News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by seibelj on Monday January 17, 2022 @09:35PM (#29974330)
In the sci-fi novel Dune there is the Space Guild that became so advanced with shipbuilding that no other entity can possibly compete with them, and they internalized all the knowledge. This made all the noble houses have to deal with them.

Perhaps some technologies are just so advanced and difficult, with so many people and specialized knowledge, that firms like TSMC are unbeatable. No one can compete and their global power is assured.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by deltaonefour on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:58PM (#29974907)
It's much more complicated then that. TSMC relies on a company called ASML which itself relies on a company called Carl Ziess.

ASML makes the EUV etchers, and carl ziess makes the optical components needed to focus the light... both companies hold exclusive technological monopolies on their respective products.

In addition to this, Samsung and Intel are not that far behind the technology curve for making these chips... with Intel quickly shifting to include the capability of being a global foundry for making chips outside of their own designs.

Historically the landscape in the chip industry changes very quickly. I'm sure your analogy fits some technology in the world, but semiconductors is not it.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by mgfist on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:37PM (#29975169)
ASML has 4750 suppliers. The supply chain in the chip world is probably the most complex system in existence. Both astounding and frightening.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by riffraff on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:21AM (#29975778)
> the most complex system in existence

And by definition, anything that uses a chip will depend on this, I think? Cars, airplanes, game consoles, mobile phones... Heck, we have chips in pregnancy pee sticks these days.

So, I think all supply chains for "modern" things are insanely complex and effectively incomprehensible.

And this is not new, see the classic "I, Pencil"[0].

> Since only God can make a tree, I insist that only God could make me. Man can no more direct these millions of know-hows to bring me into being than he can put molecules together to create a tree.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I,_Pencil

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by kossTKR on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:24AM (#29976527)
It would be highly interesting to see a "tree of suppliers" for a single product - including how many people each part relied on, history etc.

I would imagine a smartphone for example having an unimaginably large diagram.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by techdragon on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @04:09AM (#29976809)
Outside of specific fields/circumstances and/or a generous interpretation of just what counts as part of the supply chain, it’s basically impossible. The moment even the simplest items, like surplus vegetables grown and harvested by a slightly above subsistence level farmer on traditionally owned land, get carried in a truck, or even a bicycle, your supply chain explodes into a vast interconnected web of circular links. Which trucks trucked the parts to make the trucks to truck the parts to make the trucks that trucked the parts to make the trucks that… and so on.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by philistine on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @04:06AM (#29976786)
Who makes the acid used to bleach the recycled cardboard for the box?

Seriously if you include the box, a phone touches so much of our economy it’s astounding.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by knolan on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:50AM (#29976676)
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by ralfd on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:19AM (#29977203)
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by N1H1L on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:29PM (#29985260)
The complexity of modern supply chains is in my opinion the strongest case for government regulations and against a lot of libertarian economic ideas.

It is impossible for the end-consumer, and even a lot of producers to know the provenance of every component in the supply chain. Even if every American consumer is against the destruction of rainforests, connecting the dots to palm oil cultivation and understanding the scale of ubiquity of palm oil in supermarket products is impossible. The only way out of this is government regulations.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by gocartStatue on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:22AM (#29977220)
I think that Eli Goldratt would not agree with you; number of connections does not determine the complexity of the system, it can be less complicated than system with smaller amount of connections. I believe these suppliers are pretty specialized, and that among those 4k+ there are "backup" ones too. Disclosure: I know nothing about chip making :)
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by _fizz_buzz_ on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:41AM (#29976613)
TSMC obviously relies on ASML. But a foundry is a complex beast. You don't simply place an order with ASML, set up a clean room and when the machine arrives press the on-button. There are A LOT of other processing steps that have to work properly (lithography is only one of them, albeit arguably the most complex one). What TSMC does is HARD. Just as TSMC cannot build their on EUV machine, ASML wouldn't be able to run their own fab.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by deltaonefour on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:03PM (#29983086)
Of course. Never stated otherwise. However what TSMC does is arguably more easily replicate-able by another foundry (say Samsung or Intel) than the EUV machine.

That being said, my main point wasn't to say that ASML has an exclusive monopoly over EUVs and therefore all chips... far from it. I was only illustrating the complexity of the supply chain. Many different entities have monopolies and the landscape constantly shifts.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by ksec on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:53PM (#29984779)
As ASML CEO once said "Dont ask me about how well our EUV TwinScan is working, ask TSMC, they know more about our machine than we do."
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by ethbr0 on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:59PM (#29975311)
Saying that TSMC relies on ASML and Zeiss is a bit reductive. If those were the ingredients of semiconductor success, then Intel wouldn't be in the position it's in.

Historically, the landscape of the chip industry has had many leading node players.

Now, it has ~1.75. TSMC & Samsung. With Intel and SMIC behind them.

The reduction to those 4 players, coupled with demand from mobile, GPUs, and ML accelerators, is pretty unique since the earliest days of the industry... when pretty obscene profits were also made for a long time (Intel, late 80s to 2000).

I'd call a decade of dominance a pretty stable industry.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by deltaonefour on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:04PM (#29983110)
>Saying that TSMC relies on ASML and Zeiss is a bit reductive. If those were the ingredients of semiconductor success

I never said this at all.

All I am saying is that the supply chain is complex and that to say TSMC is the sole monopoly holder of semiconductors is very very inaccurate.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by blueblisters on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @12:02AM (#29975332)
ASML supplies the machines, TSMC builds the infrastructure around them to maximize yields/make the investment profitable. Both of them have built complementary IP that is nearly impossible to replicate without violating multiple patents and spending 10s of billions of dollars.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by sooheon on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @12:18AM (#29975423)
In case any readers are (like I was) torn on the question of whether such a patent based legal monopoly (or duopoly or oligopoly...) is justifiable compensation for the resources these companies undoubtedly invested, check out this short intro to a highly recommended book that deals with this issue:

http://www.dklevine.com/papers/imbookfinal01.pdf

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by Tarq0n on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @08:19AM (#29978582)
That’s a great reference. A number of mainland countries were only able to catch up to Britain in industrialisation by suspending patent law for a while. Looking back I think it’s obvious that the result of this was hugely positive.

This also makes me somewhat sympathetic towards the lack of ip protections in China and other developing economies. Too often the patent system is used to kick away the ladder once one party has gained an advantage.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by deltaonefour on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:23AM (#29977223)
Still even without the patents. The knowledge and know how is incredibly hard to replicate. China doesn't even respect patents and they can't fully replicate the associated tech.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by barry-cotter on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:08AM (#29976049)
> Historically the landscape in the chip industry changes very quickly. I'm sure your analogy fits some technology in the world, but semiconductors is not it.

Semiconductors is as close as we've ever come to a natural monopoly. Aircraft are second. Boeing and Airbus are the only games in town.,

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by baq on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @04:19AM (#29976888)
for the big aircraft, yes. there's bombardier in the smaller segment and it's doing quite well.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by atq2119 on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:57AM (#29977449)
And don't forget about Embraer.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by baq on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @06:00AM (#29977472)
i totally forgot! yes, absolutely.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by fatbird on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:51PM (#29975255)
In Dune, the Spacing Guild held a monopoly on space travel because their navigators knew how to use the Spice to fold spacetime. Later in Frank Herbert's books, the Ixians replicate this ability technologically, ending their monopoly and the guild as an entity.

The lesson from Dune is that even the widest moat can be crossed.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by philistine on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @04:13AM (#29976835)
The Dune saga ends with Paul gaining the throne. No one knows what happened after that.

Herbert spent years improving Dune since no one wanted to publish it. He shined it to a perfect diamond.

When Dune was published, it was a good enough success to warrant sequels. Herbert wrote those sequels quickly, and they did not get any polish. They are not diamonds, and no one ought to extract lessons from them.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by basch on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:44PM (#29975208)
One thing that gets overlooked in pop semiconductor talk, and casual tech discussion in general, is that not everybody needs the latest and greatest. There may be one or multiple companies making the futuristic chips, but there is also market room for smaller firms to produce last gen products and clones of older tech. As long as it is cheap and commoditized and available, there will be consumers. Think of Small Soldiers, when surplus missile cpu's find there way into toys because they are technically available and nobody wants them. At some point, things are good enough, small enough, and cheap enough to get mass produced by shoddier and shoddier participants. The market can support more than TSMC.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by Robotbeat on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:26AM (#29975819)
The thing with semiconductor tech, though, is that not only are new nodes faster, they also use less power and (eventually) are cheaper as well. Don't invest in new nodes, and it'll cost more money for the same number of transistors.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by terafo on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:27AM (#29976156)
It's not as simple as that. You wouldn't make chip with less than a 100 million transistors on TSMC N5. Chips have not only maximal size, but minimal size as well. And you shouldn't forget about horrendous cost of masks. If you need a lot of very small chips for something simple you are better off using something like 28nm or older node. At the end total cost per chip is what matters for such customers, even if cost per transistor is higher. And, IIRC, cost for transistor is currently lower on N6 than on N5.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by basch on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:59PM (#29984014)
Power usage gets passed onto the consumer. People buying $25 tablets probably aren’t evaluating yearly power costs.

Or are you saying less power in manufacturing? Like I said, at some point cheap enough is cheap enough.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by Robotbeat on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @05:11PM (#29986757)
Battery life. Thermal constraints.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by basch on Wednesday January 19, 2022 @02:46PM (#29998973)
That is not going to negate the existence of cheap chips. Those are luxury features of higher end components.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by iszomer on Monday January 17, 2022 @11:03PM (#29974939)
TSMC made the long term investments in R&D and expertise and are reaping it's rewards.

Just like the short scene spoken by the Bene Gesserit in the 2021 film:

B.G: "..our plans are measured in centuries; we have other prospects if he fails his promise." .. "On Arrakis we have done all we can for you. The path has been laid, let's hope he doesn't squander it."

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by halpert on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:01PM (#29974507)
There are many examples of such phenomenon throughout history. However, there are always economic incentives for those with knowledge to strike out on their own to increase their personal gain. That’s generally why such knowledge-monopolies end. An example of this is how textile machines were built in the US by memorizing plans from Britain.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by e4e78a06 on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:19PM (#29974625)
Making a textile factory is a lot less capital intensive than a semiconductor fab.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by barry-cotter on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:11AM (#29976063)
Think in terms of available capital at the time, and availability of the requisite skilled labour and technical knowledge.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by roenxi on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @03:20AM (#29976485)
That lacks something of the "so what" follow up. TSMC is in the usual economic vice.

1) If they charge a lot and don't innovate, then there will be a huge reward waiting for whoever invests capital to compete with them.

2) If they are innovative and cheap, then they can fend off competition and nobody cares because they are innovative and cheap.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by chasil on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:37PM (#29974765)
Because these semiconductors are approaching fundamental limits of physics, it is unlikely that TSMC can achieve this status with anything like the current technology.

I think that Sophie Wilson said that cost-per-part is rising since we surpassed 22nm, heat is more of a problem because finfet can't dissipate as well as planar, and reliability is declining at smaller nodes. If I needed a 20-year service life, I would not choose 7nm.

Sophie addresses the cost rise at 22:00.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zX4ZNfvw1cw

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:14PM (#29974599)
> Perhaps some technologies are just so advanced and difficult, with so many people and specialized knowledge, that firms like TSMC are unbeatable.

Except that modern chipmaking is so complicated that even one company can't contain all the specialized knowledge. My understanding is that the Dutch company ASML is the only producer of EUV lithography machines in the world, which the chipmakers depend on to make their most advanced chips.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by jve on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:28AM (#29976162)
> Except that modern chipmaking is so complicated that even one company can't contain all the specialized knowledge.

(And capital intensive). But then again, these words could have been said about wannabe private rocket companies (SpaceX) or squeezing inside car market (Tesla), that actually turned out to be possible. So I wonder if any startup/billionaire will start to serve some niche chip market, be it capital intensive, but with some clever tactics...

Falcon 1 vs currently flying F9 rocket and potential Starship is a huge difference after all.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by modo_mario on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @10:27AM (#29980562)
Thing to not is that both examples wouldn't have been possible or where they are today without notable government projects/tax credits/etc.

With TSMC i think we'll see government churning up the market the moment the US expects it to be at risk from China or the like.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by barry-cotter on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @02:06AM (#29976043)
You have reinvented the economic theory of the natural monopoly. Notice that it's still possible to come (close) to the technological frontier, just not economically rational, and that if it costs under a billion dollars it's definitely not a natural monopoly.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by chii on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:28PM (#29974694)
> No one can compete and their global power is assured.

until they get disrupted. For example, a wholly new approach to CPU design using lazers and light, instead of silicon, or quantum computing perhaps.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by piyh on Monday January 17, 2022 @10:41PM (#29974795)
Or say a next door global superpower decides to get testy
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by nradov on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @12:42AM (#29975553)
Over a long enough time horizon eventually every dominant technology gets disrupted. But I'll bet that we'll all be retired before a credible alternative to semiconductor chips comes along for general purpose computing.

Even if quantum computers can be made to work at scale they'll always remain niche devices for running specialized algorithms. No one is ever going to calculate their income taxes on a quantum computer.

Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by xvilka on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @01:27AM (#29975824)
Yes, likely they will become something like the modern GPU card.
Re:The money printing press that is chip maker TSMC by everyone on Tuesday January 18, 2022 @04:17AM (#29976870)
That is one of the purposes of actual medieval guilds. To keep specialised manufacturing knowledge secret so the guild members can charge more.