Ask HN: Trading research breakthrough for a permanent job?
First some context. I finished my PhD 5 years ago, and have had three postdocs since then in three separate fields within the physical sciences (I can't give more detail here as I am afraid of uniquely identifying myself). I have been publishing first author papers at a rate of about 2 per year. I am particularly good at using ideas from one field to solve problems in another, which is why changing fields each postdoc has been a path of least resistance.
Recently, I have solved a problem which feels significantly more important than what I have done in the past. It is one of those instances where you can use auto differentiation infrastructure to solve a problem which doesn't really look like machine learning. People in my lab are excited about it, but there does not seem to be any way for me to leverage this excitement into any sort of long term contract. All that is on offer is that the lab PIs want to write a proposal, which doesn't even mention my name, and then if that proposal gets funded, they will rehire me to work on the project (although, there are no guarantees that they will not hire someone else instead, which is a serious concern when multiple PIs are competing to hire someone). As a result of my field hopping, trying to become a PI myself isn't really an option.
Is there any mechanism for applying for private sector research jobs where I can bring a project with a prototype along and be like "let me develop this for you, and you can hire me as an employee", kind of like a proposal / job application combination? I am getting a little old to keep doing postdocs, so job security is becoming more of a priority for me.
Anyway, not expecting much from posting this, I just thought I would try.
On a personal note, the amazing opportunities in my career have come from the outliers of my professional network. As in people who I didn't even think would remember me. So don't be too shy in reaching out.
But as another commenter mentioned, getting a patent would be great. Is the cost of filing preventing you from doing that ?
As an individual, in most cases, you are better off being the co-holder of a patent together with a substantial entity who can better protect your mutual interests.
I've often seen patent applications, particularly provisional patent applications, as an "ace in the hole" for real and potential commercial disputes. If you are afraid you might get screwed the patent gives you a weapon to screw back.
Your university might be able to force you to assign the patent to the university and I wouldn't worry about it.
If you are filing your first patent and not (initially) putting the name of any big organization on it you can get 1/2 or 1/4 off the filing fee. I got 1/2 off the last time I filed one I spent a day gathering together my notes and I paid $65. A real patent is going to cost you somewhere in the low $1000s. The PPA starts the clock and gives you 1 year to file a real application which is enough time if you're serious. It also will keep anybody else from filing a patent.
You could go to the technology transfer office at your uni but I don't reccommend it because (1) the folks involved know some aspects of the subject very well but they are clueless in others, so they might not have good judgement about "is this worth filing a patent for?" and (2) they are going to spend more money determining if it is worth filing a patent than you are going to spend on filing fees.
You are better off begging forgiveness than asking permission I think, particularly if your first step is filing the provisional patent. Even if you are forced to assign the patent to your uni, you are much better off getting into a commercial dispute over something valuable than you are not having anything valuable to begin with.
Nolo press has some very good books on patent law that tell you all you need to know to file patents. Go get one from the library.
Good ideas are relatively common, what is less common is an environment where you can change the world with an idea, that is what you are searching for now.
Apply for work at some corporate research lab for the job security and leverage your new insights to solve some cool problems.
[0] - https://blog.ycombinator.com/how-to-spin-your-scientific-res...
Since it does carry an element of risk it's not likely to be able to be hired on it alone. If you see fit to develop it you could make a research company and raise money on it.
May be worth taking a stab starting your own company (or at least a consulting business) rather than wait for one of the big companies to suck you up into their intake vents. Or even if that's your preferred destination, this approach might help you get there (and better positioned for the kind of role you'd prefer to have).
If it’s published, can you explain your idea of using auto differentiation infrastructure to better see how good an idea actually it is?!