News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by robbmorganf on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:21PM (#29596056)
Does anyone understand why a third dose of the same vaccine improves immunity to Omicron?

I'm willing to believe the empirical evidence that boosters make a meaningful difference, but I can't figure out intuitively why the same mRNA a third time helps to address this new spike.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by thinkharderdev on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:41PM (#29596394)
From what I understand it is about affinity maturation. Basically, when you get an initial vaccine (or infection) your immune system learns how to recognize the antigen (the virus spike protein) and produces a bunch of antibodies to recognize it. But your immune system also preserves the spike protein in antigen presenting cells so it can continue to produce antibodies to recognize more features of the spike protein. Over time, your immune system learns how to produce a broader range of antibodies that are (in aggregate) more likely to recognize partially mutated versions of the antigen. That's the affinity maturation part.

So when you get a booster (or a breakthrough infection) your immune system kicks into gear again but now it produces a broader range of antibodies. In addition the number of antibodies produced from the booster is quantitatively much larger than from the first vaccine. So with a booster you end up with more antibodies but also a larger variety of antibodies that can recognize different features of the spike protein (including features that are consistent between variants).

That's my understand at least but I am not an immunologist.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by corin_ on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:40PM (#29597351)
> So when you get a booster (or a breakthrough infection) your immune system kicks into gear again but now it produces a broader range of antibodies.

Would/could it not also be the case for exposure to the virus that doesn't result in a breakthrough infection i.e. the body detects it and fights it off successfully? (I daresay you didn't mean to imply that, just checking.)

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by thinkharderdev on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:10AM (#29603597)
I would assume so but it probably depends on the "level" of exposure and such.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eagsalazar2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:24PM (#29596104)
Maybe it is less about it being the 2nd or 3rd shot and more about how recently you received your last shot? I got my 2nd shot 7 months ago and we've already heard that protection fades over time, so maybe the booster just works because it boosts, not because it is really any different than my 2nd shot.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:31PM (#29596227)
> Maybe is ... about how recently you received your last shot .. not because it is really any different than my 2nd shot.

No. That appears not be the situation. Immunity shortly after the thirds shot is substantially higher than shortly after the second

https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1460191035531878405

https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1458026852249919490

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eightysixfour on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:39PM (#29596361)
I have seen speculation that the second dose was given too quickly.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:44PM (#29596436)
Firstly, YMMV, different people got different separations of different vaccines. The US doing Pfizer 3 weeks apart was the fastest. The UK gave out AZ and Pfizer. First at a 12 week interval, then shortened to 8 weeks

The question is: too quickly for what? My understanding is that

a) If the goal was optimal immunity in the longer term then yes, it might be overly quick.

b) But if the goal was fighting the raging pandemic that needed urgent actions right now as "the house is on fire", and you have a lot of vaccine doses, then no, maybe not too fast.

Finally, a lot of vaccine courses require more than 2 doses, separated by more than a couple of months. UK standard childhood vaccination schedule for instance. "Polio" is in there 5 times. Polio is a memory, but only because because to this day they don't mess around with vaccinating against it

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eightysixfour on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:08PM (#29597703)
Agreed, I was only referencing a.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by wlesieutre on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:41PM (#29596386)
I wonder if that's a factor in the Pfizer/BioNTech vs Moderna performance. Moderna had a higher dosage, but it was also 4 weeks between doses instead of 3.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:44PM (#29596457)
> but it was also 4 weeks between doses instead of 3.

YMMV. The UK gave out AZ and Pfizer. First at a 12 week interval, then shortened to 8 weeks.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by Symmetry on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:53PM (#29596593)
If you assume an unlimited supply of vaccine then the shorter dose interval gets everybody to good level of sterilizing immunity as quickly as possible.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:57PM (#29596679)
Yep. if you need to fight against a raging pandemic, then quickly as possible (as quickly as is tested to be safe, quickly as makes a significant difference) is the over-riding concern.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by astrange on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:01PM (#29597628)
That implies we thought about it in the US, but we didn't really, and our public health people seem to be completely inflexible about everything. The schedule we used for vaccines is just what was done for their trials.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday December 18, 2021 @06:49AM (#29603787)
> The schedule we used for vaccines is just what was done for their trials.

There is a reason for that - what's being deployed is what has been tested. You could work out an optimal schedule, but that might take years of trials, and meanwhile people are dying.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by astrange on Saturday December 18, 2021 @09:16PM (#29610754)
Other countries stretched them out and saw positive results.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by xchaotic on Friday December 17, 2021 @04:45PM (#29598718)
Given how quickly the virus mutates, giving it less frequently makes even less sense.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eightysixfour on Friday December 17, 2021 @07:47PM (#29600240)
My response was with respect to maximizing immuno response following vaccination. There is some evidence that larger spacing between doses increases response.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by afterburner on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:27PM (#29596160)
Because of the way your immune system works. Vaccines aren't medicine, they work by provoking an immune response. What happens after that immune response is triggered is way more complicated than just "molecule X get response Y", there are multiple stages of responses, and the deeper, longer span ones create a resilience against mutations as well.

It is extremely common for a proper vaccination regimen to require multiple doses, and it has entirely to do with how the immune system works.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by notabee on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:47PM (#29596495)
From what I understand, the immune system has some capacity to anticipate mutations. The most basic function of antibodies is to stick to and neutralize the target, in this case the spike protein that the mRNA vaccine presents to the immune system via producing some copies in muscle cells. But the immune system doesn't just produce exact form-fitting duplicate antibodies, it also has something like a biological "fuzzer" that also produces antibodies to target anticipated mutations to its main target, the spike protein. Each time this system gets stimulated, it not only makes more antibodies and more memory cells to produce them, it also runs some more anticipatory mutations. So in aggregate, hopefully the increased quantity plus maturation of these various antibody tweaks produce enough antibodies that stick well enough to the virus to incapacitate or slow it down so that the other aspects of the immune system have time to react instead of getting overwhelmed. And it makes sense to have an antibody arms race like this since viruses mutate so fast. Obviously, this doesn't always work and viruses frequently out-mutate the immune memory, but the immune system is pretty smart.

By the way, if there are any actual scientists here that spot some atrocious mistake I've made describing this, please let me know. I find it really interesting to learn about but I'm certainly no expert.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by lborsato on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:12PM (#29598996)
Unfortunately as a result of original antigenic sin, the fact that the immune system has been trained for by a vaccine for a certain strain means that the body will respond to that strain, likely unable to mount a new defence for the different strain.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33692194/

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by freemint on Sunday December 19, 2021 @05:11PM (#29618957)
Virologist are aware of this but I seen no indication that it applies to the CoVi variants we are currently dealing with.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by Retric on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:26PM (#29596150)
Mutations in spike proteins don’t completely change it’s shape so they render a percentage of antibodies infective vs that specific strain. A boosted immune response can therefore be less efficient but still useful.

To simplify, Vaccines provide long term protection because the immune system builds infrastructure to rapidly create antibodies after infection cutting days off of the immune response. That’s huge because the virus has less time to replicate in your body. Vaccines use multiple injections to increase how much infrastructure is built and the number of types of antibodies being produced. Also this infrastructure decays over time if you never see the strain again.

However, in the short term your body reacts like it’s infected actually flooding the body with the appropriate antibodies. This isn’t sustainable but can crush most infections before they go anywhere. Kind of a bonus turbo mode which can be really helpful if your say going to treat people infected with the disease.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:35PM (#29596288)
> Does anyone understand why a third dose of the same vaccine improves immunity to Omicron?

From what I've read, 2 doses in 8-12 weeks is a small separation, as these things go.

A third dose 6 months after the second is not just a third revision of the lesson (metaphorically), but a more appropriate spacing to re-enforce it.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by pa7x1 on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:29PM (#29597931)
The CEO of BioNTech said they don't know for sure but speculated that memory B cells may keep hypermutating after a third shot which could result in the improved effectiveness against Omicron. Or that's what I understood with my very rudimentary knowledge of biology.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by Symmetry on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:57PM (#29596687)
After exposure to a pathogen the levels your body starts evolving antibodies against it. It also quickly ramps up antibody production, but ramps that down over time without additional exposure.

Having had a more recent jab will mean a higher quantities of antibodies. But more vaccinations also means your body has done more cycles of evolving better targeted antibodies against the threat. I assume that there's a certain level of diminishing return to the second factor, as well as questions about how much the extra work translates against a new variant. But the second effect exists alongside the first.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SubiculumCode on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:25PM (#29596121)
I am not an immunologist, but I imagine repeated infection is a signal to the body to build and expand immunity to the virus.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by ufo on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:26PM (#29596140)
One of the theories is that the booster raises the levels of neutralizing antibodies. While the antibodies against the original strain don't work as well against Omicron, having more of them does help.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by kgwxd on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:25PM (#29596126)
Is it not just timing? I thought the effectiveness of the vaccines only lasted around 6 months. In the US 18+ were able to get it 7 or 8 months ago.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by Retric on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:33PM (#29596258)
Vaccines can last your entire lifetime, but their effectiveness decays over time it largely depends on the disease and your risk of infection. Booster shots for various vaccines have been common for example, it’s recommended people take a Tdap booster every 10 years, Tetanus every 4-6 etc.

The flu vaccine is a special case as it’s changed every year.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by chasil on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:05PM (#29597678)
In the original use of the vaccina virus against variola (smallpox) infection, symptomatic smallpox could present after vaccina exposoure of at least five years past.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox#Prevention

"Smallpox vaccination provides a high level of immunity for three to five years and decreasing immunity thereafter. If a person is vaccinated again later, the immunity lasts even longer. Studies of smallpox cases in Europe in the 1950s and 1960s demonstrated that the fatality rate among persons vaccinated less than 10 years before exposure was 1.3 percent; it was 7 percent among those vaccinated 11 to 20 years prior, and 11 percent among those vaccinated 20 or more years before infection. By contrast, 52 percent of unvaccinated persons died."

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by dsmnd on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:45PM (#29596461)
The 'T' in Tdap stands for tetanus
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by Retric on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:14PM (#29596963)
Yes, though to be clear your supposed to get a both.

“It is recommended that adults get a Tdap shot for one of their tetanus boosters.” https://www.verywellhealth.com/booster-shots-1298291

It simply reduces the number of injections when you get multiple vaccines at the same time.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Saturday December 18, 2021 @09:59AM (#29604916)
> Is it not just timing? I thought the effectiveness of the vaccines only lasted around 6 months

No, it is not (just) timing.

"Three doses gives better protection than two doses ever did" (1)

Immune response is very complex (2) and we're not experts; but we should not measure it in just 1 number: that gives the impression that the response is a range from "high alert for this recent threat" through to "threat forgotten" - effectiveness did not last that long.

There are there are other states as well when the threat is "on file" in the immune memory. Another exposure months later influences this process. My guess is that the evolved heuristic is that "a threat that recurs more is worth remembering better".

1) https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1460191035531878405

2) https://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2020/08/covid-19-...

3) https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2021/09/waning-i...

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by awillen on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:38PM (#29596332)
My understanding is that they've studied people with 2 vs. 3 shots, both groups having received their most recent shot in a similar timeframe to account for that.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by hackerfromthefu on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:56PM (#29598248)
And no one is talking about whether we will be expected to take a fourth and subsequent
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by SideburnsOfDoom on Friday December 17, 2021 @05:46PM (#29599285)
No-one really knows that yet. Novel virus is new.

If I had to guess, I would expect another anti-COVID jab in 2022. I expect 1 injection in 2022, maybe in autumn, of a mRNA vaccine, against a strain such as Omicron, that is not original COVID-19-alpha. Not a firm prediction, just a guess at what's IMHO most likely.

[dead]
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eagsalazar2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:34PM (#29596260)
You really think the CDC and other govt and NGO organizations, as an international coordinated group effort, are in bed with pharma companies, plotting with them to falsify data and craft false recommendations, just so those farma companies can make more $$? I mean, I actually do think that pharma companies are vile, have successfully gained significant regulatory capture, and can influence policy through their own messaging and lobbying, but this wouldn't be influence, this would be coordinated and crafted disinformation across many many parties, most of whom don't work for pharma at all.

Honestly this theory seems like absolute crazy talk. Especially when perfectly reasonable explanations exist like the fact that immunity from vaccines wanes over time.

When given option 1 (crazy, complicated, far fetched, zero evidence) and option 2 (simple, makes sense, lots of independent scientific parties agreeing), and you pick options 2... ???? I'm confused about how you pick #1.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by 1123581321 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:49PM (#29596534)
It’s a valid opinion. The principle is regulatory capture and it happens when a regulatory agency isn’t competent and effective enough to remain independent in its acquisition and evaluation of knowledge. Likewise, the “capturing” is not malicious but happens when the pharmaceutical company persuasive over time, or, in extreme situations, when it appears to have the only solution. This can be exacerbated by inherent limitations to the industry in question, e.g. the difficulty of conducting long-term medical trials in an emergency. Regulatory capture is a natural drift and so believing it has occurred does not require believing in a conspiracy.

(I haven’t studied whether it’s happened in the case of Pfizer boosters.)

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by corin_ on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:48PM (#29597451)
In the case of covid vaccines there's plenty of real world data and lots of governments, universities, etc. running different studies all the time. Pfizer would be stupid to fake some initial data because it would be very quickly found out once real world results didn't stack up. For example, this thread you're commenting in is about research from a prestigious London university which found 3 jabs provides better protection than 2.

It wouldn't shock me at all to find out examples of pharma companies including Pfizer acting that way, but in this particular case of Covid vaccines there is evidence and plenty of reason to believe that it's not the case and you don't have any counter evidence, so no it's not a reasonable opinion it's just a conspiracy theory.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by 1123581321 on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:09PM (#29597718)
For sure. I don't think regulatory capture would be about faking data, rather, interpretation to the end of best improving public health (in this case) at the appropriate cost. Again, theoretically.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by AnthonyMouse on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:48PM (#29596510)
Don't think of it as a top-down conspiracy. Think of it as an alignment of perverse incentives.

New variant comes out, CDC is pressed to propose a solution. Pharma companies come in and say "here's a study we did ourselves showing that our own product provides some improvement." CDC recommends pharma product for lack of any better ideas.

You can reasonably imagine getting this result whether or not the booster actually provides more than a marginal improvement.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eagsalazar2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:06PM (#29596834)
Are all these studies and conversations from or led by pharma outsiders? If so can you provide any evidence of that? I mean it sounds like people are starting with a strongly held belief that there is a conspiracy and everyone is evil/corrupt (true of pharma I admit), then accepting, rejecting, and constructing arguments and evidence just to suit their preexisting beliefs which in turn have simply been constructed to serve their own goals and world views. Whew, well maybe this theory of why people believe what they do about covid and govt is me constructing self serving conspiracies. Shit is complex, but yeah this is my theory because otherwise I'm completely baffled that mostly smart people seem to be acting so completely irrationally.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by AnthonyMouse on Friday December 17, 2021 @02:36PM (#29597296)
It's because of human psychology.

You start off with a small group of "vaccines cause autism" crackpots, and they're irrelevant. Because vaccines still cause R < 1 if 90+% of people get them even if some single digit percentage of crackpots refuse.

But the crackpots are really loud and refuse to be defeated by science or logic. So some genius decides that what we need to own the refuseniks are vaccine mandates.

From a human psychology perspective, this was an incredibly bad idea. Because now you've gone from fighting seven lizardmen crackpots to fighting millions of regular people who don't believe in non-consensual medical treatment and can point to a long list of historical precedent for why that's a bad idea.

They literally changed the dictionary definition of "anti-vaxxer" to include people who oppose vaccine mandates:

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/anti-vaxxer

So now that you've put millions of people on "the other side," they are, by human nature, going to follow confirmation bias into being more likely to believe anything that helps "their side." So now large numbers of people start to believe that vaccines are dangerous and people should be afraid of getting them and they're less effective than claimed and they're only getting pushed by greedy pharma companies to make money, because that's what helps "their side" so they're more inclined to believe that it's true.

Conversely, the other side dismisses the possibility that any of those things are true for the same reason, even if some of them might be.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by spurgu on Friday December 17, 2021 @03:31PM (#29597949)
Yup. I'm twice vaccinated but still labeled as an anti-vaxxer because I show skepticism towards for example vaccinating young kids and I'm outright against vaccine mandates, to the point where I will refuse any boosters just out of principle.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by DwnVoteHoneyPot on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:55PM (#29596637)
Big Pharma mobilized an armies of people and equipment to create vaccines in record time to save lives, but people still like to shit on them.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by sdeframond on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:42PM (#29596405)
I just think we would rather use the doses already produced before they spoil than wait for the new ones.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by throwawayacc2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:38PM (#29596340)
> You really think the CDC and other govt and NGO organizations, as an international coordinated group effort, are in bed with pharma companies, plotting with them to craft false recommendations, just so those farma companies can make more $$?

Yes.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by somehnguy on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:45PM (#29596471)
You believe this based on what real world evidence? Or is it just your feelings?

Because if you're not using logic to take your current position then it'll be impossible to use logic to convince you otherwise and nobody should waste their time.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by teh_infallible on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:32PM (#29596235)
I was going to call it “marketing.”

I am amazed to see people discuss what are essentially the marketing claims of a corrupt industry as if they had scientific validity.

Substitute the word “immunity” with “blockchain” or “Artificial Intelligence” and maybe more people would see through it.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by xyzzy123 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:38PM (#29596338)
It's already in the supply chain, it's already approved, and it works - even if it's not as good as a variant-specific booster would be.

Timeliness matters a lot when you have doubling times measured in days, even 2-3 months and it could be too late.

Finally, it reduces people's natural hesitancy about side effects of the "new vaccine".

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by eagsalazar2 on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:34PM (#29596272)
It isn't just pharma companies saying the booster is needed. Your framing seems willfully misleading.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by ysavir on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:37PM (#29596316)
Perhaps, but without any actual statistics or expert claims to back it up, this doesn't seem to me a sound rationale against which to take risks with our health.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by stavros on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:41PM (#29596393)
> Omicron largely evades artificial intelligence from past infection or two vaccine doses according to Imperial's latest report.

Hmm, still nothing.

Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by chiefalchemist on Friday December 17, 2021 @01:36PM (#29596307)
Agreed. Came right from the CEO. What else was he suppposed to say? "Skip the booster, it barely helps."? Imagine the public panic, as well as the stock market panic.
Re:Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or tw... by chiefalchemist on Saturday December 18, 2021 @07:12AM (#29603900)
Dear Down voters...Communication 101...source matters...context matters...motive matters. These are facts.

Just because someone says X - and you agree - doesn't make it legitimate. Blind confirmation bias is not going to help us.