News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by silvestrov on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:18AM (#29735426)
Sweden and Norway has a lot of hydro power.

When wind mills in Denmark are running then Norway stops their hydro and imports cheap electricity from the Danish wind mills. They save up the water.

When the Danish wind mills stands still then Norway sells expensive electricity from hydro.

Denmark is a very good place for wind mills so the combination is a win-win. It's crazy to look independently at each country because that is not how the electricity market works in Northern Europe. The countries are very interconnected.

It just so happends that the wind often blows during the day in Denmark and stand stills during night. So this back and forth happends almost every day.

When you ignore hydro power in NO/SE it shows that you don't know anything about the electricity market in Northern Europe.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by rekoil on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:27AM (#29735484)
It is true that we have a lot of hydro power, however it is pretty much fully utilised as it stands (they're talking about hundreds of additional MW when they talk about expansion, which will not do much in the grand scheme of things), and with all of this additional load, as well as fast ongoing electrification of our vehicles, it seems unlikely that additional wind farms will be able to pick up the slack.

Obviously I'm hoping I'm wrong here, because the alternative is nuclear which is apparently still a no-no word in most political circuits over here, and thus is unlikely to happen. Even if nuclear were to happen, ramping it upp will take much longer than the pace of this additional industry and electrification...

I'm worried we're going to end up in a crisis where we have to build up capacity quickly, and the only reliable and fast way of doing so is through fossil fuels.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by londons_explore on Thursday December 30, 2021 @09:17AM (#29736857)
Hydro in general has two metrics that matter. How many MWh can you generate per year (pretty much, how much water falls in a year), and how much MW can you generate at any given moment (ie. How fast can the water come out of the lake at top speed).

As the price of electricity varies more and more hour to hour, it becomes worth installing new generators to generate more MW, so you can do all the generation in a short time window to get the best price.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by sandos on Friday December 31, 2021 @06:43AM (#29747115)
But there are strict limits as to how much water you can release downstream, too.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by tmikaeld on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:30AM (#29735510)
According to "Energikommissionen"s research, Swedish hydro could be greatly built out with minimal effects on the environment.

[0] (2015 article) https://www.nyteknik.se/opinion/dags-att-bygga-ut-vattenkraf...

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by rekoil on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:33AM (#29735526)
I found that article as well, it cites no numbers, and according to Vattenfall the plan is for an additional 600MW by 2023... Hardly enough given everything discussed here.

https://group.vattenfall.com/se/nyheter-och-press/nyheter/20...

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by tmikaeld on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:38AM (#29735549)
Yes, because I couldn't find the Energikommissionen official publications any more, same goes for net stability documents being removed from government sites (from 2013).
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by whizzter on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:21AM (#29736494)
I'm actually cautiously optimistic for once, the MP ("Greens") rage-quit out of the administration opened up for S to skip the MP imposed blockade of the long-term storage decision. If that finally gets done it at least removes some uncertainty if any company wants to start making plans for a new plant (Yes, it's almost idealistically hopeful but the blockade did impose a lot of uncertainty).
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by Loic on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:24AM (#29735809)
Denmark is pretty bad with respect to renewables. They have increased their oil consumption in the past years, they have increased the so called "other renewables" which is in fact, burning wastes because they recycle nothing. They are running at 70% on non renewables.

So, Denmark is definitely not the Nordic country you want to use as reference[0]. Sweden is a completely different story[1].

[0]: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-sou...

[1]: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/energy-consumption-by-sou...

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:43AM (#29735929)
Burning waste for electricity makes financial/carbon/environmental sense until you have eliminated all fossil fuels from your grid.

Denmark has had a reduction in carbon intensity per GDP similar to the EU average, which has brought them close to France and Sweden, who've been low for a while but haven't improved as much over recent times as say Germany.

https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.ATM.CO2E.PP.GD?end=2...

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by Retric on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:55AM (#29736317)
Buried waste sequesters carbon, burned waste doesn’t. From a global warming standpoint replacing a low efficiency wasting burning power plant with a much higher efficiency natural gas power plant is a net gain for the environment. Not just is it less CO2 in the atmosphere it’s also less lead, arsenic, etc.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by bogeholm on Thursday December 30, 2021 @09:07AM (#29736787)
Burying waste may sequester carbon, but also potentially creates a host of other environmental issues down the road when stuff starts leaking into the groundwater.

Proper incineration + smoke scrubbing is, as far as I know, the best way to eliminate organic (as in chemistry) waste in an environmentally friendly way, eg. PVC.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by Retric on Thursday December 30, 2021 @11:36AM (#29738148)
“Potentially creates” is a solvable problem. Further the ash from burning municipal waste is very toxic and still needs to be stored somewhere. The volume is significantly reduced, but waste disposal benefits from the square:cube law reducing the volume doesn’t save that much effort.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by bogeholm on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:26PM (#29738735)
As long as smoke temperature quenching, smoke scrubbing etc is done correctly, I can only see that the ash is less toxic in total than the waste, as eg. chlorocarbons are handled by incineration.

Still toxic, but less in total. Unless I am missing something?

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by Retric on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:18PM (#29740296)
It really depends on what was burned. I suspect in general municipal waste probably gets less toxic in total but more difficult to handle. That said toxicity in general is less of an issue than what escapes into the environment, and here I think traditional waste disposal has real advantages.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by Retric on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:38PM (#29742374)
PS: As an example wet wood ash normally has a PH of 9 to 11 which can cause mild chemical burns while I burned wood is harmless on it’s own.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by bogeholm on Thursday December 30, 2021 @09:13AM (#29736828)
While Denmark definitely has a long way to go in terms of energy consumption, it is demonstrably false the we “recycle nothing”.

At my local garbage/recycling facility where you can offload gardening waste, tires, washing machines, cardboard etc. there are 20+ categories into which you must sort your trash - one of those is incinerated.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by erk__ on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:02AM (#29736038)
I am really unsure where they are getting those numbers from, I guess it may be fuel usage in cars that causes the oil usage, because it is certainly not electricity production where only about 1% is oil [0]

[0]: https://en.energinet.dk/Green-Transition/Renewable-energy-in...

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by belorn on Thursday December 30, 2021 @10:00AM (#29737211)
The Swedish hydro is currently under a lot of pressure. It is overused and need to be reduced in order to prevent extinctions of multiple species. The existing plants are old and need be repaired, and a majority of them has failed the regulative requirement for environmental preservation. Some are arguing that the law need to be changed, possible including EU law, or they won't be economical viable to get them into compliance.

As one comment on the news said, it is not viable to dig out new rivers. Someone in Norway could comment if they can expand their capacity, but I suspect the answer is the same there. Hydro is good but its a finite resource, and we now know the effect it has on fish and other animals that need the water to be traversalable.

Talking about the energy grid of Sweden, how many know that the single biggest contributor to carbon emissions in south of Sweden is an oil power plant? A country full of hydro and still, that is what tops the charts each year.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by cinntaile on Thursday December 30, 2021 @10:19AM (#29737388)
> Talking about the energy grid of Sweden, how many know that the single biggest contributor to carbon emissions in south of Sweden is an oil power plant? A country full of hydro and still, that is what tops the charts each year.

It's an oil plant, of course it's going to be a big contributor if it's running. Peaker plants are almost always fossil based, especially in regions that do not have hydro like the south of Sweden. Add to that the fact that the electricity demands outside of Sweden make the oil plant profitable from time to time. I think they run it more often ever since 2 of Ringhals reactors closed last year though, but even when they weren't closed I'd expect it to be the biggest contributor. Do you know if that was the case?

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by belorn on Thursday December 30, 2021 @11:27AM (#29738047)
What I have read is that the plant operated only for a total of a few days each year before the nuclear reactors was closed down. Karlshamnsverket was built in in 1970, and the south of Sweden had a nuclear plant in Barsebäcks until 2005. It was the combined effect of both Ringhals and Barsebäcks that created the market situation where Karlshamnsverket operates regularly all over the year when ever demand goes up.

Given the amount of hydro Sweden have, it is a bit of a black mark on the country that an oil plant actually get to run as much as it does. Its worth noting that Norway doesn't seem to use a lot of oil based peaker plants. I wonder if the oil that get burned in Sweden actually comes from Norway.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by cinntaile on Thursday December 30, 2021 @12:03PM (#29738444)
Between 2016-2020 it had an average running time of 67 hours. For this year it's somewhere between 500-700hours I think, so closing Barsebäck had no real influence on this.

Norway doesn't have nuclear either, they can easily regulate using pretty much only hydro. Most of the time this works for Sweden too, but when it doesn't it's nice to have an alternative. Even if it's spewing a ton of carbon into the air. The oil for Karlshamnsverket mostly comes from Russia.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by belorn on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:09PM (#29739372)
Do you know why they are buying it from Russia instead of Norway? Funding Russia, especially individuals there with ties to the fossil fuel industry, seems like a poor decision when at the same time there is a bunch of trade sanctions against Russia.

At any rate, I don't think its a very "nice" to subsidize the fossil fuel industry in order to have the alternative to burn oil. There are 8760 hours during a year, so for most part of that we simply are giving away tax money in order to keep the plant ready in the case of high demand. That is a very high price pay for the pleasure of spewing carbon into the air. If we instead reserved a higher portion of the capacity from hydro, and invested in more peak production by modernizing the generators (and at the same time invested in more environmental friendly design!), hydro and nuclear could manage what Norway is doing. A energy grid free of fossil fuels. That would be nice to have and something I would prefer over an oil plant.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by cinntaile on Thursday December 30, 2021 @01:46PM (#29739861)
I don't know to be honest, the oil from Russia that's refined has a lot of sulphur so maybe it's just because it's cheaper?

Spewing carbon into the air is still a smaller price to pay than not having electricity when you need it in my opinion. While hydro tends to be quite reliable and predictable I wouldn't want to bet everything on it, just like wind and solar you are still dependent on the weather albeit to a much lesser extent. At least a part of your reserve power needs to be independent of the weather. On a global scale it's just a drop in the ocean.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by daniel-cussen on Thursday December 30, 2021 @03:58PM (#29741353)
Energy potential in the atmosphere, in this case meaning the oceans and the air, will always depend on the weather, by definition. The alternative is mining uranium and carbon.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by cinntaile on Thursday December 30, 2021 @04:08PM (#29741448)
I don't understand your comment. I said wind, solar and hydro are weather dependent?
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by daniel-cussen on Thursday December 30, 2021 @04:51PM (#29741900)
"just like wind and solar you are still dependent on the weather albeit to a much lesser extent."
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by cinntaile on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:03PM (#29742614)
Hydro power is more consistent than for example solar which can change instantly even though both are weather dependent.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by cm2187 on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:41AM (#29735913)
France threatened to cut the power to Jersey a few weeks ago, Ukraine faced its own threats from Russia, so I will still look at something as strategic as electricity production along borders. Cross border electricity grids are all good until there is a conflict or a major shortage (remember what happened to EU cooperation on PPE in early 2020 when EU countries were seizing PPE crossing their borders).
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by oblio on Thursday December 30, 2021 @06:47AM (#29735962)
The odds of Nordic countries fighting each other are astronomically low.

Russia was always profiting off Ukraine, while France and the UK have generally been at odds (yes, all those micro-states count as British as far as the French are concerned).

The situations you're presenting are not comparable.

And regarding PPE, yes, everyone was doing it initially but the rest of the crisis was handled together. If anything, I think the EU received extra powers to be able to handle similar crises in the future.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by unnah on Thursday December 30, 2021 @07:03AM (#29736039)
Just a couple of weeks ago, the energy market disruptions lead Swedish and Norwegian grid operators to put restrictions on cross-border energy transfers, in violation of their co-operation agreements: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-12-06/europe-s-...
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by rightbyte on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:09AM (#29736412)
> The odds of Nordic countries fighting each other are astronomically low.

War? Sure. Political fights are not that unlikely though.

Also, Norway is not part of the EU, so they can sell (or not sell) electricity how they please.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by silvestrov on Thursday December 30, 2021 @08:45AM (#29736628)
Denmark and Norway have been a single country/union for more years(290) than United States of America has existed (245).

We share so much culture and language that Denmark going to war with Norway would be like New York going to war with Boston.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by maxdo on Thursday December 30, 2021 @10:34AM (#29737517)
LOL, yeah, oh well, Ukraine and Russia always been together. But one old gremlin named Putin with a use of propaganda in 7 years made 70% of a country according to polls to be OK to kill their used to be beloved neighbors.

So don't underestimate the power of propaganda and crazy ideas politics can embrace.

Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by brtkdotse on Thursday December 30, 2021 @05:31AM (#29735518)
The bottle neck right now is distribution, and building power lines is costly and takes a lot of time because you have to cross peoples properties, plus all the usual NIMBYism.
Re:Northvolt assembles first lithium-ion battery cell at Swe... by dzhiurgis on Thursday December 30, 2021 @02:16PM (#29740258)
Does interconnect serve 100% required capacity? IIRC in a lot of places they are like 10-20% tops.