I wish we would just stop looking at infection rates as it's never going to change as long as the virus exists (and continues to mutate) and/or a sterilizing vaccine of sorts shows up and people take it.
It's a balance. E.g. Germanys current trouble is a direct consequence of official policy that had a core of "we only care about hospitalizations now", but ignored "... and based on case numbers and other statistics, what will future hospitalizations look like if we don't change anything about our approach" - not helped by election campaigns and politicians publicly admitting they haven't understood this whole "exponential" malarky yet. You really need to consider more than just one number.
That's simply amateurish, and means all measures, not all of which are bad, are usually a couple of weeks late. Even better, the 7-day average incidence is based on the daily numbers. Those numbers are, what a surprise, limited to the testing capacities of laboratories, so the incidence is reported based on the day the test was analyzed, not when the sample was taken. This flattens the 7-day average curve. Well, until the new numbers are reported once labs git through their backlog. Thing is, the 7-day average is not changed once published. Again just amateurish.
And the RKI predicted the forth basically down to a T, they were a couple of weeks of so. Doesn't matter because they predicted, along with Drosten, already during summer.
EDIT: That's also noise for HF traders, because day-to-day numbers are pointless when you worry about milliseconds.
I had a pretty high opinion of German government competence, Berlin-specific dramas notwithstanding, before the pandemic. I now have a very, very low one.
In many countries, compulsory quarantine was enforced. In Germany it never was, but they still presented it as compulsory and held out the possibility that it might be enforced.
I don’t wish they had enforced it, I wish they had been honest about the arrangement.
Almost all western governments did a piss poor job of preventing facts which why we're in the situation we are now. They appear untrustworthy because they've presented partial truths or completely changed their stance throughout.
Why would you want to control a system with 2-3 weeks of additional lag in your input data when case numbers (a thing that is somewhat easy to measure) correlates so well future deaths?
Ideally politician would have some family of models the equivalent of the CDC runs 3 weeks into the future which accounts for seasonality, social events so we could model predictive control on the death numbers but my impression is that is not done (transparently), due to mistrust in experts.
Because case numbers are actually not easy to measure.
I'm basing this of my personal experience working in a German healthcare company, we took up testing during the pandemic; All the tests we do are on unvaccinated people.
That's because unvaccinated people are the only ones who need mandatory, and up to date, tests for pretty much everything from the barber to eating at a restaurant. Recently, it's become so strict that unvaccinated people even need a test to use public transport.
Vaccinated people do not need these mandatory tests, I have no clue who tests them and at what intervals, it certainly ain't the public testing stations, as those are now literally swarmed by the unvaccinated and nobody would go there if they didn't have to.
Which means that in practice we have a massive sampling bias going on; Somebody who's unvaccinated will be very likely to get flagged as positive very quickly, while somebody who's vaccinated would need to decide on their own to do a test.
On tip of that, a lot of states are now on 2G+, recovered or vaccinated and tested (anti-gen), for things like cinemas (requiring official tests in e.g. Bavaria) or self tests on site (fitness studios for example). Kids are regularly tested in school (my son three times, my daughter twice). Sure, some of those tests, those at fitness studios, are not counted. If those are positive, I think the number of people not getting a proper PCR test is rather small.
There is little control theoretic relevance of the Dunkelziffer smoothly varying between 2 and 6 as long as that doesn't make the controller overlook a wave (it doesn't). The sign of the policy should still be the same and if measures don't work, harder measures are imposed means we basically got a PI(D) controller and can achieve stationary solutions even if the Dunkelziffer changes smoothly.
And what causes lack of access? Total number of people hospitalized. And how does that number grow? Exponentially.
So every public health department in the world is optimizing for "How do we prevent our limited number of ICU-capable health facilities from being overwhelmed."
And that comes down to predicting the future hospitalization rate, which can be predicted by the current case count as you said.
And the amount of complex hospitalizations due to COVID can very quickly become a couple orders of magnitude above "normal operations."
Matching with observed reality a better answer may be: 18 months of enhancing the comorbidities of being overweight and in poor physical condition. Sitting on couch while snacking on carbohydrates and fear has been detrimental to many people.
For example, if you implement a travel rule that every traveler needs to get tested a day before they leave and a day after they arrive, then you’re going to see an increase in cases (both real and false positives).
It’s important to be cautious, but it’s also important to not be a know-it-all who just because they can think of a limitation of a data collection / statistical method they can suddenly cast doubt on the whole thing, even though people who know much more about it already probably did exactly the same thing.
Finden a limitation of some data is extremely easy. Extremely easy. It will literally always be possible whenever people are working with data about people because this shit is hard. That doesn’t mean you get to name that limitation, cast doubt on something and piss off. That’s unproductive and irresponsible.
These are the facts: incidence is a great leading indicator if some care is taken with it and it’s regularly put into the larger context (i.e. given more vaccinations a higher incidence is possible until things turn to shit). And you can shout data limitations at that central fact until you are blue in the face but it’s still gonna be there and true.
That doesn't uniquely describe COVID. It describes pretty much every virus you have heard of.
The gradient for viruses trends strongly towards trading severity for contagiousness. They do not generally "mutate past all defenses and kill", the generally "mutate past defenses and give slight to non-existent symptoms", for several reasons, the two most important of which is that killing means they can't spread anymore, and at the Pareto frontier (which viruses live on all the time), contagiousness and severity are in active conflict with each other; energy put into one comes right out of the budget for the other. And viruses have no particular interests in making you ill... they want to spread.
You've been amped up to a level of fear so severe for viruses that if your fear was accurate, there would be no multicellular life on Earth, because highly contagious and severe viruses would kill anything that provided such a big target. So, good news! Your fear is not accurate. You can verify yourself by checking your environment for multicellular organisms that have not been killed by viruses.
But we are in a modern world where travel around the globe happens in 24 hours. Covid is contagious for some time before the patient has any symptoms, and for most people, it stops being contagious by the time some of the carriers are so sick they might die.
So, when a patient starts having symptoms in 5 days, (s)he may have had time to infect other people on more than two continents.
The fact that viruses in general can spread more widely and more qiuckly doesn't change this.
To restate this without the teleological angle: virus will not become widespread unless they are easily transmitted, and they are not easily transmitted if they make the subject excessively ill. Ergo, the most common viruses are better at being transmitted than making people really ill.
Fortunately, as of today, Omicron deaths are still at zero, and this fills me with moderate optimism. [0]
[0] https://www.cityam.com/anxiously-optimistic-south-africa-hol...
Omicron hasn't been around long enough to expect many deaths yet. Even the optimists need to wait a few more weeks.
With things like covid and the flu, vaccines will always be playing catch up with variants. Its not like the measles which doesn't mutate. Infection and hospitalization rates for vaccinated with covid are already significantly higher than the flu as far as baselines go .. it's reasonable to say we can't expect vaccines to snuff out this kind of disease.
Therefore, the only realistic way to stop the spread is with ruthless targeted testing, tracking, and quarantining. But the problem with that method is by the time we're aware of a problematic strain, its already spread too much for quarantining to be effective.
Nature is inevitable. Once we've done all we can, all that's left is to learn to live with it.
Stalling the spread is useless as well - we have already had two major mutations in less than two years.
There's a significant difference between COVID-19/SARS-COV-2 become endemic, and it continuing as a pandemic that threatens public health systems due to caseload density. Yes, we're unlikely to get beyond it being endemic, which means that like influenza, it will continue to be an issue, but we can certainly get a point where it is "just endemic", which would be a huge improvement over the current situation.
How frequently do equivalent Flu mutations occur?
Well, there is, we just don't want to pay for it: vaccinating poor countries, where effectively the mutations are being created by high infection rates.
Why would the current crop of vaccines be able to stop the virus, even if applied worldwide, seen that they don't prevent infection?
The evidence is still not solid on whether or not it does this, as far as I am aware.
Also there haven't been enough variants as to determine that most variants are coming from poor countries. Speaking of delta, India has more population than the entirety of Europe. Mathematically it makes sense than a variant could come from there regardless of whether the vaccine does anything.
It has greatly slowed the spread. The highest vaccinated countries have almost stopped it. There is every reason to believe that high vaccination across the world would stop covid, and anything less will ensure continued spread (and mutations).
People demanding an all or nothing from a vaccine are missing the big picture.
Israel has faced waves of 3 different viruses - original, Alpha and Delta what have required different level of immunization and Israel has managed to vaccinate itself out of 2 of these waves.
Looks quite impressive to me.
I also fail to understand why people pretend that 2 doses should be expected to stop Delta that has higher viral load - it does not make any sense.
It is a probabilistic game - antibodies are not smart - they are like mines - you need to have high enough concentration to stop viral particles to move around. If the viral particles can overload this concentration - they are going to win. There obviously must be some threshold of antibody concentration below what you can't avoid infection - when 2 dose regimen reaches it too quickly, well, game over. 3rd dose regimen is known to boost antibody concentration and keep it high for longer time. There is no surprise here and yet even people in position (like WHO) that should know better have intentionally ignored it.
[0] https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20200326/us-hospital-beds-we...
[1] https://time.com/5107984/hospitals-handling-burden-flu-patie...
> More than 80,000 Americans died of the flu in the winter of 2017-2018, the highest number in over a decade, federal health officials said last week. Although 90 percent of those deaths were in people over age 65, the flu also killed 180 young children and teenagers, more than in any other year since the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention began using its current surveillance methods.
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/01/health/flu-deaths-vaccine...
Other contemporaneous reporting:
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/26/health/flu-rates-deaths.h...
https://www.nytimes.com/2018/02/02/health/flu-symptoms-virus...
Meanwhile:
> Overall, more than 771,000 COVID-19 deaths have been reported in the U.S. during the pandemic. About 385,000 were reported in 2020, according to CDC data, and more than 386,000 have been reported this year.
https://www.webmd.com/lung/news/20211122/us-covid-deaths-202...
So 2021 alone has nearly 5x the Covid19 deaths as the 2017-2018 flu season. Also:
> As of last Monday, nine hospitals in Michigan were 100 percent full (https://www.michigan.gov/coronavirus/0,9753,7-406-98159-5236...), and at least 20 others were at or above 90 percent capacity. Statewide, nearly one in four hospital patients (https://www.bridgemi.com/michigan-health-watch/michigan-hosp...) has a confirmed or suspected case of Covid-19. In the last few weeks, my hospital has been consistently at or near capacity and nearly every day the vast majority of those patients are sick with Covid-19. Nearly all have been unvaccinated.
> On some shifts, the stress in the air is palpable. My colleagues and I know the patients are piling up, but there just are not enough nurses to properly triage everyone. A patient experiencing heart failure waits in an emergency room because inpatient rooms upstairs are all occupied. Patients who need surgery can’t be transferred because nearly every hospital within a two-hour drive is near or at capacity, too.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/08/opinion/covid-michigan-su...
ICU wards are designed for normal operations at near-full capacity. Maintaining a large-scale vacant ICU capacity is both uneconomical and operationally very difficult (because ICU treatment skills are highly specific and learning, maintaining and updating them requires one to be working on the area).
But those stats will be overshadowed by 2 larger factors:
1. the pendulum will swing back as covid goes to zero .. fewer unhealthy and elderly members of the population will result in overall lower mortality rates in the short term (2-3 years).
2. baby boomers are coming of age .. a baby boom is eventually followed by a death boom. This will drive up the mortality rate long term (5-10 years).
Likewise, hospital are routinely denying transfers. I’m also not sure what “above carrying capacity” would mean here. They’re not sticking two to a bed.
In England last month, 79% of Covid deaths were vaccinated. Currently about 36% of hospitalizations are unvaccinated.
The raw data is here, good luck parsing anything useful out of it: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
The risk of ending up on ICU is about 30 x higher here, when comparing similar demographics. Risk of needing to go to hospital is 19 x higher currently.
As you say, a sizable percentage of deaths (~50% in the 60+ age group) are vaccinated — because those tend to skew elderly (85 in Switzerland) and highly vaccinated (>90%).
Likewise, a sizable percentage of hospitalizations (~40% in 60+) are vaccinated — those are a bit younger (66 in Switzerland) because many of the very elderly patients never make it to a hospital.
All the ICU administrators I've seen interviewed, however, say that their ICU occupants are ~90% unvaccinated. One explanation for this might be that the ICU median age is considerably younger than the above ages, about 55 in Switzerland, and younger population groups are less vaccinated.
But IF this is in fact the case, I wish the statistics were public.
https://ourworldindata.org/explorers/coronavirus-data-explor...
(As OWID relies on official data sources, they may be skewed or manipulated for undeveloped or autocratic countries)
But if the vaccinated represent a much larger share of the population, the same absolute number represents a much smaller proportion who become infected.
We don't lock down for the flu because the virulence of the flu is lower than covid and we consider it acceptable. At some point, we'll pass those acceptability thresholds for COVID as well.
For some people, and regions, they already have passed those thresholds, as both severity and people's acceptance of different outcomes vary.
For me, the threshold when Covid becomes an acceptable fact of life is when hospitals can work normally without any measures in place. We seem to be quite far from that.
Of course, total hospital bed utilization is still over 80%, but overwhelmingly its non covid.
Also, Pfizer is only looking at antibody responses here, not T-Cell & memory B cell responses and other parts of the immune system that were primed by vaccination.
If a thousand healthy people come in contact with the virus it is possible they all will have a positive PCR test while not being contagious at the same time.
It's looking like high double and triple vaccination rates can do it (like 80%+), but that's starting to look impossible in some countries.
This doesn't end until nearly everyone is vaccinated, recovered, or dead. To paraphrase the German health minister.
What does this mean? IMHO it means that once we reached sufficient levels of vaccinations (no idea what that would be, definitely above 70%) COVID will be nothing more than a severe flue / cold for most of the population, if they get it at all. It would also, I would assume, push mutations down the more infections and less severe route in order to overcome the limited spread among the vaccinated (they are still overall less infectious then unvaccinted people) and the vaccines themselves. Both are good news.
And that drives me so crazy with the anti-vaxxers (among a lot of things with them). They don't want the shots because a) COVID is just a flew (and simultaniously a deadly bio weapon the Chinese spread in order to win a global economic war...) and b) vaccinated people are also infectious and can get it. Well, they kind of have it backwards there, don't they? it actually will be like a cold because people are vaccinated, not before. At which point the fact that vaccinated people can also transmit COVID is not really important anymore.
https://data.cdc.gov/Vaccinations/COVID-19-Vaccination-and-C...
>anti-vaxxers (among a lot of things with them). They don't want the shots because a) COVID is just a flew (and simultaniously a deadly bio weapon the Chinese spread in order to win a global economic war...)
Maybe the problem is that people who are against covid vaccines are being a) slandered as anti-vaxxers and b) lumped in with all sorts of other conspiracists.
Well, if I were an anti-vaxxer, why would being called one be a slander? Either I am one or not. And yes, they are conspiracy theorists, even worse they are of becoming even more radical every day.
But thanks for showing again the main problem I have with them: pure egoism. Covid wont be an issue for me (singing in the dark, lalala), so screw everyone else.
Which is exactly what I wrote. The problem with covid is its rate of spread, the actual complication rate per infection is very low. That's why I explicitly said the only possible justification for vaccines now is to prevent hospital overload.
>Well, if I were an anti-vaxxer, why would being called one be a slander? Either I am one or not
No, this isn't binary. Not all vaccines are created equal, and it is perfectly rational to be in support of vaccination in general but against covid vaccines. To blindly group such people with antivaxxers is disingenuous.
I'm not trying to justify the actions of govts, I'm merely stating that slow reaction times are considered by many to be a feature not a bug.
So it seems to me that as long as we all remain obsessed with case numbers and not actual hospitalizations and death, this isn't going away, at least not anytime soon. I personally find this beyond depressing.
[0] https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3963606