News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by james-redwood on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @03:28PM (#29999526)
Octopi are remarkably intelligent creatures, as any good aquarium owner will tell you.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by datameta on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:59PM (#30014899)
An even better aquarium owner wouldn't have them at all.

My Octopus Teacher is a fantastic look into the life of an octopus, their intellectual capacity, and their propensity to interact with humans.

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by shard on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:59PM (#30016575)
Here is a critique of My Octopus Teacher as a movie of a self-centered man who projects his issues onto an unsuspecting wild animal: "MY OCTOPUS TEACHER & Environmental Horror, An Analysis" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whb4unrhy44
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by awb on Thursday January 20, 2022 @06:27PM (#30016914)
> a self-centered man

Self-centered? I'm assuming you're basing that off of an edited film designed to entertain people and not because you actually know the man.

> who projects his issues onto an unsuspecting wild animal

Humans tend to project their issues onto unsuspecting things all the time in my experience: partners, co-workers, strangers, pets, etc. And inanimate objects too, if you've ever seen someone slam a door, pound a table or seek guidance from nature. We seem to be driven to share our experience with others.

In the film the octopus has no trouble hiding, running away or disappearing when it wants. And likewise, no trouble approaching after it became comfortable with him. And he refuses to intervene when its life is in danger.

After these quips, I usually hear the criticism that he was a rich white guy of privilege telling a "woe is me" storyline. If you don't like what the guy represents, fine, but his actions are not that different from many other naturalists who loves to observe animals in the wild.

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by nefitty on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:35PM (#30017587)
In the general sense of media and art consumption, I'm not sure where I stand. Some people refuse to listen to R. Kelly's music. Do his actions as a human change the quality of his output? It's not as if anything can be judged separate from the context within which it arose and the subsequent context within which it was consumed.

Another example, is it bad to watch Birth of a Nation? Does it depend on the creator's intent or the broadcaster's intent or the consumer's intent?

In a similar way, we can't help but view other beings from within our own subjective frame. The levels of abstractive difference from that octopus to my comment are dizzying. Each individual applies another coat of paint to the canvas.

I find research papers bland sometimes, but that is the point. Researchers try to hide their perspective and take on some sort of apreferential objective God view. In that attempt, we get a nutritious, unseasoned chunk of raw tofu. I can eat that sometimes. A lot of the times I want a flavorful, multi-modal umami dish. The person who concocts that sort of meal will inevitably "season to taste". I would be remiss to spit out my first bite, "This is not raw tofu!"

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by suifbwish on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:37PM (#30015429)
Why would that be better to not have them? It sounds a bit presumptive of a universal morality rather than a logical statement.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by gorgabal on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:43PM (#30015531)
It sounds like a moral statement because it is a moral statement. Nothing wrong with that IMHO .
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by ceejayoz on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:52PM (#30015638)
It's not an insane idea that octopuses might not enjoy being stuffed into what amounts to a studio apartment for their entire life.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by DoingIsLearning on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:58PM (#30015710)
They are also notorious for finding increasingly cleverer ways of escaping aquariums. Which again adds to the case that an aquarium is not a suitable environment.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by Grakel on Thursday January 20, 2022 @07:23PM (#30017466)
IDK, their main aquarium is the entire ocean, and they still come up on land.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by barrenko on Friday January 21, 2022 @03:35AM (#30020775)
Same with dogs and cats. It's just slavery.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by coldtea on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:00PM (#30015727)
>It sounds a bit presumptive of a universal morality rather than a logical statement.

Logical statements just by themselves are for Logicians and/or theorem provers.

But they're also useless by themselves (just an axiomatic rule sustitution game).

To have any value in human life they are combined with utility functions, morality, and other such things.

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by girvo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:12PM (#30015903)
For my purposes, because their short lifespan and particular needs make them pretty bad pets IMO. Never mind the moral arguments for keeping such intelligent animals in captivity.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by procinct on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:48PM (#30015588)
Octopuses are known to not live very long in captivity.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by girvo on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:13PM (#30015914)
Though they also don’t live long in the wild either. Fascinating creatures.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by animal531 on Friday January 21, 2022 @05:25AM (#30021620)
I don't know if that is true. For example dogs have acclimated extremely well to captivity, but on the other hand we know that orcas do extremely poorly.

I was watching Clint's Reptiles on Youtube where he's reviewing an octopus staying at an aquarium. It gets all the food it needs, entertainment via puzzles, interaction with the keepers etc. For an octopus it seemed like a very safe and easy life as compared to the wild.

Now the real questions would be if whether they prefer to migrate around or stay in one place. If they prefer one safe place, then perhaps given this safe aquarium space they'd choose to stay in it?

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by datameta on Friday January 21, 2022 @08:55AM (#30023483)
Dogs have been highly domesticated, but only some smaller breeds are "ok" with not getting regular walks outside.

I think it would fall on being able to empirically test whether the animal is content or perhaps even happy. It seems possible to satiate most needs and basic desires but you bring up a good point as to whether we can truly replicate the audiovisual and tactile richness of their usual habitat.

Got to thinking about VR for aquatic animals...

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by jjtheblunt on Thursday January 20, 2022 @03:48PM (#30014710)
(waiting for the recurring comments, that 2 x octopus -> octopodes or octopuses but not octopi since it's not latin 2nd declension, but rather misspelled greek)
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by colechristensen on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:11PM (#30015071)
Let’s not encourage the unnecessary language pedantry.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by totalZero on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:41PM (#30015503)
Pedantry is no felony when discussing an eight-armed genius.

I personally settle for nothing less than "octopodes," with the accent on the second of its four syllables.

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by dragonwriter on Thursday January 20, 2022 @05:00PM (#30015737)
Doesn't it actually come into English from Latin (in its later academic/international use, rather than the classical language)?

But in any case, it's English, not Latin or misspelled Greek, and octopi seems to at least be the oldest evident English plural of octopus, AFAIK, though octopuses seems to be experiencing current popularity, and octopodes is just...no, though the suggestion once made that English ought to adopt octopods, wasn't bad, but never caught on.

Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by OJFord on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:40PM (#30015474)
I think 'octopodes' should be considered incorrect on the basis that the vast majority of even the people using it are probably not pronouncing it correctly.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by mc32 on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:53PM (#30015646)
Eh, as long as it rhymes with ‘tetrapods’, it’s accepted and current pronunciation.
Re:The mystery of social behavior in octopuses by amelius on Thursday January 20, 2022 @04:11PM (#30015068)
Octopus is already wrong in itself.