News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by gautamcgoel on Saturday December 25, 2021 @01:37PM (#29685707)
A lot of commenters are sharpening their pitchforks, but this comment, in my opinion, makes it very likely that it was an honest mistake. Amazing what taking personal responsibility and earnestly apologizing can do to restore trust and credibility!
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by csilverman on Saturday December 25, 2021 @01:53PM (#29685852)
Yeah, I think this is an example of addressing a mistake that other companies should take note of. I don’t trust Microsoft-sized corporations as a matter of principle, and I don’t typically give them the benefit of the doubt, but when one of their own engineers explains in human-readable terms what specifically happened—on a holiday, no less—I’m impressed enough to believe him. Some PR flack showing up with vague boilerplate about how Microsoft values the open-source community and they’ll look into it would only have encouraged more outrage.

I always appreciate communication that acknowledges I’m a person, not a data point or a customer. I wish more companies ditched the greasy PR approach and allowed folks like Jeff to do their talking for them.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by novok on Saturday December 25, 2021 @04:14PM (#29686997)
I think a key reason that corps do try to avoid admitting fault, is because in a lawsuit that can be used as evidence for a guilty verdict in a civil lawsuit in some of the most slam dunk ways.

If we remove this feature of common law legal systems, I think you will get far more admissions of fault like this one.

If you hurt people, organizations, etc for admitting their mistakes, they're going to stop doing it.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by jdsully on Saturday December 25, 2021 @05:15PM (#29687486)
The key take away is that apologizing and admitting fault doesn't absolve one of liability. There are a number of "amnesty" laws on the books where admitting fault can server to limit or reduce your sentence - especially with tax issues. I'm not sure how desirable such a thing would be in civil law among private parties. Especially in cases where a tort is minor to one party but a big deal to the other because of disparate wealth.

E.g. if Microsoft burned your house down would an apology and explanation be enough to settle the matter? How could we encode this principle into law for minor things but not large things?

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by csilverman on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:01PM (#29687854)
I don’t think accidentally removing credits from a software license is exactly on the level of burning someone’s house down.

In general, I wouldn’t say that causing someone harm should be dismissible with an apology, but in a situation where the harm seems pretty limited, easily reversible, and unintentional—and the apology seems genuine and even informative—I don’t see a particular benefit to causing hardship to someone who made a mistake. The communal reaction as it is should give Microsoft/Google/etc an idea of what the blowback would be if this sort of thing was a deliberate corporate practice.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by jdsully on Saturday December 25, 2021 @08:22PM (#29688772)
The harm is depriving the author of their moral rights, and the name recognition from their work. Depending on how popular the library becomes this could deprive the author of substantial business opportunities.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by csilverman on Sunday December 26, 2021 @12:23AM (#29689966)
And if this was a deliberate decision that Microsoft refused to undo, I’d be as outraged as everyone else here would be.

But it wasn’t, and they did undo it, and I found their response impressively civilized and professional. So I’m not really understanding why everyone seems to want to hold this guy accountable for all the shitty stuff Microsoft could have done, didn’t do, and apparently did in the past.

[dead]
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by laserbeam on Saturday December 25, 2021 @03:17PM (#29686590)
Alright... What is a proper response to an honest mistake in your book? We have links to a bug, explanation of what happened, a clear response (that they will check to see if this happened on other forks), they reversed the change...

Unsure why the bar would need to be higher. This is all reasonable given the circumstances.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by robertlagrant on Saturday December 25, 2021 @03:40PM (#29686767)
An engineer who can write straightforwardly is worth 100 PR people in situations like this.

They're not paid like that, but they are worth that.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by csilverman on Sunday December 26, 2021 @12:34AM (#29690010)
Fully agreed. And yeah, when it comes to my expectations as far as how large companies respond to embarrassments, the bar is about as low as it gets. A tone-deaf non-apology that sounds like a robot wrote it is what I expect to hear, and I’m almost invariably right.

And that offends me. The idea that someone thinks I’d be convinced by such a response—that I’d find it persuasive and acceptable—is fucking insulting.

So when the guy who’s actually responsible for the mistake—and not some polished corporate drone—actually shows up in the comments section, explains what happened, and talks to me the way one of my colleagues would: yeah, that is above and beyond by most standards, certainly the ones I have for evil empires like FAAN(M)G companies, and I give major credit for that.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by robertlagrant on Friday December 31, 2021 @03:03AM (#29745944)
Agreed. It's mostly I think because the press can only really do bikeshedding, and so the form of what people say is all they can comment on and amplify, and so we need professional spokespeople to keep up with the rules of what's okay to say, rather than more people to make better products.
[dead]
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by itzprime on Saturday December 25, 2021 @02:29PM (#29686199)
How has Microsoft reformed? Windows 11 is more intrusive than ever, it changes default programms more frequently to their desired programms and it is so annyoing to switch browser. THey still are the same old.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by PragmaticPulp on Saturday December 25, 2021 @01:59PM (#29685921)
> makes it very likely that it was an honest mistake.

I don’t have any doubt that it was an honest mistake. They also took accountability for the mistake, shared their steps to prevent it from happening again, and they’re in contact with the original repo author directly.

At this point, anyone digging for excuses to further demonize Microsoft isn’t interested in honest discussion about this issue. This is a textbook mistake followed by rapid resolution (on Christmas Day, no less), with great communication on top.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by scorpio241 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:17AM (#29690666)
Here in "honest mistake" they try to patent somebody's method: https://www.theregister.com/2021/03/13/microsoft_ans_patent/
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by tptacek on Saturday December 25, 2021 @01:39PM (#29685734)
It was obviously a mistake. Still nice to have someone involved give the backstory.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by sharken on Saturday December 25, 2021 @02:05PM (#29685981)
Yes, very nice writeup from Microsoft.

Had a similar experience with AzureCli v2.30, where the environment variable to ignore certificate errors suddenly did not work anymore.

It turned out it was removed but there was no mention of it in the release notes.

On the GitHub page quick response was provided by Microsoft.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by laumars on Saturday December 25, 2021 @04:28PM (#29687105)
If you read the comments, most people believed it was an honest mistake. What we didn’t agree with was that it was an excusable mistake. Microsoft have since acknowledged it’s not excusable and thus will rectify that error. So as far as I see it, all parties, both for and against MS, should be satisfied with the outcome.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by hawski on Saturday December 25, 2021 @02:31PM (#29686220)
In a way I'm glad that this is not taken lightly. We all need to be informed and calm, but mega-corporations should be held to higher standards. They should feel breath of an angry mob once in a while. I imagine, that if reactions to things like that would be just "meh, it's probably just a mistake" it would not be resolved as quickly or it could just be ignored. But now that it is all cleared up let's go home and Merry Christmas.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by indrora on Sunday December 26, 2021 @09:37AM (#29692673)
A phrase I've come to appreciate:

> Prescribe not to malice that which may well be a buggy edge case.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by prvc on Saturday December 25, 2021 @09:25PM (#29689103)
Intent is a red herring, especially when the actions of an organization, rather than an individual are being considered. More important are the actions' consequences and the organization's propensity for repeating them.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by noobermin on Saturday December 25, 2021 @11:11PM (#29689589)
Honestly, doing this all on Christmas nonetheless. This sort of thing is why I never want to be in leadership roles.
[dead]
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by barnabee on Sunday December 26, 2021 @05:52AM (#29691343)
I’d rather we all ceased the collective regressive delusion that is copyright.

There are other ways to make sure artists and inventors can eat than by using the threat of violence to make the unscarce scarce.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by novok on Saturday December 25, 2021 @04:17PM (#29687019)
Lets also get rid of web search engines while we are at it, or transparent caching CDNs /s
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by throwaway82931 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @04:28PM (#29687103)
Web search engines claim fair use for snippets, and MS claims fair use for Copilot. However, a web search engine result page is only an aggregate of the excerpted pages, and it refers back to them; unlike software authored using Copilot, it does not draw those snippets together into a coherent purposeful whole, strip all reference to the original author. and claim complete originality.

That MS went ahead with training Copilot on open source code authored by people who are clearly not OK with it is why they are so short on goodwill.

Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by 32ry8we7ahui3 on Saturday December 25, 2021 @06:45PM (#29688167)
Why is Copilot any different from a human doing essentially the same thing? Complete originality doesn't exist. I think the people who are complaining about Copilot have likely done the same thing themselves. I can't erase the memory of all the code I have read and written that somebody else 'own' the copyright to, so my brain will subconsciously use copyrighted code when writing software.
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by cycomanic on Saturday December 25, 2021 @07:03PM (#29688301)
Because copilot is not a human and can do things that humans can't. Moreover I encourage you to learn music pieces by listening to them and then selling/giving away snippets. You will have big corporations on your heels fairly quickly even though you are a human.
[dead]
Re:Microsoft forked MIT licensed repo and changed the copyri... by dang on Saturday December 25, 2021 @05:31PM (#29687624)
Could you please stop breaking the site guidelines? You've unfortunately been doing it repeatedly in your HN comments. People are supposed to get the benefit of the doubt here.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html