Re:A neuroscientist prepares for death
by ok_dad on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @07:36PM
(#29803186)
I mean, to me it’s more intelligent to consider we have no idea what’s going to happen after we’re dead and think about possibilities to prepare ourselves just in case our consciousness does end up in some afterlife. I have strong suspicions we’re just dead and nothing happens, but I can’t be certain of that. Reading books and thinking about different afterlives might help if you end up in one. We don’t even barely understand our own universe, which we live in, so who knows what’s possible here?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> I can’t be certain of that
This shares notions with simulation theory and other non-falsifiable hypotheses.
I take a practical approach here. We exist today. What will we make of it? Regarding these notions, my thought is since no one can be certain, what practical impact does that have? Typically the answer is "none whatsoever."
Even the OP implies that there is some mental benefit to using hope as a coping mechanism.
Even still, I would think most practitioners are doing it because they receive some sort of practical benefit now, in addition to the hope they hold in the afterlife. Most religious communities provide social/emotional/spiritual fulfillment for the parishioner in the present.
Re:A neuroscientist prepares for death
by nicoburns on Tuesday January 04, 2022 @10:19PM
(#29804633)
> Reading books and thinking about different afterlives might help if you end up in one
Only if it's vaguely similar to the one discussed in the book. If it's completely different it wouldn't help at all.
Re:A neuroscientist prepares for death
by collin128 on Wednesday January 05, 2022 @12:54AM
(#29805653)
It's interesting when you start to think about the expected value of believing in a religion. Would the correct poker move be to maximize EV by believing in all religions?
Not trying to poke fun, just an odd thought that's been bobbing around my brain this week.
What you're describing is similar to Pascal's Wager:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal%27s_wager