News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:19PM (#30132664)
Young and Mitchell pulling their music is literally freedom of speech (free expression). Neil Young can do whatever he wants with his content (speech), just like Rogan. This is competition in the free marketplace of ideas.

You're absolutely entitled to your opinion on these actions and you're free to support Spotify or Young or Mitchell or any combination of the three. But there is no "freedom of speech" side here.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:25PM (#30132722)
Yeah, for clarity Young and Mitchell are totally within their right to pull their music as an exercise of their speech and I’m fine with that.

What I find distasteful is the framing of “Rogan or me” as a way to pressure Spotify to pull Rogan from the platform.

Sure Spotify could do that, but they shouldn’t.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:33PM (#30132795)
Why shouldn't they? Forget the names and the details of this situation for a moment.

Spotify is a business that offers a catalog of content for a fee. Their value proposition is that they provide content people want to consume. Perhaps some content has fallen out of favor for some reason. Could be objectionable or just stale, public opinion is always shifting. If someone with more appealing content comes along and says "you have to get rid of that other thing in order to distribute my content" then how is there some moral choice Spotify has to make? They can do anything they want, and as a business they will probably choose based on what will make them money. This is a proxy for doing the thing that best aligns with their customer's interests. It is impossible for any one organization to satisfy everyone's opinions. This is literally the point of freedom of expression.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:40PM (#30132863)
Well in this specific case a couple of easy reasons.

Rogan’s deal was $100M which is way more money than Young. So if it’s a business move than keeping Rogan is the obvious choice as he provides way more value to Spotify.

I care less about that though and more about the principled position here. In this case I think they’re the same.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:48PM (#30132933)
And I don't think your principles are sound. We are also participating in a marketplace of ideas. I'm not buying what you are selling. You are free to continue as you are, as am I.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:00PM (#30133044)
I think private companies/platforms are able to exercise their speech in order to decide who is or isn’t on them.

Keeping or removing Rogan is an exercise of their speech and within their right to decide.

Still, I think it’s generally a bad idea to remove someone because of this kind of pressure. In Rogan’s specific case I also think it would be the wrong decision.

I’m against internet cancel mobs as a general rule.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:12PM (#30133132)
> Still, I think it’s generally a bad idea to remove someone because of this kind of pressure.

I can't agree with this in general. I can imagine a situation where it may be reasonable so I wouldn't tie my hands. In fact making this decision on a case by case basis is the business Spotify is in.

> In Rogan’s specific case I also think it would be the wrong decision.

Sure but that's just this case, it's not a fundamental question of freedom of expression. This is what I mean when I say "there is no freedom of speech position". Literally everyone involved including Spotify, Rogan, Young, Mitchell, you, me, and anyone who reads and decides to reply or not is exercising their right to free expression.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:16PM (#30133165)
In a strictly technical sense I agree.

In a practical sense, one side is arguing to suppress someone’s ability to speak/express themselves via a popular platform and one side is not.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:33PM (#30133276)
We are triggering HN's flamewar algorithm so this is my last reply. I have not argued the merits of this case at all. I don't really care about it to be honest. You supported your opinions on this case in terms of being in favor of freedom of speech. I don't think that is a sound framing. You have stated opinions as is your right, that doesn't mean whoever disagrees with you opposes freedom of speech in any way.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by white_dragon88 on Sunday January 30, 2022 @07:29AM (#30136576)
What’s the difference between being against what they’re doing and boycotting a product? Both involve the withdrawal of participating in that business’ ecosystem as an act of protest. To continue to involve oneself with that business is to tacitly approve what that business does and doesn’t do. How does that rub you the wrong way?
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by 28304283409234 on Sunday January 30, 2022 @04:34AM (#30135368)
> Why shouldn't they?

"I will not defend your opinion, but I will defend your right to express it." Something along those lines.

With these actions,Joni and Neil say: "I will not defend your right to express them, in fact I will try to stop you from expressing it."

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by 28304283409234 on Sunday January 30, 2022 @04:34AM (#30135365)
> Why shouldn't they?

"I will not defend your opinion, but I will defend your right to express it." Something along those lines.

With these actions,Joni and Neil are saying: "I will not defend your right to express them, in fact I will try to stop you from expressing it."

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:29PM (#30132761)
It wasn't an ultimatum. Young directed his management to pull his music and explained why.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:35PM (#30132817)
"I am doing this because Spotify is spreading fake information about vaccines – potentially causing death to those who believe the disinformation being spread by them ... They can have Rogan or Young. Not both."

I read this as if you want me get rid of him, but I’ll paste it here for clarity. Others may see it differently.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:38PM (#30132843)
You left out the important part. "I want you to let Spotify know immediately TODAY that I want all my music off their platform". Probably he would reconsider if they dropped Rogan. He didn't expect it or ask.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:10PM (#30133115)
I honestly don’t think that matters? He said pull my music and explicitly said you can have one of us not both.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:17PM (#30133169)
So he should pull his music and tell no one why?
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by AnimalMuppet on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:05PM (#30133473)
Not if I understand the chronology correctly. If I understand correctly (and I may not), Young gave his "me or Rogan" statement to Spotify (or maybe indirectly, simply making a public pronouncement). Spotify didn't pull Rogan's content, so a couple of days later, then Young pulled his content off of Spotify.

As I said, my understanding. And I haven't gone groveling through the back news items to prove it. Just my recollection of how I heard it reported over a few days.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:29AM (#30134627)
Monday Young wrote a letter to his management and posted it on his blog briefly. It was what we quoted. Wednesday Spotify confirmed his music was being removed.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:25PM (#30133233)
Imo he shouldn’t pull it.

If he is uncomfortable sharing the platform so wants to remove his music fine, I’d just say that without the “you can’t have both of us” implication.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:32PM (#30133271)
> Imo he shouldn’t pull it.

Why not?

> If he is uncomfortable sharing the platform so wants to remove his music fine, I’d just say that without the “you can’t have both of us” implication.

The 1st part implies the 2nd.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:51PM (#30133392)
I don’t think pulling his music is effective in persuading people he wants to persuade (likely this stunt has the opposite effect), but I also think it’s better to engage in good faith than just argue to suppress speech.

You can’t always if the other party won’t engage in good faith, but from what I’ve seen of Rogan he does. Harder with cases like Brett Weinstein where I think engaging is a waste of time imo.

So there’s a pragmatic argument here about getting the outcome you want.

For the latter rather than pulling with a “me or him” framing. It is possible to reaffirm the shared freedom of speech yet saying you disagree and don’t want to share the platform directly (because it indirectly helps fund it). That’s probably what I’d do in that situation.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by LMYahooTFY on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:50PM (#30133796)
He didn't ask?

This is ridiculously disingenuous. He made an ultimatum, and his position is very clear. This is too obvious to honestly debate. If his desire isn't for Spotify to remove/censor Rogan, I imagine he'll clarify. Because he's blatantly calling for it.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:00PM (#30133859)
Young told his management to tell Spotify to remove his music. He didn't tell them to negotiate. Is your problem he said why he wanted his music removed?

"I support free speech. I have never been in favor of censorship. Private companies have the right to choose what they profit from, just as I can choose not to have my music support a platform that disseminates harmful information."[1]

[1] https://neilyoungarchives.com/news/1/article?id=Spotify-More...

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by umanwizard on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:26PM (#30132730)
Of course anyone who believes in freedom of speech would agree that Young and Mitchell have the right to pull their music. That doesn’t change the fact that one can disagree with that decision.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:34PM (#30132806)
> That doesn’t change the fact that one can disagree with that decision.

Obviously, but that's not the topic at hand.

> I were Spotify the move is to take the free speech position

There is no "free speech position". Spotify, Rogan, Young, and Mitchell are all exercising their right to free expression here.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by beerandt on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:57PM (#30133018)
Using leverage in an attempt to convince a business to silence someone else...

is not an argument for free expression.

It's free expression arguing against allowing others to exercise free expression.

>There is no "free speech position".

Who is Rogan trying to silence?

Spotify didn't give into demands to censor.

Those are free speech positions.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:20PM (#30133191)
Why not? I can say "dang should ban beerandt or I will stop posting" (I don't believe this and I am not making such a claim). dang can do whatever he wants in response, including nothing at all. HN is free to downvote me or say they disagree, or not. That's the competitive marketplace of ideas. If you offer something unappealing it will fail.

> Spotify didn't give into demands to censor.

Censorship is a loaded term in conversations about freedom of speech, especially in the United States. IMHO Spotify, Young, Mitchell and Rogan are incapable of censorship in the first amendment sense because they are not government entities.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by beerandt on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:33PM (#30133665)
>I can say "dang should ban.."

It is your free expression to make that argument, but the argument itself is against free expression.

>incapable of censorship

That's a mighty narrow definition of censorship. (I didn't say government censorship or even mention the 1st amendment.)

What is it that you would call Young's implied request to Spotify, if not an ultimatum to censor? Especially given the context that his demand is founded on opposing the content of Rogan's speech, and that he is attempting to leverage an authoritative power (Spotify) to unilaterally remove Rogan's published media and prevent it's distribution.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mmcgaha on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:07PM (#30133089)
Sure there is; Young and Mitchell have made an active decision to shutdown their own speech or the speech of another. The difference is taking an action against another vs taking an action against yourself.

I am sure that you will agree that determining your own outcome is freedom but forcing an outcome for others is oppression.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:16PM (#30133161)
They are not shutting down their speech. They are exercising it by choosing who to associate with. The first amendment does not protect you from the actions of other private parties, it protects you from the government. I realize this is a cliche but it is critical to understand. Freedom of speech means you can say "I don't like what that person says and they shouldn't say it." And everyone else is free to agree with you or not.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by umanwizard on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:26PM (#30133239)
> The first amendment does not protect you from the actions of other private parties, it protects you from the government.

Nobody in this thread was talking about the First Amendment. The concept of freedom of speech is much broader than its particular realization in US constitutional law.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:37PM (#30133303)
Fair enough. I do not believe anyone is or should be entitled to an audience. I do not believe anyone is obligated to speak.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by edanm on Sunday January 30, 2022 @02:10AM (#30134773)
> But there is no "freedom of speech" side here.

I believe you're arguing semantics here.

When people say "freedom of speech", they're referencing (sometimes unknowingly) hundreds of years of discussion in philosophy, politics, etc. A big part of that debate is whether censorship of so-called "bad" ideas is a good thing or a bad thing for "the public".

One side here is trying to pressure, commercially and via public opinion, a big platform. They're trying to pressure this platform to not publish certain information because it is "bad". Of course they have a right to do so! But I think it should be fairly clear that they are the side that is "against" freedom of speech, because they are literally against Spotify publishing certain information.

What's more, this isn't happening without context. This is happening in a world in which there is a lively debate happening around whether platforms should be liable for content that they allow to be published, in a world in which increasingly people are hesitant to associate with other people for voicing opinions they don't like.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by philistine on Sunday January 30, 2022 @11:56AM (#30138759)
Money. Money is the most important thing in this discussion. Spotify is not merely providing information in the classical sense, they have decided to massively invest in Joe Rogan. To signal that their podcasting efforts are centred around his dangerous entertainment product. It’s absolutely reasonable to consider this bad form, and wish for Spotify to revise.

Would we have this discussion about free speech if Spotify invested 100 million in a neo-nazi? No, we’d be appalled about the money.

It’s always about the money.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by edanm on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:00PM (#30138802)
That's a very good point.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by finite_jest on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:42PM (#30132872)
> But there is no "freedom of speech" side here.

There is. Rogan is not trying to remove Neil Young's music from anywhere.

I've heard this unfruitful line of argument too often recently. Besides being unfruitful, I think it is based on a subtle fallacy/diversion.

The idea of free expression reasonably includes the right to criticize the principle itself. For example, in the US, you absolutely have the legal right to criticize the First Amendment. However, by doing so you would rightly be labelled as being against free expression.

If you like free expression, I think you should be cheering for Spotify and Rogan in this case.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by rektide on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:11PM (#30133118)
Young wasn't trying to remove Rogan's music. He was exercising his positive liberty, to act as he wanted: which was to not be on a platform with people he perceived as ultra-shitty & socially-ruinous.

Young had (nearly) no expectation of causing change. There's a possibility he thought this really would, right now, have enacted change, but I highly doubt he was so deluded. Young simply knew he couldn't be party to such a system, and said he was unwilling to remain affiliated with it in it's current dangerous fallen state.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by finite_jest on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:43PM (#30133340)
> Young wasn't trying to remove Rogan's music.

I very much disagree. We could be a bit more accurate/pedantic by saying "he's trying to mount pressure to remove Rogan's podcast from Spotify" instead, but that doesn't change much.

> not be on a platform with people he perceived as ultra-shitty & socially-ruinous.

I cancelled my Spotify a long time ago, but I don't think it's much of a social platform. If you don't want to interact with Rogan, you simply can. I think you could even mute an artist, so Spotify wouldn't even suggest their content to you.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by rektide on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:52AM (#30134470)
whether or not Spotify is a social platform is irrelevant. Young didn't want to be involved with a business so directly supporting & fostering his/our worlds foes.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by philistine on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:02PM (#30138818)
Imagine a TV network hosting a show called neo-nazis throwing eggs at Jews at 8pm, and then you at 9pm for an important discussion on your favourite subject.

You’d have every right to rethink your association with that platform, and demand they not air the neo-nazis if they want to have you on.

This is not about free speech. It’s about freedom of association. You can’t force Neil Young to be associated with Joe Rogan if he doesn’t want to, and you can’t argue he doesn’t have a right to tell Spotify they can’t have both of them.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by baryphonic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:04PM (#30133068)
> You're absolutely entitled to your opinion on these actions and you're free to support Spotify or Young or Mitchell or any combination of the three. But there is no "freedom of speech" side here.

I'm not sure I agree. Young and Mitchell (how many decades ago were they culturally relevant?) are certainly free to participate on Spotify or not. They certainly cannot be forced to. However, if Rogan were booted from Spotify based on their threats (or others), he would certainly be a loser.

Further, if someone demands a second party take some action against a third party by making a quid pro quo threat, that is not clearly protected speech. If the threat involves revealing defamatory information, it constitutes blackmail; if the threat involves criminal harm, it is extortion; and if the threat involves breach of contract, it may be tortious interference, a civil tort. This is not to argue that Mitchell & Young are committing a crime, because they clearly aren't (though they may possibly be perpetrating a civil tort against Rogan depending on his contractual terms with Spotify and their demands), but that threats are not necessarily protected speech in the same category as merely making–or withholding–personal self-expression.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:15PM (#30133150)
> (how many decades ago were they culturally relevant?)

We're talking about them now.

> threats

They didn't threaten. Young directed his management to remove his music. Mitchell said she decided to remove hers. Is your problem they said why?

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by baryphonic on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:12PM (#30133522)
[deleted]
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:20PM (#30133987)
> Please read what I wrote again. I said Mitchell & Young were entirely free to participate in Spotify or not.

I didn't say you didn't.

> I'll leave it up to you to decide if that constitutes a threat.

It doesn't. A threat is an signal of intent before an action. Young jumped to the action.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by baryphonic on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:15AM (#30134266)
I was wrong and stand corrected: it is not a threat.

What Young said is more of an opening offer of a quid pro quo.

The overall point I was making stands, that freedom of speech (both the legal protection and the ethical principle) does not extend to coercive speech like it does to persuasive and expressive speech.

If some artist simply said, "Take my music off of Spotify because I have no confidence in the platform," then that would clearly be fully protected. If another said, "Spotify has until Feb 1 to remove Joe Rogan, or I'm pulling my catalog until they do," I think that'd be a lot more risky, especially if the artist had prominence.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Sunday January 30, 2022 @12:35AM (#30134379)
What Young said was more of a parting.

Tortious interference requires the defendant's conduct was illegal in some other way apparently. In California at least.[1]

[1] https://www.bonalaw.com/insights/legal-resources/what-are-th...

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by AnimalMuppet on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:00PM (#30133447)
> We're talking about them now.

Not as artists that have anything currently to say, though. We're talking about them as people who are trying to keep someone else from talking.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @11:31PM (#30134046)
> Not as artists that have anything currently to say, though. We're talking about them as people who are trying to keep someone else from talking.

We're talking about them as people who just said something.

Young sold half his music rights for $150 million last year. He signed a deal with SiriusXM within days after he left Spotify. Mitchell won a Grammy in 2016 and was nominated this year. Their music continued to be relevant to someone obviously.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by throwawaysea on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:25PM (#30132720)
I view it as a freedom of speech issue because one side is advocating for another side to be silenced. These musicians aren’t just pulling their content - they’re trying to use power to shut someone else down. To me that is clearly a freedom of speech issue.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by systemvoltage on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:31PM (#30132779)
> Young and Mitchell pulling their music is literally freedom of speech (free expression).

Yes, they can protest. But they can't demand to shut up others (Rogan) which is what they seem to be doing.

Personally, people should double down on their protest, hope others join against Joe Rogan's batshit insane science.

But, I will never stand behind people wanting to deny him the exact rights they're exercising. Young and others are doing exactly that. Isn't it bullying?

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:37PM (#30132833)
What evidence is there Young or Mitchell would deny Rogan the right to pull his podcast from any platform with their music?
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by eej71 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:41PM (#30132866)
None. But no one is making that claim.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:44PM (#30132901)
> None. But no one is making that claim.

They did.

> But, I will never stand behind people wanting to deny him the exact rights they're exercising. Young and others are doing exactly that.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by eej71 on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:52PM (#30132970)
You are half right! (I didn't write the text you challenged). But I did misread the OP's comments. He does make that claim. Clearly Joe could pull his content if he wanted.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:04PM (#30133070)
pseudalopex is just being a pedant - op clearly meant that Young can use Spotify and Rogan is not trying to stop that.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by throwawayboise on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:27PM (#30132737)
Yes there is. Young and Mitchell should argue their position on its merits, not throw a hissy fit and take their toys and go home.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:46PM (#30132918)
They are arguing their position on its merits. This case is being tried in the court of public opinion.