The question is only: Could it have happened this way? Is it plausible? If so, then we need to increase our security measures.
I think it is very plausible. There have been SARS lab leaks before, there were local attempts at cover up, and so on. There is no evidence for a lab leak, but it could have happened, and that is enough.
How do we tighten the security measures? One way would be to ban gain of function research. I'm not an expert, so if you say we need this research, we have to find a way to do it more safely. Maybe we can perform the research with 100% transparency. Complete surveillance of the lab, only joint multi-national labs allowed, frequent external audits, intense medical observation of the researchers, .... I'm sure experts can come up with useful precautions. The thing is there are likely precautions that were possible but considered too cumbersome or expensive. But in the light of a global pandemic and the plausibility that it may have been a lab leak, it is time to reevaluate the cost-benefit analysis.
(And of course, the zoonosis hypothesis is also plausible, and we have to do something about it... and think about deforestation, urban growth, wet markets, and so on.)
I'm not saying it's definitely a lab-leak, but it strikes me as ridiculous to confidently claim it wasn't given the information currently available.
It's really not much of a coincidence.
Source? AFAIK those bats coronaviruses were only found in caves in Yunnan, which is ~1300 km from Wuhan.
According to the previous link, HIV may have been spreading on the US since the 60s.
If you can explain how SARS-1 happened without a lab -- and you MUST be able to do this at the end of the day, because it really did happen -- then you can explain how SARS-2 happened and the lab was just a coincidence.
It's always a "kill the messenger" attitude. South Africa and the UK got punished with demonization and travel bans for doing the correct thing and sequencing a lot of positive samples to identify variants. China was also punished in a similar way, but at least there a bit of that punishment is warranted given how utterly intransparent China was and still is and how local cadres tried to hide the outbreak in the first place.
Once the pandemic is under control, humanity as a whole will have to establish a framework on pandemics that prevents "perverse incentives" aka hiding suspicious events, manipulating data, threatening researchers or not sequencing variants.
Maybe because there was a virology lab they identified the disease there first?
“Let’s weld a horn on a horse and make unicorns. No, too dangerous.” Two years later we see unicorns running around the same lab that proposed it.
It happened to be 600 to 1000 miles from where the bats carrying such viruses are found. The closest bat virus to Sars Cov 2 was found in Laos 1000 or so miles away and samples were shipped to the Wuhan lab.
since then, Biden's own security advisor has briefed him on the relevant proof (which has remained the same), but it was not broadly covered by the media
furthermore, the wet-market hypothesis was debunked in peer-reviewed science (and never had reasonable support from the start)
at this point there is literally no credible support for the idea that the lab leak data is incorrect
Nonsense. There is media outside the US, and no one really cared about that.
The problem has been that literally no one in charge had any interest to investigate. Obviously not China, but the US was involved in the gain of function research in Wuhan too; France/EU knew about the problems there.
And rightfully so, the first few weeks of media coverage were focused on other things than pointing fingers. Trump talking about blame, was seen as a distraction from the catastrophic handling of the pandemic by the administration - and there was clear evidence for that.
I think we will never know the origin of this virus, but we can prevent a possible lab leak in the future, outlaw gain of function research and internationally enforce lab safety standards on the highest political level.
Regardless of causation/correlation, that lab in Wuhan could have been the source of this pandemic, which killed 5.5 million so far and crippled the world economy for 2 years and counting: The french withdrew collaboration, because the lab wasn't meeting standards for the proposed risky research, and the exact gain of function seen in SARS2 was proposed to be researched there.
The possibility of a lab leak should not have existed in the first place. We can prevent a next pandemic of lab origin, now.
This is not a correlation/causation fallacy at all. It is a simple application of occam's razor. The "wet market" hypothesis has only ever been a convenient distraction.
Gain of function research is a vital tool in preventing pandemics. Moratoriums are pretty much universally opposed by virologists and are already regulated under DURC/DUCG (which both require unaffiliated oversight from the public). Influenza for example is able to be researched without having to infect human subjects because we used GoF to make lab strains infect rabbits.