News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by alexpetralia on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:38PM (#29688102)
I am somewhat surprised a single quote can render someone a terrible person. All of us are just one quote away from having our entire lives reduced to "good" or "bad"!
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by adventured on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:18PM (#29688389)
> I am somewhat surprised a single quote can render someone a terrible person

You should be surprised. It can't.

The important extraction from that premise, is that the opinions of essentially all people on such a subject are worthless, unless you happen to specifically know the person and value their opinion accordingly.

One of the mass delusions that is very popular today - and particularly destructive - is to treat everyone's opinions on all things as having some great value and their feelings as being the most important thing to consider. We live in hyper irrational times.

> All of us are just one quote away from having our entire lives reduced to "good" or "bad"!

Reduced by whom? Who cares. That's the correct response to such a reduction by opinions of people that do not matter to you.

A stranger on the Internets said my life is bad. Comeon. Who cares. It's meaningless garbage and a waste of precious time to consider such things.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by fnord77 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @11:44PM (#29689780)
he was advocating for a big first-strike nuclear attack against the USSR that would have killed millions of innocents.

Pretty hard to be worse that that.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by llimos on Sunday December 26, 2021 @08:44AM (#29692294)
To those doing the reducing - just "bad". Never "good".
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by ethanbond on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:34PM (#29688076)
I don’t know enough about JvN to say he is/isn’t a terrible person, but this quote seems like weak evidence either way. Of course it’s entirely different: self preservation instinct applies to self.
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by KarlKemp on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:48PM (#29688556)
No, self-preservation instincts, and other protective instincts, also apply to others. That's what so-called "mirror neurons" are known for. It isn't just some separate wish not to see other people's suffering, but an actual activation of the same pathways that react to pain experienced by the indidivual themselves.

In healthy people, that is.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by pengaru on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:56PM (#29688607)
Jackass was a popular show.
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by sinity on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:42PM (#29688905)
The perspective shifts somewhat if you look at it from Eastern European PoV.

West had a game-breaking advantage over the SU. It could've threatened Soviets with that power. Instead it folded and gave them everything they wanted.

Presumably West wouldn't even need to drop the bombs - just use the threat for negotiations.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by systemvoltage on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:54PM (#29688249)
This gets brought up on every single JvN post on HN. Can we please let the man rest in peace? Someone tried to cancel Feynman the other day.

Hell, even James Webb was on the chopping block until NASA administration pushed back on the cancel culture nonsense from Scientific American.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by KarlKemp on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:34PM (#29688480)
If the article's glorification of the man is acceptable, then so is criticism. And the fact that the term "cancel culture" is applied to a person that has been dead for more than half a century tells you that the term has become even more useless than it ever was.
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by systemvoltage on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:39PM (#29688883)
This culture, whatever it is, has had a personal impact on me. Many great people that I truly and deeply admired growing up, the reason why I am the person that I am today is because of historical figures. People need to learn how to forgive, look for the best in people and let go of decades old misgivings of a person. They changed the world. They inspired a whole generation. Anything that they did in their personal lives pales in comparison. If you want to go with this route, literally every person's great great grandfather was sexist in 1920s by today's standards. People need to understand the era, the context under which they operated. I am pretty sure my thoughts today are going to be outdated after 50 years. This is a dangerous slippery slope of wokeness that needs to be strongly codemned IMO. It's one thing to raise awareness, another to deflate historical figures because of some shit they said 70 years ago. It is toxic, futile and against your cause.

"That's not activism" - President Obama: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qaHLd8de6nM

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by api on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:04PM (#29689010)
Absolutely. If we have to throw away the work of anyone with moral failings, then all human culture must be destroyed.

I wonder how much this modern tendency to want perfect people and flat history can be related to things like the popularity of comic book films. People seem to really be craving simple absolute black and white fables with cardboard villains fighting superheroes these days.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by KarlKemp on Sunday December 26, 2021 @01:22AM (#29690216)
As a German, I am used to the idea of my Grandparent probably being immoral assholes.
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by systemvoltage on Sunday December 26, 2021 @02:46AM (#29690531)
The point is that it is trivial to find character flaws from people of the by-gone era and it only satisfies one's need to ostensibly feel morally superior. It wasn't too long ago that women weren't allowed to vote in Switzerland (1991).
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by mongol on Sunday December 26, 2021 @04:59AM (#29691054)
But have you taken down their photos from your walls because of that?
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by justbaker on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:50PM (#29688954)
That’s exactly what happens with cancel culture. Nothing is off limits and context of a person’s actions and works is lost and scrutinized as if it were now.
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by mongol on Sunday December 26, 2021 @02:55AM (#29690567)
What did Scientific American attempt to do?
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by systemvoltage on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:38AM (#29690749)
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nasa-needs-to-ren...

Accusation was not even direct, it was James Webb's complicitness for LGBTQ issues 70+ years ago!:

> James Webb. Prescod-Weinstein and other critics argue that Webb was complicit in the discrimination of LGBTQ employees in the ’40s, ‘50s and ‘60s — both as undersecretary in the U.S. Department of State and as the top administrator at NASA.

Response from NASA:

> “NASA’s History Office conducted an exhaustive search through currently accessible archives on James Webb and his career,” NASA spokeswoman Karen Fox said in a statement to The Post. “They also talked to experts who previously researched this topic extensively.

> “NASA found no evidence at this point that warrants changing the name of the James Webb Space Telescope,” Fox added.

I despise these people (Scientific American). At this point, I will never see Scientific American magazine in the same light - it is completely derailed.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by leesec on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:48PM (#29688561)
Well fortunately I choose not to judge people by their worst quotes or characteristic.
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by JamesBarney on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:19AM (#29690673)
He's a terrible person for being scared of his own death?

If the U.S. approached every death with the horror we reserve for our own we'd lose every war we ever fought.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by raincom on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:32PM (#29688841)
I don't want to call JvN a terrible person. He is like many brilliant people who develop surveillance tech for masses. The moment the lives of these brilliant people are surveilled by others, then they claim "it is wrong". Same thing for those people who work for the govt agencies in developing weapons(say, killing by drones).
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by 123pie123 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:02PM (#29688655)
true or not

this is something that I've thought about for a long time

I would say that if you delve deep enough that everybody, including every great person has had issues (some more and some less) and these have to been seen in the context of the time. But even if say for example Eistain was an evil person (I doubt it) or Chirchill a rasict person etc... should this matter?

Should this distract from their achievement and contribution to human society??

My gut feeeling says not but I can't logically piece it together in my head

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by ganzuul on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:02AM (#29691068)
It takes about 20 seconds of attention to learn with positive reinforcement, while negative is instant. This is because negative experiences are critical for survival.

These same circuits get used for dealing with things that are unrelated to survival but still produce results the same way. When e.g. propaganda is used people learn that they can weild power this way, which they believe they need for survival.

And mostly we err into this mode when our biochemistry isn't at 100%. It is simply irrationality spilling over.

Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by sebow on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:53PM (#29688238)
And he was right.Somewhat cold?Meh, i personally don't think so, maybe for some.But that doesn't make him a bad person or terrible at all.
[dead]
Re:A Man from the Future – John von Neumann’s nuclear vision by jbay808 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:16PM (#29689069)
That excerpt sounds too brief for me to know whether he was really making a point in favour or in opposition to bombing the USSR.