That of course is assuming they even bothered to pay anything back. Often enough it was a game of survival (business/personal). Nothing to pay back if the person is dead or business gone.
I'm in Canada now :)
Also in Canada now :)
I.e., you buy $3000 worth of goods, but pay $200/mo for 30 months ($6k total). You sell for $2000 cash (not on installment). So far, you've paid $200 and gotten $2000, up $1800.
If you paid back $200/mo in real terms, this would be a terrible deal! But every month your payment real value drops 10%, so you only really are only paying 200 + 180 + 162 + ... and over 30 months you only pay $1915 in original-value terms.
It also does not devalue (in the same manner) if you use it to purchase real estate which you hold onto for a long time. Much of this money was used to purchase apartments, houses, buildings, businesses, etc.
Or you don’t care and are just looking for an increase in cash flow.
Such as staples? But then, why sell them quickly at a discount? That was the question. Or, if something else, why not convert the loaned money into something that doesn't devalue directly?
So you might sell them immediately and convert the results into dollars or something. Dollars are actually less divisible than car batteries, since the US$20 bill trades at a heavy discount, but more so than, say, motorcycles.
This is not a strategy I've ever used, but it does kind of make sense.
I can understand that logic, but feel like surely this would be priced in somehow. I think most likely, nobody would ever give you a loan that wasn't pegged to another currency or to the inflation rate. In general I find that businesses don't like to make incredibly stupid loans that they know full well won't be paid back or will be paid back in worthless currency as the OP states. Maybe I'm wrong though and should move to Argentina
We're not in hyperinflation. The currency isn't worthless. It's just not worth as much as it was a year ago. Or two weeks ago: I found out today that AR$11890.99 is no longer about US$58 as it was two weeks ago, but more like US$55 now. The annual inflation rate is about 50%, which is about 3.4% per month. If it's 50% per year over the next 12 months, the total value of those 12 monthly installments will be about US$46, which you'll notice is still more than the US$42 offered by the other seller without an installment option. So unless inflation goes higher in the next year, or the buyer defaults on the loan, the installment vendor is still making a pretty decent profit on the battery. They may not be "charging interest" but offering "interest-free" installments enables them to charge a sufficiently higher price that it's a profitable thing to do.
They are taking the risk that inflation suddenly explodes three months from now and 9 of their 12 installments are much smaller than they had planned on. And the buyer is taking the risk that inflation suddenly stops six months from now, which would make their final installments are just as onerous as the first few.
There have been a lot of loans pegged to the inflation rate in the past, as well as things like pensions. Unfortunately, since the government was the creditor for most of these, and also the government publishes the official inflation rate, they solved the problem in the early 02000s by faking the inflation rate statistics. Some economic consultancies published statistics showing the real inflation rate so the government prosecuted them for "commercial disloyalty". Retirees rioted in the streets and got tear-gassed by the police until the government agreed to raise their pensions faster than the fake inflation rate. Bondholders weren't so fortunate.
Roughly: - borrow $1mln - buy $1mln of coffee, regular price $10/kg - sell immediately at $8/kg (lower price helps move the goods quickly) - pay back $1mln loan
By the time you paid the loan back, $1mln no longer has the same value. And so the $1mln you paid back is really only worth way $500k.
Add to this lack of stability due to war and you may not even pay it back … perhaps you refused to pay, company went out of business, you borrowed from someone who is no longer around (alive, fled the country, etc), or any other number of related reasons. In that case it ends up being pure profit for you. Not so easy to enforce or later track down.
- "How much is this book?"
- "9 million"
- "Here's 10 million"
- "And one million in change, sir"
OK, so that only worked up to a certain value. No one would say their rent was "1,000 million". In that case, the currency was billions!
Everything there is in the millions as well.
Wow it’s down to 20 nuevos per dollar, I remember when it was 3.
Then the war kicked off in 1991 and everything fell apart.
Another story that seems surreal to me now (having lived in Canada 25 years): My grandma and virtually everyone her age was habitually 3 order of magnitude off when it came to money. She'd give me a 2 million dinar note and say "here's 2 thousand".
Every now and then there was a reset - basically you'd print new money and lop of some digits.
I was <12 years old through this so only have vague memories but man, what a crazy way to live -- and yet it was fairly... "normal". Is what it is. Human brain adjusts to anything (including to a certain degree the civil war that followed).