News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by costcofries on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:21PM (#29663958)
Not surprised that this is the top comment, it seems to be the overwhelming sentiment on HN, which is unfortunate. My perspective is that it's very early for NFTs and the large majority (you included) are fixating on what you're seeing in the space today, or put differently, you're being shortsighted.

Mark your comment down and revisit it in a few years, having an opinion on the sidelines is just fine. Now let the downvotes commence.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by simias on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:26PM (#29664018)
We've been hearing this tune from cryptoenthusiasts for over a decade now, maybe you should revisit your comments from a few years ago?

If you dig in my own comments on this website you can probably find discussions from 2017 or even earlier where I ask when people think that cryptocurrency tech is going to finally deliver something useful. It's always "one or two years from now". It's always "we're early". Remember ICOs? Remember how it was going to revolutionize IoT? Remember dapps? Remember lightning? It's been around the corner for years now.

Can you think of a single other technical innovation that required so much faith and patience before it delivered? Maybe self-driving cars, but even then I'd argue that it made immense progress compared to blockchain technology.

In the end you can hype it as much as you want, it's still fundamentally just a crappy, slow, extremely inefficient append-only database that's only relevant because it's super good at supporting pyramid schemes.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by 58x14 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:46PM (#29664276)
Really have to challenge this comment.

"We're early" in the internet had the dotcom bubble, the development of mobile 3G infrastructure and devices, the advent of smartphones, the VC-fueled app craze, and then eventually, now. The innovation mostly occurred in certain geographical areas, under the control of a relatively small population, with global impact.

The progression of blockchain technology - and dare I say culture - is speedrunning the history of human communication, including currency. Mainstream attention is high, but not adoption of paramount fundamental tech like ENS for identity and reputation. I'm guessing critical mass sometime in the next 18-36 months.

I also worry you may be subject to observation bias and ensuing feedback loops; if you primarily encounter negative headlines around crypto, it reinforces your opinion. But there are treasure troves of data, assembled by tens of thousands of exceptionally talented engineers, researchers and philosophers, that are also available for your observation. I wonder, if you spent some time there, perhaps your opinions would be more plastic.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by simias on Thursday December 23, 2021 @02:13PM (#29665324)
>I'm guessing critical mass sometime in the next 18-36 months.

And I say in 2025 I'll be having the same discussion I had in 2017 and I'm having right now as somebody will reply to a comment I make on HN telling me that whatever cryptofad of the day is 18-36months away from mainstream adoption.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by exdsq on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:57PM (#29664428)
Interesting way to describe a computer as a append-only database
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by simias on Thursday December 23, 2021 @07:05PM (#29668159)
The blockchain is not a computer. Computers are computers, and since it's trustless every node has to recompute everything.

With enough spin you can make everything sound revolutionary. Smart contracts are effectively like stored procedures, just ridiculously wasteful.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by solean on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:33PM (#29664099)
"Remember dapps?" There are plenty of useful dapps that exist today.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by zepto on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:06PM (#29664538)
Such as?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by solean on Thursday December 23, 2021 @04:40PM (#29666823)
An obvious one would be permissionless lending/borrowing (Aave or Compound)
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by zepto on Friday December 24, 2021 @02:48PM (#29677090)
Not obvious as far as I can see. Just moving cryptocurrencies around isn’t necessarily useful.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by swalsh on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:42PM (#29664225)
When I watched the president of the United States get kicked off every popular social media platform it clicked for me. I never voted for the guy, I never liked the guy. But he was still the president, and it didn't matter. The tech companies demonstrated how much power they truely had. NO ONE should have that much unchecked power.

Before 2020, I was interested in crypto as an academic exercise. In 2021, it became an urgant need. I don't think i'm alone, to me crypto is an exit from the large tech monopolies that dominate our world today.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by blueski on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:24PM (#29663996)
Partially agree - but people have been excited about e.g. smart contracts for the last ~5 years, yet which consumer or B2B apps are using them now? When Web2 came along, Gmail, Maps and Facebook were immediately exciting and obviously better than what came before. How much longer do we need to wait for those Web3 killer apps, that appeal to users who aren't purely in it for token price speculation?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by MrPatan on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:33PM (#29664102)
When Gmail came along, like a decade after the web started getting popular, there were countless people, very much like you now, telling everybody how much better their desktop email app was.

Nfts may or may not be the blockchain's killer app (I think they are), but the average person's track record identifying a technology's killer app is a tad less than perfect

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by grumple on Thursday December 23, 2021 @06:16PM (#29667704)
> Nfts may or may not be the blockchain's killer app (I think they are)

How is a bit of data on a blockchain pointing to a URI a breakthrough? It's utterly ineffective at proving ownership of anything, since the data at the uri can be changed, or more likely - the entire server will disappear at some point in time. And then what about uris on the blockchain pointing to illegal material (things that are actually copyrighted by someone through the legal system, CP, etc)?

Obviously storing actual data on-chain is too costly as well (both financially on the large chains, and practically/environmentally on any of them).

Everyone I know who's into NFTs and crypto was a con artist before blockchain and they'll be con artists after. Wait until I tell you about the drug addict scammers I know that started a crypto coin of their own and got a friend who knows literally nothing about crypto to write their whitepaper.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by blueski on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:37PM (#29664147)
I'd argue the exponential growth curves for Gmail, Maps, and Facebook (with no financial reward for the user) suggests there was a good appreciation of the utility. When will get an equivalent Web3 app that isn't predominantly driven by price speculation? What will this look like?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:47PM (#29664300)
That’s not here yet but dapps do have millions of users already.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by blueski on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:03PM (#29664506)
Which stand the best chance of going mainstream, with those who don't care about the underlying technology or price speculation?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:11PM (#29664603)
NFTs. Gaming seems to be it.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by blueski on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:25PM (#29664755)
But do digital goods in games really justify the Web2 -> Web3 iteration? Compared to Web2 bringing us Gmail, Maps, Facebook etc, feels a little anemic so far.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:32PM (#29664841)
Yeah it’s pretty terrible so far I agree.

My hunch is that crypto is focusing on the wrong things. I suspect we’ll never have land registers in blockchain (dumb idea anyway).

In NFTs crypto kind of stumbled upon something important, because digital art didn’t have a way to be authenticated by artists themselves, they had to use galleries, it was a mess. Now a digital artist can just drop his stuff onto the world and authenticate it. This was a Real Problem, if you make physical art you can just go to the local arts and crafts or Etsy and charge money for it. But digital art was really hard to monetise. So crypto came in a bit sideways and solved a Real Problem People Had.

Curiously they seem to really focus on “real world” problems, like banks or land registry or whatever, when I’m starting to think this is the entirely wrong way to see crypto. I think it needs to focus on problems that exist in the digital arena Only IE data ownership, data portability.

But the obsessions of the original conceptions around crypto are hard to kill, and I feel like right now there’s a lot of resistance to leaving the Nick Szabo idea of “smart contracts will replace lawyers”, same as it was before with a lot of Nakamoto’s ideas. But I think the “crypto will replace lawyers” and “crypto will replace banks” folks will be sorely disappointed. I see a very low percent chance crypto will change that much about banking just due to the security issues.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by majewsky on Friday December 24, 2021 @03:39PM (#29677521)
> But digital art was really hard to monetise.

Is it though? Honest question since I'm not an artist. But looking from the outside: For ongoing support, Patreon/Flattr/etc. are a common solution. For specific work, you can commission a piece and pay for it through whatever channel, even with cash.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Sunday December 26, 2021 @03:42PM (#29696121)
It just didn’t work for individual digital art. Patreon doesn’t pay you for making art, that’s incidental. At least the way I’ve seen it used. It also creates no secondary market, there’s no resale, royalties. The possibility of making a single art piece worth 10,000$ That is impossible in patreon. Patreon was more of a decentralised art school at its best, where you could pay for individual tutors.

I also know the average income I saw being generated from Patreon was low. Not high enough to quit your day job, more of a second job type thing. NFT income is incomparable, I know of cases of people who are now millionaires.

NFTs are essentially just a way to sell digital art in a way that approximates physical art auctions, and in that regard they are an overwhelming sucess.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by pyrale on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:24PM (#29663994)
I don't see how promoting artificial scarcity is going to become a good idea in a few years. Just because the implementation is shit nowadays doesn't mean we should be happy to see better implementations in the future.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by costcofries on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:31PM (#29664077)
I'm a hobbyist photographer. I have been publishing my photographs to unsplash for the last 4 years. I have over 100 photos on Adobe contributor. The former has delivered me ZERO inbound or monetary value, just over 3 million downloads of my work. The latter has given me returns I could buy coffee with.

NFTs open a new World of opportunity for me. Not only can other humans easily collect, and compensate me for my work, I also have a whole new stream for consuming royalties. Now think further about the ecosystem potential and all the third parties that consume my unsplash content for free today, NFTs can change that.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by blueski on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:39PM (#29664178)
In what sense do the purchasers of your NFTs have "ownership" of your work - what could they do with it that I could not, and how is this legally enforced? If NFTv2 comes out in a year with 10x the financial rewards, will you commit to not offering the same pieces again?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by pyrale on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:09PM (#29664583)
What led you to make your photos available under a free sharing license, if you were expecting returns?

> Not only can other humans easily collect, and compensate me for my work

They could have done it before, what makes you think this technical change will make people want to fund artists more, beyond a momentary financial mania?

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by costcofries on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:25PM (#29664766)
1. The goal with Unsplash has always been marketing exposure and inbound traffic, though unfortunately it just doesn't really exist. So, why are my photos still there? It feels counterproductive to remove something that has ranked so well, for so long, on the platform.

2. Just my opinion - I believe that over time people will increasingly value digital assets, I don't think we're even close to understanding their utility. NFT collectors are a growing segment for artists and things like virtual galleries will represent new places to showcase and share those collections.

Edit - I think people should make an effort to distinguish between visual and "technical or attributable" ownership. Too often these threads on NFTs are, "how do you own something if I can copy it" (the picture). That's missing the point. I don't care if you replicate my NFT and its visual identity, I will always be the owner of the underlying attribute and the evolution of that attribute.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by abduhl on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:36PM (#29664135)
Then put your hobby where your mouth is. Pull all of your photos from the past 4 years from unsplash and mint NFTs for them.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by costcofries on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:40PM (#29664189)
That's exactly what I'm doing :)
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by timmg on Thursday December 23, 2021 @03:30PM (#29666104)
If I were to buy one of your NFTs, what does that get me?

Do you confer a license to the photo that I can use elsewhere? Can I use it in an ad? Can I sell copies of it?

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by swalsh on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:46PM (#29664281)
NFT's aren't about artificial scarcity, they give owners rights. Being able to control a digital asset is important. Take the ENS (it's like a domian service). Having exclusive control over a domain is not scarcity, it's what makes it practical.

To get in the right mindset, you should stop thinking of NFT's as pictures. That's not the primary use case. It's a stupid game that became popular. NFT's are just tokens on the open blockchain that you can exclusively control.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by zepto on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:07PM (#29664553)
> they give owners rights

Generally not.

> NFT's are just tokens on the open blockchain that you can exclusively control.

Exactly this, and nothing more.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by officeplant on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:42PM (#29664234)
I believe a lot of us would be more excited if they weren't also a frustrating grifter paradise.

People rant and rave about how this is a huge when for digital artists while ignoring the darker side. I see more and more small artists venting their frustrations in fighting with the NFT markets to get their stolen art taken down. Also in dealing with crypto bros cyberbullying them for refusing to participate in this whole crypto shit show.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @12:49PM (#29664313)
The stolen art thing is a problem screaming for a technical solution.

Outside of that, 99% of the artist I know are super happy NFTs exist and they can make money out of them.

Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by zepto on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:08PM (#29664566)
How many artists do you know?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:11PM (#29664600)
Quite a few since I’m a digital artist myself.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by zepto on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:14PM (#29664641)
That isn’t an answer to my question, but it does explain your financial interest in defending NFTs throughout this thread.
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by kranke155 on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:26PM (#29664778)
You mean because they are good for me and they are good for 99% of the digital artists on this planet?
Re:NFT Replicas: An app to mint a replica of virtually any NFT by zepto on Thursday December 23, 2021 @01:44PM (#29664997)
They are good for you, but you don’t know 99% of the digital artists on this planet or what is good for them.

Indeed you haven’t even told us how many digital artists you know. Only that you are one.