News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:09PM (#2984185)
The market did not create the housing crisis. The government fiddled with the market all to hell, with the Community Reinvestment Act, the regulations surrounding the ratings agencies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac's unmarket-like backings of loans, and a hodge-podge of other lesser interventions.

When the market was allowed to make decisions about who should get loans, the standards were a lot higher. But it wasn't "right" for people to have to put 20% down and have a very solid credit rating, because it discriminated against poor people (and Democratic voters), so the government fiddled until it produced the result it (thought it) wanted, forcing banks to lower mortgage standards until we eventually worked our way down to no-money down ARMs.

(BTW, the claim the government had nothing to do with it is to claim that all the regulation like the CRA and Fannie Mae and anti-discrimination all had absolutely no effect at all, in which one must answer the question, if regulations like that are so ineffectual that you can't lay any responsibility for the current crisis at their feet, then why do you think government regulations are the answer to anything? Either they are effective or they are not, but you can't flip back and forth depending on whether you like the effect or not.)

The problem is that people think of "the market" as a fundamental property, but in fact it is a derived property. The reason why the market tended to correctly allocate mortgages prior to the government's heavy-handed decades-long intervention is the incentive structure. Always look at the incentive structure. If my bank is going to issue me a mortgage, and the government leaves them alone, they are going to take a lot of steps to protect themselves, such as setting the requirements for your credit strength very high, and requiring large downpayments, and generally ensuring they aren't going to be left holding the bag when the mortgage falls through. Alternatively, if they're going to sell that risk, the receiving party is going to want the same due diligence. The government interventions basically systematically tore than incentive structure apart, by allowing them to just dump the mortgage off on Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac, by requiring them to make loans that they basically knew would fail but the government held guns to their head to do it, etc. If I had to pick one thing that really enabled the housing crisis, it was the ability to dump mortgages off on the FMs for what were in actuality above-market rates, then for the seller to be free-and-clear of the responsibilities. Other things may have accelerated it, but that structure guaranteed disaster on its own.

No, the market isn't "always right", but that's not really the question. Nothing is "always right". The question, which is more likely to be right, the market system or the government system? One of the big reasons I tend libertarian is that I empirically observe that the government almost inevitably creates incredibly broken incentive structures where the market tends to create ones that are much more connected to reality. In this particular case, the "reality" that the market is much more connected to is the question of "will X be able to pay their mortgage back?" I have to use the broad term "reality" when discussing it in general, but it actually comes back down to specifics like this.

One much also distinguish between "the market" being broken, and reality being "broken". Yes, mortgage requirements were quite high; that's because in reality it's a huge risk. It turns out the market wasn't broken here, and the efforts to "fix" it were the true brokenness.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by MaysonL on Sunday September 11, 2011 @04:55PM (#2984811)
"The market did not create the housing crisis. The government fiddled with the market all to hell, with the Community Reinvestment Act, the regulations surrounding the ratings agencies, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac's unmarket-like backings of loans, and a hodge-podge of other lesser interventions."

Right, which is why it only happened in America, not in other places like England, and Ireland, and Spain, which had neither CRA nor Fannie nor Freddie. Oh wait...

For a different, and for my money, substantially more accurate diagnosis of the crisis, go listen to William K. Black [1]. He was one of the regulators who prosecuted many of the corrupt bankers who perpetrated the savings and loan crisis.

[1].http://dailybail.com/home/dr-william-k-black-the-great-ameri...

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by nerfhammer on Sunday September 11, 2011 @03:33PM (#2984579)
Now explain to me how the Community Reinvestment Act created co-occurring housing crises in Spain, Iceland, Ireland, Latvia, et al.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by scott_s on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:13PM (#2985147)
I think you're completely ignoring the mortgage-backed securities industry which not only bought up many of these loans, but created a market for them. I read that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were actually late to that party.

Also, saying that this regulation had minimal effect does not imply that all regulation will have minimal effect.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:23PM (#2984212)
I was only providing an example of how libertarian principles don't always scale. I said nothing about the housing market in the U.S. and I don't know why you bring up the U.S. housing market.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:29PM (#2984227)
"One person who buys a house they can't really afford is not a big deal. Let such a person make that bad decision if this is their inclination is a libertarian attitude. But millions of people make a similarly bad decision affects us all."

I don't think it's exactly a stretch to assume that such a (putatively) topical example was related to current events.

Besides, in the process of describing why the crisis wasn't caused by markets, I answered your objection anyhow. When the free market was making the decisions about mortgages, they did in fact make it in a sustainable way. Once the lenders were detached from the consequences of their decisions by the government, that broke. There's no better way to ensure that we don't have a housing crisis than to use those market mechanisms.

Note carefully I didn't say "if we use those mechanisms, we'll never have a housing crisis". I said there's no better way. It's basically impossible to completely prevent periodic crises.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by yequalsx on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:48PM (#2984283)
I did write, "The problem with this is that I don't think it scales." before the quoted line. It was a stretch.

Lenders weren't detached from the consequences of their decisions by the government. They were detached from the consequences of their decisions by selling securities based on the loans they made to dupes. That it was done at a massive scale without the dupes properly pricing in the risk caused a meltdown.

Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by jerf on Sunday September 11, 2011 @02:03PM (#2984324)
The fundamental underlying reason they could sell those securities was that they were exploiting the arbitrage from being able to dump the mortgages off on the FMs, at which point everybody knew they were unrealistically guaranteed by the Federal Government. I would point out that here in 2011, that's no longer a theory or mere rhetoric; it is now historical fact that the mortgages are in fact being covered by the Feds, as manifested by all the bailouts. Check out the FM's current financial situation if you need more proof. Without that risk sink in the system, they would never have been able to fly as far off the handle as they did. The securities were just ways of slicing up the stuff that was broken by the government-created risk sink.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by scott_s on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:30PM (#2985188)
I think you're ignoring the big investment banks, which also had many (most?) of these loans. I don't see how Fannie and Freddie factor into for, say, Lehman Brothers, which collapsed because they backed so many MBSs that were becoming losses.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by inthewoods on Monday September 12, 2011 @08:47AM (#2987002)
Ugh, not that tired old horse - the CRA existed for years prior to the crisis, yet the run up happened between 2001 and 2006. That, by itself, basically refutes the idea that the CRA caused the housing crisis.
Re:Eliezer Yudkowsky: Is That Your True Rejection? by prodigal_erik on Monday September 12, 2011 @09:29AM (#2987168)
In other news, the CRA only applies to retail banks offering FDIC-insured deposits, while most of the stupid loans were written by pure mortgage banks immune from the CRA. And it's not as if they needed to be pressured into it when they could take their cut and dump 100% of the fraudulently concealed risk.