News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by umanwizard on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:26PM (#30132730)
Of course anyone who believes in freedom of speech would agree that Young and Mitchell have the right to pull their music. That doesn’t change the fact that one can disagree with that decision.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:34PM (#30132806)
> That doesn’t change the fact that one can disagree with that decision.

Obviously, but that's not the topic at hand.

> I were Spotify the move is to take the free speech position

There is no "free speech position". Spotify, Rogan, Young, and Mitchell are all exercising their right to free expression here.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by beerandt on Saturday January 29, 2022 @08:57PM (#30133018)
Using leverage in an attempt to convince a business to silence someone else...

is not an argument for free expression.

It's free expression arguing against allowing others to exercise free expression.

>There is no "free speech position".

Who is Rogan trying to silence?

Spotify didn't give into demands to censor.

Those are free speech positions.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:20PM (#30133191)
Why not? I can say "dang should ban beerandt or I will stop posting" (I don't believe this and I am not making such a claim). dang can do whatever he wants in response, including nothing at all. HN is free to downvote me or say they disagree, or not. That's the competitive marketplace of ideas. If you offer something unappealing it will fail.

> Spotify didn't give into demands to censor.

Censorship is a loaded term in conversations about freedom of speech, especially in the United States. IMHO Spotify, Young, Mitchell and Rogan are incapable of censorship in the first amendment sense because they are not government entities.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by beerandt on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:33PM (#30133665)
>I can say "dang should ban.."

It is your free expression to make that argument, but the argument itself is against free expression.

>incapable of censorship

That's a mighty narrow definition of censorship. (I didn't say government censorship or even mention the 1st amendment.)

What is it that you would call Young's implied request to Spotify, if not an ultimatum to censor? Especially given the context that his demand is founded on opposing the content of Rogan's speech, and that he is attempting to leverage an authoritative power (Spotify) to unilaterally remove Rogan's published media and prevent it's distribution.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mmcgaha on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:07PM (#30133089)
Sure there is; Young and Mitchell have made an active decision to shutdown their own speech or the speech of another. The difference is taking an action against another vs taking an action against yourself.

I am sure that you will agree that determining your own outcome is freedom but forcing an outcome for others is oppression.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:16PM (#30133161)
They are not shutting down their speech. They are exercising it by choosing who to associate with. The first amendment does not protect you from the actions of other private parties, it protects you from the government. I realize this is a cliche but it is critical to understand. Freedom of speech means you can say "I don't like what that person says and they shouldn't say it." And everyone else is free to agree with you or not.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by umanwizard on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:26PM (#30133239)
> The first amendment does not protect you from the actions of other private parties, it protects you from the government.

Nobody in this thread was talking about the First Amendment. The concept of freedom of speech is much broader than its particular realization in US constitutional law.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by mulmen on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:37PM (#30133303)
Fair enough. I do not believe anyone is or should be entitled to an audience. I do not believe anyone is obligated to speak.