The most ironic part is that Twitter will show the spam/scams, but hide other replies, from real people, that Twitter thinks are mean.
Same here. I suppose I could go find spam if I start clicking on every Tweet from a high-profile person and scroll to the bottom of the comments, but the spam isn't jumping out at me on a regular basis.
I suspect some people have a very low tolerance for any spam appearing anywhere on a platform, and will get easily triggered whenever it crosses their experience in any way. If you're consuming 100s or 1000s of Tweets and responses in a sitting and scrolling to the bottom of threads, eventually you're going to see something spam-like.
Pretty weird how multiple people refuse to believe something can be a problem even though they can't see it.
The last spam I got was where someone tagged me in some bullshit NFT giveaway, where entrants had to tag 5 of their "friends" to qualify. Definitely spam, but at a cursory glance, it was human-generated rather than bot spam.
I don't get much other spam though.
Edit: oh yeah, on a Japanese account I have I get the odd mass DM offering scam sex/easy money/whatever. I've also noticed a trickle of obvious spam account followers there (it's always "girls" with sexy profile pics and a profile blurb that invariably mentions adding her on LINE, and ~zero followers except other bots and just a couple tweets). Spam is very different depending on the market.
You only have to mention NFTs, even in a negative light, and you generally get drive-by likes from verified NFT-related accounts, and if you check their 'Likes', they've liked dozens more tweets since yours. The idea being to draw attention to itself with a certain demographic. Twitter has its own option to report people for this exact behavior.
Likewise, the number of QRTs in replies to things boggles the mind.
Play stupid games win stupid prizes?
There’s a ton of stuff like this.
Everyone I follow is computer science or software engineering focused though, so maybe Twitter's algorithm can easily recognize my preference and fill my timeline with related tweets.
Maybe someone who follows a more diverse set of interests will get more diverse tweets in their timeline, more likely to include spam.
Just a guess, dunno for sure.
Follow any normal non-celebrity account that isn't talking about the latest moneymaker and you'll find less spam.
[0] https://www.reddit.com/r/Twitter/comments/p1ggm4/rtwitter_at...
What if I want to see what the algorithm is hiding from me? If there are many replies it's time consuming to find out.
Is it bots? I follow a few bot accounts and get value out of them. Is it blatantly promotional content? This actually seems to be one of the intended uses of Twitter. Is it low-quality content? I feel like lots of people earnestly tweet out low-quality stuff, and who gets to judge what's low-quality anyway?
To test this out, just Tweet something like “my Coinbase account isn’t working”
You’ll get dozens of replies from fake Coinbase support scams.
Maybe this is the difference? Cryptocurrency attracts spammers and scammers at a rate far higher than other conversations.
Now that you mention it, the only time I recall seeing spam lately was when I read the comments on some cryptocurrency Tweets. I usually avoid cryptocurrency discussions on Twitter because the signal to noise ratio on those is so low anyway.
Oh, well there's your problem. Unfortunately the network of people you're following are very close to giant network of scammers that has grown around crypto.
reply> I know we all probably must have heard about Bitcoin but don't know how it works, I tried it in a week ago and i made a return of $10500 after a week of trading, connect with my trader at @SpamBtcAccount1234
• abuse of @-replies
• unsolicitied DMs
…which both grow with account size (& other forms of prominence, & certain topic-areas), so your anecdotal testimony that it's not in your feed doesn't do much to qualify or refute the magnitudes of others' problems.
Twitter's biggest internal spam problems are:
• Twitter's ads are repetitive, poorly-targeted crap
• Twitter does not provide reliable ways to disable their unwanted inserts – quickly ignoring any number of 'see less often' choices, and doing things like randomly reverting people from their chosen 'latest' to Twitter's algorithmic 'home' feed.
As fair definitions of 'spam' or even more generally 'harassment' include "continued unwanted interactions against expressed preferences", this means Twitter Inc is the biggest spammer/harasser on its own platform.
Indeed. I'd argue that the "Who to Follow" insert is worse than any spam I have seen or deal with.
Interestingly, we had one person's account whose search results still showed searchbanned tweets. They would not show for that person if they logged out. We also could not find out why that person's account in particular could see them.
This sounds like a bug we're aware of where an account that goes public -> private we'll reliably purge their tweets from the public index, but if an account goes private -> public sometimes we'll not re-populate the main index correctly.
> we had one person's account whose search results still showed searchbanned tweets
This part doesn't match what I'm describing, but could be explained by the logged in account having access to private tweets in search results that logged out / other accounts do not.
The spam Twitter lets through is ridiculous. Is it hard to catch all offenders? Yes. Is it obvious Twitter is no where close to that? Also yes. We should have higher standards for our social networks.
Bot Sentinel [0] can pick these up without any direct access to Twitter’s data, you would think that Twitter would be able to do it with all the extra information they have available to them.
Edit: WARNING this will immediately fill your feed with spam. Don't click anything that you get.
https://twitter.com/nickstinemates/status/148716175094431334...
> metamask trust wallet support seed phrase recovery bitcoin shib ethereum network nft help moon coinbase defi dapp shib dogecoin giveaway retweet elon musk free nfts crypto punks opensea free raffle dao hacked banned from Instagram snapchat facebook i need an artist logo designer
These guys are not on their A game here.
I’ve known a few startups that built their initial user bases utterly deluging Reddit and Twitter in manual spam.
That's wrong. Results can be seen even if the process is not transparent. If every bridge the engineer builds collapses, I can judge him without looking into all the drawings. If every business the entrepreneur runs collapses I can make conclusions from that, even without seeing the books. If there's a lot of garbage on Twitter, I can judge it's doing a bad job even if I don't get to see its algorithms.
Algorithm development has been poor and really frustrating to users because if they even come across someone who followed the Kardashians (for example), they literally get spammed with that news for the life of their accounts, and Twitter's "mutewords" functionality has also not worked for many years, I can't tell if that is intentionally so or not.
Try muting "BTS" The (K-Pop group) as an example.
But it's rather convenient for the platform to not do that update if it circumvented their profit making interests, and the interests of the other paying entities (like corps and celebrities) that need to promote things that could be otherwise muted for the comfort of their entire user community.
Sure, it's not always a conspiracy theory as someone will likely comment, but in this case, the evidence is clear as daylight.
Yep. Perfect example of the Survivorship Fallacy/Bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
Twitter could solve my spam problem tomorrow with a setting that says "don't show any posts with links if they're from accounts none of your friends or friends of friends follow".
Like, no, I see it every day. Lots of it.
Take an account that attracts bots, Elon Musk is one of many examples. What do we see...
a) Hundreds of replies in the very first few seconds. It's humanly impossible to post this fast.
b) Replies share the exact same profile photo, typically of a well known original account.
c) User names are all a slight misspelling of a well known original account.
d) What they post is repetitive, same spam links and texts.
Every single pattern above, as well as combinations of them, are absolutely trivial to detect. But absolutely nothing is done about it.
First, we don't see the spam that was outright blocked, so we have no idea of what the false negative rate is. Second, I bet that this is not a binary block/allow decision, but there are all kinds of ways of reducing the engagement that probable spam gets without outright blocking. The latter is operationally preferable since it reduces the cost of false positives and since it makes the iteration loop for the spammers a lot slower.
(But also, I can't remember when I last saw spam in my Twitter feed.)