Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se...
by rue on Friday September 16, 2011 @08:10PM
(#3006801)
The police isn't the same as a federal agent, although it's best to avoid talking to them too.
Re:Be Careful when Speaking to Federal Agents - 18 U.S.C. Se...
by prof_hobart on Saturday September 17, 2011 @03:04AM
(#3007456)
Ah. I'm British, so I'm not really aware of there being a difference (at least one of my "talking my way out of trouble" incidents happened when I was working in Texas though - but it wasn't a federal agent).
Whilst I understand the principle, I'm not sure I 100% agree with this statement. I've been in a few situations in the past - demos/football matches etc - where declining to talk would quite likely have resulted in me being detained for questioning (and in some of those cases, for others who tried this approach, this was exactly what happened), but a polite answer to the cops resulted in them simply leaving me alone.
It's true that had the cops decided to nick me anyway, then anything I said could well have resulted in bigger problems than if I'd kept quite. But they didn't.
In my view, there are quite definitely some downsides to refusing to talk, but they are far lower than the downsides could be by talking.