News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jjoonathan on Friday December 03, 2021 @12:50PM (#29432851)
> “fair pricing policy.” Even though some competing platforms charge much lower fees, if Steve lowers his prices on another shopping site, Amazon’s algorithms punish him

How the hell is this legal? Who do I donate to in order to start the ball rolling on making it illegal?

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:13PM (#29433140)
Why would you possibly want a bureaucrat in Washington, or committee of such, overseeing Amazon's pricing decisions?

Amazon's policy makes total sense. If you discover an item on its site, benefit from its reviews, specs and descriptions, and then last minute, go buy at Newegg or Walmart or wherever because its $20 cheaper, how does that help Amazon? Amazon would rather have you "discover" items that it sells at the lowest price, and thus lowest probability of you going to an alternative store. I don't like Amazon's massive dominance but I can't blame them for directing you to items you are most likely to buy from them.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jjoonathan on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:17PM (#29433193)
Obviously Amazon's anticompetitive behavior is good for Amazon. Why on earth does that make it good for me? Why shouldn't I oppose it?
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by Svettie on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:38PM (#29438174)
competing is not anti-competitive.

> Even though some competing platforms charge much lower fees, if Steve lowers his prices on another shopping site, Amazon’s algorithms punish him

I think in most cases, this "fair-pricing" bot kicks in because a seller has instead inflated prices on Amazon to squeeze more profit from Amazon customers. Amazon thinks that such tactics diminish the value of their marketplace, so they apply this crude heuristic as a way to disincentivize it.

So to answer your question: it's good for you, because if you're shopping on Amazon you can reasonably expect that you're getting good prices (at least in theory). This leads to a virtuous cycle which feeds the beast: people buy more stuff from Amazon, Amazon can operate more efficiently, you get lower prices.

Steve is griping against Amazon, but quite possibly he just has a bad business, and the core of his problem is that he can't compete effectively with other sellers on Amazon. But to him, Amazon seems like the problem because he feels like he's between a rock and a hard place.

But, hypothetical harm aside, Amazon (FBA especially) is currently a really good deal for sellers in terms of shipping costs and access to customers.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:35PM (#29433417)
Your comment isn't an argument, just a pair of questions. Don't ask me to justify your opinion, figure it out yourself.

Amazon promoting products that Amazon is most likely to sell is NOT "anticompetitive behavior."

Every company seeks to do things to benefit themselves. Do you oppose them all?

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jjoonathan on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:46PM (#29433572)
Yeah, yeah, you're "just asking questions." Lol. Questions that relentlessly frame the matter in an agrgessively pro-amazon stance.

Amazon is obviously free to show the best deals on Amazon. That's not at all what this is about, and you know it.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jessaustin on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:01PM (#29435406)
You don't seem to be discussing this in good faith. Obviously most consumers prefer what is good for consumers rather than what is good for giant retailers. We don't have to justify that to anyone.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:49PM (#29436056)
You are missing the point of the whole argument. Amazon is successful because it does TONS of things that are GREAT for consumers. And lots of other stores do too. When a store opens at 6am on Black Friday, do you think they are doing it because their employees requested it? No, consumers did. Do you think retailers like slashing margins razor-thin? No, but if they don't, consumers will go elsewhere. Result is lower prices across the board. "Good for giant retailers" would be for you to pay shipping on all orders. To limit refunds as much as possible. To be "out of stock" on popular items they put on deep discounts and have you select an expensive alternative instead (i.e. bait and switch). Amazon and Walmart have enabled consumers to buy all kinds of goods without paying the premium that established brands charge -- the cheapest tent at REI.com is an $80 Kelty. Meanwhile Amazon has a wide selection at $60 and below from "SEMOO" and "ILOFRI" and "TEKOMI".

The OP suggested lawmakers should somehow make it illegal for Amazon to offer preferential treatment -- prominently featuring their items -- to suppliers that don't charge less to other retailers. Every store does the exact same thing -- and this is GOOD for consumers. When your supermarket puts Coca-Cola on sale (because Coke paid the supermarket), it brings out extra bottles and places them at the front of the store and makes it easy to buy. Sure you can still buy Pepsi, it's back somewhere on aisle 12 where it always is.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jessaustin on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:16PM (#29437312)
...suppliers that don't charge less to other retailers.

Haha you can't even pretend to have misunderstood the situation to this extent. QED on the bad faith. Amazon DGAF what percentages other retailers get. How would they even know those? They are penalizing suppliers for the prices that consumers pay at other retailers. So long as Amazon are allowed to do this, they'll just keep slowly increasing their cut. What's 34% today will be 40% next year, etc.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:39PM (#29437832)
I concede that in haste I wrote "to" instead of "at". Amazon offers preferential treatment to suppliers that don't charge less (to consumers) AT other retailers. And before you say it's up to the retailers what to ultimately charge the consumer, this is not true in today's economy, where sites like Amazon, Newegg, eBay and Walmart act as marketplaces enabling direct manufacturer to consumer sales.

Although I made the initial mistake, I'm pretty sure you just piled on with more bullshit. I'm rather confident Amazon has a good read on what its suppliers charge other vendors, just Wal-Mart and Target do in the B&M space, and that they do very much care.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by vkou on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:20PM (#29433242)
> Why would you possibly want a bureaucrat in Washington, or committee of such, overseeing Amazon's pricing decisions?

Presumably for the same reason(s) that you want an unelected corporate bureaucrat in Seattle making these decisions instead.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by rkk3 on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:44PM (#29437865)
> an unelected corporate bureaucrat in Seattle

Do board votes or shareholder votes not count ?

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:44PM (#29433534)
The guy in Seattle is a capitalist. If you don't like his decisions, you are free to ignore him and not do any business with him. Of course, many of his decisions do benefit you -- low prices, free delivery, wide range of products, displaying reviews, etc. -- but again, you aren't obligated to participate or interact. In fact, even if you refuse to buy from Amazon, you still benefit -- because of competition, your favorite store probably also offers free delivery or has low prices because it needs to compete.

If a committee of Senators, on the other hand, makes a declaration -- Amazon cannot sell Chinese goods cheaper than American-made alternatives -- or maybe, delivery times to rural areas must match those to cities -- then everybody loses, and you can't opt out of that.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by vkou on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:45PM (#29433556)
You can only ignore a capitalist until he becomes a monopolist.

You can ignore a commitee of senators at any time by voting them out.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:56PM (#29433709)
I agree Amazon has an uncomfortable amount of power and influence in retail. But they are very far from a monopolist. And "voting them out" doesn't erase laws that those Senators passed.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by snthd on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:51PM (#29433644)
>Why would you possibly want a bureaucrat in Washington, or committee of such, overseeing Amazon's pricing decisions?

Alternatively

"Why would you possibly want your democratic representative in Washington, or committee of such, regulating markets to work in favour of the average citizen?"

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:08PM (#29433883)
How would higher prices work in favor (sorry, favour) of the average citizen?

Amazon promotes items that it sells for the lowest price. Your local supermarket sends out a flyer every week with all the items it has put on sale, then makes sure those items are easy to find in the store. It's the same thing. Or maybe you want Senators to have final approval over supermarket flyers too.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by snthd on Saturday December 04, 2021 @07:25AM (#29440416)
Allowing sellers to price their items higher on Amazon than elsewhere means it's possible for the seller to offer me a better price, and still make more money (because their costs are lower when Amazon isn't involved).

When Amazon can force a "lowest price" the cost of Amazon's service always gets passed to me, and the lowest possible price is higher.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by NikolaNovak on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:10PM (#29433096)
I think there's context & detail beyond immediate outrage.

In context of article with specific point to make, it sounds awful. But think about it: if e.g. Marriott starts selling rooms for $100 on their website, but $120 on any other site such as Bookings or Expedia or whatever, isn't this ALSO something you as a consumer would get peeved at? Wouldn't you immediately demand that they put a stop to that insidious practice, and regulate some law that forces Marriott to give same low prices to everybody? :->

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by willcipriano on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:35PM (#29434254)
> if e.g. Marriott starts selling rooms for $100 on their website, but $120 on any other site such as Bookings or Expedia or whatever, isn't this ALSO something you as a consumer would get peeved at?

I'm mad it's the other way around, the cheapest price should always be direct. If someone wants to "add value" let them justify the mark up.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jjoonathan on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:12PM (#29433133)
I'm sure Expedia would try to spin it that way. But no, if Expedia wants a $20 cut, they should be providing a $20 service.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by Svettie on Friday December 03, 2021 @08:28PM (#29437784)
Amazon wants to be the place with the lowest prices, and to be known as such.

If Steve wanted to sell through a traditional retailer, he would wholesale to them and they would set the price to whatever they want.

Amazon's model is different, but not really. Imagine Steve could come in to negotiate a wholesale price with an Amazon rep.

Amazon would say: "Steve, we want to have the lowest prices in the marketplace. We checked 10 other stores, and the lowest price we found is $10. So, if we make a deal today, that would have to be our retail price. Now, working backwards, if we subtract our profit margin and expenses, the best wholesale price we would buy at from you is $3. Take it or leave it."

Also, what are these competing platforms charging much lower fees? In any case, if you're not profitable selling at the lowest price on Amazon, you don't have to sell on Amazon. You can go to these other platforms, or set up your own website. And the reason you won't want to do that is because actually Amazon offers a lot of value both to sellers and customers.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by ceejayoz on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:03PM (#29433005)
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jjoonathan on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:07PM (#29433060)
Thanks for pointing me to the name. These things are gross, and we need to get rid of them ASAP.

The whole spirit of market capitalism is "players are allowed to be relentlessly self-interested but we rely on competition to keep them in check." MFCs clearly undermine competition and therefore undermine the very foundation of our economy.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by aidenn0 on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:42PM (#29433506)
They exist on the other side of too:

Discover typically charges the merchant lower fees than AmEx does when you checkout at a retailer. However the merchant is forbidden by it's agreements with AmEx (and Visa, and Mastercard) from giving you a discount if you use Discover card.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jjoonathan on Friday December 03, 2021 @01:49PM (#29433609)
You'll never guess what I think about credit card interchange fees and the contracts that prevent these prices from being exposed to the customers who could force Visa, Mastercard, and Discover to actually compete on price.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:17PM (#29434006)
You could word this as "AmEx protects its customers by ensuring stores cannot tack on an AmEx surcharge" and it would be exactly as true as the way you stated it. Two sides to every story, and all that.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by aidenn0 on Friday December 03, 2021 @03:30PM (#29434954)
Except cardholders are not the same thing as customers. AmEx makes most of its money from merchants not cardholders. AmEx attracts cardholders with low fees and perks, and leverages the resultant large base of cardholders to force its customers (the merchants) to pay higher transaction fees.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by ceejayoz on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:33PM (#29435843)
Low fees? Amex?

They do make about half their revenue off swipes, but I wouldn't describe Amex as low fee to cardholders. Their flagship card has an annual fee of $695.

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by aidenn0 on Friday December 03, 2021 @07:18PM (#29437331)
That's relatively low fee for a membership-perks charge card. They also offer zero annual fee credit cards.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by ceejayoz on Friday December 03, 2021 @09:31PM (#29438133)
Pretty much every lender offers some zero-fee cards, and Amex is pretty unusual in having charge cards at all. Amex relies more heavily on annual fees than their competitors in the space - Chase, Citi, Wells Fargo, Capital One...

What lender are you thinking of that makes Amex look low-fee?

Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by aidenn0 on Saturday December 04, 2021 @08:26PM (#29445965)
Diners club used to be more. They got sold for parts though
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by listenallyall on Friday December 03, 2021 @04:58PM (#29436140)
If the deal is so awful for the merchants, they can choose not to accept AmEx cards at all. Nobody is "forced." Costco switched to Visa.
Re:Amazon's Toll Road – How it funds its monopoly empire by jessaustin on Friday December 03, 2021 @02:03PM (#29433800)
This should also be illegal, but one wouldn't expect much movement on this issue during the presidency of "the senator from MBNA".