If we remove this feature of common law legal systems, I think you will get far more admissions of fault like this one.
If you hurt people, organizations, etc for admitting their mistakes, they're going to stop doing it.
E.g. if Microsoft burned your house down would an apology and explanation be enough to settle the matter? How could we encode this principle into law for minor things but not large things?
In general, I wouldn’t say that causing someone harm should be dismissible with an apology, but in a situation where the harm seems pretty limited, easily reversible, and unintentional—and the apology seems genuine and even informative—I don’t see a particular benefit to causing hardship to someone who made a mistake. The communal reaction as it is should give Microsoft/Google/etc an idea of what the blowback would be if this sort of thing was a deliberate corporate practice.
But it wasn’t, and they did undo it, and I found their response impressively civilized and professional. So I’m not really understanding why everyone seems to want to hold this guy accountable for all the shitty stuff Microsoft could have done, didn’t do, and apparently did in the past.
Unsure why the bar would need to be higher. This is all reasonable given the circumstances.
They're not paid like that, but they are worth that.
And that offends me. The idea that someone thinks I’d be convinced by such a response—that I’d find it persuasive and acceptable—is fucking insulting.
So when the guy who’s actually responsible for the mistake—and not some polished corporate drone—actually shows up in the comments section, explains what happened, and talks to me the way one of my colleagues would: yeah, that is above and beyond by most standards, certainly the ones I have for evil empires like FAAN(M)G companies, and I give major credit for that.
I always appreciate communication that acknowledges I’m a person, not a data point or a customer. I wish more companies ditched the greasy PR approach and allowed folks like Jeff to do their talking for them.