News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by aardvark179 on Friday December 31, 2021 @06:56AM (#29747206)
There are a few of these that don’t really feel like pivots to me. For example Netflix changing from delivering things via DVD to doing it by streaming just feels like evolving to suit the market. Would we consider a publisher as pivoting because they now sell ebooks and run news websites instead of printing books and magazines?
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Retric on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:52AM (#29747563)
Netflix went from legal access to any DVD produced, too needing content deals with the entertainment industry and making their own content. The technical difficulties are minor by comparison.

That’s generally what pivoting means, going from chemical to digital cameras for example is a similarly huge jump even if the customers largely stay the same you lost a huge revenue stream from selling and or processing film and now need to spend a lot more on R&D.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by aardvark179 on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:25AM (#29747768)
Changing from film cameras to digital ones is exactly the sort of thing I wouldn’t call a pivot. Many of the components and skills are identical, but you are adding sensors and storage. That’s just the sort of adaption to an evolving market that any reasonable company should do.

A pivot suggests a sudden and radical change in course. Slack feels like one, companies that have switched from manufacturing to (apparently unrelated) software feel even more so.

I’d also say Nokia doesn’t feel like a pivot. They were a company that did anything internally for which they did not find adequate solutions on the market. They produced a lot of different things over the decades and the radio business is one that found external success and grew over time. Do we consider large conglomerates to have repeatedly pivoted as different portions of their business waxed and waned?

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Retric on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:47AM (#29747992)
A pivot is mostly a question of abandoning the old model efficiently rather than simply starting to do something else. Kodak was mostly a chemical company, selling film every week and a new camera every decade.

Going from manufacturing pencils to building aircraft doesn’t make use of existing workforce, equipment, or customers so why not just expand into a new industry and keep the old one as long as it was possible? Netflix or digital cameras on the other hand eats into their customer base. Someone buying a digital cameras is no longer buying film from you, it’s a destructive transition.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Ensorceled on Friday December 31, 2021 @09:18AM (#29748244)
You're still selling movies and cameras.

If we take this approach EVERYBODY has pivoted. Walmart has online sales that are "eating into" their in store sales. CVS has home delivery, eating into their foot traffic...

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Jensson on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:53PM (#29752428)
> You're still selling movies and cameras.

That doesn't matter, the organization is the people in it, if you have to make huge reorganizations in what the people at your company do then that is a huge pivot that is dangerous and likely to fail. Digital companies are not like other companies, you are thinking of companies where brands is the main thing and you can just slap together a new product in a year. It doesn't work like that in normal businesses, Kodak couldn't just say that all their factories specialized on making goods related to old cameras be repurposed to digital cameras.

Some of the expertise can transfer over, but if that is not your competitive advantage it doesn't matter. Kodaks competitive advantage was not camera lenses etc, so they had no way to pivot to digital cameras. Digital cameras destroyed the business they were good at.

> If we take this approach EVERYBODY has pivoted. Walmart has online sales that are "eating into" their in store sales. CVS has home delivery, eating into their foot traffic...

No, not everybody has pivoted. Lots of companies failed to pivot and died. Walmart is aware of this and has started to build expertise around digital sales already, because Walmart doesn't want to die in case digital sales overtakes physical sales.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Retric on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:25AM (#29748822)
Kodak actually pivoted to making pharmaceuticals. That leveraged what they where actually good at, high precision chemical manufacturing.

Survivorship bias means you see a lot of company’s that have successfully pivoted, and the brands that failed often get bought up after the fact.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by vidarh on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:05PM (#29749941)
I think Netflix is more of an argument than Kodak. Netflix kept selling access to movies, though the way they did so changed dramatically.

But while Kodak did sell cameras, Kodak sold cameras mostly to drive sales of their film. The film and chemicals were their high margin product ranges.

The pivot to try to drive their earnings mainly from their cameras was a fundamental change of business model in a way that Netflix shift to streaming (or Walmart or CVS online and delivery) wasn't. It turned a long term recurring high-margin revenue stream into a punctuated low-margin revenue stream. (not that they could have prevented the eventual collapse of their film business)

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by RF_Savage on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:23PM (#29750161)
Nokia climbed up the value chain in their vertical. From telephone cable into PCM line concentrators. From those into small exchanges. Then to the DX-200 digital telephone exchange. They merged/bought Televa (small exchanges and Gen0 Cellphones) and bought out Salora from Mobira (Gen0 cellphones and commercial radios). When Gen1 NMT became a thing they started making phones for it and later basestations. With GSM (Gen2) they ware making basestations and handsets from day one.

And they still make basestations and exchanges to this day. So they kainda are at their roots.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by YLE118 on Sunday January 02, 2022 @01:21AM (#29766352)
Nokia started as a paper mill taking advantage of hydropower, then after starting to generate electricity they combined with a rubber company and started working on cables. They seem like a pretty good example of pivoting even if they aren't as visible in consumer electronics as they used to be.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by PeterisP on Friday December 31, 2021 @11:07AM (#29749294)
The key pivot was not changing from film cameras to digital cameras, where indeed many components and skills are identical, but from film business (the majority of which is/was film and development process/chemistry/equipment/services, not cameras) to a camera-only business. Some companies did that pivot, some (like Kodak) did not.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by bluGill on Friday December 31, 2021 @11:44AM (#29749710)
Kodak was never known for good cameras. That was cannon and Nikon who both pivoted to digital. Kodak made great film and didn't have a simple pivot in pictures. Their simple pivot was pharmaceuticals which as others noted they did do.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by ErikVandeWater on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:13AM (#29747686)
But it's obviously a lesser degree of pivot than a pivot that discards your current customer base. I also wouldn't be surprised if being a huge buyer of wholesale DVDs got them good contacts in the media/film industry.

Also, the transition from film to digital was more gradual than it appears, as many features now thought of as digital-only were actually available on late generation film cameras.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by cutenewt on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:49AM (#29749087)
I'd agree that if you're 1) delivering the same promise to the 2) same customer base -- yes, it isn't as big of a pivot and some of the other companies on the list.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by xtiansimon on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:59AM (#29748071)
> “The technical difficulties are minor by comparison.”

You mean serving video to a pc? Because I also think about the infrastructure/last mile. And it’s one thing to have 10000 customers and quite another to have 10000000 (or whatever #)

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by hk1337 on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:08AM (#29748659)
Didn’t they still need to workout deals or licenses with the entertainment industry to rent out the DVDs? Didn’t Blockbuster have to do that to provide VHS and DVDs in the store?

I still think it was a pivot but not for that reason. Evolving can still be pivoting. Netflix shifted their business from providing physical media to streaming media.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by astura on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:27AM (#29748844)
No, definitely not, in the US anyone can rent out any physical media legally without any permission from the anyone due to the first sale doctrine. Same as me freely selling or loaning my DVDs and books without asking anyone first.

Before Blockbuster/Hollywood Video came to my town there were dozens of the video rental stores, all of which were mom-and-pop operations.

Nintendo tried to stop video game rentals during the NES era but failed - there was legislation banning video game rentals that was not passed and then they sued blockbuster for making photocopies of their manuals. I think I remember reading that rental stores having to send multiple employees into multiple stores to purchase Nintendo games because Nintendo had an agreement with retailers not to sell multiple copies of the same game to a single person to discourage rental and reseller purchases.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Beldin on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:15PM (#29750063)
Not quite accurate. If you become a distributor of content, then you fall under the rules for distributors.

That's (part of) why videos typically had that "not for rent" / "only for home viewing" stuff. There's a difference between you lending or renting out a dvd once, versus this being a business model.

How this works out exactly in a US legal context, you ask? Well: always follow legal advice from strangers on the Internet. Also IANAL.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by bluGill on Friday December 31, 2021 @11:47AM (#29749745)
While legally you are correct, you want to make deals anyway, if you do you can get plenty of DVDs in on release day (they might sit in your backroom for a few days to ensure it was shipped fast enough). There are other things you can get in a deal if you make one.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by mkr-hn on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:39PM (#29752319)
See also: compulsory licensing for music. You don't need the permission of the copyright holder, but licensing deals are usually cheaper than the rate set by law.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compulsory_license#United_Stat...

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by robbedpeter on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:22AM (#29747736)
The content delivery aspect that Netflix coordinated with ISP's was a pretty phenomenal technical feat, and could be seen as a pivot into networking at scale.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by wbl on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:36AM (#29748935)
Netflix still runs the DVD service.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by thraxil on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:30AM (#29747446)
I actually think Netflix's move towards producing their own shows and movies was more of a "pivot" than going from DVD to online streaming (which I don't see as really any different than Blockbuster going from renting VHS to DVDs).
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by aardvark179 on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:26AM (#29747780)
Yes, I’d agree with that.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by bottled_poe on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:02AM (#29747244)
In one respect, this “pivot” is simply changing the medium for delivery of the service. On the other hand, this represents a major shift in the structure of the company, introducing change in basically every department. It seems very naive to presume this shift would be simply an adjustment of the business structure. I would guess the Netflix business as we know it now would have very little resemblance of what it was during those DVD days.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by rkk3 on Friday December 31, 2021 @11:55AM (#29749838)
> There are a few of these that don’t really feel like pivots to me. For example Netflix changing from delivering things via DVD to doing it by streaming just feels like evolving to suit the market.

Reed Hastings allegedly barred the delivery team executives from his leadership meetings when they were responsible for 100% of the companies revenue. It was a massive, legendary pivot.

Pivots are nothing else but evolving to suit the market, at the cost of an established existing business or use case.

> Would we consider a publisher as pivoting because they now sell ebooks and run news websites instead of printing books and magazines?

I don't see why not, except that their legacy/core businesses are still or until recently responsible for the majority of their revenue [1]. I think there is a difference between adding a new distribution channel and altering the fundamentals of the business. The pivot for publishers has been more from ads -> subs.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/05/business/media/nyt-earnin...

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by astura on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:23AM (#29748801)
The real pivot was going from DVD distribution to movie and tv show production. This, of course, only happened because the switch to streaming made it so that Netflix were dependent on content producers. Netflix knew content producers would just create their own streaming service in time and they'd lose all their leverage.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by jaredsohn on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:47PM (#29750453)
Basically is converting from being Blockbuster to being HBO.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by gcanyon on Friday December 31, 2021 @02:50PM (#29751851)
Ted Sarandos, chief content officer for Netflix, once said, "The goal is to become HBO faster than HBO can become us" I worked for HBO when he said that, and took it very seriously.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by orblivion on Friday December 31, 2021 @09:34AM (#29748380)
Looks like you can still rent DVDs from Netflix https://dvd.netflix.com/Movies
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by axiomdata316 on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:42AM (#29749008)
Wow thanks for sharing this. I know I'm weird but I think I would still rather get DVDs because you have such a wider selection. And you can get very unique and hard to find movies. You're not locked into licensing deals between large movie studios.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by mensetmanusman on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:16AM (#29748740)
Does anyone else think a new blu/dvd shipping company could work well again with same day shipping assuming the continued fragmentation gets worse and worse?
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Jensson on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:06PM (#29752522)
They pivoted from having a bunch of people managing mailing DVD's to people to having a bunch of people managing computer servers. It is really different and there is no reason to assume they would succeed at that, if they built a subpar service they would have lost.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Vespasian on Friday December 31, 2021 @06:58PM (#29753861)
Someone will reinvent cable by bundling services together and charging people for content in which they aren't interested.

It'll happen as soon as the fragmentation is worse enough for people to loose interest and willingness to pay for them separately.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by maneesh on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:42PM (#29750383)
Netflix still runs a dvd rental business, with a much higher offering of titles (less content restriction than with streaming)
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by jasode on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:49AM (#29747553)
>There are a few of these that don’t really feel like pivots to me.

Because no authority dictates the meaning of "pivot", it looks like the concept diverged and became wider:

- "pivot" as switching from a unprofitable or failed business idea to a profitable one. A "phoenix rising from the ashes" type of pivot often associated with startups that finally figured out the elusive "Product Market Fit" instead of shutting down. This seems to be the original meaning popularized in 2011 by Eric Ries "Lean Startup" book : https://www.amazon.com/Lean-Startup-Entrepreneurs-Continuous...

- "pivot" as any change in business focus whether the previous one was profitable or not.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by rexf on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:10PM (#29752043)
That's a good point. I thought pivot meant "switching from a unprofitable or failed business idea to a profitable one".

In that sense, IIRC Netflix's founder had the early vision to offer streaming services (one day in the future), so it wasn't a pivot. It was part of the plan.

I mean he named his company "Netflix". Does that sound like DVD delivery? No, it sounds like inter(net) + flicks.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by cromulent on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:01AM (#29747624)
Yeah, I would agree. Keeping up with the times and the market is different to pivoting, as is diversifying and monetising. Did Disney "pivot" from hand-made animations to theme parks and digital streaming? More of an evolution, I think.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by cortesoft on Friday December 31, 2021 @11:46AM (#29749734)
Yeah... does every new technology change mean a pivot? Or evolution of business strategy?

If Netflix counts as a pivot, I feel like every company more than a few decades old should be on the list. IBM for sure, car companies because they now sell electric cars, banks because they now offer online services...

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by maneesh on Friday December 31, 2021 @12:43PM (#29750410)
I agree that Netflix moving from dvds to streaming could be argued as an evolution instead of a pivot, but I would argue that moving from streaming and delivering others’ content to producing their own content was a very significant shift worthy of being called a pivot.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by zalebz on Friday December 31, 2021 @08:36AM (#29747880)
There is a great podcast called Land of the Giants and they have a "season" about Netflix (as well as Amazon, Google, Apple); based on the information I learned there I would certainly say it was a risky pivot.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by jrh206 on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:00AM (#29747227)
I certainly view Netflix as a pivot. The things the company has to do, day to day, are just drastically different.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by davnicwil on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:05AM (#29747260)
Wasn't the streaming delivery piece intended from the start though, but they just had to wait for the infrastructure to support it so did DVD delivery as a stopgap? I had always assumed this was the case.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by ng55QPSK on Friday December 31, 2021 @07:40AM (#29747506)
the "Net" in netflix was: you could order on the net, only the delivering changed.
Re:Companies that had successful pivots by Beldin on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:31AM (#29748891)
Yes, it hinges on the definition of pivot. From a customer point of view, this is a mere evolution. That this imposes vastly different requirements on the underlying business is not really the problem of the customer.

In a similar vein, how would you describe the move of just about every primary, secondary and tertiary educational institutions to online teaching?

I don't consider that a pivot. It was necessary to continue to deliver the basic added value of these institutions. However, that did require a whole slew of new skills from teachers. So sure, YMMV.

Re:Companies that had successful pivots by deltree7 on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:15PM (#29752083)
So does Amazon, Apple, IBM and hundreds of other companies