News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:10PM (#30133115)
I honestly don’t think that matters? He said pull my music and explicitly said you can have one of us not both.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:17PM (#30133169)
So he should pull his music and tell no one why?
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by AnimalMuppet on Saturday January 29, 2022 @10:05PM (#30133473)
Not if I understand the chronology correctly. If I understand correctly (and I may not), Young gave his "me or Rogan" statement to Spotify (or maybe indirectly, simply making a public pronouncement). Spotify didn't pull Rogan's content, so a couple of days later, then Young pulled his content off of Spotify.

As I said, my understanding. And I haven't gone groveling through the back news items to prove it. Just my recollection of how I heard it reported over a few days.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Sunday January 30, 2022 @01:29AM (#30134627)
Monday Young wrote a letter to his management and posted it on his blog briefly. It was what we quoted. Wednesday Spotify confirmed his music was being removed.
Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:25PM (#30133233)
Imo he shouldn’t pull it.

If he is uncomfortable sharing the platform so wants to remove his music fine, I’d just say that without the “you can’t have both of us” implication.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by pseudalopex on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:32PM (#30133271)
> Imo he shouldn’t pull it.

Why not?

> If he is uncomfortable sharing the platform so wants to remove his music fine, I’d just say that without the “you can’t have both of us” implication.

The 1st part implies the 2nd.

Re:Joni Mitchell joins Neil Young in protest against Spotify by fossuser on Saturday January 29, 2022 @09:51PM (#30133392)
I don’t think pulling his music is effective in persuading people he wants to persuade (likely this stunt has the opposite effect), but I also think it’s better to engage in good faith than just argue to suppress speech.

You can’t always if the other party won’t engage in good faith, but from what I’ve seen of Rogan he does. Harder with cases like Brett Weinstein where I think engaging is a waste of time imo.

So there’s a pragmatic argument here about getting the outcome you want.

For the latter rather than pulling with a “me or him” framing. It is possible to reaffirm the shared freedom of speech yet saying you disagree and don’t want to share the platform directly (because it indirectly helps fund it). That’s probably what I’d do in that situation.