News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Saturday January 01, 2022 @08:21PM (#29764755)
> People are going to notice this and call bullshit on that.

And they will be right. If it emits carbon it isn't green, it really is that simple.

By giving themselves this loophole the EU is undermining the market forces that will make green energy viable. We don't need to find economical energy sources anymore. We need to dump money into green energy now and last month and a decade ago. The price doesn't matter, just build true green energy and subsidize it until it becomes economical.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by Zenst on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:00PM (#29765693)
More so as it smells of politics. Germany was a thorn in Frances plans to label Nuclear green for while and does seem they wore down everybody and got thru a compromise that gets them off the hook by including gas. More worrying in this is how will this play into the whole gas drama with Russia.

Overall, it avoids a lot of awkward moments which would of seen both Germany and France fall short upon the EU's green regulations for energy usage/production. Whilst personally I feel it is a fair thing and well needed for France, I can't help feel that Germany took advantage of this and tailcoated their needs onto this and why we see gas labeled as `green`.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by crucialfelix on Sunday January 02, 2022 @01:54AM (#29766476)
The EU Taxonomy specifies which activites are green, which are transitional and those that are enablers for green activites.

Thus, it does describe activities that are not green, but are helping to move towards pure green.

---

Activities that in and of themselves contribute substantially to one of the six environmental objectives

Transition activities: These are activities for which there are no technologically and economically feasible low-carbon alternatives, but that support the transition to a climate-neutral economy in a manner that is consistent with a pathway to limit the temperature increase to 1.5 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels, for example by phasing out greenhouse gas emissions

Enabling activities: activities that enable other activities to make a substantial contribution to one or more of the objectives, and where that activity:

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Sunday January 02, 2022 @02:13AM (#29766569)
If they called it chartreuse energy I think I would be happy.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by richardw on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:12PM (#29765055)
> If it emits carbon it isn't green, it really is that simple.

Producing solar emits CO2 over the full lifecycle. Even during the generation and maintenance phase, it’s above zero. There’s no zero until we remove CO2 from the environment.

https://www.nrel.gov/docs/fy13osti/56487.pdf

Should we stop using solar until we find the zero-CO2 tech?

Obviously not. And obviously we need net-0 asap, but it’s not “really that simple.”

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by numpad0 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @01:18AM (#29766341)
Personally I’m not sure solar is a viable mass power production. I think it’s just a nice option for remote power production, as in “no one else in x miles” situation where x is an unsigned int.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by pjerem on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:22AM (#29767175)
Technically, the Sun send us orders of magnitude more energy that we will ever need.

So, yes, I agree with you that today, efficiency of solar panels is not enough for really big scale. But results are already impressive and furthermore, we have yet an infinity of optimizations to research to extract more energy from the sun.

In fact, while absolutely not probable in the coming decades Solar could even be one of the « magic solutions » alongside the fusion. Because we know the energy is there, we just don’t get her how to extract it.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by seunosewa on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:43AM (#29767609)
Solar panel tech extracts energy efficiently enough, actually. The problem is storage.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by willis936 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:07PM (#29765725)
You're conflating CO2 from logistics and CO2 from electricity production. Logistics can be entirely converted to electrical in a decade with no special sauce needed.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by richardw on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:28PM (#29765829)
Reference discusses power generation and plant maintenance. You can argue about words but only the net CO2 matters when you’re looking for a simple answer.

Perfect is the enemy of the good. We need net-0 but if you only have a binary 0-not-0 ideal we’ll leave a lot of intermediate options off the table. A Tesla isn’t net-0 but it’s better than a gas truck.

I’m arguing against oversimplification, because if we want to take that to extremes we have no net-0 options right now. We need to build them. Every KG of CO2 we don’t emit now is one less we need to bury in decades to come. So do a Manhattan Project on emissions but make easily-adopted changes in the near term.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by throwaway894345 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:25PM (#29765122)
Right now nuclear is the only green energy that is suitable for base load generation apart from hydro, and it takes a long time to build new nuclear plants, so I’m okay with a bridge solution that dramatically reduces emissions even if it doesn’t bring them to zero. The alternative is a dependency on much less green fossil fuel plants when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow.

Intelligent people shouldn’t quibble over an imaginary “green” line, but we should focus on minimizing emissions per unit power.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:38PM (#29765197)
It’s not ok to call gas “green”. Period. If gas is necessary then build it, but don’t claim it is green.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by Swenrekcah on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:12AM (#29766827)
The point is that gas is not green, but it’s a whole lot greener than many alternatives.

Replacing a large coal plant with gas is much better for our future than opening a same size solar plant (and not closing the coal plant).

Of course greener still would have been to build a solar plant instead of the gas plant. But solar is intermittent and coal isn’t so that wouldn’t be sufficient.

All of this is true so long as the gas plants are treated as temporary solutions and this does that.

I guess technically it could have been labelled ‘purple’ and a new rule made that all allowances made for ‘green’ also apply to ‘purple’ but honestly that sounds to me more likely to be abused in the future.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:46AM (#29766998)
> I guess technically it could have been labelled ‘purple’ and a new rule made that all allowances made for ‘green’ also apply to ‘purple’ but honestly that sounds to me more likely to be abused in the future.

How would this be abused?

The problem is that the EU talks a big game but can’t actually deliver. Calling gas green is moving the goalposts.

If gas is necessary that’s fine, just don’t pretend we are on track to be carbon neutral (or negative) in time for it to matter.

These gas plants are taking funds that could be used on actual green energy. If people don’t peek behind the curtain the numbers will say “all our energy is green”. That makes the problem look smaller than it is.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by Swenrekcah on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:30AM (#29767210)
Because it’s already a stretch to call gas green I don’t think it will be as easy to add worse things to the green label as it would be to add new labels to a ‘Colors similar to green’ pool.

What is the purely green alternative to gas that these gas plants will steal funds from? Intermittent energy doesn’t qualify.

The numbers to care about aren’t the ratio of green to non green plants, but actual CO2/MWh and those won’t be hiding the problem.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Sunday January 02, 2022 @04:49AM (#29767307)
> What is the purely green alternative to gas that these gas plants will steal funds from?

Nukes are greener than gas, at least in terms of our continued existence on this planet. If we don’t curb greenhouse gas emissions yesterday nobody will be around to die of radiation poisoning.

Energy storage can be solved, it just has to become necessary. Building gas plants today means we will be burning fossil fuels until 2080. We need to have these problems solved decades before that.

My objection is not necessarily to building the gas plants, it is to calling it green so some politicians can claim they did their jobs.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by Swenrekcah on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:11AM (#29767408)
I can see how it’s offensive to call it green but honestly I think the politicians really did do their job here.

Nuclear is a great option and should have been chosen 40 years ago but since it wasn’t we must take what we can get today. If I decide today I’m going to replace coal plants with nuclear, that means I’ll be burning coal for at least 20 years until the nuclear project is complete.

Much better then to, sure start building the nuclear plant, but also switch over to gas today, then complete the switch 10-30 years later.

And if the gas plants remain in operation until 2080 I’m optimistic enough to believe they’ll have been made to install CCS sometime in the early 2040s.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by diffeomorphism on Sunday January 02, 2022 @03:58AM (#29767060)
> It’s not ok to call gas “green”. Period.

And as helpfully explained by the top post you are replying to nobody does that.

It is labeled as a useful transitional tool towards green energy (when obeying lots of additional restrictions) and thus deemed eligible for subsidies/investment. The headline shortens "eligible for subsidies/investment aimed at promoting green energy, but only if meeting lots of other requirements and ..." to "green".

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by michaelt on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:27AM (#29767500)
> nobody does that

Except the title of the article :)

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by JumpCrisscross on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:57PM (#29765324)
> If gas is necessary then build it, but don’t claim it is green

Green is a spectrum, and a subjective one at that. Even if we limit ourselves to CO2 emissions, an absolutist stance eliminates solar and wind for the emissions in their erection.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:29PM (#29765832)
I’m not sure why this keeps getting regurgitated. Are you honestly arguing that the CO2 emissions in the production and operation of a solar plant are even remotely comparable to the emissions of a gas plant? If I have to explicitly spell all that out every time then we can’t have a conversation. It’s an absurd standard.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by JumpCrisscross on Sunday January 02, 2022 @07:08AM (#29768079)
> Are you honestly arguing that the CO2 emissions in the production and operation of a solar plant are even remotely comparable to the emissions of a gas plant?

No, just that pretending one or the other is universally accepted as “green” while the other is not is absurd.

Gas isn’t emission free. But “green” has no requirement to be zero emissions. It is in the process of being defined; this is that process and discussion. (Hybrids were once green.) “Green” should move us towards a zero-emissions future. If that happens with gas, that’s better than sitting around getting hysterical about definitions while baseload runs on dirty power.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by paul_f on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:11AM (#29768428)
It is absurd to be 100% dogmatic about solving this problem. Otherwise you look like a zealot, who refuses to talk to anyone who disagrees with you in.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by paul_f on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:09AM (#29768416)
This doesn't have to be binary. There are shades of green.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by NegativeLatency on Saturday January 01, 2022 @09:34PM (#29765175)
When you consider the other environmental impacts of hydro it’s not as green as people like to think.
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by kortilla on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:08PM (#29765729)
> And they will be right. If it emits carbon it isn't green, it really is that simple.

Then we have no green energy sources at all, which makes it sort of useless as a description.

Manufacturing and installation of the energy source always has to be included. For something with as short of a life as solar panels, the manufacturing, transport, installation, and disposal is a critical piece in the CO2 emissions that has to be amortized over the kWh it’s expected to generate over its lifetime.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:26PM (#29765817)
Oh please. Compare the CO2 emissions of a solar plant with those of a gas plant. Normalize for MWH produced. How many orders of magnitude is the difference?
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by oneoff786 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:32PM (#29765850)
If you’re asking someone to compare numbers, then it wasn’t really as simple as you originally stated
Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by mulmen on Saturday January 01, 2022 @11:39PM (#29765880)
It is as simple as I originally stated.

The argument that solar emits carbon is counting the carbon emitted in construction and plant operation. That is such a minute amount of carbon in comparison to the energy produced by a gas plant in generating power that it isn’t even worth talking about for the purposes of classifying gas as “green”.

Getting the construction and logistics of anything carbon neutral is orthogonal to the carbon emissions in the production of power.

Bringing up construction CO2 is a red herring at best. I asked for numbers to illustrate how ridiculous the argument is.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by kortilla on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:13AM (#29767423)
> That is such a minute amount of carbon in comparison to the energy produced by a gas plant in generating power

Citation needed. A gas plant dwarves solar in energy output.

The whole point is that solar does have an emission and burying your head in the sand does no good when we are comparing solutions that don’t emit during generation but do to make (solar vs wind + batteries vs nuclear?).

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by otherme123 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @05:45AM (#29767623)
Yes, solar has emissions. But in your previous message you implied that it is larger than it is by making a deceptively long list of items. These are the number of total CO2 emited per energy produced (gCO2e/kWh):

- Nuclear and eolic, 4.

- Solar, 6.

- Gas CCS, 78.

- Hydro, 97.

- Coal CCS, 109.

Citation, as requested:

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41560-017-0032-9

Implying that solar, nuclear or wind have emissions nowhere near gas or coal is not fair play.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by kortilla on Sunday January 02, 2022 @08:50PM (#29776413)
> But in your previous message you implied that it is larger than it is by making a deceptively long list of items.

No I didn’t. Your reading comprehension did that. I was simply pointing out that a dipshit stance like “no energy source can have any emissions and be called green” actually rules everything out and destroys the nuanced discussions between green energies. The statement I replied to was literally “It is as simple as I originally stated”.

> Implying that solar, nuclear or wind have emissions nowhere near gas or coal is not fair play.

Wanna try that sentence again? I think you meant to say something else because solar, wind, and nuclear absolutely have emissions nowhere near gas or coal.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by otherme123 on Monday January 03, 2022 @04:14AM (#29778819)
The message I answered was to support that CO2 emited by solar, wind or nuclear are indeed minute compared with a gas plant, even including "short of a life, manufacturing, transport, installation, and disposal" emissions.

Because someone reading that long list of items could get confused and think that those things added so much emissions that they could be near fossil emisions. It seems that it was not your intention, but I felt a clarification and a citation was needed.

Re:EU drafts plan to label gas and nuclear investments as green by AstralStorm on Sunday January 02, 2022 @09:32AM (#29768955)
Note that nobody really pulled off large scale CCS, so we should be comparing standard gas, such as closer too 400-ish.