I don't know where it goes from here - its almost too late for it to prove any real world value. Also note that as equity assets tank so do crypto currencies - that strong correlation reflects how the Feds monetary policy has unfortunately inflated crypto. Wouldn't it be ironic if that was how Bitcoin actually did become a reserve currency (it won't because it doesn't behave like one and have underlying value similar to USD).
I mean the traits you describe are not wrong, it's just that crypto is not useful as a payment method due to transaction volume, value / exchange rate volatility, acceptance, etc.
For a laugh, people bought pizzas and the like with bitcoin. Nowadays they hold onto it because it might be worth fiat money. Why spend something as money if it could be worth 20% more tomorrow?
It's an unregulated trading product, it's not practical as electronic money. I mean it might become that, but it would need a lot more oversight, which will cost the traits you mentioned (peer to peer, censorship resistant, etc).
If you need long term value storage, use Bitcoin.
Price volatility is a result of trading volume and short term human behaviour. If you have enough imagination, predict what happens to volatility if mass adoption occurs.
Sorry, gold is not money. You do know that right? It's a commodity. I think you and I talked about this - recently. Money is:
a current medium of exchange in the form of coins and banknotes; coins and banknotes collectively.
And of course our money is fiat which is: inconvertible paper money made legal tender by a government decree.I didn't know that the silver and gold minted coins traded by Roman merchants were in fact not money, but commodities. There's just so much utility in carrying around sacks of metal shards.
It was money in Roman times. Luckily we have moved on. It is no longer money, unless you're planning on trading with Marcus Aurelius. Gold was demonetized in the 30s.
Its interesting because you were even brave enough to includ "coin" in your definition. Coins are made of rare earth metal blends, like silver, copper, nickel, and gold.
So metals are only money when its in a small circular token form factor, but not when its melted together into a heavier bar. Got it.
> Coins are made of rare earth metal blends, like silver, copper, nickel, and gold.
Those are not rare earth metals. They are metals, but not rare earth metals. Those are "any of a group of chemically similar metallic elements comprising the lanthanide series and (usually) scandium and yttrium. They are not especially rare, but they tend to occur together in nature and are difficult to separate from one another."
Also, nickel isn't rare by any definition. Nickel is the fifth most abundant element on Earth.
> So metals are only money when its in a small circular token form factor, but not when its melted together into a heavier bar. Got it.
No, that's also wrong. "The characteristics of money are durability, portability, divisibility, uniformity, limited supply, and acceptability."
Gold fails the acceptability test because to be money, something must be broadly accepted as a medium of exchange. It is not accepted by anyone. Walk into a Walmart with a brick of gold and they'll tell you to get stuffed. You'll get the same response at Home Depot or if you try and email Amazon. That's why it's not money.
> Oh, so only the government definition of money is whats relevant here, and only of the last ~100 years. Historical and physical contexts of money are irrelevant.
They're relevant in antiquity. Not so relevant today. Like a hitching post. What matters isn't even the government definition but rather the social definition.
So while it seems strange to refer to ramen noodles as money in some contexts, and especially from the outside, the economic behavioural context allows us to attribute monetary function to this commodity, and allows us to say it is being used as a money.
When I'm talking about crypto/bitcoin/money, I am using a global trade and historical context, the macro concept of money outside of any single government, currency, or system. I am using money in an economic behavioural concept; something people use to trade and save with.
I understand you're not willing to accept or trade with Bitcoin, which is why it is not money to you.
But there are those that do accept it, and every year the numbers grow. Thus it is already money, and it is only a matter of time before it becomes de facto "money"
Hmm, we need to tell every Central Bank in the world that the gold bars they're holding aren't money.
Fort Knox must be a cover for government experimentation on aliens.
So its just some sort of very expensive commodity asset, which is used to store value, which we can expect to use to trade with other people, which USED to be money but somehow isn't anymore.
No they don't refer to it as money because words have meaning.
Which is kind of the definition of a deflationary currency.
We've been through all of this already with the gold standard: it was useful for a time, but the pros and cons have generally been weighed and the consensus seems to be not to use it.
What if Satoshi wanted Bitcoin to be digital cash but with a limited supply like gold?
From the bitcoin whitepaper:
The steady addition of a constant of amount of new coins is analogous to gold miners expending resources to add gold to circulation.
Before Bitcoin there was no ‘cash’ on the internet. Only electronic corporate (controlled) money.
Bitcoin is an attack on the core foundations of our society and is trying to actively undermine democracy. Thankfully it's pretty ineffective so far.
Totally agreed. Lucky it’s opt-in and voluntary! You are welcome to earn and spend money in whatever currency you wish.
The environmental effects are not opt-in, they're externalized to everyone else living on the planet:
If a few terrorists voluntarily fly a plane into a building, they're still taking countless innocents with them.
Without an attached justification I can't tell whether this is serious or not.
I'm a big beginner believer in Kreiskyan deficit spending for example. Good luck trying to do that once you can no longer print your own money.
Deficit spending is stealing from the future. Bitcoin is sound money, hard money. You can’t steal from your children to pay your bills today.
If you look at what Bruno Kreisky did, you'll see that he didn't "steal from" the future, he invested for it. He basically built the modern Austria I know and love.
I also think the whole "stealing from the future" talking point is BS - to paraphrase Keynes, in the future we'll all be dead :-).
But it's okay for us to disagree here. In a democracy, we can just vote for somebody that represents our views. If either of us can convince the majority to see things our way, we'll get our way.
Now if we had an inflexible monetary system like the one you're proposing, even if the vast majority voted to do things my way, we couldn't anymore, because we robbed the democratically elected state of its power.
This is what I mean when I say Bitcoin is antidemocratic. It entrenches your ideology on a technological level and removes all democratic control.
You don’t want people messing with the money. You can’t trust people and you certainly can’t trust the Keynesians. Taking this power away from the abusers gives power BACK to the people.
You might not agree with my view, but to try to suppress it is antidemocratic.
> You don’t want people messing with the money.
You don’t want people messing with the money. I do. You're trying to remove my democratic right to elect somebody who will do what I want.
I don't care what Satoshi said - he's not some all-knowing saintlike figure. I want the central bank to be able to debase currency. I don't believe in the same things as you and you are attacking my democratic right to see my values reflected in society.
> Taking this power away from the abusers gives power BACK to the people
If you define "the people" as "everyone that agrees with you", sure. But that's an awfully authoritarian thing to do, isn't it?
The good thing about the parallel economies is we can both have it. You can have your rapidly inflating made up Euro, manipulated by your elected and unelected politicians and Bitcoiners can divide everything of value on the planet by 21M BTC. Thing is, as the fiat gets worse and worse, more people will choose to save in things like Bitcoin. Are you familiar with Gresham’s Law?
You are trying to word this like folks are pushing this on you. Nothing is further from the case. Opt-in.
I’m not defining the people as anything. Everyone is free to believe whatever they wish.
Your opt-in is actively harmful to democratic society.
You're saying "don't worry, you don't need to break the social contract, but we will and we'll make it easy for others to do so, too. And if our sabotage makes everything collapse, well I guess that proves we were right all along. wink"
Who’s pushing their authoritarian agenda now.
The only worse thing than having people that might practice bad monetary policy having power over the currency is having bad monetary policy immutably baked into the structure of the currency.
What "democracy" is this? Is that the word you're using for a "choice" between Biden and Trump? Good grief.
- Its failures at being a store and measure of value (wild and arational daily value swings) and medium of exchange (long confirm times)
- Real life environmental impacts (overblown, yes, but still glossed over)
- Criminal enablement (there's a reason most forms of ransomware use crypto)
- Scams everywhere
- Knock-on effects on the real world (tried to buy a GPU lately?)
- OPSEC issues (it's a lot harder to secure a crypto wallet than a credit card)
1. Some of those problems are being solved. 2. Some of those problems exist in other socially-accepted technologies and we've learned to deal with it. 3. People have trouble thinking abstractly and don't think deeply enough about their criticisms.
I'll briefly try to address your points:
- Stablecoins are going to be the answer here. In the future I think people will take out micro-loans in stablecoins with their bitcoin/ethereum/etc as collateral. Daily purchases will be in stablecoins. Confirmation times are actively being worked on, namely single-slot finality in ethereum.
- This is being worked on. Ethereum is actively testing their new proof-of-stake algorithm as we speak with the goal of a full release in the next 3-6 months. Bitcoin is another story but I think it's a mistake to lump all cryptocurrencies together.
- Criminal enablement. This exists but is vastly overblown. It turns out that transactions being public is risky for criminals.
- Email has phishing scams. Phones have scams. Internet popups have scams. Any open technology is going to have scams. I suspect this will improve as we develop a social framework to educate people. How many times have you hear warnings about phishing? We can do the same with crypto.
- This is being worked on. You don't need a GPU for proof-of-stake.
- This is being worked on via UX and technology. Smart wallets for example allow people to recover their funds if they lose their keys.
Ether's ecosystem is a lot more promising, but still has a ton of rockiness. More specifically, I'm not confident in the core usability problems being UX implementation details. People don't want to have to think this much when making mundane purchases.
Also, I'd argue just being as good as the existing systems is mere table stakes. It needs to be better (outside of being a speculation vehicle). That is one I truly don't see happening. The anonymity/uncensorability benefits are questionable, the valuation problem appears to rely exclusively on fickle market whims or corrupt centralized entities, lack of refundability is an anti-feature for the mass market (and only solvable with centralized middlemen, which obviates half the reason to be using a crypto in the first place!)
The advocates will of course mention that fiat money and stocks also depend on trust, but both of those have very powerful organizations presiding over them who ensure that the value of e.g. the dollar will not crash overnight, or that you will be compensated if your account gets plundered, or who will pause trading on a stock (or the market as a whole) if people start panicking and acting irrationally. Decentralized products (whether you consider cryptocurrencies money or assets) do not have these securities and guarantees. Individual players like exchanges might, but if one exchange decides to pause trading, the others will gladly take over that business.
And look where that got us: the federal reserve printed trillions of dollars in 2020 to prop up the stock market.
They didn't print money to prop up the stock market, first of all, that was a side-effect.
A massive shock to the economy - remember COVID? - caused people to go home and stop working - to save money instead of spending it - and broke down supply chains. Without intervention this would have led to a deflationary spiral where merchants tried to lower the prices to incentivize spending, but of course this would mean they had less money to pay employees, which in turn meant employees couldn't afford goods - and so on. [1] All of the worst periods in world history were deflationary.
So the money supply was increased via QE swaps (which by the way, just swap assets on the books at banks with reserves to collateralize loans) and lower interest rates. This allowed folks to go back to work and allowed the economy to resume functioning.
Money isn't printed and handed out. Money enters the system via lending. All the money that was created will blink out of existence as the loans it was issued against are repaid. The Fed can reduce the supply if the supply itself is causing prices to go up - but it is not. The Fed has the tools to reduce supply just as it has the tools to increase the supply.
A lot of excess liquidity went into assets, but as interest rates go up, it'll come right back out and blink out of existence. So what?
The Federal Reserve literally saved the economy.
Explain to me how this is bad in any way?
This feels a lot like people complaining bitterly about the 2008 bailouts - which by the way were loans not grants, and have been repaid netting the US government over $100B in profits. [2]
Maybe, just maybe, the Fed isn't a scam?
[1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/deflationary-spiral.asp
Just like any fiat currency?
A fiat currency will only collapse if you lose faith in the state, your fellow humans and the ability of the judicial system to enforce repayment.
Once that happens you have much bigger problems. Like Mad Max style problems.
It will also collapse if people fear that the government will print too much money.
Really? Name a single one lol. Chivo is a MySQL store. And a garbage one at that. They only use Lightning to transfer value internationally between their own two accounts that they could do instead with an addition and a paired subtraction. Nobody uses Lightning. Nobody's ever used Lightning. Not to mention all the liquidity is provided by 3 centralized entities. [1]
I don't think Monero actually offers the level of security that most folks think it does, and Hydra still uses BTC no?
I did forget to mention ransomware payments, so thank you.
Chivo is one wallet. Agree it’s not great but El Salvador vendors hav implemented Point of Sale Lightning Network. It is an open system and you can use one of many mobile LN wallets. Chivo is probably the weakest. You will find that McDonalds, Starbucks, the local fruit vendor on the street can process an open LN tx. No sweat. “Nobody uses it”. Yeah ok. Those graphs indicate non zero channel balances and nodes.
Monero still has the 650k bounty on tx de anonymization. If you have a way, feel free to claim it.
RW. Sigh.
> “Nobody uses it”. Yeah ok. Those graphs indicate non zero channel balances and nodes.
I didn't see a country come on line in the charts. I see twice as many people using it as 3 years ago and virtually zero increase in usage post-El Salvador.
At the end of the day it's boat anchored to a worthless L1 which would require 75 years and ~1/3 of a trillion dollars to open a channel for everyone on earth.
I think you are being willfully ignorant about this. You said no country uses it: and I said yes they do. You said chivo sucks, I said yeah, but you can use any LN wallet.
I don’t know what more I can say. You are living in the past man, making excuses for the Fed and the State. Things have moved on, and I feel like you will be screaming as more nations adopt this. El Salvador is mining BTC from geothermal power from Volcanos.
[0] https://purse.io
Luckily that never happens.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-01-13/venezuela...
It can happen, it has happened, and will happen again.
Anything could happen at any time. But I don't live my life with a pile of weapons, canned peaches and ammo. That's prepper talk.
We have no idea what a hypothetical apocalyptic failed state America looks like. There's no guarantees that there won't be a single entity with more than 50% of the hash power. There's no guarantee that the internet will be up. There's so many things that have to go exactly right to think we'll be trading spreadsheet cells in the apocalypse.
Also, it's completely opt-in, you don't ever need to buy any Bitcoin if you don't want to. It's going to crash and burn, or prosper on its own merits.
My point was that fiat currencies live and die by the trust in governments that issue them. "Full faith and credit".
Consider that Iceland has a wonderfully stable currency and no standing army. It's got nothing to do with the army.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-01-13/venezuela...
Don’t Trust. verify.
- How are you verifying the contents and beneficial ownership of exchange wallets?
- How are you verifying market activity is legitimate, and there's no wash trading, spoofing or tape painting?
The underlying L1 is so utterly incapable that entire centralized, trusted and opaque businesses have to be built on top of and around it - offering none of the guarantees of the underlying - just to get past the fact it can't actually support more transactions than a mid-sized Costco.
I feel nothing for wild swings to my net worth. If anything, it has made the very concept of money more nebulous to me.
Yeah, no, but I do wish you luck with that. [1] USDT is 50% more volume than BTC and ETH combined. It's all the liquidity in the entire market. It's more important now than ever.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-10-07/crypto-my...
The verification you refer to prevents double spending. It does not prevent insane valuation swings due to sentiment, government action, etc. That makes it a worse store of value than most fiat currencies.
It's right in the Genesis block:
> The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks
The real problem that people have is that the money we currently use is corruptible by those in power.
I don't think the mere presence of a lot of internet arguers is particularly strong evidence of anything, tbh.
Funny how you carefully avoided making any solid points here. Let's assume what we all know you're saying - Bitcoin, if it was legitimate, would not require shills in order to be successful. Since Bitcoin is fully capable of securing $1 trillion dollars worth of value (unhackable despite the massive prize) I would say its had some success. Are there many shills around for Bitcoin today? Yes. What does that have to do with its success or value?
Even further obliterating the point you were too scared to make directly: the initial momentum which got Bitcoin started and gave the protocol its security which gave it that aforementioned success in security was grassroots and based in technological and academic interest. This is very clearly spelled in the blog post. Did you read the content before forming your thoughts about it? You might as well have not. Embarrassing.
This definitely isn't it.
The big problem with cryptocurrencies is that most of their promised "benefits" are actually detriments to people who are not anarchocapitalists (or close to it).
We don't want government control of money to be "disrupted", because governments are actually, in principle, accountable to us. The fact that there are certain prominent governments that have become corrupted by big money in practice is not even close to a good justification for tossing the whole "democracy experiment" out the window and replacing it with something that in principle does not answer to regular people in any way, shape, or form, and is very likely in practice to be ruled by those with big money from the outset.
We have about 80% of a working system already in place. What we need to do is fix the broken 20%, not have the absolute hubris to think that because we're The Smartest Guys In The Room, we can build a better, fairer, system that's built on the pure beauty of unfettered technology.
If you look through the history of amazing scientific breakthroughs, I suspect you'll find that the ones that legitimately changed the world didn't require armies of self-proclaimed experts to explain to everyone what the benefit is and what problems it solves. However, when you look through the history of snake oil, boom-and-bust market crashes, and actual Ponzi schemes, that's exactly what you find.
If you want to convince people of cryptocurrencies merit, just go solve some real problems that real people have. The fact that cryptocurrency has been around for so long and no use-case has materialized outside of pump-and-dump get-rich-quick schemes tells you everything you need to know.