Market goes down, crypto seems to go down with it. Look at something like 1-month BTC and 1-month APPL or something.
It's not supposed to be doing this. I think this is happening because it's become so easy to purchase that people now just have it in their "portfolio", basket of everything, and when they want to sell, they just sell everything, stocks and crypto. They are the same thing to a lot of people.
This means it is getting tied into the existing financial system anyway, even without specific "controls" like central banking.
The fact that its price somewhat correlates with the stock market and the fact that two parties can exchange bitcoins without any government being able to prevent the transactions from happening are two entirely unrelated things.
What's more, the first matters little (only because volatility can sometimes be annoying), while the second is an essential, even defining property of the system.
> It's not supposed to be doing this.
Why not? Again, Bitcoin was designed to solve one problem: allowing economic entities to exchange value freely.
Other than - maybe - the fixed supply, nothing was ever built in the protocol to control its price.
Is it really not? Both stocks and cryptocurrencies act as inflation hedges against the central bank.
If it were an actual currency things might be different, but instead it’s just another high risk speculative asset.
Also, it's better to look at charts by starting at the beginnning of this 4 year cycle, dont pick out a bearish 6 month period and falsely claim BTC fails the inflation test. Short termism and Bitcoin's monetary policy are incompatible.
You seem to be saying that it might pass it in the future.
If you choose to measure BTCs performance poorly (3-6 month windows), you are just feeding yourself a false conclusion since Bitcoin had a 5,000,000x return over the past decade.
> it did a 5,000,000x plus return in that time
Then it is self evidently not an inflation hedge.
No need to complicate things, just focus on 2 key questions...
1. Is the BTC supply inflation rate lower than the US dollar’s (and other fiat currencies)?
2. Will it be lower for the forseeable future?
That will give you the simple answer you are looking for...both answers are 'yes' btw.
What matters is whether the speculative asset acts like an inflation hedge.
Spoiler: it does not. It acts like a speculative bubble.
Gold is called an inflation hedge by many confused people, compare its performance to btc over the last 10 years and tell me which performs better in the face of fiat inflation.
>Price and supply are independent
Wrong. Price is literally discovered by supply vs demand.
Say 5 billionaires want to buy coin-x and the max circulating supply is 1 coin... When the bidding war starts, are price and supply independent?
I dont think you understand the topic we are discussing here, so I will move on.
What you are not seeing is that over that time, every one of the promises made about Bitcoin’s utility has been systematically disproven, which is why it has now stalled.
Past performance is no predictor of future gains, as they say.
If it is mostly used to speculate, not transact, does the supply matter at all to the price?
In essence, the idea is that if a teenager in 2010 acquired 10,000BTC the society owes him food, shelter and luxury for generations to come.
It’s like being a landlord whom passive income guarantees him and his family a good life with no work when people working their arses off to be able to pay the rent.
Not necessarily. The state still takes a percentage eg: property tax, maintenance, utilities, safety certifications, etc.
Multiple choice question: Which of the following groups have lots of control over BTC?
A. BTC Core Developers
B. BTC Exchanges
C. Credit Card Processors/ACH Entities/Payment apps that allow people to buy BTC from fiat without exchanging physical cash
D. BTC Miners
E. Any judge in the country that can order you to hand over your BTC just like he/she can order you to dig up the cash he/she suspects you have and hand it over.
F. All of the above and many more
(It's F)
>and by _state control_ I mean something along the lines of a central bank.
So central bank control would be something like "expansion of money supply beyond 21 million bitcoins". Therefore, your options (B) Coinbase/Binance (C) Visa/MC/banks and (E) courts -- really have no "control" over that "central bankish" aspect.
EDIT reply to: >Central banks [...] don't have complete control about the money supply, because commercial banks also create money via fractional reserves.
The Federal Reserve (central bank) in USA is the entity that adjusts the fractional reserve requirement.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Reserve#Reserve_requir...
> The idea that no one can expand the supply of bitcoins beyond 21 million is a nothing but fairy tale.
It could theoretically be done but it would require the coordination of the Bitcoin developers + miners + node validators. A crypto-exchange like Coinbase can't do it.
As a previous case study, Coinbase was part of the group that aligned with majority miners to change the Bitcoin protocol to increase the block size -- but all that influence and miner support still couldn't get the Bitcoin network to adopt it.
Sure anyone can affect anything but how did any of them selfishly affect the fundamental properties of the protocol?
BCH and BSV are scam attempts, and I wouldn't say they've been successful.
The BSV folks are particularly vocal that BTC is a fraud.
I have a friend of mine that retired at 40 from working at a hedge fund and investing his personal money well. Bought an 80 acre farm, has a bunch of a horses, a wife 20 years younger than him and three kids. He’s literally the smartest person I know and he believes Craig is Satoshi and that BSV is the best investment to come along since AMZN. I don’t get it - Craig Wright seems like a con artist to me and I’ve spent a ton of time looking into it.
The ideal that Bitcoin lets you escape the current financial dogmas is completely wrong, it's a parody of the existing system.
Something like Freicoin would be more appropriate as an alternative, e.g. an "abundant" currency that always makes itself available to anyone who wants to trade.
Do they?
What is your evidence for this?
Also, if we assume they do, well ... their BTC is now potentially subject to seizure, hacking, fees, bankrupt exchanges ... well, their choice.
Darwinism at work as far as I'm concerned.
Not you keys, not your coins.
There is about 250k BTC on ETH as WBTC, the largest secondary pool in escrow. Ren has about 18K BTC in escrow. Lightning network is about 3k BTC.
Bitcoin maxis literally go insane telling people to take their coins off exchanges. It's part of the dogma.
BTC was designed specifically to avoid any kind of _state control_ and by _state control_ I mean something along the lines of a central bank. Adding protections here and there will inevitably lead to a system that is similar to current financial system with all the bells and whistles.
I think you're missing the point: BTC tries to sell lack of any kind of control (or protection, however you want to call it) as a _feature_.