News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by cletus on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:10AM (#2978398)
Probably the most surprising thing about this list is that whoever made it didn't insert Amazon affiliate links into it.

Anyway, these lists always raise the question of what does "good" mean exactly? Inevitably they're dominated by books that were, in their time, incredibly significant.

You see the same things in computing books. Someone will always recommend "Design Patterns" but (IMHO) it is the dullest, driest book you could ever read. The ideas were important. As a book it's terrible.

Science fiction falls into a number of categories.

The first is space opera. This is basically a tale of adventure in a science fiction environment. Sometimes these books have some kind of message but most of the time they don't. They're typically the "Terminator 2" of books: they can be hugely entertaining, sometimes even really significant, but often don't have much substance.

Don't take that as a criticism. Stephen Donaldson's "Gap" series was, for me, a fantastic series but it really is simply space opera style entertainment.

The second is what I call "hard science fiction". It's the sort of sci-fi where the story is a backdrop for some physics. Ringworld is an example of this (as are most of Niven's works).

This is a genre I thought largely dead (with its height in the 60s and 70s) until I read Alastair Reynolds. His books have more of a story than, say, Niven's but they're still largely rooted in our current understanding of physics.

The third is what I call "literary science fiction". Literature, traditionally, was used as a means of talking about something that normally couldn't be talked about. Plays in the Shakespeare's time filled this role. Nowadays it's not so much that talking about these things is verboten, it's that the story can be an accessible way of discussing a topic that an essay never could.

Stranger in a Strange Land is very much in this category. It's almost only sci-fi by association. It does have the hallmarks of its age, most notably mental powers (a common zeitgeist in 60s sci-fi). This book probably had the same effect on society that, say, Pacific cultures did on Victorian English society.

In the 80s cyberpunk was born. Cyberpunk is largely an expression of fears about an Asian (Japanese more often than not) "takeover" of Western society. It's actually very xenophobic but it does reflect the dystopian fears of the time. Cyberpunk has waned in recent years as the xenophobia has and the realization that this isn't the future.

Does this make pioneering books in this field like Neuromancer "good"? Personally I thought that if you ignore the pioneering part, it was a fairly average book. Here again is the power of nostalgia I think (as I read it some years after it came out).

So I find many books on this list that are (IMHO) overrated, largely for nostalgic reasons.

I also find some authors missing that really should be represented, most notably the prolific CJ Cheeryh whose books Downbelow Station and Cyteen are both noteworthy and stand the test of time.

Some books on this list stand the test of time very well. Ender's Game, any of the Iain M. Banks' Culture novels, Hyperion to name a few.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by betageek on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:08PM (#2979872)
"Cyberpunk is largely an expression of fears about an Asian (Japanese more often than not) "takeover" of Western society. It's actually very xenophobic"

This is a very weird statement to make, the architects of Cyberpunk (Gibson, Sterling etc.) are Japanophiles if anything, the opposite of Xenophobic. Do you have any evidence to back this statement up?

Cyberpunk was just an extrapolation of the tech scene of the 80s, Japanese tech was massively superior to other countries and, rightly thinking that tech would rule the future, they made Japan the dominant superpower - unfortunately the Lost Decade put paid to that.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by redcap on Friday September 09, 2011 @07:04PM (#2980182)
The zeitgeist of the 80s had a lot of concern about Japan becoming "number 1" - US manufacturing was falling behind and people thought that Japan was top of the world technologically.

So while the authors are Japanophiles, they certainly tapped into the mood of the time - that the future was strange and asian-influenced.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by mindcrime on Saturday September 10, 2011 @09:06PM (#2982924)
I'm not sure it would be correct to use the word "xenophobia" here; but for those of us old enough to remember the 80's, what redcap says is very spot-on. There was a LOT of buzz in the 80's about how Japan (and Asian countries in general, to some extent) were kicking the US's arse in a lot of areas: computers, consumer electronics, cars, etc., etc. Talk about "competing with Japan" was used a motivational material to encourage students ("study hard or you won't have a job when you graduate, because you're competing against the Japanese"), and to justify various research programs, government initiatives, etc.

The whole "Fifth Generation Computing" thing really lit a fire under a lot of people back in those days: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer

So yeah... I don't necessarily agree that Cyberpunk as a genre is really focused on anti-asian xenophobia of any sort, but I don't think it's a stretch to say that that "80's zeitgeist" thing did influence Cyberpunk.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by rmc on Monday September 12, 2011 @05:05PM (#2988905)
Just look at Back to the Future 2 (the one where they go into the future and have flying cars and no mobile phones). The older version of main character (Marty McFly) has a japanese boss, and when talking to him on the videophone he drops japanese into the convesation (opens with japanese IIRC).
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by jseliger on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:53PM (#2978802)
Anyway, these lists always raise the question of what does "good" mean exactly? Inevitably they're dominated by books that were, in their time, incredibly significant.

I just started reading David W. Galenson's Old Masters and Young Geniuses: The Two Life Cycles of Artistic Creativity, (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0691133808/sr=8-1/qid=13150...), which is where Malcolm Gladwell stole / sourced his New Yorker article "Late Bloomers - Why do we equate genius with precocity?" (http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2008/10/20/081020fa_fact_...). Galenson says:

There are many common misunderstandings of the history of art, but perhaps none is more basic than the confusion over what determines the quality of art. Although it is of course possible to consider separately the quality of a number of different attributes of an artist's work, the overall importance of art is a function of innovation. Important artists are innovators whose work changes the practices of their successors; important works of art are those that embody these innovations. Artists have made innovations in many areas, including subject matter, composition, scale, materials, and technique. But whatever the nature of an artist's innovation, its importance ultimately depends on the extent of its influence on other artists.

It should immediately be noted that the importance at issue here is not the short run-interest that gains an artist immediate critical or commercial success, but the long-run importance that eventually causes his work to hang in major museums and makes his contribution the subject of study by scholars of art. These two types of success have often coincided, but in many cases they have not. {Galenson "Masters"@2}

There are many possible values a work of art can have, of course, and Galenson is only making clear the set he most plans to consider in his work. Nonetheless, I find his argument intriguing, and I also wonder how many of the works listed in the OP contain some major innovation or innovations then used by other science fiction writers.

On a totally unrelated note, it'd be nice to have HN hyperlinks so one doesn't have to put URLs in parentheses.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by radu_floricica on Friday September 09, 2011 @04:09PM (#2979637)
> On a totally unrelated note, it'd be nice to have HN hyperlinks so one doesn't have to put URLs in parentheses.

And if it did, it't be nice if the syntax would be putting the url in parentheses.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Alex3917 on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:36AM (#2978499)
"Cyberpunk is largely an expression of fears about an Asian (Japanese more often than not) 'takeover' of Western society."

I would argue that this has largely already happened. There is sort of a battle between liberal jewish culture and fundamentalist christian culture for being the official US mythology, but on a day to day basis Japanese culture and values are largely what have filled the power void. I would argue that most of our mainstream institutions, from schools to jobs to pop culture, have become and are increasingly becoming largely Japanese in nature.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by cletus on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:10PM (#2979177)
While there are definitely Japanese influences in American culture, I don't see that as a "Japanification", certainly not to the extent that was feared in the 80s (cyberpunk had megacorporations, etc).

One of the reasons for the endurance of English-speaking cultures (in particular) is the ability for both the language and the culture (which are distinct yet related) to absorb other languages and cultures.

Take as a counterexample France. There is a Ministry dedicated to keeping the French language "pure". There is plenty of lip service paid to the preservation of French culture. Basically France is acting like its language and culture is under siege... because it is. There are many examples like this.

English as a language seems to have no issue with absorbing the concepts and words of other languages. Once that have been here for centuries have long since been anglicized but more recent adoptees often preserve the original pronunciation.

So what you see as Japanification I see as English-speaking culturue and language simply absorbing another language and culture. This changes the language and culture but both remain firmly "English".

One could even characterize this as "cultural hegemony". It's not really any different to Romanization that took place 1500-2500 years ago.

I would even argue that as much as you might think of this as Japanification that Japan is probably becoming more American/English than we have become Japanese. Japan is still obviously a very different place to the US but many things have changed. There is less of the "job for life" thing that was very popular only decades ago, just as one example.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by kstenerud on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:02PM (#2978599)
I would have called bullshit on this until America imported reality shows.

But even then, everything imported is bastardized in some way. For example, Japanese reality shows are about cooperating to achieve a difficult goal (and sometimes failing in that task). The sympathetic emotional content as you vicariously experience their trials and challenges is the appeal.

American reality shows are about fucking each other over in order to be king of the hill. The drama of intrigue, revenge, and defeating enemies to reign supreme is the appeal.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by sgentle on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:01PM (#2978595)
I'm very interested in this idea; I don't think I've ever heard it before. Can you explain further?
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by rgrieselhuber on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:00PM (#2978592)
Can you offer some examples? I was surprised by this statement.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Alex3917 on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:15PM (#2978646)
So I think the fundamentalist christian thing is pretty self explanatory if you've been paying attention. In terms of Jewish culture, it's not really a secret that most of Hollywood, the media, and much of progressivism and culture in general is organized around liberal jewish values.

I'm not really an expert on why this is, but from what I can see protestantism sort of hit its high water mark shortly after WWII. Around this time we had an enormous rise in summer camps, spiritual retreats, folk music, sort of a pre-environmental movement, etc. that was all basically a reaction to the atomic bomb. Not to mention the birth of rock & roll, which came out of protestantism as well. All of this eventually led to the counter culture, which protestantism sort of pulled back from. These loosely affiliated movements were then basically embraced by liberal judaism. So today even though judaism proper is in the background, many of its values have still shaped those of the progressive movement to the point where liberal jewish values and progressivism are largely intertwined.

In terms of Japanification, one pretty clear example in schools is high stakes testing. In the workplace it's characterized by how bureaucratic large companies have become, and the way the people at the bottom are treated. I think it's in the movie The High Cost of Low Prices that there are videos of Wal-Mart employees doing their morning dance or whatever that corporate makes them do every day when they open the store, stuff like that is straight out of Japanese business culture. In general you see an increasing amount of abstract ideas being productized so that they can be sold as part of new fads, whether we're talking about rock band, credit default swaps, politicians, etc. It's essentially a glorification of surface appearances.

From everything I can see, the U.S. is basically becoming like Japan except without the ideas surround honor and the other spiritual norms, and without enough money to facilitate the same level of pop culture fads. Again I'm not a historian so if you want to call bullshit on me then go for it, I'm just calling it as I see it.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by jerf on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:50PM (#2978786)
While an interesting thesis, and I would never claim Japan has completely failed to influence the US, none of your examples strike me as evidence of Japan -> US influence rather than either convergent evolution, or things that just flat out come from different sources. High stakes testing is a result of the bureaucracy; the bureaucracy requires something to test and measure, and it will create it even if it's impossible, damn the consequences. The US is adopting it due to an increase in sclerotic bureaucracy, many Eastern cultures has histories of sclerotic bureaucracies longer than Western culture itself. Team building exercises and the term itself predate any conceivable Japanese influence. If "productizing abstract ideas", or perhaps rather, "productizing culture" flowed in any direction, it was from US -> Japan, not vice versa! See also the concept of "soft power".
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Alex3917 on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:03PM (#2978862)
"either convergent evolution, or things that just flat out come from different sources"

I more or less agree with this. At the same time, when you look at Japan everything just looks better -- even though it isn't. So while I think much of it is convergent evolution or things that come from different sources, just having Japan being the way it is vaguely over there seems to be giving US leaders more self confidence to make these sorts of reforms.

Part of it also though is that Japan has a history of taking ideas from other cultures and then perfecting them. E.g. germany invents scientific management, Henry Ford popularizes and commercializes it, and then 60 years later it's getting shipped back to us as TQM and Kanban. So yeah it's definitely all tangled up, all I'm saying is that we're becoming more like Japan currently is, regardless of why we're becoming that way or why Japan is that way.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by karamazov on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:07PM (#2980672)
In fact, many things about modern Japanese society - including scientific management and high-stakes testing - were originally copied from Europe. In that sense, it's not really accurate to say we copied Japan; much of the world currently has high stakes testing. For example, the Japanese educational system was actually based on the Prussian model.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by mindcrime on Saturday September 10, 2011 @08:42PM (#2982892)
Part of it also though is that Japan has a history of taking ideas from other cultures and then perfecting them.

As one example, a lot of the "japanese management techniques" stuff can trace its roots back to an American, W. Edwards Deming.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Edwards_Deming

Deming made a significant contribution to Japan's later reputation for innovative high-quality products and its economic power. He is regarded as having had more impact upon Japanese manufacturing and business than any other individual not of Japanese heritage. Despite being considered something of a hero in Japan, he was only just beginning to win widespread recognition in the U.S. at the time of his death.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by mentat on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:26PM (#2984219)
It doesn't necessarily matter what the culture of the person who had the idea is. It matters who has the courage to do it. Execution trumps idea.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Confusion on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:35PM (#2979000)

  it's not really a secret that most of Hollywood, the media,
  and much of progressivism and culture in general is
  organized around liberal jewish values.
Cross 'jewish' and that line make sense. There is nothing specifically 'jewish' about those values. If anything, they're Greek. We don't owe a lot to the pre-Socratic societies, apart from them inspiring the Greeks to their greatness. In Western civilization, everything after that was inspired by what the Greeks made of what came before them.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Alex3917 on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:07PM (#2979162)
I think that what's uniquely jewish is the implicit model of spiritual development that's glorified in so much of modern culture.

That is, in judaism spiritual development comes from fully engaging with the physical and secular world, and immersing yourself in all of its problems and opportunities. In protestantism, spiritual development comes from contemplative experiences (e.g. thoreau) that are set apart from everyday life, that hopefully allow you to connect more fully with both the secular world and your religious values once you get back to mainstream society. And in fundamentalist christianity, spiritual development comes from the active and purposeful rejection of secular society.

I think the reason we have so many extremists in the GOP right now is as a reaction to the existential arrogance of modern liberalism. E.g. not only do fundamentalists see things like Starbucks and Michael Cera / Seth Rogan movies as endorsing an implicit set of values and model of spiritual development, but they see also them as basically purposely shitting all over their way of life just to rub it in. That's partly why we're increasingly getting politicians like michele bachmann and rick perry.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Gormo on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:02PM (#2979843)
Most traditional religions treated the spiritual sphere as part and parcel of life in the physical world, rather than something to be segregated and distinguished from it. Only a handful of religions, mostly under the influence of Platonic philosophy, have deviated from this. But the concept is no more specific to Judiasm than it is to Catholicism, Hinduism, or Roman Paganism.

The opposing trend, which you might say treats religion as a form of escapism, is something that's really found only in certain strains of Protestantism, Islam, and Buddhism.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Alex3917 on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:32PM (#2979950)
True, but in addition to not being especially influential in the US, catholicism and hinduism aren't exactly socially liberal either. E.g. hinduism may not be isolationist, but what you can do in terms of your social life and your career and family is still very firmly prescribed. Plus if all the Hollywood financiers were catholic do you really think we'd be getting movies like Superbad? I feel like even the most liberal catholics like Steven Colbert wouldn't have been responsible for creating that sort of culture had they been in charge.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Helianthus on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:54PM (#2979581)
I think this is rather accurate, and wanted to say so after attacking you yesterday in another topic.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by dusklight on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:07PM (#2979156)
Can you please be more specific about which "liberal jewish values" you are talking about? Similarly can you give specific examples of Japanese cultural values that have taken hold in the US?
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by rgrieselhuber on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:35PM (#2978731)
I was responding to the Japanification statement as I hadn't thought about it before. I'm not calling BS, just wanted to see what you meant.

I think some of those examples are interesting points although the SF mentioned early seemed to predict an even stronger Japanese influence than what we see today.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Alex3917 on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:56PM (#2978812)
"I think some of those examples are interesting points although the SF mentioned early seemed to predict an even stronger Japanese influence than what we see today."

Definitely true, though I think we may see increasing Japanification over the next 30 - 40 years as the education and health of the average American decrease.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by RyanMcGreal on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:21PM (#2978672)
With the exception of Hollywood action movies, which are dominated by the Hong Kong action genre.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by aorshan on Saturday September 10, 2011 @02:59PM (#2982201)
I'm sorry but I don't think judaism has anything to do with this at all. None of the things you are talking about has anything more to do with judaism than it does with christianity or any other religion.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by puredemo on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:14AM (#2978407)
>the most surprising thing about this list is that whoever made it didn't insert Amazon affiliate links into it.

They did, you just didn't notice them.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by iamjustlooking on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:22AM (#2978445)
That's pretty clever then, what are they doing? Is it the _1-20 at the end?
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by puredemo on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:26AM (#2978459)
Yep, his associates ID is _1.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by r00fus on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:31PM (#2979283)
> In the 80s cyberpunk was born. Cyberpunk is largely an expression of fears about an Asian (Japanese more often than not) "takeover" of Western society.

I think this misses a huge part of the picture that Gibson, Dick and and other Cyberpunk authors painted (where it differed from other fiction):

1) (Asian) Corporate controlled dystopia - ie breakdown of western-government-controlled world order

2) Information/Data as valuable asset, even commodity

3) Rise of AI and non-human agents

4) Drugs/computing grantings paranormal/heightened state

I'm sure a number of these might have been present in other genres, but these are the hallmarks of the genre as I can see it.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by spacemanaki on Saturday September 10, 2011 @11:54AM (#2981759)
> Cyberpunk is largely an expression of fears about an Asian (Japanese more often than not) "takeover" of Western society. It's actually very xenophobic but it does reflect the dystopian fears of the time. Cyberpunk has waned in recent years as the xenophobia has and the realization that this isn't the future.

This is way off base, and really does a disservice to those authors. Cyberpunk in the 80s may have inherited some economic xenophobia but there were a lot of other ideas in there that I think were more important and continue to be, around the internet and technology.

It also hasn't waned the way you describe. The Deus Ex games are examples of cyberpunk that doesn't have as much to do with Asian takeovers of Western society as Neuromancer or Snow Crash perhaps does. Aside from the technological themes, the demons are thoroughly all-American: media propaganda, military contractors, corporate regulation, big scary government, war on terror, police actions... I would argue a lot of that came from the dystopias envisioned by sci-fi in the 80s, some of it from the cyberpunk authors.

I agree about Neuromancer being fairly average in quality, and that CJ Cherryh should be on the list.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by burgerbrain on Friday September 09, 2011 @11:40AM (#2978519)
What I noticed was what seemed to me a distinct space opera bias, combined with all the choices being the "obvious" ones. For example, two Asimov books are on there. Both are his two most famous books, and both are quite space opera-y. I would argue that End of Eternity was his best work and deserves a listing before either of those. Unfortunately, not as many people are aware of it.

In the case of Necromancer though I have to disagree with you. I think that it has held up incredibly well, the parts that were weak when it was released (totally screwy view of technology) are still the weak parts, but the strong parts (the vivid imagery for one) continue to be quite effective.

Then again, I have a strong cyberpunk/modern bias, I'd also recommend a few of Charles Stross's works :)

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by chadgeidel on Friday September 09, 2011 @12:53PM (#2978801)
Hard Science Fiction is alive and well. See works by Greg Bear, David Brin, Vernor Vinge, and other authors in this list: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_fiction#Hard_SF

I personally would add Charlie Stross to this list (http://www.antipope.org/charlie/).

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by sausagefeet on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:48PM (#2979059)
I'm a fan of Greg Egan (which is on there). Quarantine and Permutation City are really great books. Schildt's Ladder was good but a bit too hard for me to grok.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by nurbl on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:31PM (#2979509)
I agree with those titles, and would add Diaspora which I just finished. Truly mindblowing stuff, although it may be a bit too abstract and technical for some.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by sbayless on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:07PM (#2979870)
I second Diaspora; his vivid description of artificial intelligence is worth the read by itself.

Egan's stuff divides evenly into near-future and distant future science fiction; the distant future stuff tends to be very abstract. His latest novel, Zendegi, is a very near-future setting, and coincidentally is a more accessible read than most of his other stuff. I'd recommend it to start with.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by rmc on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:58PM (#2980035)
I wasn't too keen on Zendegi. About a third of it is how a revolution could happy in Iran next year, and seemed a bit too influenced by the Iranian presidential election protests. I was also annoyed at how it wasn't as hard sf as his other books.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by jacoblyles on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:25PM (#2979937)
Don't miss his short stories, like luminous and dark integers. Egan rekindled my excitement for SF recently, great stuff!
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by epivosism on Sunday September 11, 2011 @11:51AM (#2983971)
yeah, his short stories are mind blowing. I really liked Distress, too.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by alanfalcon on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:46PM (#2979552)
Quarantine had me running around in high school reading Quantum Physics books and mostly failing to understand them. Good book.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by psykotic on Friday September 09, 2011 @09:57PM (#2980548)
It's also his most tautly plotted novel because of the detective noir framework. Altered Carbon by Richard Morgan and the earlier Vlad Taltos books by Steven Brust also used detective noir conventions to great effect. It's a writer's crutch, but so many fantasy and science fiction writers suck at plotting and pacing that I'd prefer they lean on crutches occasionally rather than bore their readers to death.

Egan's two most recent books, Incandesence and The Clockwork Rocket, are great if you're a math and physics guy.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by crc on Saturday September 10, 2011 @02:16AM (#2980991)
Egan looks interesting. Which is a good book to start reading Egan?
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by psykotic on Saturday September 10, 2011 @03:28AM (#2981081)
Depends on what you like. Permutation City and Diaspora are fan favorites. They are heavy on idea porn but not very good yarns. That goes for most of Egan's books. His short stories are probably his most polished works because the form's constraints force him to keep everything tight. But on the flip side it means he doesn't have time to develop his ideas in great depth.

If you're a programmer, Permutation City would be my recommendation. If you're more mathematically inclined, Diaspora is a good choice. Just so you know what kind of book you'd be in for, the first chapter of Diaspora has a proof outline of the Gauss-Bonnet theorem. His short story The Planck Dive gives a good flavor of Diaspora: http://gregegan.customer.netspace.net.au/PLANCK/Complete/Pla...

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by chadgeidel on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:52PM (#2979077)
Thanks - I'll have to check those out.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by amalcon on Friday September 09, 2011 @06:18PM (#2980080)
I've always maintained that there are two types of science fiction. There's the "Star Trek" kind that does social commentary, and tries to get the audience to think about something directly by sidestepping the trappings of modern society. Then, there's the "Star Wars" kind that is basically a far-reaching exercise in world building that only has a plot so that you're not reading a technical description.

Stranger in a Strange Land is perhaps the purest example of the former, because it's very meta: the thing Heinlein wanted you to think about is the very idea of preconceived notions and full understanding. He spends the first half of the book explaining that you can understand something intellectually without understanding it emotionally, and the last half systematically questioning more and more ingrained ideas (at least at the time) so that you think about them intellectually.

Most of the list is the other type. I'll pick on Dune, since it happens to be number one on the list. Herbert introduces you to a universe that's really completely unlike any other conceived: people fly around in spaceships and have enormous mental powers, but there are no computers (they are illegal), people still fight with bladed weapons (all others are rendered either useless or too dangerous), and universal government has become feudal in nature (for various reasons). People send messengers. A bioengineering project and a social engineering project (gray projects by the same faction, no less) collide, and turn the universe upside down.

As far as hard SF goes, I'd originally clustered that with the world-building type, basically because every good example I've read happens to be in that category. Now that I think of it, though, it's not strictly required. It's really just a question of how much effort they put into reasoning out the science.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by kisielk on Saturday September 10, 2011 @03:50PM (#2982316)
I wouldn't stick Dune solely in the second category. It has a great deal of social commentary, and touches on a number of environmental and ethical issues. Herbert simply went to great lengths to create an extremely detailed world in which to present these ideas.

I think Stephenson's Anathem is a better example of the second category. It's almost purely world-building escapist fiction. There's not any obvious message apart from perhaps a satirical introspective of our own society.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by mentat on Sunday September 11, 2011 @01:38PM (#2984254)
I'm a bit shocked at your statement that there's no message in Anathem. The message I got out of it is to question my assumptions about the flow of history, most specifically about things that "everyone knows are true". For instance, why doesn't everyone know that you have to plan projects in certain ways if you expect them to get done at a certain time? Well, in part because the idea of getting done at a certain time is new to this half century (which is a small amount of time in history) and because the idea of project planning is about as young. Even now those ideas are getting disrupted too by other things that everyone's suppose to know are true.

Basically Anathem introduced me to the historical progression of ideas and the constant forgetfulness of that process as its practiced by at least Western society. You can make the argument that academics know that this isn't the case, but I'm not sure that they're not caught up in the same progressive forgetfulness as the "common person".

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by kisielk on Sunday September 11, 2011 @07:28PM (#2985185)
Well, I guess it just goes to show that everyone gets something else out of reading a book and categorizing them using sweeping generalizations isn't a good idea :)
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by jholman on Friday September 09, 2011 @05:41PM (#2979979)
First, I'd like to note that your usage of "space opera" is arguably a relatively archaic usage of the term; while that meaning is still in use, there's a more contemporary meaning wherein "space opera" refers to a sort of setting. A setting of broad spatial scope (interstellar/galactic), a setting with war involving starships, a setting full of action. It is adventure, but it can be literary, and it can be hard SF.

Neuromancer isn't just pioneering (which it was), it's incredibly well-written. But like other commenters, I disagree that it's xenophobic, and I don't think its success is rooted in xenophobia in the audience. I also disagree that Gibson's work portrays a "takeover" of Western culture; the ethic ruling the world of Gibson's novels is the ethic of the international mega-corporation, which is hardly a Japanese thing. And also there are lots of non-asian cultural bits: the Turing cops are Swiss, there's the whole cultural slant of Count Zero (not to spoil it for any who haven't read it), the Tessier-Ashpools are French/Australian, etc.

Props for mentioning Cherryh, though. Cyteen is frigging fantastic. Indeed, Cherryh in general is fantastic, although some of her stuff is serious business and some of it is (good) fluff.

As others have commented, hard SF is so very very not dead.

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by dusklight on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:04PM (#2979137)
I have to disagree with your statement about T2 .. To me at least it is one of the best (true) science fiction movies because it made me think more deeply about what does it mean to be human, what is love, courage, self-sacrifice? I didn't realize I didn't know the answers until this movie.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by Jun8 on Friday September 09, 2011 @01:49PM (#2979065)
Earlier examples of cyberpunk exist. For example Tiptree's The Girl Who Was Plugged In is so modern, could have been published today. Dick said that he was greatly influenced by this story as was Gibson for Neuromancer.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by mortenjorck on Saturday September 10, 2011 @02:26AM (#2981004)
The common ancestor is Alfred Bester's The Stars My Destination (1956, on the list). World-spanning megacorps, globetrotting anti-hero, bizarre subcultures, explorations in transhumanism – it's all there, rocket-powered. Highly recommended.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by anthony_barker on Friday September 09, 2011 @03:36PM (#2979520)
not a bad break down - I would say that ratings for me should not be based on nostalgic quality but rather on quality of ideas.

One of the best under rated in terms of "hard" and in terms of quality ideas for me has been Greg Egan (especially his short stories). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greg_Egan

Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by yxhuvud on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:30PM (#2979280)
If you enjoyed the Gap series, I can really recommend checking out Leviathan Wakes by James SA Corey. It has largely the same gritty feeling as the Gap does but is a lot closer to us in technology.
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by aboodman on Saturday September 10, 2011 @06:34PM (#2982676)
The first Culture novel was printed in 1987, and he's still writing new ones. I don't think you can really say yet whether they'll stand the test of time :).
Re:The Best Science Fiction Books (According to Reddit) by thirdhaf on Friday September 09, 2011 @02:07PM (#2979163)
In the hard SF category you may also like Neal Asher's work.