Then we learned that viruses cannot spread like that, and so that old theory is basically invalid.
But some time ago I read somewhere that this theory might still hold true somehow, because our nose stores all kinds of viruses, and they might burst out when we are weakened.
Maybe someone more knowledgeable about this might chime in here ;).
For making fire, there is the rule of three, the triangle, and you need all sides to keep combustion going:
- Heat
- Fuel
- Oxygen
knock one out and it falters.
We should describe infections the same way. Needed for infection:
- Virus/pathogen
- Outer defenses penetration (skin/mucous membranes)
- Immune system defeat
Seeing it that way, it doesn't have to be so mysterious. Some viruses are dormant or almost omnipresent. The infection may be triggered by other conditions changing, including factors that affect your immune system status or efficiency of your outer protections!
Wikipedia (I don't link cause unpretty images):
"Worldwide rates of either HSV-1 or HSV-2 are between 60% and 95% in adults. HSV-1 is usually acquired during childhood. Rates of both increase as people age."
"Following a primary infection, the virus enters the nerves at the site of primary infection, migrates to the cell body of the neuron, and becomes latent in the ganglion"
"The causes of reactivation are uncertain, but several potential triggers have been documented. A 2009 study showed the protein VP16 plays a key role in reactivation of the dormant virus. Changes in the immune system during menstruation may play a role in HSV-1 reactivation. Concurrent infections, such as viral upper respiratory tract infection or other febrile diseases, can cause outbreaks. Reactivation due to other infections is the likely source of the historic terms 'cold sore' and 'fever blister'. Other identified triggers include local injury to the face, lips, eyes, or mouth; trauma; surgery; radiotherapy; and exposure to wind, ultraviolet light, or sunlight."
1) The atmosphere is in an unusual state (lots of fast moving water droplets, probably with a lot of backscatter as they hit the ground fast or bounce off leaves). Maybe bacteria use that as a travel mechanism.
2) Maybe an immune system defence is weakened by high humidity.
3) Maybe wet weather causes changes in behaviour unrelated to being wet, but that lead to higher disease transmission and the correlation is being misintepreted.
4) Maybe the bacteria really like rain and multiply like crazy when it is wet.
5) Maybe some people have an unrelated non-infectious illnesses that are triggered by the cold, damp weather and that is being misinterpreted as a cold.
6) Maybe grandmothers just say that because it seems like good advice and they don't like water being traipsed through the house.
There are enough different options there that any correlation is not actionable. Leaving aside whether any correlation even exists.
(Note how even your wording of the grandma theory is surprisingly in line with infection principles: the wet hair makes you "catch" a cold, from someone else, not directly causing the cold)
First off, I am impressed by your credentials, very nice work, you should be proud.
But this segment in your about: box is oddly hilarious to me. Maybe I've just had too much champagne. Happy New Year, from a West Coaster posting at 12:05 AM.
>yt code channel: https://www.youtube.com/playlistlist=PLf5mA1y1vDNlydJ8d5CmSt...
>[censored by desine] dot [also censored] at the only useful google service
That depends on who you ask. Different people have different hypotheses and concepts they explore.
There's a few different frameworks people are working within. From my experience, linking or forwarding to any "outside the box" ideas in this sphere will only invite more downvotes, argumentation over the details, and flamewars. Any linking of these ideas would be interpreted by some to be an endorsement of them. In my parent comment I made sure to mention that none of them were worthy of my endosement at this time, though I do find them interesting. Anyone reading this comment, buried deep in "hacker news" is capable of finding alternative ideas outside the norm. You can do your own research, if you like.
I mentioned them because the idea of people disagreeing on this was actually more foreign to me than "flat earth" which I find "pretty far out there", when I first stumbled upon it. It's very uncommonly discussed, and I don't have the clout to either endorse or properly antagonize these ideas. It's intriguing to me that something as preposterous as "the earth is flat" can be much more widely known and discussed than "maybe the way we frame viruses is incorrect".
Really? Do you have a reference for that? It doesn't match the experience of myself and others that I know. Everyone I know was talking about how great it was that they hadn't had a cold for so long, during the lockdowns.
Flu cases are tracked due to its severity. Cold cases are likely not often even paid attention to by many of those experiencing them.
Anecdotally, I and my friends and relatives hunkered down for COVID in 2020, and we had more cases turn out to be actually COVID-19 than common colds.
From this I made an uneducated extrapolation that the common cold pretty much stuck around somewhere and began to rapidly spread again as soon as people got out and about (I got one first week of schools going back in September, as per usual), whereas flu clearly did not.
There is a well known research paper from years ago showing that both exposure to cold temperatures and exposure to cold virus could cause cold symptoms, if I recollect right 30% probability when subjects were intentionally exposed to virus, 10% when exposed to cold temperatures. I don't recall the control group results.
This is consistent with covid appearing as an outbreak out of nowhere.
virons = a complete virus particle that consists of an RNA or DNA core with a protein coat sometimes with external envelopes and that is the extracellular infectious form of a virus.
For me, the intrigue centers on my personal realization that I pretty much never think about individual pieces. And that is what this word is all about.
It's everything needed for Covid to happen, no less, no more.
Apparently PCR tests and antigen tests differ in this regard, but RIP to our insurance providers paying for millions of redundant tests
In this case a medical dictionary might help. For reference here’s what the Merriam Webster Medical Dictionary says:
To discharge usually gradually from the body (e.g. exposed persons may shed virus from the oropharynx)
I do a lot of scuba diving. There are many anecdotal reports of divers who briefly experience cold / flu symptoms after failing to decompress correctly. The popular hypothesis is that tiny bubbles in the bloodstream trigger an inflammatory immune response, but who knows?
But again, not my area of expertise. Or even in the same ballpark.
There's nothing "peaceful" about pneumonia. It's a very frightening strangling feeling. The only thing "peaceful" about it is that you don't have the energy express the horror.
> The term is attributed to William Osler, who in the first edition of his book The Principles and Practice of Medicine (1892) wrote:
> In children and in healthy adults the outlook is good. In the debilitated, in drunkards and in the aged the chances are against recovery. So fatal is it in the latter class [i.e. the elderly] that it has been termed the natural end of the old man.
https://pneumonia.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41479-...
I also feel like lockdowns are a red herring in discussions like this. People not being locked down by force of law doesn't mean that a huge amount of people are minimizing their contact with other people.
https://www.science.org/content/article/new-ebola-outbreak-l...
Until then unlikely
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nipah_virus_infection
Read that and be afraid.
If COVID-19 were to evolve to become milder, it could become a fifth coronavirus that causes the common cold.
Maybe some sinus washes would help.
Critical part of the conclusion for those not wanting to skim the article:
> Virus might have persisted in the respiratory tract of one or more men at the Base. If such were the case it would be necessary to postulate a triggering mechanism to precipitate symptoms, and it is interesting to note that symptoms occurred 4 days after a precipitous fall in outside temperature, and during one of the coldest months of the year, which Hope-Simpson (1958) and Lidwell, Morgan & Williams (1965) have correlated with increased incidence of respiratory disease. There is disagreement about whether the viruses which cause common colds can be carried by adults, and how important this is in epidemiology. The pattern of virus infection revealed by long-term studies, such as the virus watch programme (Elveback et al. 1966), is of a series of short infections with different viruses, and in the case of influenza virus disappearance of the current strain when a new serotype appears. On the other hand, adenoviruses may be shed by children for periods of months and recove"ed from the tonsils in a high proportion of cases, without evidence of acute respiratory infection, and non-respiratory viruses such as those of the herpes group often persist for the lifetime of a man. Furthermore, observations in animals have shown that pigs can carry swine influenza and transmit infection to other pigs 3 months later (Blaskovic et al. 1970), turkeys may carry and shed influenza virus A after apparent recovery (Robinson, Easterday & Tumova, 1972), and cattle which have recovered from foot and mouth disease still reproduce virus in the pharynx, and can initiate epidemics on contact with non-immune cattle (Graves et al. 1971).
> There are thus precedents in both children and animals for persistence of respiratory viruses, but in adults the laboratory evidence for carriage and reactivation of common cold viruses is weak. It may be that such evidence can only be found in rather unusual conditions of isolation and stress, such as occur in Antarctica. It is likely to be a rare phenomenon, but it might well be important in explaining the persistence of the large number of rhinovirus serotypes which make an appearance in many areas when the temperature falls.
(I'm no virologist but given that the common cold didn't seem to be impacted by the severe lockdowns in the UK at all, whereas flu was, I've gotten the - uneducated - feeling the cold is a bit like some STDs in the way it can linger around in people and pop up whenever the conditions are right. Maybe some COVID variant will end up similarly persistent and endemic?)