrasmussen on Monday January 31, 2022 @12:23AM (#30144823)
> I would not even consider the speed being on the center console so I’d have assumed it would be the temperature either way.

When I saw it in the article, I actually initially assumed that it was the speed set for cruise control, as it lacked a degree symbol and had up/down symbols suggesting that it can be adjusted in increments. The up/down symbols suggests to me that it cannot be tapped to access other functionality, but that I should tap the arrow to adjust the number.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by iamevn on Monday January 31, 2022 @01:22AM (#30145163)
did not realize you had to look to the side to see your current speed in a Tesla, that seems really odd
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by bener on Sunday January 30, 2022 @11:19PM (#30144441)
But the demister is in the same section as the climate control for just about any car with hard buttons, it's literally part of the system.

The UX sucks, but if you did know where climate control features are hidden, why would you not assume the demister function is elsewhere?

UX is interesting because what is seemingly common sense to me (demister = climate control) is totally not to others.

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by avianlyric on Monday January 31, 2022 @05:12AM (#30146448)
Cars like the model 3 use resistive heaters built into the windscreen to de-mist, so hitting that button doesn’t always result in the climate control running full tilt.
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by jiehong on Sunday January 30, 2022 @06:14PM (#30142261)
I didn’t even realise it could be a temperature, as it has no units, and temperatures are in Celsius over here: 70 is just not possible, unless it’s about the engine oil temperature…
Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by yumraj on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:43PM (#30142989)
> Seeing as how 60-70 are both reasonable temperatures in Fahrenheit and speeds in miles per hour, it is not at all clear at a glance what that number means.

Maybe some brainiac at Tesla thought that you can just accelerate/brake to figure that out. :D

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by zoomablemind on Sunday January 30, 2022 @09:48PM (#30143920)
> ...Seeing as how 60-70 are both reasonable temperatures in Fahrenheit and speeds in miles per hour, it is not at all clear at a glance what that number means.

In my view, the actual cabin temp reading is not of such importance to be on the main view panel as such. Maybe just some +/- warm/cold controls. I'm not into measurements, just immediate comfort.

If needed, then, sure, detailed info/climate subscreen.

But defroster/defogger button must be visible, just for the sake of "least surprise" principle!

Re:A UX designer walks into a Tesla Bar by dbbk on Monday January 31, 2022 @08:38AM (#30147706)
If my mum owned this car and it updated overnight to this UI, I'm very concerned it could actually kill her. This is absolutely insane.