edit/ These game companies themselves are also quite incestual, for want of a better word. Once a developer moves from one team in one company to another team in another company they typically try to heavily recruit the solid folks that they "left behind," as it were.
And I get that, but, anecdotally, it's never been something that I did when I moved around in my non-games industry. It's never even really crossed my mind.
It still sucked compared to industry positions I took later. There’s a lot more pressure to ship for Christmas, to demo for E3, etc. New consoles invariably have terrible documentation (“it can never not be forgotten to fail to initialize the blah”), and in general the game (and entertainment broadly) industry is less linear/more hit-driven than others.
I also hated that it broke my enjoyment of playing games if I got distracted wondering how they did some effect or why their renderer had a certain glitch.
It's great. I'm really enjoying it. I snipe people from my old work (who are willing to leave games) whenever I see an opening.
Or some of the extremely high quality indie games?
I'd take many of the indie games over WoW or CoD any day of the week. I don't need MMOs to enjoy a well written game.
Unless you think these transformations happen overnight, supply dwindling and working conditions being reevaluated would most definitely decrease quality of games in the short term.
And it's a solution that doesn't involve asking people to quit the job they love so they can get their soul sucked at an advertising company.
Also offering a theoretical that so far isn't happening isn't an interesting argument.