News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by blunte on Sunday December 26, 2021 @02:44PM (#29695613)
Question for you OS geeks: did we take the good things learned from BeOS and implement them in Windows/Linux/macOS?
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by codr7 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @02:50PM (#29695676)
I ran BeOS off and on from the Intel transition to the end, I still regret not joining the party early enough to experience their custom hardware.

I'd say mostly not.

Sure, you can browse the Internet and play music at the same time on any platform today, but a lot has changed.

Much of what was good about BeOS was breaking with the past and starting from zero based on today's desktop needs, a modern take on the Amiga in many ways.

Existing platforms may be able to steal an idea or two, but that's different from being built from the ground up to solve a specific class of problems.

To begin with, absolutely everything was multi-threaded, there was just no way around it.

Fast file system queries that could be stored as shortcuts were nice, still haven't seen that implemented nearly as well elsewhere.

I wrote some software interfacing the system C++ API's and found everything very convenient, clean and tidy compared to any other platform I've programmed.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by watersb on Sunday December 26, 2021 @07:33PM (#29697771)
Fast file system queries that could be stored as shortcuts were nice, still haven't seen that implemented nearly as well elsewhere.

NTFS metadata architecture really inspired by BeFS, or at the least, a fellow traveler.

You can tweak the Windows Explorer (the filesystem UI) to operate on arbitrary metadata. Well, I was able to get an email inbox, where each email message is a text file, just using Explorer the BeOS way, on Windows 2000. It wasn't exactly fast.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by tablespoon on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:37PM (#29696064)
> Question for you OS geeks: did we take the good things learned from BeOS and implement them in Windows/Linux/macOS?

Somewhat of an aside, but I wish there existed a kind of "encyclopedia" of operating system features (both UI and otherwise, with a special emphasis on "dead ends" like BeOS), that pulled together demos and documentation into one exhaustive reference.

It seems like a lot of good ideas get lost is the sea of lowest common denominator solutions, and an ecyclopedic reference would make it easier to resurrect those ideas.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by thequux on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:00PM (#29696309)
I tried to start a talk series last year about these dead ends, but only https://media.ccc.de/v/rc3-525180-what_have_we_lost actually made it out. Perhaps I'll pick up the thread later, because there are a lot of dead ends that had some amazing ideas that it either wasn't the right time for (BeOS, DomainOS), bad business decisions (Genera), or particularly insular communities where they were used (OS/400, TRON)
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by hackmiester on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:13PM (#29696434)
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by yjftsjthsd-h on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:08PM (#29696382)
https://archiveos.org/ is kind of a step in that direction, although not exactly the same
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by tambourine_man on Sunday December 26, 2021 @02:52PM (#29695704)
Not much, unfortunately. File system metadata query and responsiveness is something that I haven't seen matched still. The latter is an exhilarating feeling that I'll never forget. Also, the UI had a “fun” but still elegant feel to it that I was very fond of.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by Veliladon on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:43PM (#29696132)
This. The filesystem has yet to be duplicated in terms of sheer metadata functionality and probably never will be again.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by nerdponx on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:54PM (#29696754)
What's an example of something you could do with the BeOS filesystem that you can't do with today's filesystems and operating systems?
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by weikju on Sunday December 26, 2021 @06:44PM (#29697475)
The below is based on vague memories from 20+ years ago...

Some examples:

Every email received was stored as a file. All metadata about the email (sender ,subject, headers, etc) were stored as attributes.

Tracker, the file manager application, could display any arbitrary attribute. I seem to remember that instead of an email application's window, my inbox was a simple Tracker window showing the specific attributes required to know about my emails.

My music collection was stored and displayed the same way.

Everything was searchable but also usable. File attributes weren't hidden behind CLI commands and flags like xattr, they were part of the GUI and every application using the SDK would know/understand them.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by rbanffy on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:48PM (#29698189)
> Every email received was stored as a file.

This was, at least in part, how Microsoft's "Internet News and Mail" worked. Not sure where it kept metadata, but the initial implementation seemed like an Windows Explorer extension, which was a very clever approach, IMHO.

I wish Gnome did an e-mail client like that, synchronizing a local folder with a remote IMAP mail store, or presenting a remote IMAP storage as a mounted folder under an IMAPFS sort of thing. Arguably, that's easier to do with POP3. Same thing with an outbox, where writing a properly formatted file would send an e-mail.

> File attributes weren't hidden behind CLI commands and flags like xattr

This is a design choice in the UI, not something intrinsic to the OS.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by smallstepforman on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:59PM (#29697194)
Find file(s) with queries in less than a second? Save the query as a folder and now you have “live” searches?

I cant tell you how often I waste time searching for the lication of a specific file. But never gad this probkem with BeOS/Haiku.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by rewgs on Sunday December 26, 2021 @07:44PM (#29697833)
Okay that's sick. Absolutely awesome idea.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by wmf on Sunday December 26, 2021 @06:23PM (#29697358)
BeFS maintained indices of extended attributes; in other OSes indexing is done in userspace which is safer and more flexible but can introduce race conditions between filesystem operations (e.g. moving a file) and updating the index.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by wmf on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:38PM (#29696080)
Most of what I learned from BeOS was what not to do (endian-specific code, C++ ABI, proprietary toolchain, messages on top of byte streams, forced multithreading, etc.). I still don't understand where the responsiveness came from.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by laumars on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:43PM (#29696670)
The multi-threading was probably part of the reason. SMP was quickly becoming more and more common place with even Power Macs having a second processor despite Mac OS 9 and it’s predecessors not supporting SMP (applications had to specifically be written to support it).

Likewise on Intel, you had Windows 9x that didn’t support SMP so you were stuck with the NT line if you wanted multi processor support. I recall NT4 being pretty poor for desktop usage due to patchy driver support but Windows 2000 was amazing. Linux and BSD weren’t really desktop ready either.

So BeOS was basically a workstation class operating system designed to be running on lower footprint hardware (the comparison someone else made to Amiga is pretty apt).

As much as I typically hate Windows and prefer Linux and FreeBSD, Windows 2000 was pretty solid release and particularly when you place it in its era where only BeOS really competed with it in terms of performance and stability on commodity hardware.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by fault1 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:13PM (#29696435)
> I still don't understand where the responsiveness came from.

personally, I thought it was because it was macos, which was riddled with a lot of legacy code, for example 68k emulation in the innards of the kernel, and tacked on cooperative/preemptive multitasking.

I remember playing with a leaked version of Copeland/Gershwin. It felt way more modern in a different way than BeOS, but I can't remember how complete it was.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by rbanffy on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:52PM (#29698224)
> I still don't understand where the responsiveness came from.

You can get a lot of snappiness from prioritizing GUI processes and lowering the priority of everything else. In modern machines, with lots of cores, you can also try to increase affinity of different interactive processes with a set of cores so that they avoid migrating and losing caches. Finally, Apple is placing low-priority process in the efficient cores and leaving interactive code on the performance ones.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by pavlov on Sunday December 26, 2021 @02:50PM (#29695675)
A lot of BeOS veterans ended up at Android.

Any direct influence would probably be felt most on the mobile side rather than desktop.

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by danieldk on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:41PM (#29696658)
Dominic Giampaolo, who made BeFS (the modern BeOS filesystem) works at Apple and is one of the main designers of APFS.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dominic_Giampaolo

Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by pjmlp on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:09PM (#29696860)
Unfortunately the mess of Android APIs lacks any proof of BeOS influence.
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by bitigchi on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:13PM (#29695881)
Haiku is still alive, no need to look for other things in other OSs. :)
Re:Using BeOS on a Power Mac (2001) by catb0t on Sunday December 26, 2021 @06:25PM (#29697370)
https://www.haiku-os.org/ is the open-source successor to BeOS and runs on amd64