News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by Cthulhu_ on Thursday January 06, 2022 @09:56AM (#29824253)
There it is, the comment that uncritically defends cryptocurrencies.

I mean the traits you describe are not wrong, it's just that crypto is not useful as a payment method due to transaction volume, value / exchange rate volatility, acceptance, etc.

For a laugh, people bought pizzas and the like with bitcoin. Nowadays they hold onto it because it might be worth fiat money. Why spend something as money if it could be worth 20% more tomorrow?

It's an unregulated trading product, it's not practical as electronic money. I mean it might become that, but it would need a lot more oversight, which will cost the traits you mentioned (peer to peer, censorship resistant, etc).

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by randomhodler84 on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:03AM (#29824356)
It’s fine, Bitcoin has worked exactly as expected for the 13 years of its life. It will work as expected for the next 13. It doesn’t need your approval, it just is. The next 13 years might well be considerably more interesting than the first. You are welcome to throw rocks from the side lines. It is an entirely opt-in and voluntary monetary system.
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:06AM (#29824389)
Flailing wildly around in value, unfit for purpose is how it was intended?
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by scottiebarnes on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:23AM (#29824643)
If you need short term value stability, don't use Bitcoin, because anything rapidly scaling is inherently volatile and unpredictable. This can partially be attributed to Bitcoin's protocol (block halving), but mostly due to human speculative behaviours. Block halving is relatively dramatic in the short run, but much less so after more halvings have passed, simply as a matter of math.

If you need long term value storage, use Bitcoin.

Price volatility is a result of trading volume and short term human behaviour. If you have enough imagination, predict what happens to volatility if mass adoption occurs.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by randomhodler84 on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:14AM (#29824494)
Works for me, maybe you are holding it wrong.
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:15AM (#29824511)
It's not money if all you do is hold it lol. That makes it an asset. Spending it in exchange for goods and services makes it money, and 4 tx/sec doesn't give you a lot of room to do that. And uh, well, you see, many other assets have outperformed it over the last 5 years.
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:29AM (#29824751)
> Hmm, we need to tell every Central Bank in the world that the gold bars they're holding aren't money.

Sorry, gold is not money. You do know that right? It's a commodity. I think you and I talked about this - recently. Money is:

  a current medium of exchange in the form of coins and banknotes; coins and banknotes collectively.
And of course our money is fiat which is:

  inconvertible paper money made legal tender by a government decree.
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by scottiebarnes on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:33AM (#29824800)
Ah, so what were we using before Bretton Woods?

I didn't know that the silver and gold minted coins traded by Roman merchants were in fact not money, but commodities. There's just so much utility in carrying around sacks of metal shards.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:54AM (#29825132)
> I didn't know that the silver and gold minted coins traded by Roman merchants were in fact not money, but commodities.

It was money in Roman times. Luckily we have moved on. It is no longer money, unless you're planning on trading with Marcus Aurelius. Gold was demonetized in the 30s.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by scottiebarnes on Thursday January 06, 2022 @11:12AM (#29825382)
Oh, so only the government definition of money is whats relevant here, and only of the last ~100 years. Historical and physical contexts of money are irrelevant.

Its interesting because you were even brave enough to includ "coin" in your definition. Coins are made of rare earth metal blends, like silver, copper, nickel, and gold.

So metals are only money when its in a small circular token form factor, but not when its melted together into a heavier bar. Got it.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @11:23AM (#29825555)
Oh scottie.

> Coins are made of rare earth metal blends, like silver, copper, nickel, and gold.

Those are not rare earth metals. They are metals, but not rare earth metals. Those are "any of a group of chemically similar metallic elements comprising the lanthanide series and (usually) scandium and yttrium. They are not especially rare, but they tend to occur together in nature and are difficult to separate from one another."

Also, nickel isn't rare by any definition. Nickel is the fifth most abundant element on Earth.

> So metals are only money when its in a small circular token form factor, but not when its melted together into a heavier bar. Got it.

No, that's also wrong. "The characteristics of money are durability, portability, divisibility, uniformity, limited supply, and acceptability."

Gold fails the acceptability test because to be money, something must be broadly accepted as a medium of exchange. It is not accepted by anyone. Walk into a Walmart with a brick of gold and they'll tell you to get stuffed. You'll get the same response at Home Depot or if you try and email Amazon. That's why it's not money.

> Oh, so only the government definition of money is whats relevant here, and only of the last ~100 years. Historical and physical contexts of money are irrelevant.

They're relevant in antiquity. Not so relevant today. Like a hitching post. What matters isn't even the government definition but rather the social definition.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by scottiebarnes on Thursday January 06, 2022 @11:51AM (#29825982)
In prison, a prisoner may trade packs of cigarettes and ramen noodles for favours. Those "commodities" to us on the outside, become "currency" to them, a medium of exchange; money.

So while it seems strange to refer to ramen noodles as money in some contexts, and especially from the outside, the economic behavioural context allows us to attribute monetary function to this commodity, and allows us to say it is being used as a money.

When I'm talking about crypto/bitcoin/money, I am using a global trade and historical context, the macro concept of money outside of any single government, currency, or system. I am using money in an economic behavioural concept; something people use to trade and save with.

I understand you're not willing to accept or trade with Bitcoin, which is why it is not money to you.

But there are those that do accept it, and every year the numbers grow. Thus it is already money, and it is only a matter of time before it becomes de facto "money"

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @12:15PM (#29826367)
Mackerel may be money in prison but we’re not in prison are we? It’s broadly accepted there which is why in the context it is money. Gold is not accepted anywhere broadly and therefore not money anywhere.
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by scottiebarnes on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:26AM (#29824698)
> It's not money if all you do is hold it lol.

Hmm, we need to tell every Central Bank in the world that the gold bars they're holding aren't money.

Fort Knox must be a cover for government experimentation on aliens.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by detaro on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:30AM (#29824766)
... which Central Bank refers to their gold assets as "money"?
Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by scottiebarnes on Thursday January 06, 2022 @10:37AM (#29824866)
You're right, they wouldn't refer to it as money because that would undermine the power of their own printed fiat currency.

So its just some sort of very expensive commodity asset, which is used to store value, which we can expect to use to trade with other people, which USED to be money but somehow isn't anymore.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by arcticbull on Thursday January 06, 2022 @11:06AM (#29825301)
> You're right, they wouldn't refer to it as money because that would undermine the power of their own printed fiat currency.

No they don't refer to it as money because words have meaning.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by throw0101a on Thursday January 06, 2022 @12:28PM (#29826567)
> For a laugh, people bought pizzas and the like with bitcoin. Nowadays they hold onto it because it might be worth fiat money. Why spend something as money if it could be worth 20% more tomorrow?

Which is kind of the definition of a deflationary currency.

We've been through all of this already with the gold standard: it was useful for a time, but the pros and cons have generally been weighed and the consensus seems to be not to use it.

Re:Bitcoin: Addressing the Ponzi Scheme Characterization by tomputer on Thursday January 06, 2022 @03:15PM (#29829385)
> It's an unregulated trading product, it's not practical as electronic money.

What if Satoshi wanted Bitcoin to be digital cash but with a limited supply like gold?

From the bitcoin whitepaper:

The steady addition of a constant of amount of new coins is analogous to gold miners expending resources to add gold to circulation.

Before Bitcoin there was no ‘cash’ on the internet. Only electronic corporate (controlled) money.