But the best part? Seeing all the other users of maps along the route! Barely enough room for two cars to pass. But we had each other. Everyone would hold up their iPhone and mouth “WTF?” with wide eyes.
Google's servers have this information, compiled in real time from countless sources including direct satellite cartography and all beamed to a phone acting as little more than a user interface. Take your phone a few hundred feet below the water where it is cut off from the outside world and even the best maps in the world aren't accurate and you're going to run into a lot of things.
No one, least of all a qualified submarine officer, is proposing that VMS should somehow get a real-time feed of oceanographic surveys while deployed on active operations.
I read the article, and I agree VMS could likely be better, but the map apps on your phone are not examples of navigation systems that have fixed VMS' problems.
The author is suggesting to implement what VMS is meant to do with an application with the same level of usability, reliability and performance as what was put into Google Maps, and Apple Maps, or frankly any reasonably-popular mobile app that doesn't involve gaming.
Do not confuse VMS with a turn-by-turn navigation system, that isn't what it does, or what an actually-usable replacement would have to do. VMS is meant to help plan a voyage and ensure you're safely executing to that plan in transit, and it doesn't do a good job of that for all the reasons the author provided.
You can actually operate Google maps with no internet connection: https://support.google.com/maps/answer/6291838?hl=en&co=GENI...
This will not have the same feature set but the UI will let you know that this is operating with reduced data. Route planning is still very good offline. I had to use this feature because for some time part of my route home had no cell signal.
It is GPS.
Also, "GPS" in the United States colloquially refers what people in the UK would call "sat-nav" not to the satellites + protocol (what it actually means on paper).
Maybe? When hiking it makes some sense to forego GPS to save battery power. I didn't consider that possibility when I commented earlier, but in my defense the context of the comment is using maps without an internet connection.
> Also, "GPS" in the United States colloquially refers what people in the UK would call "sat-nav"
Sure, but sat-nav doesn't require internet service...
If I had to guess, these conflations of cell service with GPS are a product of misleading UX created by Google. OSMAnd makes the nature of GPS clear, displaying a count of satellites it's managed to hear. Enough satellites to get a location good enough for car navigation almost always takes less than a minute.
Couple that with point clouds of the sea floor, manual input from humans, etc, you can do quite well.
Couple this with the lack of good maps of certain sections of the sea floor, and human error, and a collision every couple of years becomes probable.
For a submarine, you need to know the topography of the sea floor down to meter scales. Accurate maps are few and far between, and difficult to create. Changing currents, underwater landslides, silt from rivers, sunken wreckage and even just garbage can create and move obstacles large enough for a submarine to care about in relatively short timeframes. Of course submarines can and do navigate with maps prepared ahead of time, but it's tough, and every now and then you get a run in with a sea mount.
Even if the data set is huge, you should be able to fit the system and a redundant system in a full rack. When I was on a surface ship, our entire nav system fit on a single server with an additional server as a backup. Our system could be updated live because we had internet on board. Subs don’t have this luxury so they would need the full dataset on board.
It's hard to redundantly guarantee correctness, if you wanted to rely on VMS to avoid hitting the seafloor that would indeed be difficult. But come on, how hard is it to offer a highlight for the shallowest points near your course, or a warning that says "you added an extra zero here"?