News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ipspam on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:20PM (#29842660)
So your for using power to totally destroy all the hard won battles for transparency, destroy trust in public institutions, and feed conspiracy theories?

I don't think you have thought this through. I don't think you read the part where the FDA has 18,000 employees.

The FDA should be above politics.

Isn't it suspicious that the FDA is doing this, and that the public have a right to know and see the underlying documents within 90 days of drug approval? Isn't is Phizers responsibility to submit the documents in a way that protects privacy?

All the norms are lost here. You couldn't find a better way to destroy the credibility of the FDA than to "never" have meaningful transparency on the fastest, most hastily produced, many corners cut drug.

Quite frankly, the FDA would rubber stamp a pile of cow poop if it were politically expedient.

The only way to win back trust is to hold them accountable, for better or for worse, even if it feeds vaccine conspiracies.

It can't be done in my generation, but maybe in the next when this COVID saga is largely memory holed

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by daveevad on Sunday January 09, 2022 @06:13PM (#29868426)
I'd like to add that the situation is so severe we should prioritize a solution to COVID at the expense of individual privacy.

This is the biggest problem we've ever needed to solve as a society. Release the documents and we'll find the bugs.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by dopylitty on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:24PM (#29842722)
No, none of it is suspicious, unless you're a person who is trying to cast doubt on vaccines by claiming that vaccines on platforms that have been under development for two decades and went through enormous trials were 'hastily produced' with 'corners cut'
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by steelstraw on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:23PM (#29845024)
It's about being suspicious of the pharmaceutical industry and the FDA, which has a revolving door that has been abused.

The FDA has never been held to account for its improper handling of the opioid crisis. But the FDA’s conduct is all the more troubling in light of the close relationship between the agency officials responsible for opioid oversight and opioid manufacturers. For example, the 2 principal FDA reviewers who originally approved Purdue’s oxycodone application both took positions at Purdue after leaving the agency. Over the past 20 years, several other FDA staff involved in opioid approvals also left the FDA to work for opioid makers. Last January, the head of the FDA’s analgesic division retired from the FDA to start her own consulting business, which promises drug makers “help” to “successfully and efficiently bring your products to market” with “more than 30 years of experience at the FDA.”

To be clear, the revolving door between the FDA and the pharmaceutical industry is not limited to opioids. A 2018 study found that 11 of 16 FDA medical reviewers involved in approving 28 products now work for the companies whose products they regulated. Without appropriate limits on employment after leaving the FDA, staff might be tempted to put the interests of future employers, whose favor they wish to gain, ahead of public health.

https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/how-fda-failure...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by avs733 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:29PM (#29845076)
Do you have any evidence to support that accusation in the last paragraph or is it just a hypothesis that you linked to minimally related other facts?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ghufran_syed on Friday January 07, 2022 @06:43PM (#29846596)
you mean prove that conflict of interest is real? Isn’t that something that any experience with human behavior would confirm quite easily? Do we need to prove that judges should not receive money from one of the parties in a lawsuit they are presiding over?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by keneda7 on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:04PM (#29843289)
Are you referring to the mRNA vaccine platform? Could you point me to the mRNA vaccine application that was approved before covid?

When I looked into it all, of them had been denied until covid and I did not hear of any breakthrough in mRNA technology that suddenly fixed the issues the previous ones (I found 8) had been denied for.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by jaywalk on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:47PM (#29843787)
It's just a coincidence that these companies that have been working for years on this stuff failed every single time in the past, but then within a few weeks in early 2020 they suddenly figured everything out.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:10PM (#29844072)
Not a coincidence, no.

Just a very different cost/benefit analysis on "do all the steps we can in parallel to speed things up" during a pandemic.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by keneda7 on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:38PM (#29844493)
I am confused here. There were issues with the previously submitted mRNA vaccines created pre covid. Of the 8 I could find all were rejected. Doing a process that does not work in parallel will not suddenly fix it.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:43PM (#29844545)
Well, let's say you're exploring a cave with six entrances.

If it's any old cave, you might just explore one at a time.

If you're pretty sure the Holy Grail is somewhere in it, you might hire six explorers, at higher initial expense.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by jaywalk on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:59PM (#29844727)
Moderna was founded precisely to find the Holy Grail. Making a breakthrough in a matter of weeks that couldn't be found for 8 years is incredibly hard to believe no matter how much additional money is thrown at the problem.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:02PM (#29844765)
"Matter of weeks" or "they've been working on the tech for eight years".

Pick one. You can't have both.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by jaywalk on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:27PM (#29845068)
No, I can have both. For 8 years, they've tried a bunch of different things that they thought would work. Literally none of them did. And then in a matter of weeks, they figured the whole thing out.

Obviously they didn't start from zero. But it wasn't like they had something from, say, 2018 that was looking promising but just hadn't made it all the way through trials yet. They had nothing but failures.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:32PM (#29845117)
They spent eight years iterating their technology. The idea that they had nothing but already-failed candidates at the start of the pandemic is simply false.

Their 10-K from the end of 2019: https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1682852/000168285220...

> We have a diverse pipeline of 24 development candidates, 12 of which are currently in clinical trials, and many of which have the potential to be first-in-class or best-in-class medicines.

All of this is a bit academic, anyways. We've plenty of evidence the Moderna vaccine works. You can quibble over the exact rate of rare side effects a little, but it's abundantly clear it's good at reducing deaths and severe disease in the vaccinated population.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by newrotik on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:22PM (#29845683)
Moderna use has been suspended for individuals <30y in several Scandinavian countries due to its side effects.

The point discussed is not whether it works or not, but what are the actual safety parameters.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:24PM (#29845708)
No, they're saying "Making a breakthrough in a matter of weeks that couldn't be found for 8 years is incredibly hard to believe".

That's not a "Pfizer's is slightly safer in 30+ males and should be used preferentially in that population if both are available" safety quibble.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by allturtles on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:05PM (#29845466)
So if they didn't make the breakthrough in weeks, what do you think happened? They already had a secret COVID vaccine for years? The trials were faked and all the post-trial evidence about vaccine efficacy is also faked?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by dragonwriter on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:09PM (#29845511)
> So if they didn't make the breakthrough in weeks, what do you think happened?

The expected vaccine sales were high enough to justify spending resources initiating developement on lots of candidate mRNA vaccines in parallel, and spending the money testing more of the potentially viable ones at a time than would otherwise have been the case. When you throw a lot more against the wall, you find something that sticks a lot faster.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by mike00632 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:51PM (#29845323)
Wait, what were the issues with the mRNA vaccines? If you are accusing the mRNA vaccines of having "issues" then it's important you provide details and a citation
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:54PM (#29845353)
Moderna had some pre-COVID mRNA clinical trials that failed for various reasons. (As is, to say the least, common in the pharmaceutical industry.)

https://www.statnews.com/2017/01/10/moderna-trouble-mrna/

> But the Crigler-Najjar treatment has been indefinitely delayed, an Alexion spokeswoman told STAT. It never proved safe enough to test in humans, according to several former Moderna employees and collaborators who worked closely on the project. Unable to press forward with that technology, Moderna has had to focus instead on developing a handful of vaccines, turning to a less lucrative field that might not justify the company’s nearly $5 billion valuation.

Of course, as the apocryphal Edison quote goes, "I haven't failed, I've found 10,000 ways that don't work."

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by jaywalk on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:28PM (#29844345)
If only Moderna had realized in that they could "do all the steps [they] can in parallel to speed things up" 8 years ago! They managed to accomplish what had eluded them for 8 years in a matter of weeks. Astounding stuff.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:46PM (#29844583)
Again, it's a cost/benefit analysis.

The benefit went up. The acceptable costs of parallelization similarly went up.

(Some steps got easier, too, for the same "everyone really wants a solution yesterday" reasons, like recruiting trial volunteers. For example: https://www.sciencenews.org/article/covid-coronavirus-vaccin...)

> For instance, it took just under 16 weeks to recruit and enroll more than 43,000 volunteers for the final phases of testing Pfizer’s vaccine. When volunteer recruitment began for clinical trials of the rabies mRNA vaccine in 2013, it took 813 days to get 101 participants enrolled. Based on this comparison, that’s roughly 730 days — nearly two years — saved in recruiting alone.

The same article cites precisely one of those parallelization steps I'm talking about:

> In a final jolt of speed, some pharmaceutical companies, bolstered by big vaccine contracts and research cash from the U.S. government’s Operation Warp Speed, were also churning out doses during clinical trials in the hopes that the vaccines would work. Once the companies had emergency use authorization in hand, they were ready to ship doses immediately.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by jaywalk on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:56PM (#29844695)
Sure, you're explaining why and how testing went faster. I totally understand that, but it's not at all what I'm talking about.

All of the previous mRNA drugs failed testing due to safety concerns. But we're expected to believe that those safety concerns were resolved in a matter of weeks.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by ceejayoz on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:00PM (#29844739)
> All of the previous mRNA drugs failed testing due to safety concerns.

Sure, and all the planes leading up to the Wright Flyer failed.

https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02483-w has a great timeline graphic of the various advances and breakthroughs required to get to this point, including the first drug using the lipid nanoparticles - key to fixing the safety concerns! - approved in 2018.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by shard on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:25PM (#29845048)
Nothing like a pandemic and millions of people dying to light a fire under some asses.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by colpabar on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:39PM (#29844500)
For sure. I know if I had an opportunity to create and sell a product that would be all but required for everyone across the world, I'd hurry my ass up to create it.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by hotz on Friday January 07, 2022 @01:30PM (#29842818)
It boggles my mind that anyone can oppose transparency. Why do some people view these vaccines/pharma companies as something sacred, not to be questioned.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:34PM (#29843641)
There is a difference between normal transparency and demanding the release of 450,000 pages of patient data.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by chaps on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:07PM (#29844833)
(disclaimer: my experience with FOIA is mostly at the state level and though I've read, used, and litigated federal FOIA issues, I'm no expert there)

Transparency doesn't work in isolation. If there's a problem where the release of 450,000 pages of patient information is so difficult that it can't be done, then there's a fundamental process fuckup that should be corrected. For example, if everything's on paper, then the process failure is in a lack of transcription. If it's because private information is typed in a form, that form should be broken up in a way so that the important private information is typed into another field. Generally there are ways to make sure these issues don't happen -- from the beginning. Keep in mind, these people are aware of the existence of FOIA and the possibility that these records would be subject to FOIA. These processes should be built with that in-mind, especially considering the importance of the information.

It's such a big deal that in states like Illinois, the law disallows the use of the unduly burdensome exemption if the gov agency doesn't respond within the time limits of the statute. Takes 10k hours? Big deal, shoulda responded in time.

A lot of these issues stem from the fact that in so many cases, the agency's estimates are either beyond any possible worst case scenario (ie, unrealistic), or an intentionally naive estimate in order to urge the requester to go away. If we take these public agencies at face value that something would take forever without litigation, then they can easily just make it a routine process to call something unduly burdensome, so it's important to call them out on their shit. See: https://mchap.io/that-time-the-city-of-seattle-accidentally-...

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by shard on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:23PM (#29845033)
I would imagine it's like technical debt. There's benefits to paying that debt down, but there are always other issues that have higher priority. Sure, the software should have been architectured to be easily extensible / system should have been set up to make it easy to release half a million pages of documents, but this update has to be released in time to beat the competition / these drug approvals needs to be completed to save lives.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by chaps on Friday January 07, 2022 @05:27PM (#29845735)
The argument on technical debt isn't wrong, but it doesn't fully take into account the importance of this information and the legal requirements these agencies are held to. Just because it's difficult doesn't mean the information shouldn't be released. If we accept that the request is difficult as a reason to not release the records, then they'll never get released. Once that seed's planted, it's so unbelievably hard to come out of. It's something you see with agencies that never get held accountable to their lack of transparency.

It sucks, but the alternative is much worse.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by shard on Friday January 07, 2022 @08:41PM (#29847632)
Absolutely. Even with highly profitable global megacorps, technical debt is an issue, but eventually they have to pay the piper. I'm not sure if it is true in this case, but my image of governmental agencies are that they are perpetually underfunded and short-staffed, so it must be an even greater difficulty to choose between what should be done and what must be done.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by klabb3 on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:54PM (#29844680)
Remember pfizers own report and raw data are not the only options, it's a false dichotomy.

In order to make the report in the first place, Pfizer had to preprocess the data to intermediate, tabulated formats. However, this data is their secret IP, which in and of itself is absolutely insane, given that we're moving in the direction of mandates.

I don't get how one of the most foul industries – by public track record — suddenly get a carte blanche from otherwise sane and critical people. There are so many scandals in Pharma, and suddenly overnight you're a conspiracy theorist if you want independent scientists to double check the biggest public health mandate in history.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Miner49er on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:19PM (#29844203)
This is very useful information, though. People can analyze this to find out if there is any increased risk of adverse effects (or not) by all kinds of factors that hasn't been released. Things like underlying medical conditions.

Some people with certain medical conditions are vaccine-hesitant because of their health condition. If this data can prove that people with certain health conditions aren't at any increased risk from the vaccine, it could mean more people get vaccinated.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by postalrat on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:04PM (#29844003)
So in the future if they have something to hide just produce 450k pages of patient data to hide behind.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by lalaland1125 on Friday January 07, 2022 @03:06PM (#29844027)
Or maybe the plaintiffs could be more explicit about what data in particular they are looking for.

The reason why they are getting the endless pages of patient data is because the plaintiffs are asking for it.

Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by chaps on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:09PM (#29844856)
Sorry, no. These gov agencies don't tell us what information they have (often intentionally!) and so we can't always be explicit about what information we want. If they told us exactly the extent of information they have, then we wouldn't need to play these silly little games of requesting more than what necessarily exists.. but what choice do we have?
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by vorpalhex on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:44PM (#29843759)
That is normal transparency.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by allturtles on Friday January 07, 2022 @02:18PM (#29843468)
Who is against transparency? Has anyone argued that this information shouldn't be released? AFAICT the court battle is just about speed, and whether the FDA should go out of its way to satisfy this particular FOIA request more quickly.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by Karunamon on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:10PM (#29844874)
At least one person is arguing precisely that in this thread.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by merpnderp on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:09PM (#29844858)
Anyone taking the FDA's side is against transparency. In 75 years no one will care about this data except like a single historian working on their PhD in a bizarre medical history field.
Re:Judge orders FDA to hasten FOIA release of Pfizer vaccine... by avs733 on Friday January 07, 2022 @04:25PM (#29845045)
> So your for using power to totally destroy all the hard won battles for transparency, destroy trust in public institutions, and feed conspiracy theories?

If the FDA screws up in their now legally compelled rush to produce these documents what happens?

Pfizer could have their trade secret info leaked (like it or not that shouldn't happen)

Participants in vaccine trials could have their private health information leaked (or have their identity stolen)

The FDA is responsible and liable

FOIA abuse is a thing, just like DMCA abuse is a thing. People abusing the FOIA process are the ones who are likely to lead to its power being destroyed, not the government here.

It isn't suspicious...this group is intentionally misinterpreting things in bad faith under the guise of accountability.

It's classic bad faith, and I'm deeply saddened at how easily this country falls for it.