News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nknight on Sunday September 11, 2011 @11:46AM (#2983960)
I think the main problem I have with this is that it's not internally consistent. He talks about the evolution of a complex system by incremental improvements, but apparently maintains the libertarian instinct of "This is broken, throw it out." instead of "This is broken, how do we improve it?". There are an enormous number of governance models that have never been seriously tried on a large scale. There is no fundamental reason to believe that the libertarian value of "shut it all down" is going to produce better results than any of the other possible models.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:16PM (#2984042)
I think you are putting words into his mouth with the "this is broken, throw it out". The reason why unconventional governance models are treated with general skepticism is one of the major points of the essay, which is that if the unconventional governance models are being designed and implemented by the same crew of people with the same basic beliefs that are dominant today, there's no particular reason to believe the outcome is going to be any different in the end. "What makes me a libertarian is that the prospect of having that reconfiguration done by the same system that managed to ban marijuana while allowing tobacco, subsidize ethanol made from corn, and turn the patent system into a form of legalized bludgeoning, makes me want to run screaming into the night until I fall over from lack of oxygen."

Also, characterizing the libertarian answer as "shut it all down" is a strawman in its own right. I daresay one of the major ideas that prevents people from understanding libertarianism is understanding that "let the market deal with it" is not anything remotely resembling "shut it all down". The market provides very sharp constraints on what actions one may profitably take, and one of the advantages of the market system is that said constraints are much more closely connected with reality than any other commonly proposed system is. As an also-little-l libertarian I don't deny that some further regulation may be necessary, but defying the market is less like defying people and more like defying physics. You will pay the price. (In fact, we are, right now.) In particular I strongly believe in the need for regulations that ensures that the market stays free, so I'm very in favor of regulations to prevent monopolies from forming, and very hostile to government-granted market monopolies.

If you understand the market as "it's all, like, greed man, and greedy people abusing other greedy people, and, like, evil, man", you really ought to spend some time understanding the theory of the market as an actual existing entity, rather than a politically-oriented strawman designed cognitively innoculate you against ideas that may actually change your mind if you were to truly learn about them. Perhaps it won't change your mind, but I'll say that most people online's efforts to pry me away from my libertarianism fails on the grounds that almost nobody actually understands it in the first place, which puts them at a bit of a disadvantage.

(Remember, almost nobody is raised libertarian. Few libertarians hold their beliefs unexamined, the way that those who were simply raised liberal or conservative can, though of course not all do.)

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:46PM (#2984120)
You appear to have a sentiment that is roughly equivalent to the "market is right". The problem with this is that I don't think it scales. One person who buys a house they can't really afford is not a big deal. Let such a person make that bad decision if this is their inclination is a libertarian attitude. But millions of people make a similarly bad decision affects us all.

The market isn't always right. Imbalances can and do occur. The effects can be devastating to nonparticipants. Cartels, monopoly rents, etc. are some other types of bad effects that markets can devolve into.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by SwellJoe on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:13PM (#2984196)
I find it interesting that you use the recent home mortgage crisis as an example of market failure. Libertarians often use it as an example of governmental failure. Markets and governments were involved in the creation and fallout of the crisis...and people on either side want to blame the other. It's actually pretty analogous to the problem Eliezer pointed out about the balance of heredity vs. environment.

While the mortgage crisis would not have happened without market forces (+ human greed) and government involvement. The question becomes which of those factors we can alter or remove to make such an occurrence impossible in the future, rather than which factor to blame. From a pragmatic perspective, since we can't remove human greed, the other option is to not implement government programs that make it easier for millions of people who can't afford a house to get a mortgage.

So, more government might have prevented the problem, perhaps in the form of education programs for home buyers who only qualified because of the government programs. But, less government could have prevented the problem, as well, since the vast majority of those loans would have never happened without government programs to encourage them.

My instincts tell me to go the less expensive route, and let the market decide who can afford a house or not. If a bank knows the government isn't going to bail them out (as would be the case if these loans weren't government-backed), they're going to be more careful about who gets those loans.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by scott_s on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:08PM (#2985140)
since the vast majority of those loans would have never happened without government programs to encourage them.

I'm going to copy-and-paste something I said before on this topic (which was actually a reply to jerf):

I slogged through much of the Financial Crisis Inquiry Report (http://fcic.law.stanford.edu/). One of the conclusions was that while mandating loans didn't help, they weren't numerous enough to be a major cause. Because of the mortgage-backed securities industry, there was incentive for banks to make sub-prime loans and offload the loans (and the risk) elsewhere. Once the MBS engine got churning, there was an enormous demand for more loans to feed it. In other words, the government's requirements did not lead to the glut of sub-prime loans.

Education for the home-buyers would probably not work. I can't remember which author it was who made this point, but on reading about the crisis, someone pointed out that people will take what you give them. That's not really fixable. The fixable problem was that banks were willing to make such loans. And they were willing to make such loans not because they knew the government would bail the loans out, but because the banks would not keep the loans. They'd turn around and sell the loans to investment banks that packaged the loans up into MBSs. The banks making the sub-prime loans weren't the same banks that were on-the-hook for them.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by inthewoods on Monday September 12, 2011 @08:42AM (#2986988)
Actually the majority of the housing crisis would have been avoided had the government stepped in and simply required confirmation of income on mortgage applications. The lack of this simple and obvious requirement (which Obama put into place as soon as he came into office) allowed independent mortgage companies like Countrywide to put together ridiculous mortgages for people that could not afford it. Those same mortgage companies then sold the mortgages for packaging and had no risk. Thus, they were incentivized to get as many mortgages done as possible - regardless of the risk.

From my point of view, this is a classic example of where government regulation not only makes sense, but keeps market participates from creating abnormal risk.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:22PM (#2984210)
I was only providing an example of how libertarian principles don't always scale. I said nothing about the housing market in the U.S. and I don't know why you bring up the U.S. housing market.

From what I've read about libertarianism (the economic principles of libertarianism) it is highly impractical. It seem like a set of principles that work at the local level provided there is plenty of competition. Libertarian principles don't scale at a macro level. Especially in the presence of cartels or monopolies. Or in an environment when risk is being transferred to parties who don't understand the risk that is being transfered to them and when this risk transfer is being done on a truly massive scale.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by SwellJoe on Sunday September 11, 2011 @02:13PM (#2984356)
"One person who buys a house they can't really afford is not a big deal. Let such a person make that bad decision if this is their inclination is a libertarian attitude. But millions of people make a similarly bad decision affects us all."

I assumed you were describing a recent real-world scenario where exactly this occurred. What did you have in mind, if not the recent US mortgage crisis? It seems, to me, that real examples are more useful than imagined ones. If we are using imaginary problems, we can come up with all sorts of interesting solutions, but they don't necessarily carry over to real world problems.

Thought experiments can be useful tools, but when the results conflict with reality, you have to be willing to adjust and accommodate new data.

"Especially in the presence of cartels or monopolies."

Which cartels and monopolies do you have in mind? The biggest monopolies and cartels I can think of in the US are those that have government support to protect their monopoly. Phone, cable, power, water, are the most firmly held monopolies (occasionally duopolies) in the US, for instance, and all are protected by government. Toll roads in the northeast are another good example of government-endorsed monopolies (I'm not saying the toll roads are necessarily a bad thing, just that they are solidly a monopoly; you can't really drive from NYC to anywhere without travelling on those toll roads, and they are, by far, the most expensive toll roads I've ever driven on, and I travel full-time in a motorhome, so I've seen a lot of toll roads).

Microsoft was frequently called a monopoly for several years, but the market eventually removed those monopolistic powers. Anti-trust actions barely put a dent in their power, and targeted quite small, quite unimportant elements. The market is where the real change came from. Heck, many of the remaining strongholds for Microsoft are in governments, which are unable to move as fast as private organizations. And, a not insignificant amount of Microsoft's power came from having a stranglehold on government schools, offices, etc.

I can't think of many other good monopoly examples that aren't government-backed, though I'm sure there are some examples. I'm willing to believe that anti-trust legislation has a place; but I'm also very suspicious of the argument that all government is good government because monopolies and cartels are dangerous, which seems to be the root of your bias against libertarianism or reduced government.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nerfhammer on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:28PM (#2984568)
Perhaps the reason you have trouble thinking of monopolies that aren't government sanctioned is because anti-trust law already prohibits monopolies from forming unless government sanctioned.

The exceptions that are sanctioned are examples in economic theory of "natural monopolies", typically utilities, where competition would be highly impractical. For example, it would be impractical to have many different competing networks of privately owned telephone poles, sewer lines, water lines, etc. serving the same municipality. So a natural monopoly is allowed to exist but is heavily regulated and may face price controls.

see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by kiba on Sunday September 11, 2011 @09:14PM (#2985448)
Perhaps the reason you have trouble thinking of monopolies that aren't government sanctioned is because anti-trust law already prohibits monopolies from forming unless government sanctioned.

I remember anti-trust law being used against smaller companies because lawyers find it easier to persecute than fighting against bigger companies. Even anti-trust regulations can be used to decrease competition.

Sometime it's better to opt for the least worst option rather than opting for a solution that kill the patient.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nknight on Sunday September 11, 2011 @10:48PM (#2985636)
Microsoft aside, Standard Oil, Kodak, AT&T, and, well, AT&T-2, off the top of my head. These are/were "smaller companies"?

Antitrust claims get tacked on to a lot of lawsuits by overzealous attorneys, but they're usually dismissed out of hand. Serious antitrust litigation is rare, and by definition targets companies that are large in their particular industries.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:09PM (#2984185)
The market did not create the housing crisis. The government fiddled with the market all to hell, with the Community Reinvestment Act, the regulations surrounding the ratings agencies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac's unmarket-like backings of loans, and a hodge-podge of other lesser interventions.

When the market was allowed to make decisions about who should get loans, the standards were a lot higher. But it wasn't "right" for people to have to put 20% down and have a very solid credit rating, because it discriminated against poor people (and Democratic voters), so the government fiddled until it produced the result it (thought it) wanted, forcing banks to lower mortgage standards until we eventually worked our way down to no-money down ARMs.

(BTW, the claim the government had nothing to do with it is to claim that all the regulation like the CRA and Fannie Mae and anti-discrimination all had absolutely no effect at all, in which one must answer the question, if regulations like that are so ineffectual that you can't lay any responsibility for the current crisis at their feet, then why do you think government regulations are the answer to anything? Either they are effective or they are not, but you can't flip back and forth depending on whether you like the effect or not.)

The problem is that people think of "the market" as a fundamental property, but in fact it is a derived property. The reason why the market tended to correctly allocate mortgages prior to the government's heavy-handed decades-long intervention is the incentive structure. Always look at the incentive structure. If my bank is going to issue me a mortgage, and the government leaves them alone, they are going to take a lot of steps to protect themselves, such as setting the requirements for your credit strength very high, and requiring large downpayments, and generally ensuring they aren't going to be left holding the bag when the mortgage falls through. Alternatively, if they're going to sell that risk, the receiving party is going to want the same due diligence. The government interventions basically systematically tore than incentive structure apart, by allowing them to just dump the mortgage off on Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac, by requiring them to make loans that they basically knew would fail but the government held guns to their head to do it, etc. If I had to pick one thing that really enabled the housing crisis, it was the ability to dump mortgages off on the FMs for what were in actuality above-market rates, then for the seller to be free-and-clear of the responsibilities. Other things may have accelerated it, but that structure guaranteed disaster on its own.

No, the market isn't "always right", but that's not really the question. Nothing is "always right". The question, which is more likely to be right, the market system or the government system? One of the big reasons I tend libertarian is that I empirically observe that the government almost inevitably creates incredibly broken incentive structures where the market tends to create ones that are much more connected to reality. In this particular case, the "reality" that the market is much more connected to is the question of "will X be able to pay their mortgage back?" I have to use the broad term "reality" when discussing it in general, but it actually comes back down to specifics like this.

One much also distinguish between "the market" being broken, and reality being "broken". Yes, mortgage requirements were quite high; that's because in reality it's a huge risk. It turns out the market wasn't broken here, and the efforts to "fix" it were the true brokenness.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by MaysonL on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:55PM (#2984811)
"The market did not create the housing crisis. The government fiddled with the market all to hell, with the Community Reinvestment Act, the regulations surrounding the ratings agencies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac's unmarket-like backings of loans, and a hodge-podge of other lesser interventions."

Right, which is why it only happened in America, not in other places like England, and Ireland, and Spain, which had neither CRA nor Fannie nor Freddie. Oh wait...

For a different, and for my money, substantially more accurate diagnosis of the crisis, go listen to William K. Black [1]. He was one of the regulators who prosecuted many of the corrupt bankers who perpetrated the savings and loan crisis.

[1].http://dailybail.com/home/dr-william-k-black-the-great-ameri...

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nerfhammer on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:33PM (#2984579)
Now explain to me how the Community Reinvestment Act created co-occurring housing crises in Spain, Iceland, Ireland, Latvia, et al.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by scott_s on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:13PM (#2985147)
I think you're completely ignoring the mortgage-backed securities industry which not only bought up many of these loans, but created a market for them. I read that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were actually late to that party.

Also, saying that this regulation had minimal effect does not imply that all regulation will have minimal effect.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:23PM (#2984212)
I was only providing an example of how libertarian principles don't always scale. I said nothing about the housing market in the U.S. and I don't know why you bring up the U.S. housing market.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:29PM (#2984227)
"One person who buys a house they can't really afford is not a big deal. Let such a person make that bad decision if this is their inclination is a libertarian attitude. But millions of people make a similarly bad decision affects us all."

I don't think it's exactly a stretch to assume that such a (putatively) topical example was related to current events.

Besides, in the process of describing why the crisis wasn't caused by markets, I answered your objection anyhow. When the free market was making the decisions about mortgages, they did in fact make it in a sustainable way. Once the lenders were detached from the consequences of their decisions by the government, that broke. There's no better way to ensure that we don't have a housing crisis than to use those market mechanisms.

Note carefully I didn't say "if we use those mechanisms, we'll never have a housing crisis". I said there's no better way. It's basically impossible to completely prevent periodic crises.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:48PM (#2984283)
I did write, "The problem with this is that I don't think it scales." before the quoted line. It was a stretch.

Lenders weren't detached from the consequences of their decisions by the government. They were detached from the consequences of their decisions by selling securities based on the loans they made to dupes. That it was done at a massive scale without the dupes properly pricing in the risk caused a meltdown.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @02:03PM (#2984324)
The fundamental underlying reason they could sell those securities was that they were exploiting the arbitrage from being able to dump the mortgages off on the FMs, at which point everybody knew they were unrealistically guaranteed by the Federal Government. I would point out that here in 2011, that's no longer a theory or mere rhetoric; it is now historical fact that the mortgages are in fact being covered by the Feds, as manifested by all the bailouts. Check out the FM's current financial situation if you need more proof. Without that risk sink in the system, they would never have been able to fly as far off the handle as they did. The securities were just ways of slicing up the stuff that was broken by the government-created risk sink.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by scott_s on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:30PM (#2985188)
I think you're ignoring the big investment banks, which also had many (most?) of these loans. I don't see how Fannie and Freddie factor into for, say, Lehman Brothers, which collapsed because they backed so many MBSs that were becoming losses.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by inthewoods on Monday September 12, 2011 @08:47AM (#2987002)
Ugh, not that tired old horse - the CRA existed for years prior to the crisis, yet the run up happened between 2001 and 2006. That, by itself, basically refutes the idea that the CRA caused the housing crisis.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by prodigal_erik on Monday September 12, 2011 @09:29AM (#2987168)
In other news, the CRA only applies to retail banks offering FDIC-insured deposits, while most of the stupid loans were written by pure mortgage banks immune from the CRA. And it's not as if they needed to be pressured into it when they could take their cut and dump 100% of the fraudulently concealed risk.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jdietrich on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:37PM (#2984250)
It doesn't matter whether the market is right or not. What matters is that the market is. Politicians routinely forget that. Communism's core failure was ignoring the irrepressible nature of market forces. The same applies to our system of capitalism.

One of the core factors that drove the credit crisis was ignoring market forces. "Too big to fail" led directly and obviously to recklessness. Bankers knew that they had nothing to lose and everything to gain. In a system where a government explicitly or implicitly guarantees banks, there is little incentive for anyone involved to guard against cataclysmic failures. As we so often do, we privatised gains and nationalised losses.

The desire to fix "market imbalances" is only that, a desire. The evidence is that most attempts to fix the market only make things worse. If we merely want to be seen to be doing "the right thing", then it's reasonable to legislate and hope for the best. If we actually want to improve the world, we must recognise that the market is tantamount to a force of nature.

Decades of trying to control wildfires led only to fiercer, more devastating fires. It was only when we realised that fires are a natural part of a forest ecosystem that we began to reduce the damage caused. Attempting to prevent any negative outcomes of a free market is similarly futile.

We can't control markets. Khruschev and Breshnev couldn't, nor Greenspan or Bernanke. All we can do is nudge it a little, build a firebreak here, drop a bucket there. Until we recognise that, we're doomed to the cycle of boom and bust that has dominated post-industrial economies.

People do stuff. You can attempt to change their incentives, but they'll still do whatever makes sense to them. That's the core of libertarian thought. Accept that lack of control, accept that the drug war can't be won, accept abortion and gambling and credit default swaps, then try and work out how best to mitigate the externalities of those things. Legislate based on what is not on what we think ought to be.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by bermanoid on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:03PM (#2984652)
It doesn't matter whether the market is right or not. What matters is that the market is. Politicians routinely forget that. Communism's core failure was ignoring the irrepressible nature of market forces. The same applies to our system of capitalism.

And libertarians routinely forget that the unwashed masses actually want social programs and regulations, and they hate seeing people get rich off of "the market" by doing things that seem abusive. They want public services like police, fire, ambulances and schools. They want to have some assurance that when BigCo tries to get anti-competitive and monopolistic someone will step in, and they want to know that if the CEO shorts his own stock in anticipation of bad news that nobody else knows about he will be punished for it rather than profit. Libertarians may not want any of this because of their philosophical and economic leanings, but most other people do...

Why is it that the free market is such an immense force that we should uncritically accept that it is unchangeable, yet the desire of millions of people to control it, regulate it, or otherwise make it work for everyone instead of only the richest of the direct participants is somehow negotiable?

I understand that you're saying that nothing we can do will change the markets, all I'm saying is that it's just as possible that nothing we can do will make people happy about the way they function uninhibited, so maybe there's a good reason we've ended up somewhere in the middle.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:58PM (#2984313)
In a truly free market system too big to fail can occur. Bank runs, financial panics and collapses occurred for centuries before governments made explicit or implicit guarantees to banks or other large enterprises.

That there wasn't a total collapse of the banking system in 2008 was precisely because of government intervention. Everyone would have withdrawn their funds from banks had it not been for FDIC. Imbalances can't be prevented. What can be prevented is a total collapse and the effects of imbalances can be mitigated. This is one of the main reasons for the modern interventionist view of governments with regard to market regulation.

The goal is to prevent millions of small bad decisions ending up adversely affecting the whole country. This is my problem with libertarianism. There is no mechanism for dealing with the scaling issue. Negative externalities are not dealt with.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nknight on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:39PM (#2984101)
Well, first, if you want to complain that I or anyone else don't understand libertarianism, I think you should first have a long chat with how your fellow professed libertarians portray it. Amongst other things, you're one of only two or three of the dozens of purported libertarians I've encountered who claim to be in favor of any commercial regulation beyond fraud and contract enforcement issues. The near-universal stance has been that monopolies are a natural byproduct of the free market, and not a "problem".

As for the rest... Well, I've never had a problem with the idea that a properly competitive market would be far superior to where we are now, but libertarianism, at least as portrayed by professed libertarians, doesn't restrict itself to that. It seeks to completely tear down social safety nets in favor of that market and ditch environmental and safety regulations. My own experiences and those of my family are all that is necessary to convince me of the disaster that would result by going that far.

I'm the last person who's going to defend the ridiculous things cited (marijuana/tobacco, corn ethanol, patents) and many others, but if you're being intellectually honest, you also have to look at the bad things that have resulted from unbounded market forces (serious pollution/poisoning, worker deaths, building collapses, ...) until government stepped in and imposed regulations on the "free market". There are tradeoffs here.

If you don't think these things are part of libertarianism, you need a new name for your beliefs, because the existing one is too corrupted by people who either don't actually share your beliefs, or don't understand that they've done a horribly negligent job of explaining them.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by Jach on Sunday September 11, 2011 @02:36PM (#2984420)
Naming issues get overlooked too often, I think, and it just asks for "no true Scotsman"-style discussions. The confusion you're having seems to be thinking that "Objectivist-style Libertarians", with no compromises, and self-proclaimed "small-l libertarians", of the type jerf and Eliezer belong, are the same when they're in fact pretty different.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by randallsquared on Sunday September 11, 2011 @10:42PM (#2985617)
The near-universal stance has been that monopolies are a natural byproduct of the free market, and not a "problem".

There's a large subset (possibly the majority?) of libertarians who expect that monopolies are a byproduct of state intervention, and not a natural product of the free market, which is precisely why one shouldn't interfere in ways that lead to monopolies (among other ways).

Are there examples of monopolies which didn't have state support?

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nhaehnle on Monday September 12, 2011 @04:47AM (#2986352)
Are there examples of monopolies which didn't have state support?

What about Microsoft and Facebook? Of course, it depends on your definition of monopoly - if you define it to be 100% market dominance, then almost by definition this is only possible using government intervention - but in the case of Microsoft, few people would seriously doubt that they have (or at least had) monopoly status. I don't see the state support that allowed them to get there.

More generally, a free market greatly favors monopolies whenever there are network effects involved.

Moreover, it is not only monopolies that are bad. Many markets "naturally" end up in the hands of only a few large corporations. This can sometimes (but not always) be as bad as a monopoly, e.g. electricity providers here in Germany. It is not clear to me what it is that makes some oligopolies problematic, while others (e.g. processor manufacturers) appear to be more benign.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by randallsquared on Monday September 12, 2011 @09:28AM (#2987161)
If a business has even 100% of a market because they're consistently cheaper/better than all contenders, they may be technically a monopoly, but they aren't one in the usual pernicious sense. I'll leave alone the third-rail topic of Microsoft, but Facebook is an interesting case because they only became prominent after the domination of their niche by MySpace, and yet now they're dominant. Was MySpace a monopoly? Well, in the Microsoft sense, yes, but not in the pre-1980-AT&T sense. Yet, as soon as a solution people preferred came along, they were no longer.

Can a business get to 100% of a market, or nearly so, without state help? I think they often can. Can they hold that position in the face of better and/or cheaper startup competition, without state help? I think that's an open question, and I lean toward thinking that they can't.

The other major question is so-called "natural monopolies", such as infrastructural service provision (phone, power, cable, etc). The fact that there are communities which have multiple competing firms in some of these seems to show that they aren't natural in the sense that they will arise unless prevented. While most communities in the US have a legislated monopoly on, for example, cable service, those that do not often have competing cable services, which is exactly what we are told won't happen. (My father lives in a place with three overlapping cable companies, as it happens, and he's tried all of them at one time or another). I've seen people in some of those communities who are arguing for a city-granted franchise switch seamlessly from arguing that regulation is needed to keep monopolies in check to arguing that such regulation is needed to prevent the wasteful laying of lines that duplicate existing lines. I guess that's neither here nor there, just a pet peeve. :)

Anyway, searching on Rothbard and monopoly will turn up more rigorous arguments against the idea of free market monopolies than I've given here.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by guelo on Monday September 12, 2011 @03:02AM (#2986148)
But libertarians that believe this believe it without evidence since there has never been an example of the ideal free market without government intervention the way libertarians imagine it.

Edit: Maybe Somalia is an example, I remember a few years ago people touting the proliferation of Somalian cell phone companies. But the instability there doesn't seem like something we should try to emulate.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by danenania on Sunday September 11, 2011 @11:03PM (#2985666)
The near-universal stance has been that monopolies are a natural byproduct of the free market, and not a "problem".

In my experience, this is quite a mischaracterization. The position isn't that monopolies are 'natural' and 'not a problem'. On the contrary, monopolies are seen as being extremely harmful, but also as products of government intervention and barriers to entry, not the market.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by ohashi on Monday September 12, 2011 @05:12AM (#2986400)
Not all monopolies rely on government entry or barriers. Something like economies of scale can be a natural barrier to entry and prevent competition.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by _delirium on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:41PM (#2984262)
I mostly agree, though I don't have a strong position on the correct answer. But as someone who does study complex systems sometimes in my day job, I find that argument for libertarianism extremely unconvincing. Most complex systems you find do not, left alone, function in any sort of reasonable way. They are full of crazy oscillating attractors, pathological feedback loops, more-stable and less-stable states that you (or an actor in the system) can deliberately manipulate it into, etc., etc. "Well-behaved" dynamical systems are comparatively hard to design even when you're deliberately designing, and ones you just find somewhere are usually not well behaved.

Which makes me particularly skeptical of "the market just works" type analysis, which claims that this particular complex dynamical system does not have all those pathologies, and in fact can be analyzed with fairly high-level, aggregate laws like the classical economics analysis of supply/demand adjustment. Heck, even fluid dynamics (another complex system) doesn't work that way--- all our general laws about how pressure/flow/velocity/etc. relate only apply to specific flow regimes, and can have different or even opposite-of-normal relationships in different flow regimes (especially anything turbulent).

One argument for why there should be some intervention would be: the classical-economics analysis of how economies should work is an appealing one, but is not in fact how they always work, so the government's job should be to dampen out the pathologies and turbulence that would take us out of the "normal" regime where the classical laws do apply. That's sort of the line taken by ordoliberalism. The question would be whether it can, on the whole, do more good than harm. But I wouldn't start from the assumption that what you get without government intervention operates "well" or "ideally".

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by bermanoid on Sunday September 11, 2011 @06:23PM (#2985042)
I think your concerns are absolutely spot on, and they match mine almost exactly - I've spent practically my whole working life modeling complex systems, and pathologies are the rule, not the exception, so it strikes me as unbelievably naive to just assume that there's something magical about free markets when in reality they are made up of millions of different entities with different objectives, costs, and constraints. Even when you're simulating a system that's provably stable, when simulation errors and noise creep in, you're batting about 50/50 as to whether your particular simulation method will go off the rails or not (as anyone that's ever tried to simulate a damped harmonic oscillator starting from Newton's laws and the obvious method of approximating a derivative knows quite well). In simulation we take stability arguments and proofs very seriously, the presumption being that if you can't prove that a system is stable, you can't assume anything about it (the exception being physical processes, where stability of the underlying can usually be taken as a given because of anthropic principal arguments and we're merely tasked with finding the proof, as well as a simulation scheme that doesn't screw up - that's a lot more difficult than it sounds, especially for complex systems like fully relativistic gravity).

These concerns are of the utmost priority in most fields that involve complex systems, especially processes that we have a hand in influencing, except for economics and politics, where everyone's pet arguments are balls to the wall, and tend to either imply that we should be living with full blown communism or complete unregulated anarchy (okay, I suppose contract law and the military are typically carved out as the exceptions). It's one of the few areas I've ever seen where none of the popular arguments seem to have any sort of balance - and I'm not talking "balance" as in fairness, I'm talking about "balance" as in trivial idea that if both extremes suck (which they usually do, whatever particular idea or disagreement you're arguing over), and something in between is better, then there exists some optimum between the extremes. Step one involves admitting that either extreme has a problem, but instead everyone seems to keep arguing that the whole problem is just that we're not actually at that extreme, 100%.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by wjy on Tuesday September 13, 2011 @11:52AM (#2991990)
Thank you both _delirium and bermanoid. You have managed to express my sentiments exactly, but much more eloquently than I could have.

I am always so frustrated by the notion of "the market is always right". As if a system with billions of complex actors could somehow be described like a first order linear system, that will always find a stable equilibrium.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by Jach on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:07PM (#2984011)
I don't believe Eliezer has ever said that evolution works by incremental improvements, only by incremental changes that become increasingly complex as a system when there are dependencies. Therefore even if you have a super-complex system it can still suck, the complexity may add nothing to its goodness, incremental changes can be directly harmful, and the right solution may indeed be to throw it out and start over. This should be clear to any programmer.

I'll profess historical ignorance here, though from my knowledge I believe that most instances of government change to a better government (and there have of course been changes to a worse government) have come through sudden revolutions that upset much of the previously existing power hierarchy. Additionally, to me it seems like government is naturally against any change at all, which precludes it from being improved easily. Eliezer has written numerous times elsewhere: "Not every change is an improvement, but every improvement is necessarily a change." So I don't think a "scrap the current system" is necessarily a bad idea, though I don't want bloody revolution.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by loup-vaillant on Sunday September 11, 2011 @06:01PM (#2984996)
Eliezer may not have been explicit about this but if your genes suck, you likely die before you spawn. Regardless of the complexity of your genome.

So, any harmful incremental change would be eventually selected out of the gene pool (or at least won't spread). Neutral changes are unlikely to become universal. Therefore, only improvements can be universal enough to be build upon.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nknight on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:14PM (#2984036)
But start over with what? I don't interpret libertarianism as "throw it out and start over", but as "throw it out and do nothing". They seek to strip government down and put it in a sealed box of predetermined size that can never change. It should be equally clear to any programmer that boxing yourself in eventually leads to disaster.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by Jach on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:36PM (#2984092)
I don't seek to argue for/against libertarianism here (neocameralism intrigues me more), I just aimed to show that your initial statements about a complex system improving automatically with changes were false. I also wanted to show that "throw it out" by itself isn't unreasonable.

I'm not sure that the programming metaphor here fits, considering languages like Haskell et al. that do box you in have had tremendous success. There are also programs that have been 'running things' just fine for 10+ years unchanged. I'm not aware of any government that could claim that, though with the former I think one of the motivators for having a constitutional government in the first place is to box-in the government. The merits of that vs. having a "Lispy" government that does what it pleases can be argued some other time. (Separately, there is an argument of "premature boxing in" that I have used to argue against full-fledged unit tests early on, but that's getting even further off-topic.)

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nknight on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:57PM (#2984149)
Actually, the metaphor works fine. Haskell doesn't fundamentally try to restrict what is done, but how it is done. Some things may be harder to do because of those restrictions, but they don't become entirely impossible, even if eventually you might find a corner case where you have to modify the language itself.

Constitutions can (usually) be amended. The US Constitution in particular has essentially no restrictions on what can be done by amendment (and it's pretty obvious that the one operative restriction can be dealt with if necessary). This is done out of knowledge of our own ignorance -- we cannot possibly conceive of every situation society will face, nor how our governance models will interact with those situations.

This is why libertarianism irritates me. It comes across as such an absolute. Few things are absolutes, and when you're talking about something that will affect millions of people, you can't realistically expect to arrive at an absolutely right solution that will work for everybody every time.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by DevX101 on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:11PM (#2984023)
The inertia associated with implementing a new governmental model on a large scale is VERY high. If your experiment does not work, you may need a war or a revolution to abandon the experiment.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nknight on Sunday September 11, 2011 @12:17PM (#2984044)
Virtually every functional democracy (or reasonable facsimile thereof) has built-in mechanisms for changes, and most provide for quite radical/unbounded changes. Unless you're starting with the premise that governance shouldn't be subject to voting, revolution/war should not happen.