News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:16AM (#29746274)
Dumb questions: Why does "web3" need venture capital. Why are VC (like this author) pushing for web3.

Someone suggested it is because they have invested heavily in ETH mining.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by grey-area on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:20AM (#29746286)
Because VCs have heavily invested over the last few years in blockchain companies and cryptocurrencies in general, they need to keep pumping this bubble, so NFTs, web3 etc became necessary to invent.

Web3 is just the latest excuse to keep the game of musical chairs going and preserve the chimera of use-value for cryptocurrencies since very few people want to use them to actually transact.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by kevin_thibedeau on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:17AM (#29746279)
Interest rates are zeroed out and they need another tulip frenzy.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by JohnJamesRambo on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:27AM (#29746320)
ETH mining is going away forever with ETH 2.0’s The Merge that is set for June 2022.

https://cointelegraph.com/news/eth2-devs-put-out-call-to-com...

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by pudo on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:35AM (#29746363)
You mean the thing when the ETH people are going to hand the power over the people with the most money? I'm sure this idea is deeply chilling to... venture capitalists, they're probably shaking in their boots.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by JohnJamesRambo on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:17AM (#29746553)
How do you think proof of work operates now? Do you think big mining operations don’t take massive capital? They do, and also waste ungodly amounts of power at the same time.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by whywhywhywhy on Friday December 31, 2021 @09:06AM (#29748146)
The difference is PoW can still be distributed beyond what exists today if someone decides to get involved and take power away from the consensus.

With PoS the consensus chooses if they want to give up power and you can only gain decentralization if they choose to give it up.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by yazaddaruvala on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:25AM (#29748825)
POS only works with an active economy i.e. validation requires something to validate e.g. consumers using ETH to buy goods and services. This implies the general population has access to large amounts of liquidity of the currency.

A new institutional investor just needs to start hoarding that easily accessible liquidity and the biggest players in the space will need to give up their share or risk the price of the currency dropping to zero because it’s too hard to transact in it and therefore it’s no longer profitable to tie up 32 ETH and run validators.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by latchkey on Saturday January 01, 2022 @01:54AM (#29756209)
You're conflating bitcoin mining with ethereum mining. Anyone with a GPU can mine eth and therefore the capital requirements are far lower. Now, of course if you want to make big money, then that requires big capital... but that could be said of nearly any business out there.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by stavros on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:17AM (#29746550)
Whereas now power is with the people with the most... GPUs? Those don't grow on trees either.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by M2Ys4U on Friday December 31, 2021 @06:32AM (#29747036)
Right. And both are bad.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by 0x64 on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:19AM (#29746563)
You gain more power by having more money in both PoW and PoS. In PoW it means you can buy more hashing power, in PoS it means you can buy more of the network's currency to stake. Even under PoS, the network's upgrades still rely on social consensus, as in node operators (!= validators) agreeing to forks, and the network's finality requires 2/3 of the network's almost 300'000 validators to come to consensus.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by hnbad on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:23AM (#29746592)
Yes.

"Actually both systems give power to those who are already wealthy" isn't the argument for democratization and decentralizations crypto believers apparently think it is.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by hnbad on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:19AM (#29746566)
Because Proof of Work requires computational power, which is expensive and thus requires a lot of capital, and Proof of Stake requires controlling a significant amount of the currency, which also requires a lot of capital. Basically the consensus is built around ways to demonstrate you already have a lot of money, either through conspicuous consumption (PoW) or flaunting your balance (PoS).

As to why VCs would invest in it: it's currently dodging most regulations that apply to financial transactions (money laundering, pyramid schemes, pump & dump schemes, etc) much like loot boxes dodge most gambling regulations (and it turns out selling gambling to kids is extremely profitable). This makes the market uniquely profitable to invest in right now with promises of extreme ROI as long as it remains unregulated.

"Humanitarian" campaigns to normalize tracking public records and qualifications on the blockchain in technologically underdeveloped countries also produce a high amount of technological lock-in while increasing the capabilities of automated decision making on the blockchain without having to bother with externalities. For example, if one's ability to use an NFT on social media hinges on demonstrating ownership of that NFT, copyright law becomes a tangential consideration much like systems like ContentID make it harder to claim fair use rights because the ContentID claim is not based in copyright law but in the terms of service.

Additionally a lot of the more vocal tech VCs are libertarians bordering on anarcho-capitalism (i.e. free market maximalists who think humanity's survival and progress hinges on a few Great Men rather than the unsophisticated masses). The greater Web3 ecosystem is trying to solve cooperation with people you actively distrust and represents every interaction as a financial transaction. This is extremely appealing to them. Their problem with capitalism isn't that it inevitably leads to a massive wealth disparity (because after all, some people are "just better") but that the government gets in the way. This makes the promise of decentralization (even if it defers to consensus between the already wealthy) ideologically appealing to them.

Based on my conversations with web3 believers, they would generally agree with most of what I said but object to the language I'm using because it doesn't sound very flattering.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by SyzygistSix on Friday December 31, 2021 @11:21AM (#29749449)
regarding "free market maximalists who think humanity's survival and progress hinges on a few Great Men rather than the unsophisticated masses" -

Libertarianism may have changed in character, or perhaps more in how it is characterized in media, but it used to be that libertarians believed in lots of little people acting freely and that states and the large corporations they are mutually supported by are the opposite of what they want.

Hopefully it is because the little people have largely left the relatively pointless large media spaces online and does not represent a genuine change in how the majority of libertarians, who used to not be terribly wealthy if they were wealthy at all, think.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by hnbad on Monday January 03, 2022 @12:41PM (#29783590)
I think this is a common misunderstanding because "libertarianism" nowadays can refer both to what is now called "libertarian socialism" (i.e. anarchism, individuals cooperating voluntarily for the common good) and right-wing libertarianism (i.e. laissez-faire capitalism or "anarcho-capitalism", natural selection via the free market).

The latter generally believe some people are inherently superior (though they will not always make a point of where this comes from) and that everyone therefore deserves their lot in life because those at the bottom either are inherently inferior (and thus undeserving) or failed to activate their potential (and thus undeserving).

The former generally believe we don't stand on the shoulders of giants so much as on the shoulders of billions and billions of people no worse or better than us. Some individuals may have genuine innate talent making them better at one thing or another without trying but while that may make their opinion on those matters more qualified it doesn't justify any claim to power as societal decisions (such as allocation of resources) should be reached by gaining consent from everyone affected.

Without regulation, markets naturally tend towards centralization and thus a significant power imbalance. Heck, if you were to fully abolish the public commons and the state, you would inevitably reinvent feudalism as the owners of the largest corporations would need to hire private militias to subdue their workers and defend their property claims against competitors, customers and colonies. This is why many right-wing libertarians still want a public police and military and why libertarian socialists generally don't want markets as a political instrument even if they may be favorable towards coops as an intermediate step or for the production of commodity goods.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by Ekaros on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:45AM (#29746741)
Even deeper question. Why does "web3" need to make money? Wouldn't it be better to go hobbyist providing services? Or everyone running their own things at their own cost, marginal let's say 10 or 100 a year? Like true decentralization, that isn't burden to profit...
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by aryc19 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @01:41AM (#29756153)
Because incentives. The beauty of crypto/web3 is to reward the service providers with incentives for their services. Nobody is going to provide things for free and even if they do it won't be sustainable in the long run.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday January 01, 2022 @06:45AM (#29757539)
This is more or less what I am asking. Apparently Web3 does not solve the problem of VC. Perhaps it does not even contemplate this as a problem.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by shrikant on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:31AM (#29746345)
Gatekeeping access to (edit: online, but I suppose this could also apply to offline) resources based on digitally verifiable ownership and the subsequent rent-seeking is a capitalist wet dream. I'm not the least bit surprised the VCs are slavering over web3.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by onion2k on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:34AM (#29746357)
Why does "web3" need venture capital.

There's no reason why a business trying to use "web3" wouldn't need to raise a round. Every business that wants to grow more quickly than the founders can manage alone needs some sort of capital to pay people to help. One way to do that is by giving up a bit of equity in return for money.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by pudo on Friday December 31, 2021 @04:44AM (#29746409)
That sounds a lot like, you know, web 2.0. Let's scheme this out: Facebook (and its corporate policies) is often named a motivating factor for web3. If I wanted to make a web3 replacement (let's call it MastoCoin), how would the economics of that actually work? People would still want to upload lots of posts and pictures and stuff, and that would presumably continue to live on S3 (etc.). Somebody needs to pay the bills for that monthly. So even if I had to pay $3 bucks in gas to post my sarcastic tweet, someone else would incur an indefinite expenditure on it, no? I really cannot think of a non-pyramid model here.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by onion2k on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:21AM (#29746585)
Society should certainly protect people from being scammed by others, but I don't think that's what web3 is. It's not a "pyramid scheme" in the traditional sense because it's not a scheme. It's just a pyramid. It's a collective delusion. If people believe in it, great. If they think they can profit from it then they should try. If they win, cool. If they lose, also cool.

I definitely don't think web3 should be 'stopped' on moral grounds. Maybe it should on environment grounds, or on the grounds of how annoying web3 evangelists are, but stopping it to protect people from investing in something silly is not a good idea. Let people learn from their mistakes (or maybe I'll learn to be less cynical when NFTs turn out to be the next BTC, which I also regret not buying, or Amazon stock that I didn't buy, or Apple, or Pixar, or MSFT... this is a long list.)

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by chrisco255 on Friday December 31, 2021 @10:58AM (#29749194)
Filecoin, Sia, and Arweave are three of the bigger chains involved in decentralized file storage. A combination of IPFS for data verification and one of these services for storage is typically enough. Many apps will store both on S3 and on Filecoin and link the IPFS hash for redundance. It's not a pyramid model, the native tokens are used to purchase storage and incentivize the bootstrapping of the storage network build out. Arweave has created an endowment like structure to guarantee data storage for 200 years.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by whywhywhywhy on Friday December 31, 2021 @09:04AM (#29748120)
> Someone suggested it is because they have invested heavily in ETH mining.

VCs own ETH from the presale not from investing in mining.

Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by latchkey on Saturday January 01, 2022 @01:56AM (#29756220)
That is simply not true. VCs have invested in mining operations.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by UncleMeat on Friday December 31, 2021 @09:05AM (#29748135)
VC funding is needed to raise funds for software engineers and provide access to mentorship and community, like every other software company that uses VC funding. You can raise funds through other means (bootstrapping, ICOs, etc) but these have their own sets of downsides.
Re:Web3/Crypto: Why Bother? by mattwilsonn888 on Friday December 31, 2021 @05:01AM (#29746473)
What makes you think it needs it? If every person in the world shilled something they called Web3 that wouldn't change the conclusion of this blog post? What are you on about, exactly?