There are plenty of game dev companies where employees are treated well (I work for one of them) but "game company treats employees like human beings" is not an interesting enough headline, so you don't tend to hear about it.
But in spite of working for a really good studio right now, I recognize that many people are not (I've also worked with ones that were middling at best), and unionization is a great step towards getting better conditions, especially for artists and content people. Engineers tend to get the best treatment since toxic management know they are more expensive, harder to replace and have more opportunities across a variety of industries. Conversely, if you are a 3d artist (just as an example), there are only so many places you can work, and unfortunately you are often considered more disposable.
Hmm... interesting advice, I wonder why people getting treated like shit by their employers never thought of that.
a) Too young or inexperienced or fearful of reprisal to understand how to advocate for themselves and others; and/or
b) Just unaware that better places to work do exist, and are convinced (much like the thread parent here) that "this is just how gamedev is"
Unfortunately because gamedev is a dream job for a lot of folks they are unwilling to rock the boat because they want to live their dream. That is why unions are a great opportunity for people like this, it gives them some agency to make a positive change.
Reprisal is real, especially for the young and inexperienced in places where employees are treated like shit.
> Just unaware that better places to work do exist, and are convinced (much like the thread parent here) that "this is just how gamedev is"
I find it hard to believe that you really think people getting treated like shit at work are "unaware that better places to work do exist". They are absolutely aware that better places to work exist, the problem is knowing which places those are, and then getting a job there.
The negative statements being made about gamedev in this thread are generalizations, of course there are some excellent gamedev studios out there, but on average you're going to do a lot more work for a lot less pay with a lot less respect and a lot more drama than pretty much anywhere else in the software industry.
*I managed to confuse myself about how you spell this word...
It's great. Most game companies are very comfortable. Nice offices with free food, good pay, flexible hours, remote friendly, full benefits. Crunch is rare these days. This is all true of Blizzard, btw.
The vocal minority on twitter are trading in outrage; the currency of social media. And there's a distinct lack of perspective. Have they ever worked on a farm? A restaurant kitchen? A construction site? A warehouse? Or anywhere outside of an Aeron chair? Mostly no. This doesn't mean it's perfect or can't be improved, but it's really nice compared to most and this gets lost in the noise. I often visit poor neighborhoods and poor countries and read history and thank my lucky stars.
And yes, you can get even better pay in the financial services industry. If that's what you want, please, go work there. No one's stopping you.
I think therein may lie the difference.
Rephrased (accurately for intent) I thought it would be:
> Just to clarify, when you say "I am an artist and I love playing the games I've made with friends and strangers", do you mean artist as in the game-asset creator type of artist, or artist as in a romanticized version of a software engineer?
I could be wrong. Maybe he is just being a dick. But I primarily saw a somewhat more charitable interpretation.
The usage of quotation marks in journalism to say things using other people's words or to imply doubt on if those words are correct has been growing looser and looser. I generally take such usage as an indicator of bad and lazy writing.
edit/ These game companies themselves are also quite incestual, for want of a better word. Once a developer moves from one team in one company to another team in another company they typically try to heavily recruit the solid folks that they "left behind," as it were.
And I get that, but, anecdotally, it's never been something that I did when I moved around in my non-games industry. It's never even really crossed my mind.
It still sucked compared to industry positions I took later. There’s a lot more pressure to ship for Christmas, to demo for E3, etc. New consoles invariably have terrible documentation (“it can never not be forgotten to fail to initialize the blah”), and in general the game (and entertainment broadly) industry is less linear/more hit-driven than others.
I also hated that it broke my enjoyment of playing games if I got distracted wondering how they did some effect or why their renderer had a certain glitch.
It's great. I'm really enjoying it. I snipe people from my old work (who are willing to leave games) whenever I see an opening.
Or some of the extremely high quality indie games?
I'd take many of the indie games over WoW or CoD any day of the week. I don't need MMOs to enjoy a well written game.
Unless you think these transformations happen overnight, supply dwindling and working conditions being reevaluated would most definitely decrease quality of games in the short term.
And it's a solution that doesn't involve asking people to quit the job they love so they can get their soul sucked at an advertising company.
Also offering a theoretical that so far isn't happening isn't an interesting argument.
Any game company that unionizes will, in my opinion, have those studios shut down, and new ones open up in non-union environments.
To be honest, even if Blizzard doesn't unionize, I imagine that the parent company is going to wind down the employees in the studio and move content elsewhere.
No, try to make it better! Fight like hell to make it better! That is how we progress. That is how we got the worker's protections we have now. They weren't given magnanimously. We fought long and hard for every single one, and it made everyone's life better.
Demand better. Always demand better.
That's not what it reflects. It reflects the monetary value that it takes to get someome to do work for you. In games, it takes less money because people want to work on games. To get me to work on your advertising plaform you would have to pay me a ridiculous sum, because I don't want to work on an advertising platform. Companies pay people as much as it costs to get them to work, not an amount reflecting the value they provided to the company. Sometimes those values line up, but usually when profits go up salaries don't linearly follow along, so it's clearly not the latter.
Choosing to work there despite poor working conditions and the availability of work you're qualified to do with better working conditions is the thing that causes the poor working conditions.
Wtf is wrong with people here asking thousands of people to quit their job? Would you quit your beloved job to improve other peoples working conditions?
Because it's too high, enabling employers to offer poor working conditions. The poor working conditions then drive away prospective employees, lowering supply until working conditions improve.
Unless you for some reason volunteer to suffer the poor working conditions unnecessarily.
> Just make more games then demand will go up?
Making more games doesn't cause demand for games to go up. It causes the price of games to go down. Then each game maker has less to pay workers with.
What you need is for the industry to make fewer games, so they cost more (or at least have higher sales volumes at the same price), allowing workers to be paid more. But fewer games means fewer employees and some of them have to go do something else.
> Would you quit your beloved job to improve other peoples working conditions?
You can't have it both ways. Either your working conditions are bad, in which case quit, or your working conditions are "beloved," in which case what are you complaining about?
This makes zero sense. You can be doing a job you love while your boss is a piece of shit. You can be doing a job you love but not getting paid enough for it. You can be doing a job you love but being put at risk while doing it. And a million other things.
Come on, man, you are not this dense.
This is an absurd argument.
If you love making video games and one video game company has worse working conditions than all the others, quit that one and go work for one of the other ones.
If you love making video games and all the video game companies have poor working conditions because too many people love making video games and therefore the market is saturated, this a thing that only you can do anything about. The company you work for is already trying to maximize profits in a competitive market. To improve your working conditions they'd have to make more money, but if they could do that so easily they'd have done it already.
You, by contrast, have an actual choice. Do you love this job, working conditions and all, better than your other available alternatives? If the answer is yes, you've made your choice. But for some people the answer is going to be no, and it's those people, choosing something else, that establish the floor for working conditions. They can only go as low as you're willing to put up with. So don't put up with less than you find reasonable.
It's the thing that creates change. Less people are willing to do the job, so less video games get made, competition is less aggressive so each company makes more revenue which allows working conditions to improve. Other solutions will have results no better than this and most of them are just roundabout ways to achieve the equivalent result with higher transaction costs or some kind of perfidious rent seeking or gatekeeping.
The real "problem" is that people want fun and interesting jobs that everybody wants to pay as much as dull and dirty jobs that nobody wants, but that's not how it works. At the same skill level, the shittier job pays better. Because if it doesn't, you quit.
workers fighting their employers never ends how you think it will. They won’t raise conditions, they’ll just get rid of the jobs, outsource, use AI, etc etc etc
Has it ever occurred to you that improving working conditions doesn’t necessarily always result in “making the world better”? And that measurement is completely arbitrary. eg The west has very little manufacturing left because we chose to raise working conditions instead of remaining competitive - thus all the manufacturing jobs disappeared anyways. Is that “making the world better”?
It’s simple supply and demand - a large number of programmers want to work on games. Therefore the pay and conditions aren’t great compared to other less ‘cool+trendy’ options.
Absolute factually untrue. Learn from history.
You should not need to give up on what you want to do because of shitty bosses.
If that's true, how would "Fight like hell to make it better" (presumably by threatening to withhold labor) work? They'll just replace you with the next batch of starry eyed graduates.
Unionizing may be a sensible response to that. I’d expect the company to make a sensible response as well.
Not only management is probably the worst kind I have seen but you know that the best can happen that the result of your work is going to make people spend time on video games instead of doing something better.
You could say the same thing about any hobby activity. Playing games isn't inherently bad just like drinking alcohol isn't inherently bad, its how much you let it consume your life (and in my personal opinion and experience, if you binge something its usually to fill some hole in your life, eg loneliness, and removing the thing to binge doesn't solve it and will simply get replaced with something else. The underlying issue needs to be addressed)
Agree. Playing _video_ games is, _sometimes_.
Playing for a limited time vs. excessive time, playing in your free time instead of playing during times when you should be learning or working, etc. I think there are some potentially negative outcomes associated with video games exclusively, as opposed to other game types (table games, etc.).
Anecdotal evidence time: I have personally met with several players who got severely addicted to video games and had to go through therapy. Not to mention professional players. Of course, the waste majority of players still might be ok. Also, just because some people get addicted it does not mean that the rest of the gamers experience any negative impact.
The kind of problem I see with video games is that it takes away time from children that could have been spent outside doing something more important to their development. I am not sure if this subject is studied, the studies I have seen are inconclusive (some claim positive impact, some claim negative).
> if you binge something its usually to fill some hole in your life, eg loneliness, and removing the thing to binge doesn't solve it and will simply get replaced with something else. The underlying issue needs to be addressed
Absolutely. I just think that playing video games is probably the least healthy option.
https://www.scmp.com/abacus/tech/article/3087444/chinese-esp...
https://www.healthygamer.gg/blog/video-games-and-mental-heal...
https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.0026...
What about movies and TV shows? Theatre? At least video games are less passive than those activities.
I think games can be more addictive (citation needed).
> Theatre?
You can't go to the theatre for 12 hours a day, can you?
Fair point!
I guess it’s the mixture of a relatively passive entertainment, sitting still and being able to do it for long periods at a time (there’s no natural break like the theatre has, nor do your muscles tire like with physical activity).
i have not considered this work-hobby aspect before. the gaming industry is not that different from other artistic fields. music and anime comes to mind because that's the other two i know about.
the work conditions inside anime studios is awful. nothing you would want for anybody. and despite that fact, people kept choosing to do that kind of work. people with responsibilities too, families, kids, etc.
they deliberately choose these awful work conditions.
It's the responsibility of management to provide a healthy working environment. This isn't just a moral obligation, but a creative one as well - businesses that operate like large-scale game developers or Japanese[0] animation studios will ultimately produce uninspired work that people will stop buying.
On the worker's end, there doesn't necessarily have to be a choice to work in the same industry forever, either. Most of these companies have dangerously high employee churn. The company doesn't have to convince people to stay forever, they just need to replace people faster then they burn them out. For the past few decades, they've been able to do that by managing their image and hiding public awareness of their working conditions.
In other words, management can choose to operate their company like a KyoAni or like an A-1 Pictures. They can choose to be a Valve[1] or an Ubisoft[2].
[0] Technically speaking a lot of tween work gets outsourced to lower-COL countries in east Asia, but those studios are often run just as bad as domestic animation studios in Japan.
[1] Hedging my bets: if a bunch of shit comes out of Valve about horrible working conditions please note that this comment was written before that came to light.
[2] A lot of stuff has come out about Activision-Blizzard-King, but let's not forget that Ubisoft is still worse - they actively shuffled sexual predators around their organization, Vatican-style, to keep them on their payroll. The only reason why we're talking about ABK is that the dueling EEOC/CFEH investigations have basically exposed everything.
...and pay the associated costs for it. Alternatively, I'm happy that people churning out enterprise CRUD apps are well rewarded for working in a boring field.
I am planning to get back into game dev after I make enough money to start my own studio.
0% of Blizzard SWE are forced to work there and do so voluntarily - they obviously like it there
I doubt a large percentage of the people requesting this are engineers. Activision/Blizzard has 9500 employees and only 1800 signed the request for the CEO to step down. They apparently need at least 30% of employees to sign up for the union but haven't released any numbers as far as I can tell.
Game companies take advantage of the fact that there is a large population of software engineers who want to meld their work and their hobbies by offering worse working conditions, lower pay, and less stable employment than they could get elsewhere.
Just... play games. And work in a field that treats its employees well.