News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by trynewideas on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:02PM (#29394370)
I'll just copy this section of the right-to-work article on Wikipedia,[1] because I've sat here trying to explain it to myself for a while and realized there isn't a better encapsulation of it:

-

Besides the U.S. Supreme Court, other proponents of right-to-work laws also point to the Constitution and the right to freedom of association. They argue that workers should both be free to join unions or to refrain, and thus, sometimes refer to states without right-to-work laws as forced unionism states. These proponents argue that by being forced into a collective bargain, what the majoritarian unions call a fair share of collective bargaining costs, is actually financial coercion and a violation of freedom of choice. An opponent to the union bargain is forced to financially support an organization for which they did not vote in order to receive monopoly representation for which they have no choice.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right-to-work_law

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by revolvingocelot on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:06PM (#29394426)
Whereas Canada's decision on this topic is almost the exact opposite, using almost the same logic. "Fascinating".

>In Canadian labour law, the Rand formula (also referred to as automatic check-off and compulsory checkoff)[1] is a workplace compromise arising from jurisprudence struck between organized labour (trade unions) and employers that guarantees employers industrial stability by requiring all workers affected by a collective agreement to pay dues to the union by mandatory deduction in exchange for the union agreement to "work now, grieve later." Historically, in some workplaces, some workers refused to pay dues to the union even after benefiting from wage and benefit improvements negotiated by the union representatives, resulting in friction and violence as they were seen as 'free-loaders;' at the same time, absence of a peaceful grievance settlement mechanism created industrial instability as union members often walked off the job. The compromise was designed to ensure that no employee will opt out of the union simply to avoid dues yet reap the benefits of collective bargaining, such as higher wages or health insurance.

from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rand_formula

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:12PM (#29394530)
> using almost the same logic

This appears to be completely separate logic? A balance of interests, in the Canadian case, and an inaliable right, in the U.S. one.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by revolvingocelot on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:49PM (#29395071)
The situations seem to me to be literally identical, which is why I brought it up in the first place -- if merely most of a workplace joins a union, those who do not don't have to pay dues yet reap the benefits of unionization anyway. Stripped of euphemism, the American response is "yes, that's a good thing" whereas the Canadian one is "no, that's a bad thing". It's a completely different justification, sure.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @04:02PM (#29397412)
> situations seem to me to be literally identical

The situations are similar, but the logic used and conclusions reached are quite separate. Understanding the different paths taken exposes it as far from euphemism.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by revolvingocelot on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @07:21PM (#29399156)
I think I do understand the different paths taken. Strip away the false-friend of interpreting jurisprudence as compiler-output of legal code, and its decisions will reflect the pragmatism of the society that created it. The differences in priorities are stark, both here and elsewhere: "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" vs "peace, order, and good government".
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:22PM (#29394668)
There is no inalienable right to be hired. Freedom of contract is a stronger right in the US and one that "right-to-work" states put restrictions on.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by brightball on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:36PM (#29394869)
How so? One of the big perks of right to work states is that non-compete agreements are virtually unenforceable because no agreement can prevent you from earning a living to provide for yourself and your family.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:05PM (#29395308)
No? In fact, the correlation goes the other way - most states which ban unions security clauses in contracts have legally enforceable non-competes whereas California (for instance) which has no such ban on voluntary contract does not allow for non-competes.

Regardless, "right to work" is more about banning certain union contracts than about providing some "right" to have a job or anything like that.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:19PM (#29395474)
"Right to work" has absolutely nothing to do with noncompetes.

Edited for precision in response to whimsicalism's reply:

The extent of right to work laws is that union contracts (or I guess any contract) cannot require all employees to pay union fees as part of the union contract. That's it. There's no further restrictions on employers, only this particular restriction on employer-union contracts.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:22PM (#29395514)
There is a restriction on employers - they are prohibited from entering into such a contract.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @04:00PM (#29397394)
> There is a restriction on employers - they are prohibited from entering into such a contract

No, they are not.

Employers are prohibited from altering employment contracts ex post facto. But employers are free to make offers conditional on joining a union. Given most employers have wide latitude to alter terms of employment under threat of termination, practically any employer who wants to unionize can trivially do so.

But that is a straw man. In practice, a fraction of employees want to unionize and the employer (with some employees) does not. The argument against unionization is that the first group can't force the second groups into a union contract. The argument for is that they can, provided they represent a majority of the employees.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @05:47PM (#29398441)
> But employers are free to make offers conditional on joining a union.

Here's Alabama's Right to Work amendment, which is broadly representative: https://ballotpedia.org/Alabama_Right_to_Work,_Amendment_8_(...

Key passages are

> (c) No person shall be required by an employer to become or remain a member of any labor union or labor organization as a condition of employment or continuation of employment.

> (e) An employer may not require a person, as a condition of employment or continuation of employment, to pay dues, fees, or other charges of any kind to any labor union or labor organization.

The employer is not allowed to make union membership or dues a condition of employment, whether due to a union contract or out of their own volition.

Interestingly, if you want to look at my other post where I discuss noncompetes vs. Right to Work, you'll find that a number of states, when dealing with noncompetes, consider continued employment "sufficient consideration" for the noncompete. This means that in practice, they're allowed to change your employment contract (w.r.t. a noncompete, and presumably other things), and continuing to employ you is enough to make the contract valid, they don't need to offer you anything additional.

Georgia and Florida are two (but there are more) "right to work" states, where the employer is fully within their rights to change your employment contract ex-post-facto, except in regards to union membership.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @07:31PM (#29399246)
Thank you, I was incorrect.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by gotoeleven on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @02:28PM (#29396347)
You're saying because an employer is not able to enter into a contract with a union that requires a 3rd party (the worker) to pay dues to the union, this is a violation of freedom of association? That doesn't even really sound like a contract, more like a coercive scheme.

Right to work laws do not prevent union members from entering a contract with the union to pay it dues because they think it will benefit them. That's how contracts should work. I think you're just trying to play leftist word games to confuse the issue.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @02:55PM (#29396669)
Yes, the actions of two unrelated third parties can impact your job. For instance, if the company you work at is bought by a private equity firm that fires all of the workers, the sale of the company was still legal - even if it infringes on your "right to work." Likewise, employers can enter into contracts with other third parties that require them to change their contract with other employees. This is basic freedom of contract & association. Right-to-work laws make it so that companies are banned from voluntarily agreeing to such contracts with unions. The contract with the private equity firm remains legal.

In my view, the word games are around the phrase "right to work." Freedom of contract and association is quite unambiguous.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by brightball on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @04:54PM (#29398002)
The attorneys I’ve spoken to would disagree with you.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @05:32PM (#29398314)
Note, I'm not an attorney, but you should talk to better attorney than the ones you've been talking to, because they're flatly wrong.

Here's the right to work laws by state: https://www.ncsl.org/research/labor-and-employment/right-to-...

Here's a (pdf warning) list of noncompete laws by state: https://faircompetitionlaw.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/No...

Note that only 3 states (California, Oklahoma, and North Dakota) ban non-competes (and I'd quibble with this, California and ND afaik ban noncompetes about poaching customers/clients, while Oklahoma allows you ban employees from poaching client, so CA and ND have the strongest noncompete protection, and one is right to work and one isn't). Of these, North and South Dakota are Right-to-Work, and California is not. It's also hard to draw particular conclusions about trends among (I think the only real one I see is that non-right to work states have salary minimums before you can be subject to a noncompete, but so much of the specifics comes down to how courts have interpreted things). What is pretty clear is that there isn't a strong correlation between right to work laws and noncompete laws.

And further, if you look at the right to work statues (for example Alabama's constitutional amendment: https://ballotpedia.org/Alabama_Right_to_Work,_Amendment_8_(..., or Oklahoma's : https://www.findlaw.com/state/oklahoma-law/oklahoma-right-to... as examples), you'll find that they're tailored specifically to prohibit requirements about union dues. They have nothing to do with noncompetes.

So the text of the statutes are unrelated, and its not even clear that there's a general trend of states with right to work laws having more noncompete protection.

I sort of expect you or your lawyer is extrapolating from one state (probably North Dakota, if I had to guess).

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by brightball on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:06PM (#29398577)
What I was told by 2 different attorneys in SC is that a a non-compete cannot be enforced if it prevents you from earning a living. It cannot force you to move out of the area to obtain a job.

Reasonableness is key to enforcement, meaning a reasonable radius, time and field. Any agreement that prevents you from working in your field is defacto-unenforceable specifically because it’s unreasonable.

Both of these attorneys had been practicing in the state for 20 years at the time of the conversation. One graduated from Georgetown and the other from University of South Carolina’s law school.

My understanding from them was that right to work was interpreted as ensuring you actually have “the right to work” via case law with noncompete agreements.

IANAL

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @06:27PM (#29398773)
What your lawyers said sounds believable. It has absolutely nothing to do with "right to work" laws, which are a particular legal concept that have to do with union fee requirements. A quick google search suggests that there was a South Carolina supreme court ruling about noncompetes that addresses "the right of a person to use his talents to earn a living", so I can see what your confusion might stem from, but this is distinct from "right to work", which is a sort of political/legal shorthand for something specific to union contracts.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by brightball on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @07:55PM (#29399394)
Fair enough. Maybe that was the point of confusion.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @12:11PM (#29394515)
Yes, right to work states limit the freedom of association by making it illegal for private businesses to agree to certain contracts that are legal in the rest of the US.

I'm downvoted, but that is literally what right-to-work is.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by andrew_ on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:32PM (#29395648)
Former IBEW Local 58 member here

That take seems very myopic and lacks nuance. There were entire jobsites (which had multiple crews from different companies) that we couldn't work on unless we were members. That's illegal in right-to-work states. It doesn't limit the freedom of association - I suggest it prevents discrimination by association.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:45PM (#29395805)
Freedom of association broadly implies both the freedom to associate with whom you choose, and the freedom to refuse to associate with whom you choose. If the law requires you to associate with people, that's a restriction on freedom (and yes, this argument extends to things like civil rights and anti-discrimination laws, but the consensus seems to be that discrimination based on protected classes trumps freedom of association, although this can get murky in some situations, e.g. private golf clubs or where religious freedom gets involved).

So it absolutely limits freedom of association by preventing organizations from choosing whom they associate with. Requiring you to employ someone can hardly be seen as a "freedom". Whether such a restriction is ethical or not, and whether such a restriction is constitutional or not are two different questions (and those two questions, and the question of whether it is a restriction on freedom of association may have different answers!).

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by jjk166 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @03:16PM (#29396922)
Right to work laws in no way limit who can or can not be hired. Everyone is still free to associate, or not associate, with whomever they want. All it means is that non-union members can't be forced to pay union fees as part of their employment contract. An organization can still restrict its association to only union members, but if it chooses to associate with non-union members, it can't penalize them by charging them a fee to remain non-union members.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @03:53PM (#29397319)
> Right to work laws in no way limit who can or can not be hired.

I don't think I said they did.

> Everyone is still free to associate, or not associate, with whomever they want.

But are limited in the ways they can associate: certain contract terms are prohibited. Again, whether or not this is good is a distinct question. Minimum wage laws prohibit certain contract terms that I consider predatory (but in a sense the government is simply collectively bargaining on behalf of all workers in setting a minimum wage). Conversely, a government setting a maximum wage would probably be considered problematic. But all three, a minimum wage, a maximum wage, and "right to work" laws, limit how you can associate.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by jjk166 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @04:14PM (#29397539)
Well no one is arguing that freedom of association gives you the right to do whatever you want while associated. I can go to the bank with whomever I want, but I can't rob a bank with whomever I want. Forbidding me from being a getaway driver doesn't impinge on my freedom of association.

Freedom of association is the right to join or to leave groups voluntarily. You still need to respect peoples other rights, and follow other applicable laws while associated. There are some laws like child labor laws which do restrict people from being able to voluntarily join or leave a group, but right to work and minimum wage laws are not such cases.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @04:19PM (#29397606)
It literally is a restriction on the ways in which you can associate with other groups or individuals.

You can sign an agreement to use only a particular supplier for a product, unless that product is labor and the supplier is a union.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by jjk166 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @11:52PM (#29400808)
No, it isn't. Look up what right to work laws actually cover. Organizations are still free to enter an agreement to use only a particular supplier of labor. Right to work laws just make it illegal to enter an agreement where non-union members are forced to pay union agency fees despite not being members of the union. As I said previously, freedom of association means you can enter a contract with whomever you want, it does not mean you can enter a contract to do whatever you want.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @01:48AM (#29401364)
> Right to work laws just make it illegal to enter an agreement where non-union members are forced to pay union agency fees despite not being members of the union.

I guess I'll cite Alabama's right to work amendment for the 4th time today:

> No person shall be required by an employer to become or remain a member of any labor union or labor organization as a condition of employment or continuation of employment.

The screen actor's guild often works as a labor supplier, but they cannot negotiate a contract in Alabama to be the only supplier of labor for a film. I mean I guess you can split hairs and claim that it's the combination of Taft-Hartly and right to work laws that create the situation, but since such a contract is valid in other states, it's really only the right to work law that's relevant.

> As I said previously, freedom of association means you can enter a contract with whomever you want, it does not mean you can enter a contract to do whatever you want.

I think you'll have a hard time describing how the law banning some of these would violate freedom of association, but for others it wouldn't:

    - A contract that requires the employee to be black
    - A contract requiring the employee to hold some certification
    - A contract requiring the employee to hold membership in a professional organization
    - A contract requiring the employee to hold membership in a union
    - A contract requiring a salary of $2.00 an hour (minimum wage laws are also often considered a violation of freedom of association)
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by jjk166 on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @11:17AM (#29405332)
It's a really easy litmus test: if to do something you are compelled to associate or disassociate with some people but not others, it's a violation of freedom of association. If you can or can't do something no matter who you do it with, it's not a violation of freedom of association.

I suspect there may be some confusion due to how we use language, but it should be noted that the freedom of association is a right that people have to join or to leave groups. Organizations, including companies, are not people and thus don't have this same right, at least not to the same extent, even though the individuals within the organization do.

> A contract that requires the employee to be black

Technically races aren't groups that can be freely associated or disassociated with, so not a freedom of association violation, but obviously still discrimination and thus an invalid contract to enter into. If you broadened it to be a contract that required employees to be members of some traditionally black group, then it would be a violation of freedom of association.

> A contract requiring the employee to hold some certification

So long as anyone is free to get the certification without being compelled to associate or disassociate with anyone, this is fine as it does not restrict who can join and leave groups. If your association is a condition of getting the certificate, it's an obvious violation.

> A contract requiring the employee to hold membership in a professional organization

Restricts a person's right to voluntarily join or to leave a group, obvious violation.

> A contract requiring the employee to hold membership in a union

The same situation as the professional group.

> A contract requiring a salary of $2.00 an hour

So long as you can't pay anyone a salary of $2.00 an hour, has no affect on who people can or can't associate with, there is obviously no violation of freedom of association, regardless of whether people falsely claim it is. If, on the other hand, people from one group can be paid $2.00 an hour but people from another group are restricted from being able to enter that same agreement, then it's an obvious violation.

Now here's an example for you:

Should an employer be permitted to require an employee to register as a member of the employer's chosen political party and contribute some financial minimum to that political party as a condition of employment? How about political group technically unaffiliated with any political party but nevertheless with a distinct ideology? How about a religious group instead of a political one? If your reaction is "employers should not be allowed to compel me to become a member of and pay money to these organizations as a condition of employment" then we're on the same page.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by joshuamorton on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @12:07PM (#29406162)
All of your examples would be legal, as far as I know.

We can argue about morality (and whether or not I'd work for such an employer) but yes they are, afaik, all legal things for an employee to mandate.

> > A contract requiring the employee to hold membership in a union

> The same situation as the professional group [a violation]

Then you agree that right to work laws like Alabama's violate freedom of association?

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by jjk166 on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @12:26PM (#29406473)
You misread my post. I am saying such a contract is a violation. Right to work laws forbid such contracts.
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @08:19PM (#29399543)
Do you not see the difference between robbing a bank and a voluntary contractual agreement not to associate with someone?
Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by jjk166 on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @11:56PM (#29400834)
Well in one case you're entering into an agreement to force a non-consenting third party to give you their money, and in the other you're robbing a bank.

Less facetiously, bank robbing is merely one extreme example of something you're not allowed to enter into an agreement to do. You also can't enter an agreement to provide sexual favors for financial compensation, or employ people full time for less than minimum wage, or require someone to donate an organ to you in exchange for financial compensation. None of these are violations of the freedom of association - there's no restriction on the groups you can freely join or leave, there are just certain things that you can't do regardless of the groups you are or aren't in. In right to work jurisdictions, requiring non-union members to pay union agency fees is just one of those things you are not permitted to do, and thus can't enter an agreement to do.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Wednesday December 01, 2021 @12:34PM (#29406599)
If your company says, I'm sorry we have to reduce your salary to save money, so take it or leave it, is that "forc[ing] a non-consenting third party to give you their money"?

Nobody is being forced - everybody is voluntarily accepting or refusing contracts.

Re:US labor board official orders Amazon to redo union vote ... by whimsicalism on Tuesday November 30, 2021 @01:43PM (#29395783)
Yes, entering into a contract limiting a jobsite to union workers is prohibited by right-to-work, ie. an abridgement of freedom of contract.

I am curious how this works with agency fees though - it shouldn't be legal to require union membership, but it might be legal to require agency fees paid to a union.