News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by nekcihc on Thursday January 27, 2022 @01:59PM (#30104619)
Some of the issues, that are not in article:

1. Taiwan was not part of neither communist China or Chinese Republic, so neither of them have claim on this territory.

2. Up till 1945 Formosa was was territory of Japan. It can be compared to Prussia, that from 1945 is currently occupied by Russia. After 1945 US still has all the rights to decide status of Formosa.

3. It could have been independet Formosa, but apparently for political reasons US 75 years ago decided to let Chinese take over this territory and oppress natives of this island and deny dream of native Formosians to be free and independent and erase history of these people by both Japanese and also Chinese and US has taken part in another deadly sin of theirs - once again in erasing natives.

Both Russia and Ukraine are new countries, that arised from USSR.

US(along with Russia) has signed agreement about guaranteeing territorial integrity of Ukraine. It apparently meant nothing for Russia, but with this agreement US has signed a trap, because apparently that also means, that US signed treaties are not worth anything...

* There has been talks, that Ukraine is corrupt country, but apparently it is ok for US goverment officials(and relatives) to deal with corrupt countries for financial gains, because from ancient Roman times "money does not stink". This involvement in corruptions is nothing new - Hillary Clinton in similar fashion(when dealing with Western Sahara) destroyed mining industry in US, so these things are coming full cycle and affects US, too.

* For the same reasons it is ok for Western companies to invest in corruptive countries for profit, that is shared with local thieves, that are robbing their own people.

There are no similarities between Taiwan and Ukraine, however war in Ukraine is linked to Taiwan and China will be watching how the things are going to progress there. So, this is a test trial for US - what it is going to do about this? Russia has become dog of China and China is not commanding Russia(yet), but Russia acts as a dog, that likes to impress owner, when rattling chain and barking on neighbour.

China might attack Taiwan, while Russia is attacking Ukraine. Despite what author is writing, attack of Russia on Ukraine is a dire warning to all of Eastern Europe and stirs up 100 years old memories, that behaviour of Russia is unpredictable and who knows who will be next. Russia is still pushing borders of what is acceptable to them and so far Europe and US has not stopped them. Btw, some of Scandinavian countries are not in NATO, so essentially they are a free snack for next aggression after Ukraine, before final real escalation with NATO.

The issue with China attacking Taiwan is quite opposite - China might be forced to attack Taiwan, to try to end supremacy of US, just like Japan was forced to attack US. Talk about economic reasons is from previous century. Changes in economy are happening all the time - it is not constant state- if for whatever reasons US economy becomes weak, US does not allow China access to it, most of US owned factories are relocated outside of China - does it really makes sense to claim, that China still won't risk breaking economic contacts with US, because uh - oh... they have economic ties, if suddenly there are none anymore?

Russian patriotism nowadays is about war - it seems, that Chinese have similar mindset. And this is a very big question - why chinese also have this mindset, that Russians have? Whom are they going to attack?(China also have claims on Russian territories). No idea, why Chinese lost cool and started to argue with US and started to use military talk, as it was too early, unless we know nothing about Chinese. There are political talks and then there is a street talk and it knows more, than any analytical mind.

It does not matter - those people are ready for war - it all depends if leaders of China decides if it is time to attack. Collective Putin thinks, that attacking Ukraine is their right and in their minds they are already prepared to invade Ukraine and the only question is if it is total invasion of Ukraine(just like finalized integration of Belarus into Russia), or only biggest part of it(just like USSR initially did not had western Ukraine). So, it all depends on how successfully Ukraine will defend itself and what US gonna do. Because, frankly - US has been sh!t so far and it does not help, that European powers are even worse and they have made Russia as it is, because they were so stupid, that they thought that criminals can become business men and become civilized.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by vanusa on Thursday January 27, 2022 @02:38PM (#30105240)
Just like Japan was forced to attack US.

I'd go with "seduced itself into attacking".

But "forced to"? That seems to be an unfalsifiable assertion.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by bllguo on Thursday January 27, 2022 @02:46PM (#30105374)
it's very likely a reference to the US oil embargo.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by vanusa on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:10PM (#30105717)
Agreed, it most likely is.

Its unstated premise being of course - that they were "forced" to keep the GEACPS running at all costs.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by wbsss4412 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:00PM (#30105563)
This is poor history. Prior to Japanese occupation, Taiwan was a part of Chinese territory under the Qing for several hundred years.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by mytailorisrich on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:25PM (#30105989)
And rightly given back to the Republic of China in 1945 (hence why the Chinese government retreated there in 1949...)

Those claims related to changing regimes are of course disingenuous and only aimed at creating a false narrative. It is fake history for political purposes.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by wbsss4412 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#30106030)
I’m confused, is it your assertion that the ROC is the legitimate government of China, hence there’s no CCP claim on Taiwan?
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by mytailorisrich on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:55PM (#30106522)
I am not asserting anything. I am stating that Taiwan is indeed Chinese territory, historically and today.

Now, there has been (arguably still is) a civil war and the overall territory of China is split with both sides claiming the whole but only one side is strong enough to think they still have a shot a it.

Now, to go back to the article, it serves the US' interests to support one side against the other hence why they do it, in the same way that it serves their interests to 'grab' Ukraine against Russia. It's the same old global Great Game.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by wbsss4412 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @04:00PM (#30106612)
Ah ok, I just got confused. Thank you for the clarification.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by nekcihc on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:46PM (#30106381)
This is poor understanding about internationally recognized rights on owning territories, that has nothing to do with history and who owned them centuries ago.

Today Qing are as relevant, as Russian historical claims on California.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by vanusa on Thursday January 27, 2022 @04:03PM (#30106648)
Yeah, point 2 is rather silly.

There's no way the Russian influence in California can be compared with the Han Chinese influence on Taiwan.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by wbsss4412 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @04:12PM (#30106765)
I’d be curious to know what GP’a position on Israel is given their stance on historical claims.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by nekcihc on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:33PM (#30109657)
Undeniable rights for native people to claim their native lands. In a global scale not really seeing what is so special about Israel compared to native people of US, who are displaced from their lands for ceturies, but still maintain claims on their lands. It is only a question of mere 1500 years to get their lands back. Maybe they can succeed quicker than Jews - only time will tell.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by wbsss4412 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @10:55PM (#30110543)
So land claims by the Chinese from 125 years ago are irrelevant, but land claims by Europeans from 1,500 years ago are?

Serious lack of consistency.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by nekcihc on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:19PM (#30109021)
Qing were Manchu - not Han. Though, the comparision should be about CCP influence, otherwise all Americans should be scared of all naturalized Chinese, as if all Han are the same...
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by vanusa on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:59PM (#30109410)
My understanding was that the actual immigrants to the island were mostly Han.

But then, my understanding is wrong about a lot of things.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by nekcihc on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:28PM (#30109621)
I mean, you are not wrong about big picture, though you are missing very small, but important detail, that they migrated there, because they were not communists and they are still not communists.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by vanusa on Thursday January 27, 2022 @09:04PM (#30109871)
Yeah, given that they started migrating there (by the millions) decades before The Communist Manifesto was written -- it's probably pretty safe to say that most of them were not communist.

A very important detail indeed.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by wbsss4412 on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:57PM (#30106566)
Then why even make point 2 at all?
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by s1artibartfast on Thursday January 27, 2022 @03:22PM (#30105921)
>US(along with Russia) has signed agreement about guaranteeing territorial integrity of Ukraine.

Source?

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by T-A on Thursday January 27, 2022 @07:12PM (#30108971)
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by s1artibartfast on Thursday January 27, 2022 @08:07PM (#30109460)
I see nothing about coming to the aid of Ukraine unless it is subject to nuclear aggression. Conventional conquest is A-OK.
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by T-A on Friday January 28, 2022 @03:17AM (#30112009)
> I see nothing about coming to the aid of Ukraine

Red herring. The text is a commitment to respect territorial integrity (as nekcihc correctly said and you questioned) not to aid it.

In particular:

2. The United States of America, the Russian Federation, and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, reaffirm their obligation to refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of Ukraine, and that none of their weapons will ever be used against Ukraine except in self-defense or otherwise in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations.

That's Russia guaranteeing that "that none of their weapons will ever be used against Ukraine except in self-defense or otherwise in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations."

None of their weapons, not just nuclear.

Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by s1artibartfast on Friday January 28, 2022 @07:12PM (#30122305)
And the us isn't using their weapons against Ukraine. They are fully respecting their boundaries, just not going to war over them. Russia is clearly in violation, not the USA
Re:Taiwan is not Ukraine: Stop linking their fates by T-A on Saturday January 29, 2022 @06:53AM (#30125626)
> Russia is clearly in violation, not the USA

Of course. Nobody claimed otherwise. The argument made by nekcihc

with this agreement US has signed a trap, because apparently that also means, that US signed treaties are not worth anything

is not that the US is violating the agreement; it is that an agreement signed by the US (among others) has been continuously violated (by Russia) since 2014 so "US signed treaties are not worth anything".