News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Nate75Sanders on Friday September 16, 2011 @02:07PM (#3005563)
The most important paragraph if you're not interested in reading the whole thing:

Is there an intelligent alternative to lying or telling the truth that we have not yet examined? Yes. In our hypothetical interview, you can politely decline to be interviewed by the FBI agent. Tell the agent that you have an attorney and that "my attorney will be in contact with you." If the agent persists, say that you will not discuss anything without first consulting counsel. Ask for the agent's card, to give to your attorney. If you have not yet hired a lawyer, tell the agent that "I want to consult a lawyer first" or that "an attorney will be in touch with you." The absolutely essential thing to keep in mind is to say nothing of substance about the matter under investigation. It is preferable to do this by politely declining to be interviewed in the absence of counsel. If the agent asks "why do you need an attorney?" or "what do you have to hide?" do not take his bait and directly respond to such questions. (Do not even say that you have nothing to hide.) Simply state that you will not discuss the matter at all without first consulting counsel and that counsel will be in touch with him. If the agent asks for a commitment from you to speak with him after you have consulted or retained counsel, do not oblige him. Just respond that you will consult with your attorney (or "an" attorney) and that the attorney will be in touch. And by all means do not get bullied or panicked into making up a phony reason for refusing to talk. You are not obliged to explain your decision to anyone.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by ugh on Friday September 16, 2011 @02:17PM (#3005602)
These three paragraphs also seem important:

“It is crucial to note that affirmatively declining to discuss the investigation in the absence of counsel is not the same thing as remaining completely silent. If you are not in custody, your total silence, especially in the face of an accusation, can very possibly be used against you as an adoptive admission under the Federal Rules of Evidence.

Your invocation of counsel, however, cannot be used against you at trial. United States v. McDonald , 620 F.2d 559, 561-64 (5th Cir. 1980). Your refusal to talk substance in the absence of counsel will force the prosecutor to decide whether your information is important enough to justify a grand jury subpoena for your testimony.

If the prosecutor responds to your declination by serving you with a grand jury subpoena, this will present you with an interesting range of options such as: 1) testifying; 2) refusing to testify, by invoking the Fifth Amendment privilege against self-incrimination, which broadly applies to anyone , innocent or guilty, facing criminal exposure; 3) testifying (or talking to the government) only after receiving a grant of immunity; or 4) proffering to the government–that is, giving them a sneak preview of what you will tell them if they agree to grant you immunity. The important thing to remember is that declining to speak to the agent in the first place buys you time in which to weigh these alternative strategies with your white-collar criminal defense attorney.”

There are no downsides when you decline to talk, it gives you time to take a more considered approach and you can avoid errors you might make in the heat of the moment (when you are most likely stressed and maybe even panicked).

I will always decline answering questions, no matter the situation. There might be situations where talking is unproblematic but I don’t want to make that decision on the spot and when I’m stressed. I doubt my abilities to make right decisions in those situations. That’s why I made that decision now, and it’s to take the safest route: I decline.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Natsu on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:15PM (#3005851)
You've both missed the most damning sentence in the entire document: To begin with, you are not qualified to know whether you are innocent of wrongdoing under federal criminal law.

That's what ought to keep people awake at night.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:58PM (#3006039)
If the law was computer software, at this point it would be a giant unmanageable screwball of spaghetti code that would crash daily and would require patches 3 times a week.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jbooth on Friday September 16, 2011 @04:09PM (#3006104)
It does, both of those. Except the patches are driven by lobbyist donations or ideological axe grinding rather than fixing defects, for the most part.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by duggan on Saturday September 17, 2011 @09:37AM (#3007971)
So it's exactly like software then :)
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by InclinedPlane on Friday September 16, 2011 @10:46PM (#3007078)
It's worse than that, if the law were software then it wouldn't even run on client machines, it'd only run on specialty hardware in the lab.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by thehotdon on Saturday September 17, 2011 @02:31AM (#3007417)
if ... 1000 dollar fine

else if ... 5 months jail

else if ... capital punishment

else if ... licence suspended

else if ... 3 years jail, 20000 dollar fine

// handle a few million more cases

else you're innocent

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by nazgulnarsil on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:59PM (#3006500)
cases are rarely dismissed for this anymore: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_for_vagueness
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jpdoctor on Friday September 16, 2011 @08:08PM (#3006796)
> To begin with, you are not qualified to know whether you are innocent of wrongdoing under federal criminal law.

In other news, barbers believe that everyone needs a haircut immediately.

(Both are the FUD sale. Lawyers employ it regularly, so get used to it.)

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by VladRussian on Saturday September 17, 2011 @02:10AM (#3007386)
the point of having lawyer doing the talking instead of you (scroll down to the bottom of the page):

http://www.aaronsw.com/weblog/fbifile

" GOOD is AARON SWARTZ’s attorney in Boston, MA. GOOD wanted assurance that if SWARTZ was interviewed, what he said would not be used to jeopardize him. SA [REDACTED] explained that assurance could not be given but that we were in an information gathering phase. GOOD refused the interview without the assurance.

April 20, Washington Field Office:

    CASE ID #: 288A-WF-238943 (Closed)"
One phrase from a lawyer made the difference between walking the painful path toward federal conviction for computer crime and "Case closed".
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by nonce483837 on Friday September 16, 2011 @09:24PM (#3006933)
You could save a lot of money by never going to a barber and a lot of money by never speaking with a lawyer. Of course, you'll look like a fool in both instances.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by philwelch on Saturday September 17, 2011 @02:05AM (#3007380)
Slightly off topic, but it's surprisingly easy to go your whole life without going to a barber. If you want short hair, go over your head with the number 3 guard every month or so. If you want long hair, never cut your hair at all, and you look awesome after a couple years. I haven't had my hair cut in eight years. Women come up to me on the street and tell me they're jealous of my hair. It's not that hard.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jamesbkel on Sunday September 18, 2011 @03:06AM (#3009684)
I'm intrigued by this, but seriously, how does one manage that much hair?
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by philwelch on Sunday September 18, 2011 @04:56AM (#3009821)
There are two secrets to this. One is that you don't actually need to wash your hair every day. The other is that masculine long hair styles are trivial.

Washing your hair every day puts more wear and tear on it, and it's time consuming. If you have short hair, you get away with this because you keep cutting your hair long before it gets worn out. So only once or twice a week will I actually wash my hair (and use conditioner, this actually becomes important with long hair). Most days, I tie it up into a bun before showering so it doesn't get wet. You might be able to find another solution. Depending on your water quality, your hair might smell gross if you just get it wet without washing or at least conditioning it.

After showering, I generally brush my hair, especially after washing it or if I want my hair down. If I'm in a hurry or it doesn't look good loose, I just tie it back in a ponytail. There is literally nothing else you have to do to make it look presentable. After a certain length it doesn't really get in your face unless it's especially windy or something. If you want it loose during some sort of physical activity, I've noticed a lot of longhaired footballers will wear a thin black hairband around the base of the skull and the hairline--if you do an image search for Leo Messi or Didier Drogba I'm sure you'll see what I mean.

Human hair actually stops growing at a certain point, or to be more precise it grows at the same rate that it gradually falls out over time leaving you with a consistent terminal length. Mine seems to be around the small of my back.

As you grow it out between an ordinary short hairstyle and shoulder length, you're likely to look kind of strange for awhile, and have no good way of managing your hair. On male longhair web forums, this period is usually referred to as "the awkward phase". You might be tempted to get haircuts so you can at least have a decent medium length style at this point, but really that only makes the awkward phase take longer. From a short hairstyle to shoulder length usually takes within 2 years, but only the middle part of that is likely to be too awkward. From short to shaggy it just kind of looks shaggy, and from almost-shoulder-length to shoulder length it just looks increasingly awesome, but there's a bit of an awkward gap between "nice and shaggy" and "almost shoulder length" where you can't tie it back, you can't quite keep it all tucked behind your ears, and it gets in your face.

One last point--I suspect my hair is naturally very attractive, so I'm certainly not going to guarantee that women will approach you on the street and say they're jealous of your hair if you grow it out. Generally, most styling and hair care above and beyond not cutting it, washing it, conditioning it, and brushing it does more harm than good in the long run. The whole point about barbers saying everyone needs a haircut rings very literally true--hairstylists and hairdressers will suggest a variety of treatments, products, chemicals, cuts, and other solutions to often completely imaginary, self-solving problems like split ends, based upon completely fictional notions about the physiology of hair.

And that is certainly more than I ever thought I'd have to say about hair on Hacker News.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by stephth on Sunday September 18, 2011 @05:46PM (#3011356)
The only way was to sneak it under a story about federal law. :)

self-solving problems like split ends

Could you explain that? I though split ends forced to cut one's long hair regularly.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by philwelch on Sunday September 18, 2011 @06:09PM (#3011416)
Split ends aren't even noticeable unless you look closely at the tips of the hair. And they don't travel up the hair or anything, they stay put, one side breaks off and then the other side breaks off. I've not even looked for split ends for years and I have fantastic hair. It's a total non-problem that you can safely ignore.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jpdoctor on Friday September 16, 2011 @09:55PM (#3006989)
Or you could try a sensible strategy: Consult someone other than a lawyer/barber about when to seek a lawyer/barber.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by marginalboy on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:14PM (#3006345)
Could that just mean that "ignorance of the law is no defense"?
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by ovi256 on Friday September 16, 2011 @06:40PM (#3006604)
Not when knowledge is impossible.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by prof_hobart on Friday September 16, 2011 @06:47PM (#3006623)
>There are no downsides when you decline to talk,

Whilst I understand the principle, I'm not sure I 100% agree with this statement. I've been in a few situations in the past - demos/football matches etc - where declining to talk would quite likely have resulted in me being detained for questioning (and in some of those cases, for others who tried this approach, this was exactly what happened), but a polite answer to the cops resulted in them simply leaving me alone.

It's true that had the cops decided to nick me anyway, then anything I said could well have resulted in bigger problems than if I'd kept quite. But they didn't.

In my view, there are quite definitely some downsides to refusing to talk, but they are far lower than the downsides could be by talking.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by rue on Friday September 16, 2011 @08:10PM (#3006801)
The police isn't the same as a federal agent, although it's best to avoid talking to them too.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by prof_hobart on Saturday September 17, 2011 @03:04AM (#3007456)
Ah. I'm British, so I'm not really aware of there being a difference (at least one of my "talking my way out of trouble" incidents happened when I was working in Texas though - but it wasn't a federal agent).
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by crenshaw on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:27PM (#3006395)
There are no downsides when you decline to talk

Doesn't the highlighted section actually note that silence can be used against you? It would seem you need to decline to talk and request counsel, if I understood correctly.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Mithrandir on Friday September 16, 2011 @06:25PM (#3006565)
You have the right to ask for your attorney. If you don't say anything, that might be used against you.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by matusz13 on Friday September 16, 2011 @02:39PM (#3005691)
I remember seeing this talk some time ago - simply titled 'don't talk to the police'. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by danvideo on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:05PM (#3006311)
yep that's a fantastic video
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jpdoctor on Friday September 16, 2011 @02:28PM (#3005650)
But also note: Part of why Bernie Madoff lasted so long was that he arrived for an SEC investigation without a lawyer. Everyone in the room thought he had nothing to hide, so they didn't pursue him.

Whether we want to admit it or not: It's ingrained that you are inviting an investigator to hassle you further by invoking a right to counsel. (For the record: I think that sucks too.)

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by teej on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:01PM (#3005802)
I'd rather not take cues from Bernie Madoff on legal matters.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jpdoctor on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:32PM (#3005924)
You missed my point: One strategy that should be safe is telling the god's-honest truth. But even with the truth, you invite a whole lotta hassle by bringing a lawyer.

Conversely: Even if you're a dishonest crook, you get the feds off your back by omitting a lawyer.

This is not how it should be; It is how it is.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jellicle on Friday September 16, 2011 @04:23PM (#3006165)
There are hundreds of thousands of people in prison right now who arrived for their interview with the authorities without a lawyer. I'm not sure your theory actually pans out.

(Madoff wasn't caught when the SEC first investigated because they thought he was front-running orders, not a giant Ponzi scheme. They were looking for the wrong thing.)

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by scott_s on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:03PM (#3006301)
I have to disagree with what you said about the SEC. According to Markopolos' book, the SEC wouldn't have caught him even if he was front-running. It's not that they were looking for the wrong thing. They just didn't look.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by hyperbovine on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:48PM (#3006000)
This guy was the former chair of NASDAQ and had friends in high places. Your chances of getting the same red carpet treatment from the Feds are effectively zero. Hire a lawyer.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by VladRussian on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:40PM (#3005975)
You point is : if you're a talented con artist who was able to con $50B out, then you would mislead/charm/fend off a SEC or any other investigator better than a lawyer. I'm completely agree with you here. For the rest of us - talk to your lawyer first.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jerf on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:31PM (#3006404)
Actually, use of the word "truth" is itself leading. What's illegal is not lying to the government, because the government is not magically capable of telling that you are lying. What's illegal is giving the government information that the government interprets such that the government determines it conflicts with what the government determines be the official-truth.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by scott_s on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:00PM (#3006290)
That the SEC investigators were completely incompetent helped him far more. See Harry Markopolos' book "No One Would Listen" for support of my "completely incompetent" claim: http://www.amazon.com/No-One-Would-Listen-Financial/dp/04709...
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by notaddicted on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:21PM (#3005881)
One can hardly consider Bernie Madoff a paragon of astute judgment. I'll admit this is argumentum ad hominem, but his tolerance for risk was insane. Also notable is that he declined counsel when he really needed it, which is different than doing the same thing when you are secondary or tertiary to the investigation.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Florin_Andrei on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:59PM (#3006047)
> this is argumentum ad hominem, but his tolerance for risk was insane.

That's the crucial point.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Anti-Ratfish on Friday September 16, 2011 @04:04PM (#3006075)
The Mandoff saga reflected more on investigators abilities than on Mandoff's in my opinion. The SEC having botched 6 investigations of Mandoff so badly that even Mandoff couldn't understand it. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/31/business/31sec.html?pagewa...
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by dredmorbius on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:46PM (#3006455)
That said, what you say can be held against you. What your lawyer says for you can't so much. Which is why even lawyers may want to have lawyers.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by Anti-Ratfish on Sunday September 18, 2011 @10:03PM (#3011917)
Sorry about the repeated misspelling of Madoff. It won't let me edit it now.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by drv on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:11PM (#3006336)
Who's "Mandoff"?
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by jpdoctor on Friday September 16, 2011 @04:45PM (#3006239)
> The Mandoff saga reflected more on investigators abilities than on Mandoff's in my opinion.

That is exactly the point. Nobody shows up with a lawyer because they want transparency above and beyond the call of duty.

Investigators will take the need for a lawyer as having something to hide. Arriving without a lawyer says the opposite.

But apparently several posters above don't believe so.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by kelnos on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:02PM (#3006297)
I think regardless of what investigators think if you bring a lawyer, you have a much better chance of avoiding incriminating yourself (even if you don't believe you've done anything wrong!) if you bring one.

If you have done something wrong (again, whether you know it or not), you'll likely have a better outcome with a lawyer present from the start that without.

But if you actually haven't done anything wrong, the lawyer can still help you avoid accidentally telling a "lie" or getting yourself into a situation you don't know how to handle. Even if the investigators believe you're hiding something just because you lawyered up, if you genuinely did nothing wrong, there's not much they can do... aside from making up evidence and framing you, or believing unreliable witnesses telling lies about you... which could happen in any case.

The bottom line (as stated in the article) is that you are not qualified to know whether or not you have or have not truly done anything illegal. A lawyer will be much better able to help you make that determination and guide your interaction with the authorities for your benefit.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by scott_s on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:08PM (#3006326)
I actually don't think you understand the parent's point. The SEC was incompetent. They weren't capable of finding Madoff's fraud.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by zeteo on Friday September 16, 2011 @03:39PM (#3005970)
>Part of why Bernie Madoff lasted so long was that he arrived for an SEC investigation without a lawyer. Everyone in the room thought he had nothing to hide

Got a source for that?

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by chalst on Saturday September 17, 2011 @10:14AM (#3008051)
Madoff ‘astonished’ SEC did not catch him, FT, Oct 2009

http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/a039e91c-c5ac-11de-9b3b-00144...

It falls a bit short of backing up the claim "[e]veryone thought he had nothing to hide", but it's along those lines.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by mahyarm on Friday September 16, 2011 @04:19PM (#3006146)
Thats bit like saying a lawyer didn't bring a lawyer to a police interview. He had expertise and experience that would of helped him avoid common pitfalls. Almost every normal person does not have the expertise to execute that kind of gambit properly.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by glimcat on Friday September 16, 2011 @10:32PM (#3007053)
"Why do you need an attorney? What do you have to hide?"

I need one because it was important enough put in the Constitution. What have you got against the Constitution?

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by rjurney on Friday September 16, 2011 @09:56PM (#3006992)
In practice, such people will often threaten you. They are experts at this, and can easily get under most people's skin. This is why most people fold and give up their rights. Out of fear.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by EGreg on Friday September 16, 2011 @05:42PM (#3006441)
What if they bring you in and detain you for not cooperating with the investigation? Under some reason? Are there laws for that?
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by 3pt14159 on Friday September 16, 2011 @11:39PM (#3007168)
Basically they take a risk when they do that, but they can only hold you for 72 hours (at least here in Toronto). There are avenues that you can take to get back at them for that though, such as class action lawsuits.

A Hispanic former coworker of mine was wrongfully arrested then beaten with phone books by some thugs at the Toronto police. He got lucky, it was a case of mistaken identity and even though they found a small amount of weed on him they let him go completely and he was given a card with a cops phone number on it. He has had to use it 3 times since.

He's an apprentice tradesman and lives in a poor area of Toronto so when I told him to sue, he said "Sue? For what? Damages? I've been beaten up worse before by the people they're trying to catch. I live in a bad neighborhood and the officer who gave me his car and I have an understanding now."

Pretty messed up. When you don't look or sound like the people that know these little loopholes in the system you get to deal with what I consider to be a couple steps up from a mob. Some of them are awesome, for example cops have helped me get out of a snow bank before and didn't write me up for a driving infraction. Some of them are generally nice and will smile at you on the street or laugh with you as they give you a ticket, but they have power and some of them, especially those that have to deal with messed up shit in the ghettos abuse it.

Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se... by mmaunder on Friday September 16, 2011 @10:58PM (#3007101)
This is really great advice. I'd just emphasize to be honest about whether you have an attorney or whether "an attorney will be in touch" with him. Awesome article conover, thanks for posting.