News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by wefarrell on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:08PM (#29983176)
It's telling that 20 years after 9/11 we're still taking our shoes off at airports yet we still don't have federally mandated sick leave despite being two years into a pandemic that has been more fatal than 9/11 by several orders of magnitude.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by webmaven on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:39PM (#29984585)
> It's telling that 20 years after 9/11 we're still taking our shoes off at airports

Obligatory Nitpick: the shoe bombing attempt happened in December 2001:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2001_American_Airlines_Fligh...

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by beamatronic on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:11PM (#29983240)
It's the will of the voters.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by vmception on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:18PM (#29983330)
This isn't a direct democracy at the federal level. there is no mechanism for it so we should stop pretending that there is.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:30PM (#29983540)
You don't need a direct democracy to reflect the will of the voters.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by sslayer on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:13PM (#29984205)
At the Local and State level - I don't understand why people don't get this - at the Federal level you have representation. The United States intent was to Unite the States on Federal/National issues - not local ones - the intent was to leave the states to rules at the state level, not make sure "everyone in the United States" is "doing the same thing".
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:34PM (#29984529)
And it's not even really a conservative view to say that. Even the most liberal of politicians would acknowledge that laws governing certain areas don't make sense everywhere, and there's a reason for keeping states, given the gigantic size of our country.

This comes up all the time in redistricting conversations; very often the goal for some of the strangers gerrymandered districts is to keep populations together.

People should have a say in how their day-to-day lives are governed, and not just be ruled by a huge cluster of people on a completely different part of the planet.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by vmception on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:47PM (#29984685)
This has nothing to do with whether there could be a referendum mechanism or not.

Congress (and the rest of the federal government) can and does do all of the absurdities you are suggesting is prevented by the people having no direct say.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:58PM (#29984837)
I'm sorry, I don't understand your reference to referendum.

It's by design that people have no direct say, however. That's a substantially worse system, by nearly every measurement, to generally employ.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by vmception on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:35PM (#29985360)
Most people’s referendum concepts only make it a ballot based on a swell in support for the referendum to begin with. A decent threshold of the population needs to want any particular measure to begin with. So most things would be squashed.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by Sargos on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:07PM (#29984115)
It would be disingenuous to claim that taking off shoes at the airport is the will of the people. Nobody voted for that. The public was never consulted.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by akvadrako on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @04:13PM (#29985908)
But there are polls and the TSA has public support.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by rcoveson on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:17PM (#29984262)
In the same way that you don't need a mirror to reflect your appearance; a bowl of dirty water does just fine.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by tylersmith on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:37PM (#29983666)
Direct democracy isn't the only way for voters to express their will. More than 60% of eligibile voters participated in the voting system last presidential election. Does a voting system that continues to be endorsed by a majority of the people not express their will?
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by jhickok on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:52PM (#29983896)
Not defending direct democracy, but it's not clear that if 60% of eligible voters participate it entails A) the people endorse the voting system B) it expresses their will. You can waffle a little and say that if people hold their nose while voting they still are endorsing it and it expresses their will, but I don't think that's what I understand "the will of the people" to be. I prefer a punch the leg over a punch to the nose, but that doesn't mean I endorse being punched and that the leg punch expresses my will.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by vmception on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:22PM (#29984344)
California residents have an extremely low and practically irrelevant voting weight, for example.

I’m not here to debate why that is, I’m pointing out the stretch of the imagination involved to consider the outcome to reflect an aggregate voter will, versus basically accidents.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by lm28469 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:18PM (#29984282)
Participating in a system doesn't mean you endorse it. 40% of eligible voters not voting is much more worrisome....
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by andrew_ on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:15PM (#29983287)
That only works if you think we're truly represented by our representatives.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by willcipriano on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:44PM (#29983773)
Most of them have been in power for decades, at certain point you have to start blaming the voters who pull the lever for more of the same.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:32PM (#29983587)
"Truly" is doing a lot of work here, and creating an is/ought problem.

Representatives do reflect the will of the people who elected them. The real problem is, on an individual level, your vote is statistically irrelevant, so it's easy to disassociate, and to blame "the others" who, collectively, have a vastly more powerful say over who represents you than you do. "They ought to vote more like how I want them to." you can say, "They don't vote correctly and I can't stop them, so it's the system's fault for giving them power over me!" This, of course, completely undermines the entire point of democracy, that it represents the collective will of the people, not any individual's arbitrary will.

A representative democracy works even if you don't believe it does. It stops working if everyone doesn't believe it does, which is certainly not even close to the case in the US.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by thomascgalvin on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:54PM (#29983926)
> Representatives do reflect the will of the people who elected them.

First, this is false. Policy in the US is dictated by campaign contributions, not voter sentiment.

Take a wildly popular idea, like universal background checks for firearm purchases. This enjoys something like 80-90% support among both Republican and Democratic voters, but it will never get through Congress, because of the NRA.

Second, "the people who elected them" is not itself representative of society as a whole. The US Senate and the US Presidency are decided by mechanisms that intentionally award oversized representation to certain geographical areas. There are only ten states with a population higher than Los Angeles County, but those states still get two Senators.

So American democracy is built to reflect the will of the monied, and the will of small population centers. Most of us are not rich, and most of us live in dense population centers. This means our system of government is giving us the exact opposite outcome we should be looking for.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by nradov on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:57PM (#29984821)
In the 2016 presidential election, Hillary Clinton received far more campaign contributions than her opponents but she still lost. Campaign contributions aren't sufficient to overcome negative voter sentiment.

https://www.opensecrets.org/pres16

US states are free to impose universal background checks on firearm purchases, and several have. It doesn't need to be done at the federal level.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:24PM (#29984383)
It's not "false" in the sense that 1+1=3 is false, though you may disagree with it.

American democracy does not reflect the will of the monied, it reflects the will of the people, you just don't like what that aggregate will represents because it's not your will. No matter how much money gets dumped into elections, people actually have to vote in them, and you cannot serve in any elected capacity without first being elected.

Maybe the will of the people can be changed with money, and maybe it can be changed to reflect views that are ultimately harmful to the very people who hold those views, but it is the will of the people.

Wealth doesn't actually, literally, buy votes, and it is "1+1=3" kind of false to claim it does.

You may not like what your system of government produces as its outcomes, but it's exactly what it should be producing; a reflection of what its people want. I'm sorry it's not what you want, and I'm sorry that individual issue polling doesn't reflect reality, but when the polling actually matters, people vote differently than when a single issue is up for a non-binding, theoretical discussion.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by thomascgalvin on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:35PM (#29984543)
> You may not like what your system of government produces as its outcomes, but it's exactly what it should be producing; a reflection of what its people want.

This is absolutely untrue, because representation is intentionally not proportional to population. Our electoral system produces a reflection of what some people want, and those people are typically from smaller, more conservative, less populated, less economically viable areas.

Because of this, US policy does not reflect the will of the majority on most major issues.

Most people support taxing the ultra-wealthy at a higher percentage of their income, but this is not US policy.

Most people support background checks on all firearms sales, but this is not US policy.

Most voters support campaign finance reform, but this is not US policy.

Most voters support a ban on Representatives actively trading stocks, but this is not US policy.

More than half of voters support at least some form of student loan forgiveness, but this is not US policy.

You can basically walk the link of current important issues, and find that the will of the people is not represented at the Federal level. I don't like what our system of government produces, not because it goes against what I want, but because it goes against what most people want. It is a majority held hostage by the tyranny of a minority, and that is becoming less and less tenable as time goes on.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:47PM (#29984693)
Again, nothing I'm saying is "absolutely untrue" in any objective sense; you're saying you disagree with it sure, but it's not objectively false.

You claim "most people support" a bunch of things here, but how do you know? A poll conducted on one specific issue, without discussing tradeoffs? "If you could snap your fingers and get this for free with zero downside?" style polling options? They're not realistic and don't give people any stake, which means people will answer in ways they wouldn't otherwise if actually given the choice (and all its downsides).

These things you list aren't US policy because people don't actually want those things to be US policy. They trust their selected representative to dive into the details of those issues, and when those representatives do, those reps tend not to support them to the degree that you claim the people do.

You're upset your favorite things don't get the attention you want them to get, but that's the point; one person doesn't wholly determine anything in the US government. It's built to keep one group of people from crushing other groups of people, and it's working.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by skrbjc on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:02PM (#29984893)
Does the NRA not represent the will of a group of people? If a group of people get together, put their money together and tell that group of people to sway politicians with that money, then you can reasonably say that that is the will of people, albeit, people with a specific issue on their mind.

I don't think it is the best system, but you can't say that PACs aren't working toward the will of the people that put the money behind them.

If you didn't realize we have the senate and the house of representatives, one is proportional to population and one is based on state-hood. I think it creates a reasonable balance, especially because small states would otherwise have almost no voice in the federal government. The densely populated cities in the US already have a lot of sway in general elections and especially in state-wide elections, which have a greater influence on their lives anyway. Making sure less-densely populated regions, which are vital for the country in their own way, is not a terrible thing, as much as that irks Democrats that would like more control.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by Bellyache5 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:28PM (#29984448)
I agree with your comment about representatives catering to special interests, bribes, etc. Their constituents aren't usually first or second in priority. Public corruption is a serious problem.

But as for the Senate and Presidency being decided by mechanisms that aren't directly tied to population—that's by design. The United States is comprised of 50 States that jointly gave up some of their sovereignty to become a republic. They're more than just administrative districts of a national government. Aforementioned issues aside, the House of Representatives is supposed to represent the will of the _people_ while the Senate is supposed to represent the will of the _States_. The Senate is the States' representation at the Federal level. (Indeed, before the 17th Amendment US Senators were elected by State legislatures, not popular vote. Part of the motivation for the 17th Amendment was—wait for it—corruption in the state legislatures!)

It may be that moving to more population-based representation scheme would alleviate some issues. It also brings a downside: less populated states would get steamrolled by the more populated ones. (This was the Virginia Plan at the Constitutional Convention.) The 10th Amendment explicitly states that any power not expressly granted to the Federal government by the Constitution is retained by the States (States' rights/sovereignty), so basing Senate representation on population rather than giving each State equal representation would disenfranchise some States.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Connecticut_Compromise

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seventeenth_Amendment_to_the_U...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virginia_Plan

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tenth_Amendment_to_the_United_...

edit: formatting

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:58PM (#29983995)
This is trivially refutable by anybody who has voted for a compromise candidate, which is effectively everyone. 60% of Americans think that marijuana should be legal for recreational use [0], yet it remains illegal at the federal level. You cannot claim plausibly claim this situation reflects the will of the voters. Rather, the voters' will is herded into a few bundled choices, who differentiate themselves on hot button topics while safely ignoring consensus on less divisive ones.

[0] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/04/16/americans-o...

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:28PM (#29984447)
"America" is not the jurisdiction, it's the 435 districts and the 50 states. It's the will of each of those constituencies that decide who is sent to congress, rather than a straight popular vote.

National issues do not impact the nation equally, and the US's legislative body represents that fact.

Deciding how we, as a group of people, live together is much more complex than, "Let's just vote on each thing!" A system like that is rife with all kinds of "wolves vote to eat the sheep" problems, to a degree much worse than any system we might have right now in the US.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:41PM (#29984618)
If 60% of voters are in favor of legalizing marijuana, then legalizing marijuana is the will of the voters, period. The voting system limits the way the voters' will can be expressed, thereby making the outcome not reflect the will of the voters.

If you'd like to make an argument that our national representative system weighs voters from different states unequally, I'm open to that. But that's the kind of thing that will generally get you a few percentage points, not 10%. Or translate the argument to medical marijuana which per that link is supported by 91% of Americans. That magnitude can't be explained away with weighting or quantization error.

I'm very aware of the tyranny of the majority ("wolves vote to eat the sheep"), and would have included such a caveat that following the will of the voters is not always just and that it's an assertion to judge by simple majority, but that is not what we're discussing. Also on the topic of marijuana deillegalization, this isn't a majority wanting to aggress onto a minority and take away their rights, but rather a majority wanting to end such aggression - tyranny of the majority does not apply.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:54PM (#29984792)
> If 60% of voters are in favor of legalizing marijuana, then legalizing marijuana is the will of the voters, period.

How do you know this? I'm sure polls have been conducted, but without stakes, and understanding of the consequences, of the downsides, of the costs, there's no way a random voter would be capable of executing a policy decision as complex as legalizing a drug.

That's why they elect representatives, and at a national level the people have not chosen to elect representatives who have made this an important enough priority to create and pass legislation making this view into law. At a state level, some voters have chosen to prioritize this, by picking representatives who value this view over other views, and prioritize passing legislation. The system worked, for those people.

The point here is that if your favorite poll were accurate, and did indeed reflect the will of the people, they'd prioritize it highly enough to vote accordingly. However, it isn't important enough to supercede other issues, so it remains not the will of the people.

It's a lot more complex, figuring out what people want, than just asking them.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:04PM (#29984928)
> at a national level the people have not chosen to elect representatives who have made this an important enough priority

> The point here is that if your favorite poll were accurate, and did indeed reflect the will of the people, they'd prioritize it highly enough to vote accordingly. However, it isn't important enough to supercede other issues, so it remains not the will of the people.

You're essentially falling back to a simple tautology, shoehorning the "will of the people" to simply mean how they voted, even though a vote is an extremely limiting expression of a voter's overall will. This is utterly useless when discussing the effectiveness of our specific voting/representational system.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:41PM (#29985439)
How is, "A poll on a single issue is not the same as electing an entire person." a tautology?

The will of the people is (usually, always federally) expressed in selecting a representative, not in any single issue, and that's by design. "The will of the people" isn't, "Legalize marijuana" it's, "My representative figures out a way to sanely legalize marijuana while balancing thousands of other initiatives and objectives according to their urgency and importance in a way I would, overall, approve of."

Very few people want chaos, so very few people are voting simply on, "I just want this done, regardless of the cost."

I don't think you're interpreting these single issue polls in a way that's applicable to how Americans want the US as a whole governed, instead you're interpreting those polls to just mean what you want them to mean, because it's a useful thing to point out as a mismatch between expectation and reality.

It is not, however, a mismatch at all.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @06:13PM (#29987504)
> How is, "A poll on a single issue is not the same as electing an entire person." a tautology?

The problem isn't that you're saying they're different. The problem is that you're defining "will of the voters" narrowly, being equivalent to the result of an election. This makes your argument itself a tautology - if the "will of the voters" consists purely of how they voted, then of course the currently elected representatives are always the will of the voters. But if we're discussing how effective our representational system is, then your tautological definition is completely uninteresting.

> The will of the people is (usually, always federally) expressed in selecting a representative, not in any single issue, and that's by design. "The will of the people" isn't, "Legalize marijuana" it's, "My representative figures out a way to sanely legalize marijuana while balancing thousands of other initiatives and objectives according to their urgency and importance in a way I would, overall, approve of."

You're doing it again here, presupposing that a "voter's will" can only consist of what they can express through the current voting system, as opposed to what they would like to express when voting but cannot.

My reference to a single issue opinion pole is precisely to show how voters' desires differ from their representatives' actions (with the assumption that pollees are representative of voters). If we use your definition, then the obvious "will of the voters" is to keep marijuana illegal, but this isn't saying much. Whereas using the broader definition, then we can talk about how the representative and plurality systems thwart the will of the voters by making them express their will in terms of constrained choices.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @06:27PM (#29987638)
Of course I'm presupposing that voting on individual issues for a country as large and diverse as the US is a terrible idea, because it's a terrible idea. That is, definitionally, anarchy, and does not create a stable or fair government for anyone.

I did presuppose that you understood that. Maybe that was not appropriate, but I'm not willing to discuss it, because I find it, a priori, a non-starter.

This is well trod intellectual ground, and if you're curious, you can find ample writings debating the topic of a direct democracy vs. a representative democracy elsewhere that'll more accurately frame the discussion than anything I could come up with off the top of my head for free on HN.

Given that a direct democracy results in substantially negative outcomes for the people who participate, therefore a representative democracy is about voting for the person, not the policy, and in that environment, the will of the people is indeed expressed as the selection of their representative, not on any isolated "What if you could magically have something with no downsides?" issue based polling.

Narrowly focusing on one specific issue is naive. the US doesn't exist in a single-issue bubble, it exists in a complex web of political and practical (not to mention entirely unpredictable) needs which all have to be balanced simultaneously. If you want to pretend legislators can snap their fingers and make any individual issue "just happen" that's fine, but it's not reflective of reality on any level. You will continue to be confused and disappointed if you decide to live that way.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @07:42PM (#29988346)
I've made no claim to the contrary, and I agree at the very least that any proposal for direct democracy would be quite complicated even if it sounds simple.

But that doesn't really have bearing on what I said. Voter opinion on individual issues is merely one metric we can use to evaluate how well the "will of the voters" is being represented. Another one, more focused on representational government, would be whether most voters are happy with the vote they cast, or whether they feel they had to compromise and vote "strategically".

These questions are important for being able to discuss changes to our system. For example, posing the question of whether RCV/Condorcet would represent the will of the voters better than party-controlled primaries plus first past the post.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @08:27PM (#29988679)
Voter opinion on individual issues is not a valid metric for evaluating how well the "will of the voters" is being represented.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @08:47PM (#29988818)
Do you care to back up that assertion with some reasoning?

To me, seeing that 91% of people support medical marijuana while representatives continue to do nothing is pretty damning.

Just for context here, I don't have a personal stake in the marijuana question. I just think such a governance failure is galling.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @09:32PM (#29989172)
> Do you care to back up that assertion with some reasoning?

I already did.

> Narrowly focusing on one specific issue is naive. the US doesn't exist in a single-issue bubble, it exists in a complex web of political and practical (not to mention entirely unpredictable) needs which all have to be balanced simultaneously. If you want to pretend legislators can snap their fingers and make any individual issue "just happen" that's fine, but it's not reflective of reality on any level. You will continue to be confused and disappointed if you decide to live that way.

What's more interesting is why you'd claim I hadn't, when I very clearly did.

It's almost like you're not even reading what I'm writing...

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @11:10AM (#29995526)
I was focused on responding to what I perceived to be the core of your argument, and that got lost by the wayside. To me, the core of the argument continues with my Condorcet point.

Specifically about this point, I disagree. You're greatly exaggerating the intrinsic difficulty of change - witness any "emergency" bill that gets passed after a few months with very little debate. I agree there are bureaucratic difficulties in general, but when discussing how well representatives represent the will of the voters, the inefficiency due to those difficulties are still quite relevant! The argument you're making basically lets you write off any outside metrics that aren't the ballot box - deferring to the opaque paternalism of "that's just how the system works" and shutting down any criticism of the representative bureaucracy itself.

Furthermore on the topic of marijuana deillegalization, most of those bureaucratic difficulties simply do not exist. No legal regime needs to be pondered and crafted, rather the laws that criminalized it in the first place simply need to be repealed - strike them by number and name. That we're likely to end up with more complex legislation rather than a straightforward repeal is entirely due to the corruption of the system where all of these incumbent moneyed interests get their says before the will of the voters can become law. That corruption is exactly what you're defending by rejecting basic objective critiques of the system's effectiveness.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @11:52AM (#29996197)
“Why don't you just” has plagued the software industry for decades, and now you try to use it on legislation.

It’s funny, how misdeeds can transcend profession.

If you can’t accept that passing national legislation is an incredibly complex, subtle, and nuanced activity that requires delicacy and care, then I simply cannot help you.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by nradov on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:11PM (#29984174)
Several serious candidates in the 2020 presidential election explicitly supported federal marijuana legalization (or at least decriminalization). They didn't get many votes in the primaries, so apparently voters don't consider that an important issue.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by mindslight on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:41PM (#29984627)
You demonstrated my exact critique - voters were made to express their preferences in an extremely limiting fashion. Having to prioritize issues directly implies not being able to express your will on some issues.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by andrew_ on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:45PM (#29983790)
And if people believe that politicians are more about self-interest than representative interest and that it doesn't generally matter who is elected?
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by TameAntelope on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:49PM (#29983856)
Some people do believe that, but most don’t in any actionable sense, otherwise they’d do something about it.

It’s easy to pretend we’re collectively helpless just because we individually are, but being individually helpless is by design.

You were never meant to have more of a say than your neighbor, even if practically you may have at one point.

Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by busterarm on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:18PM (#29984290)
Revolution and the lack thereof is also a kind of voting.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by brimble on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:11PM (#29984170)
There's a significant and well-documented gap between voter preferences and our laws. Last I checked it's even larger in the US than in most democracies (our electoral system is designed to be that way, and also has failed in ways not originally expected, magnifying the effect)
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by d0mine on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:57PM (#29983974)
Research shows ordinary voters have zero influence.
Re:Workers are calling out sick in droves by rdtwo on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:19PM (#29984293)
People voted in a democratic senator and got a Republican traitor instead. I’m not sure it’s anyone’s will just bad luck